Joe Morris remembers the conversation between the trainer and coach Bill Parcells. “Bill goes, ‘I need him back in the game.’ And Ronnie just goes, ‘No, he goes into the game when I say he does and when the doc says he does,’” Mr. Morris recounted, still in awe. “Now, you gotta have a set of stones to tell Bill Parcells that.”
Give Reese a do over and let him pick Cordy Glenn and Martin instead of Wilson and Beckham. We would have a great OL and the same skill players we have now.
If only.
RE: Mrvax..good point . I'm guessing though Beckham is due back Â
how good ODB will be. I do know that this year may be a wash for him though. If TC said 2-3 weeks, it may easily be 4-6 since hammies are such an unknown injury. IMO, if he is 99.9% healthy when the bye comes around, I would prefer just to IR him because he isnt in playing shape, he doesnt know the offense, his timing is most likely off.
Not there is anything wrong with a red shirt year for him, but as days go on, my anticipation of him playing this year dwindles.
there is everything wrong with a redshirt year for him. They are Â
not the kind of settled team where that is acceptable. They need high picks to come in and play so that by year end you know they can be solid contributors the next year. If he misses the year then he is just another ? for 2015.
as you go through life and you find yourself agreeing with obvioustrolls like kepler and bossman, you should rethink your stance on a topic.
Who? Me?
I thought my ideas were more realistic than theirs. Coughlin already said 2-3 weeks he will be out for. But sometimes they linger. My point is if he isnt completely healthy, I rather just keep him out. No need to bring him back even with the slightest injury.
If in 3-5 weeks, he is 100% to go and practicing.... then unseat Jerrigan and Randle and go out and be a playmaker.
Begins to sound like the Giants may never be able to rely on this guy -- this season or ever. The comments about the continuing nature (that is, recurrence) of hamstring injuries to WRs are worrisome. Tell me that this is nonsense, please.
Yes. Makes perfect sense. Rookie hurts his hamstring and therefore we will never be able to rely on him. Ever.
It seems reasonable he could get in 7-8 games. That gives him 8-9 weeks to continue healing. He's a talented rookie and getting him that much PT in his rookie year makes it worth having an empty roster spot for half a season.
Instead of bitch and moan about a guy we haven't. I'll be bitching and moaning and if I see Jernigan instead of Washington for one... But not about this dude
Coughlin and Reese were horrified when he dropped every pass thrown to him. Rather than expose him, they told the medical staff to give him improper treatment and will continue to do so and he will never see the field and embarrass Reese.
With really careful, attentive treatment he could come back stronger than ever in 10 months AND maybe he'd never face this problem again. Bringing him back raw in November in the Northeast - just to pacify the fan base or surprise Seattle - would be short-term stupidity.
on another ODB thread, The body responds to strains by creating scar tissue around the area. Its protective in that its the body's cast essentially, but it is mostly inflexible, just like a hard cast. While there are ways to break it down like massage and ultrasound, you never get all of it. Each time he re- aggravates it, more st forms. Thats how it becomes chronic. He's certainly not damaged goods yet, but they need to be very careful with him or he will be.
careful when they do believe he's ready for practice. Maybe they should have him do light weight exercises first? Rather than have him go full bore running a route/cutting etc.
RE: The most troubling thing is that a few posters here have stated that.. Â
I don't think Beckham had chronic hamstring issues at LSU. Posters have made this claim, but it seems every time they are just echoing another poster. Not sure where this idea came from, but I can't find anything corroborating it...at all. He played in every game at LSU except 1. If you had chronic hamstring issues, anything remotely similar to what is going on here he would have certainly missed more than a single game in 3 years time.
I have had a problem with our strength and conditioning program for a while. There is something seriously wrong here. Too many guys getting injuries that are preventable. Too often we see our guys up front get physically dominated.
BTW, I am going to bet that by the time this kid gets healthy, and by the time Coughlin trusts him enough to actually play... he may catch 5 balls this year.
transform themselves into track conditioned athletes for the combines and that does not always transcend to football ready shortly thereafter. Let the kid get healthy and lets see what happens. No culpability on either side.
You can curse me all you want, but I am really doubting the Giants Â
Staff in how they manage injuries. It seems our players always take longer than other teams to get back. I am not a doctor and have no medical expertise, but not to be able to manage a hammy from the beginning of June is problematic in my eyes.
It doesn't have to be about being cheap, the Giants could have incompetent staff. Simply because a doctor is at HSS (warren), doesn't mean he is a good doctor either. Obviously, the odds improve that he is a good doctor coming from a good hospital like that, but one of their alleged best surgeons completely botched my father in laws knee replacement surgery and now he has to get it done again with a small possibility he can lose his leg. The Giants are loyal. I would hope that we would invest heavily in exercise science like the a Eagles do with Kelly.
