I'm wondering whether the Giants, especially after signing two OGs in the offseason, would be willing to reshuffle the entire OL were we to bring Lewan in to play OT.
It seems to me that:
1) Lewan could either play LT, with Beatty sliding to RT and Pugh moving to LG; or
2) Lewan takes over RT with Pugh moving to LG; or
3) Sitting Beatty, and letting Lewan and Pugh man the OT spots. I think this option is absolutely a non-starter for them.
But does it seem to you like the Giants would be willing to move Pugh inside when he's proven to be a highly competent OT who will likely only get better as he gains more experience and weight?
What say you? And I'm not asking for your opinion about what they SHOULD do as much as your opinion about what the Giants are likely to do.
Lewan would be a stud at RT.
That would be goal.
Quote:
on IR which means he won't be available until week 9 at the soonest?
Haven't heard that.
Either had I. It's in this post:
x meadowlander : 12:31 pm : link : reply
Lots of talk about Beatty starting the season on IR, and even if he wasn't, last years performance is worthy of giving someone else a shot. Really, drafting Lewan or another top tackle would go a long way toward restoring the offense. Would give the OL quality Depth that has been lacking for years.
Plus this is the same team that trotted out a horrible Diehl for 3 seasons. I highly doubt they give up on Beatty after one bad year. Especially with the salary he is receiving .
And it is looking like they will take a center in this draft. Though I wonder how they view Mosley, Pugh and even Herman. I think Pugh is wasted at center.
I wonder if a playmaker is too much for them to pass up. And I include Donald in what they view as a playmaker.
If Beatty struggles or is still injured:
Lewan to LT; Pugh to RT; Snee to RG
If Beatty struggles or is still injured:
Lewan to LT; Pugh to RT; Snee to RG
What would you be doing with Snee in your scenario?
I doubt he'd be IRed as he'll start camp on the PUP list no doubt ... then decision time would come as late as the final 53 cut ... like 5 months from now ... very far in the future to guess his condition then ...
That better?
Why is that?
Schwartz is Snee's successor at RG this year or next.
Quote:
Beatty at LT; Lewan at RT; Pugh at RG
If Beatty struggles or is still injured:
Lewan to LT; Pugh to RT; Snee to RG
What would you be doing with Snee in your scenario?
Riding the pine. I know Coughlin loves him (being family and all), but he hasn't earned the right to start anymore. He's not the player he once was
Ah, a man of reason.
BBI explodes blaming Reese for a bad pick
That better?
Says who? Any links, articles, sources to such a claim?
I'd believe maybe he starts camp on PUP, but even that I think is worst case.
There are two assumptions being made here: One, that Beatty won't be ready for the season. I don't know who is supposedly discussing it, but he's going to be ready for camp. Second, that it is automatic that the Great Wolverine is going to step in and beat out an experienced NFL tackle. Not happening, no matter how much of this year's whipping boy Beatty might be.
I think the phrase "start of the season" has led a lot of people to believe he won't be ready for the start of training camp. Then those people leaped to the conclusion he'll be on PUP or IR, and posted about that. And then other people posted about their posts, because now they have heard other people say stuff, and it becomes a self-perpetuating rumor mill.
But I don't think the Giants have said whether they expect Beatty to be ready to take the field in training camp. I don't think they've even said whether he'll be at OTAs, have they? I know the Giants are really close-mouthed about some injuries, but I want to hear from the organization before I draw any conclusions.
He didn't, but he played Guard in the Senior Bowl and did well. That and the obsession over his arm length leads people to say he's a better fit at Guard.
By nobody?
Giants won't go for him in one. He might not even be a starter,
The math: If Evans, Lewan, and Donald are all gone see if we can trade down with Baltimore or Pitt and then take Martin.
BINGO
GOT TO look at more games...
Pugh was solid last year, but lets not pretend we're risking messing up Orlando Pace's career or something by moving him inside.
Repeat procedure. I leave it to yuuz guys on the who of it.
Beatty was never great, & has had injury issues, but until 2013 he wasnt awful either. Collectively, everybody blocking sucked... the entire OL, the TEs, and at times the RBs too. That made everything (collectively and individually) worse.
I dont expect Beatty & Pugh to give up their jobs so willingly. If Giants draft Lewan, & IF he's ready and able to push Beatty/Pugh, what to do with them is a great problem to have... no matter what/how, the Giants will have a considerably better OT tandem/OL than they did in 2013.
I'm way short on free time this year with the new wine just having hit the market...
LT Beatty
LG Schwarz
C Pugh - mentioned as a possibility when drafted
RG Snee
RT Lewan