mike freeman & #8207;@mikefreemanNFL 6m
Source tells me Josh Freeman will work out next week for the Giants. Maybe as early as Tuesday. He recently visited the Bears.
freeman has proved that he can be successful,whereas painter has been a p.o.s. on the field since he's been in the pros.but to be honest,i'd rather have carr back.
Freeman played like crap against us in Minny, but let's be honest - he'd been on the team for something like what, 6 days? Then he didn't get to play again?
I think this is a kid who showed some real talent, regressed under Schiano, and who could be developed to be at least a competent backup in this league, if not a league-average starter.
When a guy who they formerly had a positive scouting report on has a huge fall from grace, they bring him in for a look if they can. Usually, nothing comes of it. I guess Kerry Collins is the best example of it going well.
Freeman played really well against the Giants in the 2012 NYG-TB game.
Why not bring back Carr? Freeman is a train wreck.
Why would you rather bring back a used up never-been like Carr? At least Freeman has potential that was squandered by a useless head coach. It's a smart move to see if he is salvageable...
second season. That year he threw 25 touchdowns and only 6 interceptions. Now he obviously has not played anywhere near that the past two years but he has much more talent than Painter. Perhaps sitting behind Eli and seeing how hard he works and prepares will help him immensely. Worst case scenario is that it makes the preseason a little more exciting.
He can start in a pinch and is certainly better than Painter. However I don't think he can be a full-time starter, and I thought this even during his 1 good season.
Reese's to-do list is to upgrade their backup QB slot. While you have every confidence that Eli should be fine after the surgery and will be ready to go this year, you need to keep in mind that he's now 33 years old and took a beating last year. The Giants have been incredibly lucky the past few years in his string of health. They have gotten away with guys like Jared Lorenzen and Anthony Wright as a backup, and last year Painter as well.
Depending on how Nassib has developed (and now he's got to learn a new offense as well), the Giants would be better served to get a veteran in here as a backup who is an upgrade over Painter and let them compete. If nothing else, they might need to rest Eli during mini camps with that ankle so you need someone to throw the ball and help the rest of the team work in McAdoo's offense as well.
Freeman is a guy with a lot of talent, a big strong arm, but by all accounts he was lazy as hell. I'm sure the Giants have their own reports and could just as well give Sullivan a call to get his thoughts on him. Maybe the lightbulb will go on after his release last year. Either way, it would be a smart move to look around for something better than Curtis Painter.
I would 100% take Freeman as a backup. He'd be better than anything we've had behind Eli since he's been the starter by a fair margin.
And stop with the Vikings stuff. They signed the guy and Frazier was forced to throw the guy out there knowing only about 1/4 of the playbook. He was basically winging it and had no idea where any of his WR's were going. He did miss a lot of throws but it is what it is.
Reese has been offered a pick for Nassib and they are trying to secure a viable backup if g-d forbid Eli has a set back. One of the Espn analysts had Nassib going in the first round of the draft.
but would love to see him and Nassib duke it out for the #2. Do we keep 3 QBs again this year? Is Eli in the stage of his career where he is no longer iron-man? Problem is a 3rd QB holds down another roster spot we can't afford to give up too!
you guys are focused on giving him a pass for his 'effort' against us last year only one week on his new team - which is fine - ....but you've completely omitted all the reports about just how bad his work ethic was as a member of the Vikings. Just do a google search.
There is a reason a team well out of contention didnt consider starting him again the rest of the season even as Ponder & Cassell continued to show week-after-week that neither was the answer.
Ralph Vacchiano @RVacchianoNYDN 14m
Josh Freeman may not be the only vet QB the Giants workout in the near future. They have also reached out to free agent QB Matt Flynn.
Great potential- if developed. TC could work wonders with this kid. He is not at the end of a career; he's still at the beginning. He ran into problems at the same time the entire Bucs Organization did. That speaks volumes. He could beat out Painter throwing with his other arm. He needs a good supporting staff and good coaching, and a wake up kick in the ass. Unfortunately for him, he would be coming to a team in transition with unknowns in many respects. But he is worth a look.