It doesn't have to be about being cheap, the Giants could have incompetent staff. Simply because a doctor is at HSS (warren), doesn't mean he is a good doctor either. Obviously, the odds improve that he is a good doctor coming from a good hospital like that, but one of their alleged best surgeons completely botched my father in laws knee replacement surgery and now he has to get it done again with a small possibility he can lose his leg. The Giants are loyal. I would hope that we would invest heavily in exercise science like the a Eagles do with Kelly.
If we're finding it open season to criticize the Giants medical staff, I think it's important to recognize that they were dead right about Kenny Phillips, and dead right about Steve Smith when everybody else was going nuts assuming the Eagles knew something the Giants didn't. But somehow they don't know what they're doing managing a hamstring injury?
Phillips you are right about and so were the Giants. Smith was not so much about whether the Giants wanted him back, they did. It was about length of term and that they were messing around with him, so he bolted without them knowing and got a better deal in Philly. Oh, and where do u want to put Wilson? Guy was back five minutes before his career was over.
Anyway, managing and diagnosing are two different things. Never criticized the Giants about diagnosing.
Give Reese a do over and let him pick Cordy Glenn and Martin instead of Wilson and Beckham. We would have a great OL and the same skill players we have now.
is just a hamstring injury and all the stretching and exercise won't prevent it because all these guys have individual training regiments and suggested diets worked out to the tiniest detail. To say the doctor training staff or strength and conditioning team I is to blame is lazy and trying to scapegoat. Shit happens despite all the preventive measures taken for it not to happen
I don't know if it is being lazy or scapegoating. Â
I admit that most fans think that their team is the only team that suffers injury. However, why is it that it seems, and I stress seems, that our guys always get reinjured and have the longest timetables? My friends and I always joke that going on the Giants injured list is like going into a black hole, never to be seen again. I am actually shocked that Beason and Prince will be ready, if I would have bet, I would have bet the house we would not have seen them until week 4.
Anyway, you are right that it could be scapegoating, since fans only react to limited information. However, I am really intrigued by what the Eagles are doing with their exercise science. They had almost no injuries last season, and there guys always come back fast. For instance, Maclin injured a hammy and was out less than a week, Cary Williams injured his hammy in the Chicago in the preseason game and was back the next week. Riley Cooper was in a boot, and was back in two weeks. If they don't suffer injuries again, I think we can't attribute it to luck anymore. I wish we were more avant-garde with our approach is what I am saying (to the extent this stuff is public).
because part of the reason beckham rushed back 2 begin with was all the reports about tom being pissed at him
remember it got 2 the point where beckham actually had 2 go into tom's office and reassure him that he wasnt a flake
couple days later he gets back on the field only to badly reinjure himself
this one stinks and its no surprise tom is distancing himself from it now, as it appears now his reaction to beckham sitting out may have caused the setback in the 1st place
Since he's been here TC has been frustrated with everyone that is rehabbing. He wants them on the field not on bicycles where they do the team no good. The doctors make the call when they can resume practicing no the player and not the coach. If there is one question he hates answering is about rehabbing players
I remember as a kid being angry at Rickey Henderson over his infamous hammy. I still think he was milking it, but I took a whole new perspective on hamstring injuries when I pulled my own. It was a mild pull and I rested for a couple of weeks. It felt good, but my first game of softball (this was post college) I ran in and over to the foul line from LF to haul in a weak pop up and remember I kept running in, flipped the ball to the pitcher and said I was done.
It wasn't really a pull, like the original injury. I just felt a twinge and it felt very tight. This was after a lot of stretching before and during the game. It was several weeks before my leg felt normal, without the even slightest trace of tightness.
After taking a lot of crap for asking the question(except for natefit, who was kind enough to try to answer it), I thought to look into it it myself. For those interested, check out the following as to hamstring injuries: "Recurrence levels are high, ranging from 12% to 63%. The first month after return to play (RTP) is the highest risk time for recurrence, though the risk remains elevated for at least 12 months." This is from http://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2013/02/14/bjsports-2012-091400.full , which goes into the various treatment and rehab options and outcomes, based on a limited amount of available data. See also this "Hamstring strain injuries remain a challenge for both athletes and clinicians given the high incidence rate, slow healing, and persistent symptoms. Moreover, nearly one-third of these injuries recur within the first year following a return to sport, with subsequent injuries often being more severe than the original" from another article. Bottom line for Beckham is he has an uncertain future long term, to say nothing of this year.
