for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

Congratulations Perry Fewell!!!!!

Joey in VA : 11/12/2012 1:24 pm
Thanks a ton for that 3-4 look with JPP at ILB and Osi at RDE that left a hole you could have driven John Holmes through with no pain. Brilliant way to use your best edge rusher, on the fucking inside. I'm also pretty happy with how you haven't closed down the zone coverage at all and moved your safeties closer towards the hash marks and 2-3 yards further up the field like a real Cover 2 would, you don't need to study what a shitty team like the Bears do on offense, and certainly you wouldn't want to pattern anything after the Steelers and their rolled up C-2. Be your own man!!!

And Corey Webster being totally flummoxed 9 weeks into the season against the opponents best player? Bravo sir, why on Earth would he want to waste time playing defense when standing still is just as easy and the results are the same? I'm also particularly proud of how wide you allow your worst DL to play outside at RDE, why use gap discipline when Osi can fly upfield 8 yards past the QB and have a nice view of the Cincinnati 100 sections which are chock full of tubby midwestern goodness. Kudos as well for allowing teams free reign over the middle as you did in week one Vs. Dallas and continue to do in week 10. I predicted the night prior to the opener that our biggest issue would be deep and medium middle because you don't press your CBs, your LBs don't sink well enough usually (save for one play in the Super Bowl) and you love to stunt your tall athletic DEs inside or play them at DT so there is no WAY they could affect the wide open passing lanes that have existed since you got here.

Pressure? You don't need no stinking pressure, just send a 265 slow footed LB on a..delayed blitz on Osi's inside shoulder, that should work because the two guys who had to block #72 are really bored as he runs himself outside of the play by ignoring essentially 3 gaps at once. A gap blitz with a fast LB because double teams are aimed at JPP? Noooo JPP is inside or at LB or ..where is he?? that's a fun game. Using the talent you have at DE to open up the inside to LB, S, CB blitzes would be silly, you just keep looping them around like very slow flies swarming a carcass they may or may not want to eat. Most coaches would have watched tape, adjusted or gone back to the basics of the Cover 2 that you learned but not you big guy. You just won't let anyone dampen your creative spirit, now matter how badly you fingerpaint a all over our defense.

In your defense, you don't have much to work with, only 4 All Pro players, and certainly no high draft picks, I mean Corey Webster was a 2nd round pick...what a LOSER, Phillips, Rolle and Amukamara are all #1s so trust me pal, I feel your pain. Your DL?? Big money on Chris Canty, Rocky Bernard, premium picks in Kiwi, Tuck, Osi, JPP, Linval Joseph but your hands are tied by that confounded Jerry Reese who just keeps stockpiling OL players but won't even look to the DL or secondary. He sure never got you any LBs, he didn't sign a high priced one, draft 3, trade for another and dust one off and buff him to a big white shine so he could rescue you in the Super Bowl. What are you supposed to do when you have no talent, and the front office does nothing to help your side of the ball at all. Stay strong Perry, you'll show those bastards.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 <<Prev | Show All |  Next>>
or we have a Super Bowl level coaching staff  
Bill in Springfield : 11/12/2012 2:41 pm : link
.
Who has more teeth?  
drkenneth : 11/12/2012 2:41 pm : link
Fewell or Mile Austin?
lot mixing and matching  
bc4life : 11/12/2012 2:43 pm : link
in the secondary doesn't help - Webtser with a gimpy hamstring - Phillips out - Hosley getting more playing time but has missed some time - Prince - just getting back - Stevie Brown starting - lots of youth and injuries back there.



if thats the case bill  
snablats : 11/12/2012 2:44 pm : link
then why were we 7-7? why did we miss the playoffs in 09 and 10??

when is Phillips supposed  
bc4life : 11/12/2012 2:44 pm : link
to be back? Or Williams?
Fewell D to my untrained eye..  
pencap75 : 11/12/2012 2:45 pm : link
doesn't seem any different than Tim Lewis' soft Bend/don't break D.
I seems like we executed better late last season, and the 3 safety look seemed to work.
This year, we are not executing so we look like shit.
if communication is key  
bc4life : 11/12/2012 2:46 pm : link
tehn it has to hurt having different and often inexperienced players in the secondary just about every week.
He's been a pretty unimpressive  
Phil in LA : 11/12/2012 2:47 pm : link
gameplanner. And his D is basically awful unless it creates a turnover. Stops are more important than takeaways, and our D doesn't get enough of them.
I don't think I've ever seen one person look like two people before.  
Dave in Hoboken : 11/12/2012 2:48 pm : link
Here, he looks like a slightly more bloated version of Marshall Faulk, or a slimmed down Warren Sapp. Mindblown.