If he displays that work ethic here, he's gone. No harm, no foul. But his physical tools make it more worth an investment of time and coaching than a nobody like Painter...
You don't remember the numerous arguments on here in Freeman's first two years? I believe it was started do to an espn poll that had freeman ranked higher then Eli. And a good amount of posters piled on. And they weren't all trolls. I don't keep tabs on handles.
I'm sure the new OC has said Eli just doesn't fit his offense and Flynn and Freeman will battle it out, not to mention the twenty million to fill out the roster.
you guys are focused on giving him a pass for his 'effort' against us last year only one week on his new team - which is fine - ....but you've completely omitted all the reports about just how bad his work ethic was as a member of the Vikings. Just do a google search.
There is a reason a team well out of contention didnt consider starting him again the rest of the season even as Ponder & Cassell continued to show week-after-week that neither was the answer.
I'm assuming if the Giants wind up signing him, they've done their due diligence and have reason to believe it won't continue to be an issue going forward. If it is, he's gone. I'd think a guy like Josh Freeman probably has to realize sooner than later that he's running out of chances and that he'd be best served by putting in the work to be a good player again.
Ability-wise, he's a big upgrade over the Curtis Painters of the world. If he can get his head on straight, that's a backup QB you can actually win a couple games with god-forbid Eli gets hurt.
I'd like for it to work out. If the Giants determine that his work ethic is still in question and opt not to sign him, so be it.
You don't remember the numerous arguments on here in Freeman's first two years? I believe it was started do to an espn poll that had freeman ranked higher then Eli. And a good amount of posters piled on. And they weren't all trolls. I don't keep tabs on handles.
All I remember is the righteous indignation that Eli was too low, but he has always had a cadre of haters I guess...
Bart Hubbuch @HubbuchNYP 4m
If the Giants are suddenly looking at Josh Freeman and Matt Flynn, it's not just as camp arms. Sounds like there is real concern about Eli.
to have an actual QB as a backup - whether it's Freeman or Flynn I don't care too much. Eli has been remarkably durable, but injuries are unpredictable. One of these guys could come in and play and potentially not be terrible.
Flynn would be the optimal backup. Solid, but no threat to Eli.
Flynn knows what they ran in GB.. we aren't running GB's offense. It may have some of the same elements but I don't know why every time a Packer player comes up, someone inevitably mentions that they "already know the offense."
for camp arms isn't as urgent sine the development of the truncated camp schedules I said this earlier in the Spring & I think it still should be considered. Eli's at the point in his career where he should take nothing for granted. If one of these guys, including Nassib, shows Reese something , change at QB could come in 15. These guys cut Phil Simms. Reese is an unsentimental prick. Could happen
Flynn knows what they ran in GB.. we aren't running GB's offense. It may have some of the same elements but I don't know why every time a Packer player comes up, someone inevitably mentions that they "already know the offense."
that's a good point arc. TC has said that it is a "new offense" that will incorporate both KGs and BMs. We'll see
If there IS "real" concern over Eli, it might just as well be how much longer he wants to play vs whether or not he'll bounce back well from this arthroscopic ankle procedure IMO.
Eli has at times struck me as a guy that could "walk away" easily enough whenever he feels the time is right. And the right time for him may not be, like Peyton, chasing every single career statistical passing record there is. He already has his 2nd ring. If Eli should get a 3rd ring, I can see him and TC walking out the door hand in hand.
According to their wonderlic scores, Eli is the smarter of the 2 brothers...
All I can think of is how much the Bucs wanted to unload Freeman and how thrilled I was when we played the Vikes later in the season and had to face Freeman. He was absolutely awful overthrowing receivers constantly. He's also got a pretty high opinion of himself. I, for one, don't want him.
QB in the meeting room to go over stuff with, as well. Someone that has been there when the bullets were flying. Painter, to me, is the guy who should be camp fodder. Freeman and Flynn both have some pelts. Nassib may still need fine tuning before he would be given the keys to the car. This is a good thing and is not an indictment of Eli's play or injury.