Beckham
Percy : 9/1/2014 12:14 pm : link : reply
Begins to sound like the Giants may never be able to rely on this guy -- this season or ever. The comments about the continuing nature (that is, recurrence) of hamstring injuries to WRs are worrisome. Tell me that this is nonsense, please.
Who in the holy fuck types this with a straight face? NOBODY!
Even this moron must look like Munch's The Scream painting.
Hence, any setback (or bringing a player back too early) is the sole fault of the medical staff.
Because they fear TC and Hanlon.
Well played, maestro.
Generally speaking most NE teams have the best medical professionals.
Give Reese a do over and let him pick Cordy Glenn and Martin instead of Wilson and Beckham. We would have a great OL and the same skill players we have now.
If only.
reports are Schwartz will be back within a month temp ir would be dumb if that's the case
Not there is anything wrong with a red shirt year for him, but as days go on, my anticipation of him playing this year dwindles.
Who? Me?
I thought my ideas were more realistic than theirs. Coughlin already said 2-3 weeks he will be out for. But sometimes they linger. My point is if he isnt completely healthy, I rather just keep him out. No need to bring him back even with the slightest injury.
If in 3-5 weeks, he is 100% to go and practicing.... then unseat Jerrigan and Randle and go out and be a playmaker.
Quote:
Begins to sound like the Giants may never be able to rely on this guy -- this season or ever. The comments about the continuing nature (that is, recurrence) of hamstring injuries to WRs are worrisome. Tell me that this is nonsense, please.
Yes. Makes perfect sense. Rookie hurts his hamstring and therefore we will never be able to rely on him. Ever.
Jesus Christ on a cracker.
Thank you. I second.
I don't think Beckham had chronic hamstring issues at LSU. Posters have made this claim, but it seems every time they are just echoing another poster. Not sure where this idea came from, but I can't find anything corroborating it...at all. He played in every game at LSU except 1. If you had chronic hamstring issues, anything remotely similar to what is going on here he would have certainly missed more than a single game in 3 years time.
Yup, this is definitely on Reese. He fuckin knew this kid was gonna tear his hammy multiple times, yet drafted him instead of Martin anyway!
Next man up. Run the ball, play clean, and keep moving forward until the unit gels and gets healthy.
BTW, I am going to bet that by the time this kid gets healthy, and by the time Coughlin trusts him enough to actually play... he may catch 5 balls this year.
If we're finding it open season to criticize the Giants medical staff, I think it's important to recognize that they were dead right about Kenny Phillips, and dead right about Steve Smith when everybody else was going nuts assuming the Eagles knew something the Giants didn't. But somehow they don't know what they're doing managing a hamstring injury?
Anyway, managing and diagnosing are two different things. Never criticized the Giants about diagnosing.
Give Reese a do over and let him pick Cordy Glenn and Martin instead of Wilson and Beckham. We would have a great OL and the same skill players we have now.
Broken record, broken record, broken record, broken record, broken record, broken record, broken record...
Anyway, you are right that it could be scapegoating, since fans only react to limited information. However, I am really intrigued by what the Eagles are doing with their exercise science. They had almost no injuries last season, and there guys always come back fast. For instance, Maclin injured a hammy and was out less than a week, Cary Williams injured his hammy in the Chicago in the preseason game and was back the next week. Riley Cooper was in a boot, and was back in two weeks. If they don't suffer injuries again, I think we can't attribute it to luck anymore. I wish we were more avant-garde with our approach is what I am saying (to the extent this stuff is public).
During the years we had our best offensive lines, from 2006-2010, how many games did those guys miss? Practically nothing.
remember it got 2 the point where beckham actually had 2 go into tom's office and reassure him that he wasnt a flake
couple days later he gets back on the field only to badly reinjure himself
this one stinks and its no surprise tom is distancing himself from it now, as it appears now his reaction to beckham sitting out may have caused the setback in the 1st place
the difference is this one went extremely public 2 the point we were hearing about the player going to the coach to clear the air
btw, if u dont think the player has any say in when he gets on the field, ur kidding urself
It wasn't really a pull, like the original injury. I just felt a twinge and it felt very tight. This was after a lot of stretching before and during the game. It was several weeks before my leg felt normal, without the even slightest trace of tightness.
Percy : 9/1/2014 12:14 pm : link : reply
Begins to sound like the Giants may never be able to rely on this guy -- this season or ever. The comments about the continuing nature (that is, recurrence) of hamstring injuries to WRs are worrisome. Tell me that this is nonsense, please.
Who in the holy fuck types this with a straight face? NOBODY!
Even this moron must look like Munch's The Scream painting.
How many games did he miss in college due to a bad hammy?