Phil  
JonC : 11/12/2012 2:48 pm : link
Agreed.
snablats  
Bill in Springfield : 11/12/2012 2:49 pm : link
it's all part of a master plan, have faith.
Perry Fewell  
ghost718 : 11/12/2012 2:49 pm : link
Looks like the mad scientist blew up his lab again.
Phil nails it...also  
drkenneth : 11/12/2012 2:51 pm : link
many here have mentioned that:

-The D can't get a friggin' stop unless it gets a turnover. The D is on the field WAY too long.

-Offense goes 3 and out

Rinse. Repeat.
great non answer bill  
snablats : 11/12/2012 2:51 pm : link
in other words, you dont have a clue
Gilbride and Fewell  
drkenneth : 11/12/2012 2:52 pm : link
are a bad mix.....We really on big plays to succeed on both sides of the ball.
Gene (Homer) definitely has a point  
HBart : 11/12/2012 2:52 pm : link
About yesterday. It felt like such a crapfest on D because of the first drive and the fact that after that all of Dalton's TD throws were on 3rd down, 2 of those 3 on 3rd and long.

And that, coming on the season to date where we've been gashed mercilessly on the ground 4 times on through the air 4 even while winning makes it seems like the D is sucking worse than they are.
Rely...  
drkenneth : 11/12/2012 2:52 pm : link
..
Some of the things we have been doing  
gmen4ever : 11/12/2012 3:16 pm : link
on Offense, Defense and ST lately have been shocking this year. The list of things that have caused me to yell "WTF!!!" is getting longer and longer.
Kick his ass  
Spackler : 11/12/2012 3:22 pm : link
Joey.
Reminiscent of one of your posts from  
GregN : 11/12/2012 3:22 pm : link
a few years ago where you had a rant about the offensive side of the ball and were shown to have overreacted as the season progressed. Hoping for the same result here. Coaching on the defensive side of the ball was not completely to blame-the other team made contested catches and blew us off the line on many occasions.
I will hold off on my opinion until  
Rich in L.A. : 11/12/2012 3:24 pm : link
Randy weighs in with his defensive analysis.
snablats  
Bill in Springfield : 11/12/2012 3:24 pm : link
That's correct. I don't have a clue but I have faith!
Bullshit.  
Spackler : 11/12/2012 3:25 pm : link
Joey's never wrong.
Im not a fan of Fewell or his schemes  
Mighty : 11/12/2012 3:38 pm : link
and have felt this way ever since he got here. I realize our personnel is a bit mismatched but we shouldnt be seeing the same thing over and over again. He constantly goes back to a loose zone heavy scheme until it fails miserably and later in the year when the players,fans, etc are in an uproar he gets aggressive. And even with that success the next year he goes right back to it. This is the 3rd year in a row now this is happening and that is more damming that anything. I can understand trying to go back to your comfort zone the 2nd year but in this 3rd year when you see the same thing as 2 times prior you gotta realize and make the change quick. We need a new coach because i dont see an overhaul of new players coming anytime soon and our players simply dont match his scheme. We have mainly press man CBs trying to play zone, and right now 2 aggressive safeties being asked to play mainly deep zone when their instinct is to move forward, and a MLB who cannot cover the deep middle.
HomerJones45 leaps into the coaches  
LauderdaleMatty : 11/12/2012 3:45 pm : link
are never wrong breach