Has sucked the last two years with numbers which are very close to Freeman like numbers when being a full time starter. In fact their career numbers are very similar except for the years played let's not act like Eli is godly ok.
He must be involved with Quinn in the blackmail of Tom Coughlin...
what does that say about Nassib if he is behind him. Yikes
Here's what it says: painter is there to be a human shield because nassib is a rookie and not prepared to play. That's it. It's not a referendum on nassib's potential or painters talent,
Freeman is known as a lazy bum. Doesn't want to put in the time or work. Not really what you want with your backup.
You don't think Josh Freeman is better than Curtis Painter, David Carr, Jared Lorenzen, etc? I sure do. It's fair to question his work ethic but he's much more talented than guys like that and quite frankly it's not even that close.
see if a little mentoring from Father Tom helps this kid's head on straight.
And if not he's gone. Absolutely no risk and there's nothing not to like about the move. Unless of course you have an unhealthy attachment to a bully failure of a coach just because he coached your college team...
I can never figure out the objection to these low risk moves
Eli is going to be coming off of surgery. That means they need QB's for OTA's and minicamp, let alone training camp if there is any sort of setback with Eli.
These two QB's, Freeman and Flynn, both have experience in aspects of the Giants offense. Freeman played under Sullivan, and Flynn came from the Packer variant of the WCO.
They may be looking for guys that can hit the ground running to help get them through the offseason, in addition to the goal of providing competition and extra arms in camp.
While Eli is limited, you still have to get work to your other skill players. QB's that have at least some idea of what you're trying to do help you get that.
Wait... Eli has only thrown 21 picks over the past 2 years. I challenge that. I bet its double.
But he's still a lot better than Freeman. Two superbowl rings aside (which... is kind of a big deal), at least he's not a grade A lazy asshole like Freeman is.
Yes......... Yes he can
I think this is a kid who showed some real talent, regressed under Schiano, and who could be developed to be at least a competent backup in this league, if not a league-average starter.
Am I remembering this correctly?
The last time Carr looked like a pro QB was 10 years ago. Freeman has had a couple of decent to pretty good seasons in the last 5 years.
I'd be worried if Painter were starting on the local high school's JV squad.
Freeman played really well against the Giants in the 2012 NYG-TB game.
Why would you rather bring back a used up never-been like Carr? At least Freeman has potential that was squandered by a useless head coach. It's a smart move to see if he is salvageable...
He still has some speed.
Depending on how Nassib has developed (and now he's got to learn a new offense as well), the Giants would be better served to get a veteran in here as a backup who is an upgrade over Painter and let them compete. If nothing else, they might need to rest Eli during mini camps with that ankle so you need someone to throw the ball and help the rest of the team work in McAdoo's offense as well.
Freeman is a guy with a lot of talent, a big strong arm, but by all accounts he was lazy as hell. I'm sure the Giants have their own reports and could just as well give Sullivan a call to get his thoughts on him. Maybe the lightbulb will go on after his release last year. Either way, it would be a smart move to look around for something better than Curtis Painter.
He must be involved with Quinn in the blackmail of Tom Coughlin...
And stop with the Vikings stuff. They signed the guy and Frazier was forced to throw the guy out there knowing only about 1/4 of the playbook. He was basically winging it and had no idea where any of his WR's were going. He did miss a lot of throws but it is what it is.
I'd take him in a second.
I know we have a new OC now, but I'm sure we're adding the new wrinkles while using our offense as the base.
I don't recall anyone on BBI making that claim. Please name them.
There is a reason a team well out of contention didnt consider starting him again the rest of the season even as Ponder & Cassell continued to show week-after-week that neither was the answer.
Josh Freeman may not be the only vet QB the Giants workout in the near future. They have also reached out to free agent QB Matt Flynn.
And counting ...
There is a reason a team well out of contention didnt consider starting him again the rest of the season even as Ponder & Cassell continued to show week-after-week that neither was the answer.
