To start off, I like the top half of our draft. all the picks make sense and seem to be solid players. I like the production on all. But looking at our rosters depth chart, the OT position is frightening. I can't get that JAllen sack out of my head -- Beaty was atrocious at times and now coming off an injury -- and there's no one behind him. Pugh was great, but again an injury and we have nothing. I'm shocked we didn't select anyone in the last 3 picks nor pick up any free agents. I pray they try to swing a trade or get some more free agents in here, because our lack of players are scary.
But I agree with the post overall.
One injury (knock on wood) and things are scary.
I'm hoping for a late solid veteran signing before seasons end.
That's not a ringing endorsement of Brown, but I saw Beatty get his shit pushed in enough before he was injured to have my doubts about his ability.
That's not a ringing endorsement of Brown, but I saw Beatty get his shit pushed in enough before he was injured to have my doubts about his ability.
Beatty: coming off a broken leg, and was terrible in 2013.
Brown: started 13 games for the Saints, but was benched for bad play near the end of the year, and was ultimately released.
Pugh: played LT in college, but has never done it in the NFL.
Brewer isn't playing LT. He only makes the team IMO if we are decimated by injuries. Another of Jerry's projects that I think we're getting away from in the draft. Goodin was actually decent at LT IIRC. He'd probably get the call if something happened to Beatty and/or Brown.
Not sure what we'll get and who we got behind 3 guys (barring injury God forbid) almost guaranteed to make our roster.
Link - ( New Window )
What went wrong and is it fixable?
Don't know what you were seeing, but Diehl was nowhere near Eli.
No one drafted this week has even played in an NFL game.
With the versatility of the O-Linemen the Giants have, I think they can put a better line than last year on the field, even if Snee can't make it back and Beatty is PUP.
Don't forget free agency after June 1.
Quote:
Judge for yourself. Looks to me that Diehl ran by Eli, brushed his arm, and effectively stopped him from moving to his left. Link - ( New Window )
Don't know what you were seeing, but Diehl was nowhere near Eli.
Look again...right before Allen makes his move to grab Eli...Diehl was up on the line, nobody to block, so he turns and runs back to help Pugh, but in doing so he runs by Eli (and I think brushes his right arm) at the same time Eli was about to sidestep to his right to avoid Allen.
One of the messages from passing on Zack Martin in the first is that they feel that Beatty is going to be able to get the job done, and that Brown will be able to do it if for some reason Beatty can't.
And if that all goes to hell, they still have Pugh, John Jerry (who has played some OLT for Miami), and Goodin (who played OLT in college and who filled in very adequately after Beatty got hurt at the end of last season) - assuming the last two make the 53-man roster - to plug in.
So it's not surprising that they didn't draft an OT over the weekend.
Maybe next year.
He broke a leg people.. thats like 8-10 weeks..
The voice of reason from an eminently reasonable poster.
They paid Beatty they need to give him the shot. If he fails I hope they are quick to put Pugh in at LT. We may never have a chance at a 1st round tackle again. I know Pugh is developing at RT but Pettigout and Diehl followed the same career path. Hopefully Pugh does the same as a RT is easier to find then a franchise LT. But best case is Beatty rebounds and we're set. Lewan has bust risk and they must have viewed Martin as a guard only. Matthews would have been ideal but never happening.
Martin would have solved the problem, but then we wouldn't have a potential game changer at WR in Beckham. Can't have everything.
I so wanted Juwuan James in the 2nd, which would have allowed us the flexibility to move Pugh to LT if the need arose, but he went at 19 after having been considered a 3rd rounder a few months ago. That kid would have been great for us. But then we'd have needed a C at a later stage of the draft...musical chairs.