It all depends on your thoughts on Nicks. Is he done as a top WR? Was he "saving" himself ala DJax a few years ago? I believe it was the latter. I believe Nicks was upset he didn't get his contract and I believe he wasn't motivated to do all of the things he needed to do for this team. I don't think he's finished and I believe he will be back to the threat he was next season(for a different team).
All that being said, I believe Nicks is vital to this offense and becasue he was a non factor all season, it destroyed our offense. Clearly our problems go deeeper than that, but not having Nicks command his usual attention effected the whole offense.
His play is so lackluster- he just doesn't fight for balls like he used to. The Giants are in a tough situation. Obviously, he has talent, we have all seen it, but do you committ to a guy who will allow his emotions to dictate his effort? Probably not.
Nicks is a part of.. not THE problem..
That being said People clamoring about nicks yesterday are just in denial about how bad the throws to him were. they were horrific.
Is he simply pouting and not preparing/playing like he has in the past because of it?
OR
Is he 25 soon to be 26 year old receiver with a chronic leg problem that will never regain his speed/explosiveness?
Do you think the Giants organization is going to be willing to pay to find out?
Not every pass is going to hit the WR in the numbers. But the problem is unless the ball hits them in the numbers, Giants WRs cant make plays.
1. He's been so banged up in the past, he doesn't want to risk getting hurt which would effect his next paycheck.
2. He's pissed. He's pissed we gave cruz all that money and wouldn't even talk to him about his contract. He wanted security and we weren't willing to give that to him.
That being said, I strongly disagree with the above post that Cruz has done "jack shit". He has close to 1,000 receiving yards, and, more importantly, plays at 100% ALL THE TIME, which is more than I can say for Nicks. Nicks has played with his emotions on his sleave. Last time I checked, he was getting paid to play, not to pout. Let Nicks be someone else's problem and take the money you had set for Nicks and spend it on someone whon actually cares.
He's not going to get anywhere near the contract Mike Wallace got.
If Nicks were playing through an injury he'd either shut himself down, or the team would, so I don't see that as being the reason.
Sometimes players have to do what's best for them even if the fans don't want to hear it. I don't like it, but I understand it.
and Dep separation only counts when you want it to? like the last pick when he beat sherman and eli threw late and short... the separation was there... u just dont want to see it.
Nicks did nothing yesterday, has been not a value add guy all year... but people just make sh$t up. the throws yesterday were ALL awful and deserve to be picked and VERY unlikely to prevent them.
It's entirely possible for both of them to suck, because, both of them very much do right now.
and Dep separation only counts when you want it to? like the last pick when he beat sherman and eli threw late and short... the separation was there... u just dont want to see it.
Nicks did nothing yesterday, has been not a value add guy all year... but people just make sh$t up. the throws yesterday were ALL awful and deserve to be picked and VERY unlikely to prevent them.
He had separation on both fade passes.... you msut be drunk or high. Because Sherman was in perfect position on both passes. The crossing route was a pass where he actually got both hands on it, yet the defender wrestled it away from him.
Time and time again, I see WRs in the NFL make diving catches, one handed catches, outjump people, go over DBs, and make hard catches look routine.
Hakeem Nicks has not done any of these things. So since he cant get separation, cant out run people, and doesnt win 1-1 matchups - he is literally useless. Again, if a WR can only catch a ball where he is open by 5 yards and hits him in the chest.... well he isnt much of a WR. At this point, he isnt even a number 3 WR on most teams.
No one actually knows the reason yet. In any case, he's made a good case for not being back here.
Losing your #1 receiver is going to certainly affect your offense's performance. Couple that with all the other offensive problems and you have a little NFL disaster.
On all 3 interceptions thrown his way. Nicks didn't have any seperation.
I know Sherman is the best corner in the league. But he ran the route better than Nicks.
Nicks is moving around like he's a 33 year old wr. Some players just lose it early.
I believe this as well. And when he does it, you will hear the experts here say because he finally had a good QB to throw him the ball and that he was open all year this year.