Way to go.
Wow  
Johnny5 : 11/12/2012 3:46 pm : link
this is why  
Harry53 : 11/12/2012 3:50 pm : link
the D started to play well from the Jet game on.....
Link - ( New Window )
more aggressive??  
area junc : 11/12/2012 3:51 pm : link
we never got more aggressive last year. we simplified things. if u can go back and watch a "more aggressive" D those final 6 games i gotta question it. we were dropping 7 almost exclusively just like we do now..

what he did was simplify things and take the inexperienced players off the field as much as he could (g.jones, j-will and prince). they were getting abused and constantly breaking down

after the washington debacle he put his "vets" on the field for the stretch run - going almost exclusive 3 safety with deon grant. (and thus, taking prince off the field). he would just have rolle over the slot WR if they went multi-WR. no prince unless absolutely necessary. and he got some guys back reasonably healthy.

he is back at that point now: hosley is getting burned. stevie brown has stepped up as a playmaker. nobody outside of boley can add to the coverage at linebacker. i expect we emerge from the bye using the 3 S look with KP on the field again (Rolle over the slot, instead of Hosley).

we get one last chance to fix this. put everything on the plate of your vets. onus on them to communicate and execute. no excuses. we will see if the vets can bring us home but i expect everyone 2 know what time it is coming out of the bye.

it's time
Shmuley Boteach  
JonC : 11/12/2012 3:53 pm : link
.
Well  
Johnny5 : 11/12/2012 3:59 pm : link
I have to say, I had my fill of Fewell up to (and including) the first half of the Jet game last year, but obviously they (he) redeemed themselves in a big way.

But once again the season starts this year and it's the same inconsistent defense. It is absolutely maddening. I'm sick of giving up so many yards to TEs (Or anyone running across the middle of the field), I'm tired of giving up so much in the run game, and I'm tired of the horrible tackling.

I don't know, is it talent (lack of)? Or is it scheme? Have we just been figured out, waiting for a reinvent in the 2nd half of the year again? Is Fewell really just a mediocre DC that over-acheived last year? I just don't know what to think anymore.
Not that it matters  
islander1 : 11/12/2012 4:00 pm : link
but I approve of this thread, 110%
Hmmm Area  
Johnny5 : 11/12/2012 4:04 pm : link
That is a pretty damning article right there. He gets to cute in his scheming. I guess he and Gilbride went to the same school... lol. Well you know what? If a couple of stink-bombs lead to some simplifying and bang-on defense? I can live with that if it happens like last year.
sorry, but they were also more aggressive  
snablats : 11/12/2012 4:08 pm : link
maybe it was because of the simplicty, but they were not in soft zones nearly as much after the skins loss, and they did blitz more
I'm not necessarily down on Fewell, but  
BigBlueBuff : 11/12/2012 4:08 pm : link
I do have a two questions: Why does an ineffective Osi line up at DE every third down? I'd rather JPP out there or better yet, Kiwi at DE full time. Also, what is up with the constant mistakes in coverage? Where is the teaching?

I can't blame Fewell for Hosley's rookie mistake or the great catch made on Prince or the turnovers and return that set up the short fields.
You can't just look at the score and say they did well  
JOrthman : 11/12/2012 4:09 pm : link
They are keeping themselves on the field too long. YOu need to give the offense more chancces and additionally you can't wear yourself out. YOu need to get off the field so late in the games you have something left if you need a big play or a stop.
how different are we now than we were  
nyynyg : 11/12/2012 4:11 pm : link
at this time last year defensively under Fewell.

it seems to me that if we didn't do a complete about face under Fewell and go on the run we did, BBI would have collectively run the guy out of town.

what is bizarre to me though is why have we regressed to Nov of last season form defensively and not continued our defensive growth as a unit from the end.
JOrthmann  
BigBlueBuff : 11/12/2012 4:16 pm : link
It goes both ways. The offense had way too many three and outs as well.
BBB...to my point above  
drkenneth : 11/12/2012 4:18 pm : link
We have a D that can't get off the field, and an O that can't stay on it.

