What past Giants do you with could have a SB victory

Keith Hamilton

Brad Van Pelt. Brian Kelly. Doug Van Horn. Spider Lockhart
Dave Jennings Doug Kotar

Jethe Ahmthtead could've won a Thuper Bowl.

then there would be no Eli to Dilfer comparisons.

There are a lot.. Hilliard was the first who came to mind for me. Loved that dude.

They played well on a lot of bad teams.

Shockey had an SB here (I know he was part of the 2007 team, but he was not part of the SB run & thus, not remembered as such). He was a fan favorite for a few years and had some great games & plays, but the poor manner in which he left makes the bad outweigh the good he brought and we remember him in such a negative manner.

I'm not saying it's not warranted, but I wish he was part of that magical run and that he remained a beloved Giant, despite his multitude of shortcomings.

Victor said.

In comment 11403802 Victor in CT said:

Quote:

Brad Van Pelt. Brian Kelly. Doug Van Horn. Spider Lockhart Dave Jennings Doug Kotar

I'll add John Mendenhall to that list.

I with they all could have won one.

Bob Tucker - my #38 jersey. My mom bought it for me many, many years ago, obviously. He should've been able to enjoy a Super Bowl. In fact, I'd like to think the Maras invited him to one of the past 4.

Sorry about that last q

Hammer. I thought about Shockey and Hampton but since they had a ring I didnt include them

Charles Way also would have been nice to get a ring

Yeah, I'm that old.

In comment 11403838 Rocky369 said:

Quote:

then there would be no Eli to Dilfer comparisons.

Don't you mean Kerry Collins?

In comment 11403813 Enoch said:

Quote:

Jethe Ahmthtead could've won a Thuper Bowl.

I did enjoy this one...

Ike, Jesse and Hammer

...There. I said it.

Life could have been so much different for #21 if he had ring with some diamonds.

Doug Kotar
John Tuggle

Hilliard

Ron Johnson
Earnest Gray

Rodney Hampton. Ike Hilliard.

Fred Dryer
Fran Tarkenton

.

There really is so many

Hampton was on the '90 team. He has a ring.

Rob Carpenter was in uniform. He was critical to the surge that got it started in 1981, it's a shame he wasn't there for the culmination.

and John Mendenhall ... for sure ... Who else? Let's see ... Brad Van Pelt & Brian Kelley ... Also 100% ... Beasley Reece & Terry Jackson ... Andy Headen ... (I don't think he was on the '86 team) ... Earnest Gray ... Jim Clack too!!!

& Keith Hamilton too!!!!

I will say that everyone else previously mentioned deserves it too!!! I've been watching Giants football (good AND bad) since 1977!!! So ... CLEARLY ... I know!!!

disagree with Dave Brown ... mentioned here!!! I also would not mention Danny Kanell ... So there!!!! ;)

Kerry Collins. I really liked him when he first started playing in Carolina and was really excited when the Giants picked him up. I was sick of Brown, Graham, and Kanell.

Of course guys like Hamilton & Armstead, too.

That I didn't watch... definitely John Tuggle

you watched them ... but ... rather ... do you KNOW their history in the NFL!!!!

I loved them but they sucked. I'm glad Tiki didn't win one.

Carpenter, Kelly, Van pelt, felt bad for Mark Haynes, even though he forced the trade. Hammer, sehorn, armstead, Tiki, even Marty schottenhrimer, he was our LBs coach in the 70 s? After the football life program feel so bad for him, seems like a.great guy and coach who just had no luck. Off the subject but I always felt that if Cleveland had beat Denver in 86 it.would have.been a much tougher game.for us in XX1,

.

He and Byron Hunt probably could have started for a lot of teams in that era. Truly a different game back then,

As to the question originally posed Keith Hamilton and Armstead for sure, Phillippi Sparks, Joe Danelo are some more.

He named all the excellent guys who went through the tough times.

Bobby Duhon, Charlie Evans, Vin Clements, Bob Hyland, Richmond Flowers, Ralph Heck

.

.

It would have spared us twenty-three years (and counting) of hearing about how he wouldn't have. It also would have prevented R*y H*ndl*y from even considering the switch to Hostetler the following season.

Most of all. Guy always played to the short string. Died earlier than most just after getting a new house. Stunning athlete. Spider Lockhart . Greg Larson , Pete Case, Jim Clack. Aaron Thomas, and just for Squint's enjoyment-Fran Tarkenton. The Ron Johnson nomination deserves his couplet: Tucker Frederickson. And throw In Bobby Duhon, too.

is the first guy who came to mind - he was really good for a while, but never quite got the amount recognition I thought he deserved.

Those late 90's/early 00's teams weren't the greatest and were really inconsistent. But they had a lot of guys I enjoyed rooting for and would've liked to see have some more success -- Hilliard, Sehorn, Collins, Tiki, Armstead

He carried the Giants offensively for years...retired one year too early...

Brian Kelly.

In comment 11404088 Marty866b said:

Quote:

Hampton was on the '90 team. He has a ring.

oh yeaaaaaaaah. Wow I forgot.

remember his big blitz against Montana to end "The Comeback." Giants need players like Headen
ah - ( New Window )

iirc he looked good early and then was injured for most of the season. Fortunately, the Giants had OJ Anderson

and nothing against the Coughlin-Eli era, but i loved those smash-mouth Parcells teams

.

In comment 11403843 NJGiantFan84 said:

Quote:

Shockey had an SB here (I know he was part of the 2007 team, but he was not part of the SB run & thus, not remembered as such). He was a fan favorite for a few years and had some great games & plays, but the poor manner in which he left makes the bad outweigh the good he brought and we remember him in such a negative manner. I'm not saying it's not warranted, but I wish he was part of that magical run and that he remained a beloved Giant, despite his multitude of shortcomings.

He was (is) an asshole. And he was the real reason they lost to SF, dropping an easy TD that would have buried the Niners. Of course, he won the water and ice throwing contest with their equally stupid fans.

Armstead, Hampton, Way, Jennings, Tiki, Van Pelt

.