Its pretty pathetic that one of your top 5 players coming into the year is an absolute dog.
I really think its as simple as that. If he were injured, he wouldn't be playing right now.
i cant even discuss things with you if you arent watching the game. Eli hesistated throwing and then undershot him. He did not have separation on the first deep one... hence you SHOULD NOT throw it and force it against the #1 corner in the league.. and if you do go outside. good lord.
2 hands on the ball while running full speed and the ball being behind you... and the guy with momentum gets it... shocker... and the "2 hands"... i mean come on dude. give me a break.
How could he not be motivated in his contract year?
I believe that because of that fact, Nicks was not the threat he once was for this offense and it had a ripple effect on the whole offense/team.
his teammates know he is bitching out as does the NFL exec boys club. the time tested way to get paid if u are an elite player like nicks is all in, work hard, block out everything else and focus on football. biggest year of your life.
he's butchered it and when he clears head he will never forgive himself! u have to wonder how much blame JR Rickert deserves too. is it quality advice??
i cant even discuss things with you if you arent watching the game. Eli hesistated throwing and then undershot him. He did not have separation on the first deep one... hence you SHOULD NOT throw it and force it against the #1 corner in the league.. and if you do go outside. good lord.
2 hands on the ball while running full speed and the ball being behind you... and the guy with momentum gets it... shocker... and the "2 hands"... i mean come on dude. give me a break.
I know Nicks does no wrong to you. But if you get 1 on 1 matchups, you have to win them. Nicks made 0 play on both deep balls, he kept running straight, and never adjusted. Again, if the ball doesnt fall right into his lap, he aint catching it.
Amd just because he beat Sherman off the line, doesnt mean he created separation. This just in, Hakeem Nicks is very slow for a WR. Sherman made up the ground within a few steps. Nicks was not open by the time the ball was thrown.
And as far as the other INT, again - it goes back to my point where unless he is hit right in the chest, he aint catching it. Nicks' hands are suppose to be his strength, as they are so big and he is suppose to hold onto everything. And lets stop with this full speed shit, if that was full speed, there are OL who run faster than him.
He dogged it this year. Hakeem Nicks put Hakeem Nicks ahead of the team, which is fine. But stop making excuses for him. He was in position to make plays this yesterday and throughout the year. He didnt. To be honest, I dont care if he leaves and becomes a 2,000 yard receiver. He is not a "Giant". Ill take Dez's immaturity over Nicks selfish attitude any day of the week.
How could he not be motivated in his contract year?
Well, who are we talking about here? We can eliminate the likes of Tim Carter or Sinorice Moss because they just weren't any good. Smith's career imploded because he was physically ruined. Post-prison Plax was 34 and had missed two full seasons of football. Toomer was was old and finished. Essentially, you're talking about one guy - Manningham.
But many immediately blame a lack of effort for every throw to him that goes wrong. The int over the middle yesterday was a great play by the DB and the throw didn't lead Nicks to where he could catch it and not the DB.
On the int in the end zone, the DB had perfect position and Nicks' hands are higher than those of the DB. Nicks says he jumped too soon.
Bottom line is Nicks won't be back and finding his replacement will be the highest draft priority.
He's still young and still has good seasons under his belt. He's getting paid next year because of that and not being injured this year (a known injury).
I don't see how that can be disputed. People look for fancy answer all the time, sometimes its a simple as a guy looking out for himself. That is what I believe is the case.
But many immediately blame a lack of effort for every throw to him that goes wrong. The int over the middle yesterday was a great play by the DB and the throw didn't lead Nicks to where he could catch it and not the DB.
On the int in the end zone, the DB had perfect position and Nicks' hands are higher than those of the DB. Nicks says he jumped too soon.
Bottom line is Nicks won't be back and finding his replacement will be the highest draft priority.
I think Eli, with good reason, is this years whipping boy. Its only been lately people have gotten on Nicks.