Bad combo.
BBB  
JOrthman : 11/12/2012 4:19 pm : link
I agree, but this thread was about PF. The offense is a thread in and of itself. I'm simply saying you can't blame the game on the offense. They need to compliment each other.
..  
TheShouldersOf : 11/12/2012 4:22 pm : link
Quote:
or we have a Super Bowl level coaching staff
Bill in Springfield : 2:41 pm



Last Year, not this year
Joey  
lawguy9801 : 11/12/2012 4:30 pm : link
Seriously, don't you know criticism means that you're just a nattering ninny and that down the stretch we're going to magically start dominating the fuck out of people again?
Fewell  
TMS : 11/12/2012 4:32 pm : link
gave TC what he needed at the time after the Sheridan disaster. A limited defensive analyst who related well with the players. Then we won the Super Bowl so how do you replace tour DC? Hope we do not pay the price this year for that fact.
Joey  
Marty866b : 11/12/2012 4:44 pm : link
Great post.I've been thinking the same thing for awhile now.Unless we have the worst back seven in history,it is incredible to me that game after game opposing receivers are WIDE open due to poor scheming,communication,or lack of ability? Our defense sucked last year to besides the last handful of games.Our defensive roster at least appears to be much better then the results on the field.
The offense is in a funk right now but I am much more confident that they will bounce back then I am of the defense actually being good.
Why is Fewell still with the Giants?  
oipolloi : 11/12/2012 4:54 pm : link
multiple choice

a. The liberal media would be all over Coughlin for firing a black man.

b. Coughlin does not read BBI and does not know what simple adjustments are needed to fix the defense.

c. Coughlin is too loyal.

d. Giants won a SB just ten months ago with Fewell's defense throttling the opposition.
I've always been a huge supporter of coach Spags  
NyquistX3 : 11/12/2012 4:58 pm : link
and not overly impressed with Fewell. Some of the blitz packages Spags dialed up were incredible here and his scheme was the single largest component of that Super Bowl win over the 18-0 Patriots, IMO.
Am i the only one that it bothers  
Mighty : 11/12/2012 5:03 pm : link
when Fewell is talking about his LBs and his reversed Sam/Will? I mean ive had coaches that called the LBs something other than Sam/Mike/Will but to call the Sam Wil and vice versa just bothers the hell outta me. The strong side and the weak side is not something that is subjective and can be interpreted different ways. It is what it is. Its like somebody now coming to you and trying to tell you that your right hand is really your left hand and your left hand is really your right hand. It must cause confusion sometimes and makes me wonder if there are other assbackwards terminology being used causing some of our mixups.
Mighty  
dorgan : 11/12/2012 5:06 pm : link
you're not alone.
But, that's a minor issue compared to some of the other shit he does that drives me nuts.
I'm going to wait until the end of the season to assess anything  
Go Terps : 11/12/2012 5:08 pm : link
I don't know why we would assess anything now given this team's history. But I guess that's just me.
dorgan  
Mighty : 11/12/2012 5:16 pm : link
I just cant help feeling if he is messing up something so simple as Sam and Will then what else is he messing up. Id be interested in hearing your critique in some of his Xs and Os decisions.

Terps. i think assessment should be a daily/weekly thing and cant just wait till the end of the season. You always need to assess your team/players/coaches and make adjustments. If its a major adjustment then maybe you wait till the offseason to do the adjustment but you should be constantly assessing. But i think you are meaning more not making knee jerk midseason reactions to the assessments.
TD throws  
HomerJones45 : 11/12/2012 5:30 pm : link
Let's see. If Holsey simply tackles the receiver instead of trying to knock the throw down, that's a field goal try for the Bengals at best. As it was, Holsey missed AND the receiver had to make a one hand catch for the td. This is on Fewell?

On Sunu's td, the defender is right there AND hits the ball AND Sunu proceeds to catch it against his frigging leg. This is on Fewell too?

So, even though the defense was handed a shit sandwich, not once, but twice, Fewell had players in position to stop the TD and it took circus plays from two Bengal receivers to get touchdowns.

The defense is missing one tackle, for all practical purposes at this point, a 3rd down linebacker and its starting safety. Fewell is having to cover several holes- whether some of you want to recognize them or not.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 <<Prev | Show All |  Next>>
Back to the Corner