you're beating the war drums when people are still in shock. We get it, u think Smith is Chris Calloway part 2. I think you're wrong about Smith's value to the Giants but you have a right to your opinion.
Nicks may be better/more talnented. But Maningham (see fumble that started the avalanch in Eagles game) last year has talent but not even half football smarts Smith has. THIS SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!
i don't think hes calloway part 2, hes a nice player, i don't want to get into all the various criticisms of his game because ive done it before and it would just get lost in this soon to be 8000 post thread anyway
get back to me on Mario by seasons end. Lets also forget that he spent the better part of that day raping the Eagles before that fumble, scored twice, got deep on their secondary routinely and was missed a couple times by Eli for some potential huge gainers
Hes going to break out this season. The light is ready to come on
they're gambling. it's a good complimentary part for them if they can get him on the field. they have burners but they don't work the middle of the field that well.
if they can't get him on the field, they're not stuck with him for 3 more years afterwards.
are going to have a shit load of egg on their face ifhe ever comes back healrhy. People can sugar coat things any way they want, but they have done absolutely nothing to get better
I will admit, though, I'm a little perplexed as to where the possesion
type guy is coming from, the guy who can get open in the middle of the field, get down and not get hit, so he can keep doing it. I don't know if Nicks can do it without taking abuse.
Manningham's light about to come on doesn't discount Smith's importance to the offense or the need for a 3rd WR to step up and convert the 3rd and 7's that keep drives alive and win games.
What the hell does Manningham have to do with Smith or whoever is the 3rd WR this year?
By about week 3 or 4 most of the Mario myths around here will be well dispelled. For people paying attention, they saw the difference as the season wore on last year. Hes got more of a comfort level in the offense and with Eli now
He and Nicks are going to unleash a brutal pillaging on opposing secondaries this season the likes of which we have never seen before on this team.
Don't care how many times i say it. And this is not after the fact homer talk and sour grapes on him because he signed with Philly. I was yelling this even when it appeared Smith could be back this year.
I applaud the Giants for holding firm here with him
MikeGarafolo
And if we're giving proper credit, btw, the Smith signing was first posted on @BigBlueInteract. They were all over it. #nyg
less than 1 minute ago from web
I think alot of Giants fans for some reason will always shit on Mario. Whether he be how he talks in interviews, his wonderlic score, or his 1 fumble in a game where they came right back to get another TD after, some people are just stupid on here. Im biased because Im a huge Michigan fan but I'd take Mario over steve 100% of the time.
I agree with you.This team is has done little to get better from last year.IMO we are worse off then we were a year ago at this time. Reese is reminding me of George Young when he let all our free agents leave. Show me another team in the NFL who has lost three startes who were less then 27 years old to free agency?
to step up, but there's no reason why it can't happen. We just spent a high draft pick on a guy who does a similar thing that Smith does. Get him on the field.
Jerry Reese you better know what the heck you are doing. This is a sad day. A very sad day. No positive spin. This was a no brainer for eagles, if he can't contribute no big deal, if he can they hit the jackpot with him.
in multiple WR in recent years, Cruz also continues to impress in camp. At some point these guys need to get a chance to sink or swim. The depth will work itself out, and these guys are no more of a question mark than Steve Smith coming off this surgery
Between Cruz, Beckum, Hixon, Barden...there are guys that simply are too good to be not getting snaps. Not brining back Smitty was not a bad move, especially considering the injury. That being said, him going to the Eagles fucking sucks. There's no way to spin it.
from my standpoint, is that another 07 Giant bites the dust. You watch those playoff games on DVD, it always strikes you how fast roster turnover occurs in the NFL. And we lost a bunch more this offseason. But thats just the business of football
He is going to be signed Day 1 ..
- BBI
But just watch the passing game this year.
if they get him out there healthy, and he produces, yes, it sucks.
if he doesn't get healthy he wasn't getting healthy here, either. hell, here, he'd probably end up an amputee. lol.
when they bring him in to be looked at (which you would think would be a precursor to a signing), and they don't sign him....
Hes going to break out this season. The light is ready to come on
they're gambling. it's a good complimentary part for them if they can get him on the field. they have burners but they don't work the middle of the field that well.
if they can't get him on the field, they're not stuck with him for 3 more years afterwards.
type guy is coming from, the guy who can get open in the middle of the field, get down and not get hit, so he can keep doing it. I don't know if Nicks can do it without taking abuse.
I can't even paste them they are soooo bad, I am pissed he was signed by the Iggles but to wish he blows out his other knee is bullshit
What the hell does Manningham have to do with Smith or whoever is the 3rd WR this year?
He and Nicks are going to unleash a brutal pillaging on opposing secondaries this season the likes of which we have never seen before on this team.
Don't care how many times i say it. And this is not after the fact homer talk and sour grapes on him because he signed with Philly. I was yelling this even when it appeared Smith could be back this year.
I applaud the Giants for holding firm here with him
terrible..smh
And if we're giving proper credit, btw, the Smith signing was first posted on @BigBlueInteract. They were all over it. #nyg
less than 1 minute ago from web