Next HC should be a defensive guy.

should be a defensive guy

for changing to a 3-4 defense

I hope we go with a defensive guy as well.

I've mentioned Dan Quinn before.

.

Quinn would be a very good HC and while it will be tough to replace TC he would be a somewhat easier sell in that he's a Jersey guy who grew up a Giants fan with the Parcells teams. He seems opposite of Fewell in the sense that he has a very good rapport with his players and you would hope the constant communication issues on D would end. Unknown however is if Mc Adoo would be comfortable with this as his contract is up after '15..

As fans we get too caught up on which side of the ball the coach is from; We've had 4 straight from the O side but have had good defenses. No one thought Indy would hire a coach from the D side when drafting Luck but they did. I highly doubt though it matters since they won't fire TC nor is he ready to retire but if either occurred you'd;have to give Quinn a long look along with Adam Gase Mc Daniels and Bowels among others..

seriously?

though, i'd say our bowels are full, based on how this team has been playing.

when given his first shot it's quite possible he's matured and earned another shot just like BB got another shot; Plenty in the league believe he'll get another shot' NE doesn't have much talent on O other than the QB and he's done very good work there..

Thanks

but in found one of the threads about Fangio from 2010
Link - ( New Window )

If TC goes, I think Bowles might be someone the Giants will be very interested in.

it's an offensive league, I'd prefer an offensive HC and very strong DC.

I think the defense needs a multi-year overhaul and development of philosophy in order to truly implement a new defense/style, etc.

I really like Bowles. I think he is HC material. He's got lots of ideas, but is flexible, adaptive in terms of what he's got to work with versus what he will be facing.

He's played in the league, can relate to the grind that players face and what they are thinking on the field and this year might be his finest work so far.

Just a lot of pluses. I'm not sold on Quinn. He largely inherited a D that Carroll and Bradley built. It's a D that is not as good as the past few years too.

Fangio is solid as a defensive mind, but he's had a wealth of talent to play with in SF after a pretty nondescript coaching career before heading to coach under Harbaugh at Stanford.

so at least we can have a better idea and not just name people.

a defensive guy is that he may keep and give McAdoo full control of the offense.

and no we dont need to move to a 3-4.. why is it so many people think that a 3-4 defense will be better.

Would be either Spags or Mike Nolan all coaches with Giants connection if we went with a Defensive minded coach.

Sean Payton,if available, if we went offensive.

In comment 11985510 Blue Blood said:

Quote:

and no we dont need to move to a 3-4.. why is it so many people think that a 3-4 defense will be better.

Anything is better at this point. I prefer the 3-4 defense mainly because of linebacker play. Not saying 3-4 is better overall. With the players we currently have I think we are as close to being able to switch to a 3-4 as we have been in over a decade. That isn't saying much though.