Which players are keepers for next year and beyond

it's the coaches.

.

I think he wants a career in broadcasting post NY career.

I'd also add Washington, Harris, Rogers Gaines, maybe Mosley.

else being on the roster going forward, sticking for the long haul.

Frankly, while not rational, if I never saw anyone from the defense that played tonight again in a Giant uniform, I would no shed tears.

Rolle and Thurmond re-sign here.

I don't have high hopes for many of those defensive guys, but I suppose we have to keep some of them.

are the only guys I view as starters on a good defense. Maybe Kennard someday. Rolle hasn't played as well as last year - he's lost a step.

he's a terribly average LT but he'd cost more to cut than it would to keep him next year (you'd lose $8,150,000 in dead money as opposed to paying him $8,050,000)

In comment 11996710 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

Rolle and Thurmond re-sign here.

Eric,
I would really like to know why you see it this way. Rolle has been treated well. Do you know of him personally being fed up with the team? It would be understandable. Is Thurmond fed up?

from a blue jersey, I'm good. Same goes for Fewell, Quinn, Flaherty, Nunn and Hermann.

By the time this team is again 'top drawer' Eli is past his prime and Beckham is a free agent.

OH THE HORROR!!

did John Mara make a statement at the beginning of the 2014 season, that he does not expect to be as active in free agency in 2015 as he was in 2014?

In comment 11996701 kepler20 said:

Quote:

it's the coaches.

It's very likely a combination of the two.

...its all irrelevant.

with the defense. The o looks on the uptick to me, just needs more talent up front.

The D is a goddamn joke. They will always ALWAYS fold in a big spot.


Gotta blow up the D

In comment 11996780 rocco8112 said:

Quote:

with the defense. The o looks on the uptick to me, just needs more talent up front. The D is a goddamn joke. They will always ALWAYS fold in a big spot. Gotta blow up the D

Nothing like the prevent defense to prevent your team from winning the game. Any quarterback (except maybe Dave Brown) could have engineered that last drive with that much time to throw.

Showed me his value on that last drive. Not worth significant cap space. He is not a consistent force to the qb. Rolle is not worth any considerable amout of cash and I would try to resign Thurmond.

In comment 11996780 rocco8112 said:

Quote:

with the defense. The o looks on the uptick to me, just needs more talent up front. The D is a goddamn joke. They will always ALWAYS fold in a big spot. Gotta blow up the D

Agreed. I think the talent with some additions on the OL and WR are on the up.

The Defense is where the majority of the problems are. I do not think the scheme suits what talent is on the roster. The secondary, when healthy, is very solid but the DL, and LB areas are just plain bad.

where I can see how many snaps Giants players played? I see Jay Bromley on this list, but I never hear his name. Not advocating giving up on a 3rd round pick after one season, but I just want to know exactly how much this guy sees the field.
Character was a big plus in drafting him.

Reese and Ross do not have a clue about evaluating talent that will succeed in this league. Until we replace them we will have more of the same. Spending FA $$$ trying to fix problems that should have been addressed in the drafts. Picking up vets who are looking for golden parachute contracts who get hurt shortly after we acquire them. It could get worse before it gets better with this crew making the decisions.

I don't see why he wouldn't re-sign here. Seemed like he was fitting in nicely until his injury.

In comment 11996701 kepler20 said:

Quote:

it's the coaches.

I believe it's mostly on the players. Coaching has it's ups and downs (normal), but they're not the real problem here. It lies on the players imho.