I have a promotion in the works to move from ATL to NYC. I have no idea where to move. Is it worth it to live in like Hoboken and commute in with getting taxed the from NJ on top of NY State, and NYC. Or just live in a commutable borough of Long Island or the city? Any tips are much appreciated.
Hoboken is a great town, affordable, and quicker to get to some parts of the city than if you were to live in brooklyn or even the upper east side.
There is no (or almost no) double taxation.
It really comes down to how much you will be making and are willing to spend. Hate to be that blunt and not asking for you to diverge that info, but honestly, that's the majority of where your decision will come from.
I hate commuting. So i'll pay more to not have to.
Grew up in that area, and unfortunately sea streak wouldn't work since my office is 2 blocks from Penn Station. The biggest issue is my 2 pups. Not sure where I can live with them involved!
And if you're looking for more space, Jersey City may be an option, as you can still catch the path to 33rd from there.
I live in Manhattan now (Harlem, specifically). If you're working in Manhattan, living in the borough is great. I love having the greatest city in the world right outside my doorstep. If you're interested in living in Manhattan, I'd suggest restricting your search to areas where you can either walk to work (unlikely if you work in or near midtown) or get to work using a single subway (no transfers). I'd also suggest, instead of just picking a neighborhood based on what other people recommend, to take a quick weekend trip up here and spend the weekend walking around various neighborhoods to get a feel for what they're like.
But if you don't absolutely *have* to live in Manhattan, instead of just assuming Hoboken is the right place to live (I don't know anyone who lives in Hoboken so I can't say either way), it's worth considering Queens. You'll be able to afford a nicer place in Queens than in Manhattan (and large sections of Brooklyn are similarly priced to Manhattan), if you're into good food Queens has the sort of scene you'd expect from the most ethnically diverse urban area on the planet, the commute into Manhattan can be very straightforward depending on where you live, etc. I changed boroughs because our move allowed us to live walking distance from my brother and from my girlfriend's work, and I love my new neighborhood, but the three years I spent in Queens were three of the best years of my life.
tl;dr: Don't move to Long Island, otherwise keep an open mind, and if possible check out various neighborhoods first before narrowing your search - you're more likely to find the right fit that way.
Dogs will be a problem, as is avoiding broker fees. But both can be achieved - I've avoided broker fees by just targeting a neighborhood and walking into buildings to see what's available.
Good luck
Constant cluster fuck is NYC.
Move in, get the fuck out.
Stay in the south, look at Charlotte, Charleston.
Go to the beach on weekends or a walk before work. The quality of life is superior to NYC.
Simply, don't do it.