But drafting a WR early is going to be interesting. Watkins, Lee, and Evans. Are any of them worth that high of a 1st round grade, and will they make a difference?
(1) OVER Richard Marshall;
(2) Or out of bounds!
I think maybe the same could be said of the first INT as well.
i mean make a play man! great job.
I dont defend Nick's production. I defend the BS that comes out of your posts and others who act like this guy gives zero effort and cant ever get open. its simply not the case. hes had a down and disappointing year but if there are 8 big reasons our offense stinks he is about #8.
LG, C, RG, LT, TE, QB, O coordinator are LIGHT years ahead of the few plays that nicks has botched that he realistically had a shot of completing. realistic means not by your judgement
i mean make a play man! great job.
I dont defend Nick's production. I defend the BS that comes out of your posts and others who act like this guy gives zero effort and cant ever get open. its simply not the case. hes had a down and disappointing year but if there are 8 big reasons our offense stinks he is about #8.
LG, C, RG, LT, TE, QB, O coordinator are LIGHT years ahead of the few plays that nicks has botched that he realistically had a shot of completing. realistic means not by your judgement
Let me ask you this...
Ifguys like Megatron, Marhsall, Jeffrey, bryant, Green, Jones, and other WRs are given 1-1 opportunities, do you think their QB throws it to them and gives them a chance to make a play. Id say they do it MULTIPLE times a game. Good to great WRs make plays. The ball doesnt fall in their lap for all their catches. They outjump, they outmuscle, they outwork, and they get separation to make catches. You think Hakeem Nicks does that? Not even close. He stops on routes, he runs routes half speed.
If Eli doesnt throw it in his chest, he cant catch it. And if Eli would only throw it to him when he is open, he would get 1-2 target a game. HE had 5 targets yesterday that resulted in 3 INTs which he could not get open on. His production is so bad, that many believe we need to take a WR with a top 10 pick this year.
You dont think that a problem? Of course not. Hakeem Nicks has been the biggest disappointment in skilled players in the NFL this year. But hey, at least he still smiles in a blowout!
(1) OVER Richard Marshall;
(2) Or out of bounds!
I think maybe the same could be said of the first INT as well.
I dont disagree with this analysis. But again, it comes back to watching other games around the league. There are many WRs who have less talent that just make better plays on the ball and do a better job of getting open. The point is Nicks doesnt separate on routes, cant out run DBs, and cant out jump them on 1-1 situations.
The real question is, why is he even playing?
Quote:
tons of chances to make plays yesterday... underthrown jump ball, underthrown crossing route, and late and underthrown fade route.
i mean make a play man! great job.
I dont defend Nick's production. I defend the BS that comes out of your posts and others who act like this guy gives zero effort and cant ever get open. its simply not the case. hes had a down and disappointing year but if there are 8 big reasons our offense stinks he is about #8.
LG, C, RG, LT, TE, QB, O coordinator are LIGHT years ahead of the few plays that nicks has botched that he realistically had a shot of completing. realistic means not by your judgement
Let me ask you this...
Ifguys like Megatron, Marhsall, Jeffrey, bryant, Green, Jones, and other WRs are given 1-1 opportunities, do you think their QB throws it to them and gives them a chance to make a play. Id say they do it MULTIPLE times a game. Good to great WRs make plays. The ball doesnt fall in their lap for all their catches. They outjump, they outmuscle, they outwork, and they get separation to make catches. You think Hakeem Nicks does that? Not even close. He stops on routes, he runs routes half speed.
If Eli doesnt throw it in his chest, he cant catch it. And if Eli would only throw it to him when he is open, he would get 1-2 target a game. HE had 5 targets yesterday that resulted in 3 INTs which he could not get open on. His production is so bad, that many believe we need to take a WR with a top 10 pick this year.
You dont think that a problem? Of course not. Hakeem Nicks has been the biggest disappointment in skilled players in the NFL this year. But hey, at least he still smiles in a blowout!