I'm assuming if the Giants wind up signing him, they've done their due diligence and have reason to believe it won't continue to be an issue going forward. If it is, he's gone. I'd think a guy like Josh Freeman probably has to realize sooner than later that he's running out of chances and that he'd be best served by putting in the work to be a good player again.
Ability-wise, he's a big upgrade over the Curtis Painters of the world. If he can get his head on straight, that's a backup QB you can actually win a couple games with god-forbid Eli gets hurt.
I'd like for it to work out. If the Giants determine that his work ethic is still in question and opt not to sign him, so be it.
All I remember is the righteous indignation that Eli was too low, but he has always had a cadre of haters I guess...
If the Giants are suddenly looking at Josh Freeman and Matt Flynn, it's not just as camp arms. Sounds like there is real concern about Eli.
that's a good point arc. TC has said that it is a "new offense" that will incorporate both KGs and BMs. We'll see
Eli has at times struck me as a guy that could "walk away" easily enough whenever he feels the time is right. And the right time for him may not be, like Peyton, chasing every single career statistical passing record there is. He already has his 2nd ring. If Eli should get a 3rd ring, I can see him and TC walking out the door hand in hand.
According to their wonderlic scores, Eli is the smarter of the 2 brothers...
Eli: 32 Games started; 638 comp; 1087 att; 58.7 comp; 7766 yds; 44 TDs; 21 INTs
Freeman: 20 Games started; 369 comp; 705 att; 48.9 comp; 4826 yds; 29 TDs; 21 INTs
Which definition of close are you using?
He must be involved with Quinn in the blackmail of Tom Coughlin...
what does that say about Nassib if he is behind him. Yikes
Quote:
miught be the worst QB I have ever seen..
He must be involved with Quinn in the blackmail of Tom Coughlin...
what does that say about Nassib if he is behind him. Yikes
Here's what it says: painter is there to be a human shield because nassib is a rookie and not prepared to play. That's it. It's not a referendum on nassib's potential or painters talent,
However, he's also proven to be a lazy pro athlete which has attributed to his downfall.
I wouldn't trust this guy.
You don't think Josh Freeman is better than Curtis Painter, David Carr, Jared Lorenzen, etc? I sure do. It's fair to question his work ethic but he's much more talented than guys like that and quite frankly it's not even that close.
And if not he's gone. Absolutely no risk and there's nothing not to like about the move. Unless of course you have an unhealthy attachment to a bully failure of a coach just because he coached your college team...
It's almost like the hand wringing over the 7th rounder for Beason.
These two QB's, Freeman and Flynn, both have experience in aspects of the Giants offense. Freeman played under Sullivan, and Flynn came from the Packer variant of the WCO.
They may be looking for guys that can hit the ground running to help get them through the offseason, in addition to the goal of providing competition and extra arms in camp.
While Eli is limited, you still have to get work to your other skill players. QB's that have at least some idea of what you're trying to do help you get that.
Say WUT?!?
#ULTI-MONGO
Quote:
Numbers are very close to Freeman the last two years so not sure if this is a good or bad move.
Eli: 32 Games started; 638 comp; 1087 att; 58.7 comp; 7766 yds; 44 TDs; 21 INTs
Freeman: 20 Games started; 369 comp; 705 att; 48.9 comp; 4826 yds; 29 TDs; 21 INTs
Which definition of close are you using?
Wait... Eli has only thrown 21 picks over the past 2 years. I challenge that. I bet its double.
But he's still a lot better than Freeman. Two superbowl rings aside (which... is kind of a big deal), at least he's not a grade A lazy asshole like Freeman is.
Quote:
Numbers are very close to Freeman the last two years so not sure if this is a good or bad move.
Eli: 32 Games started; 638 comp; 1087 att; 58.7 comp; 7766 yds; 44 TDs; 21 INTs
Freeman: 20 Games started; 369 comp; 705 att; 48.9 comp; 4826 yds; 29 TDs; 21 INTs
Which definition of close are you using?
Eli threw 27 picks last year and 15 in 2012. Step your fuckin' game up, kid.