Well said dep(for once!!). Top WR's make plays on bad thrown balls more often than not. Nicks hasn't come close to making a play this year. I believe he's fully capable though. That smiling at the end of the game annoyed the crap out of me.
Quote:
He has not played well, that is obvious. He has played through injury in the past, and has been a solid guy. Nobody here knows his frame of mind or his physical condition, and how either impacts his play.
But many immediately blame a lack of effort for every throw to him that goes wrong. The int over the middle yesterday was a great play by the DB and the throw didn't lead Nicks to where he could catch it and not the DB.
On the int in the end zone, the DB had perfect position and Nicks' hands are higher than those of the DB. Nicks says he jumped too soon.
Bottom line is Nicks won't be back and finding his replacement will be the highest draft priority.
I think Eli, with good reason, is this years whipping boy. Its only been lately people have gotten on Nicks.
But drafting a WR early is going to be interesting. Watkins, Lee, and Evans. Are any of them worth that high of a 1st round grade, and will they make a difference?
It's always about Eli with you. Both Nicks and Eli have played poorly, but only Nicks gets called out for lack of effort/desire. I don't pretend to get in these guys' heads. Football is a damn tough & dangerous way to make a good living, so I try not to question a player's courage etc.
but you cant make bad throws become good throws. if you believe that he should have prevented those picks yesterday... ill give you maybe 1... the first one where his timing was terrible and the DB was in PERFECT position as a bad ball. the 2nd short one laws of physics tell you the defender gets it. and the last one he beat the guy the throw was late and the defender popped it up. it was a good play against a terrible throw.
nicks has not been good, ive never said that. but you cant make bad throws good throws. these are not 50/50 balls.
Many analysis, WRs, and coaches would disagree 110% on this. Watch other WRs in the league. A lot of them make bad throws into big plays.
The players and teams understand that this is a business and a job. The fans do not.
Sure, his gigantic $30 million guaranteed money payday is probably over, but $20 million is certainly in the realm still as long as he isn't injured.
I believe that Nicks' problems this year go way beyond injuries and a bad offense. I believe he was most concerned with staying healthy going into a contract year. I also believe that he is upset with the Giants for not signing him and giving him the security he wants. Especially after Cruz got paid.
I believe that going into the offseason, Nicks has a better chance to see a bigger contract if he's healthy coming off of a down year as opposed to getting hurt again.
I believe that teams and players understand that this is a business decision and while it will hurt his next contract, there will be a team willing to pay him as a top WR. He probably won't get as much as he would have coming off of a good year, but being healthy is more important.
i apologize for slightly invading the thread earlier. bad form. apols.
Nicks has history of not making it thru the season
this year he did
,He had a down year on a lousy team , someone who needs a number 1 receiver is going to pay him $$$
The Tell for me was the first few games where Nicks was dropping balls that hit his hands -
Nicks' mitts are huge , previously the guy did not drop balls that got into his hands - you could see his was not concentrating on the field and he did not care.
Wilson threw a few balls off his back foot up for grabs and the only one picked off was by Rolle..Prince should have had 1 if not 2..
One thing "seems" clear: if so many BBIers have it right, and Nicks is just dogging it out there; protecting himself; conducting a silent protest against the Cruz contract; just sulking and yadda yadda yadda...
...then it is a 100% guarantee he would have been "sat down" already. But the fact that he's still starting should give everyone pause before they rush to judgement on "what the hell is wrong with Nicks?"
This is a bit of a mystery!
Nicks can go screw himself.
I also think his pride took a big last offseason when all the talk was about needing to resign Cruz.
I've had tried my best to stretch and exercise to avoid injury. Then I'd play my ass off so hard it would shock my team.
If I was also a shitbird (USMC nomanclature) I go on vacation AFTER I had my guaranteed money in the bank.
Why take the year off in 2013? Could he be damaged goods?
Nicks is sulking because Cruz signed a big contract, is Eli's favorite WR and does the salsa.
I like Nicks and appreciate what he did for the Giants in the past. So, I hope he doesn't suffer the same fate that Mario did with his new team.