FF: Eli outscored Aaron Rodgers 30.5 to 7.95

and I wondered who you started! Just goes to show you never know whats gonna happen.

listening to our dumbasses.

thanks for thinking 'bout my Ginuts ;>)

In fairness to both sides, it is not an easy decision. I don't think there was a right or wrong answer. I weighed on and I gave a slight edge to Rodgers, and as many probably know, I am definitely a big supporter and believer in Eli.

FF points and scores, I thought about that thread. Sorry it didnt work out for you. I would have went with the bills imo unless there was familiarity between the two teams. Looking at the history of what the bills were doing to teams, it was going to be a tough day.

meant to say, go with eli and not bills

Right or wrong.

For the record, I'm one of the people who said to start Rodgers. I'd give the same advice if you asked, because that's MY belief. Start the better player.

YMMV.

pretty much all said one of the following:
a. I'm insane
b. I'm an idiot
c. I should get off meds
d. I should get on meds
e. All of the above

Giving bad advice since 1995

I told you to start Rodgers and I'd tell you to do the same exact thing every single time. If a similar scenario came up next year, I would say it again.

I also said if you felt strongly enough about Eli, go with Eli.

At the end of the day, when it comes to fantasy football, you should never leave yourself in a position where you make a decision you don't feel confident in because of other people's opinions.

I always look for input on a situation just because I think I can be biased but 99% of the time, I will go with the guy I feel deep down is the best play. I don't like leaving it in the hands of other people. If my team loses, I want it to be because of my decisions.

you wouldn't have the balls to do it and I was correct.

If you told me they would have half their drops for the season yesterday, I may have given you different advice. Actually, I wouldn't have, because I only sit Rodgers if he's not playing.

I've only asked BBI for ff advice 2-3 times and won't be doing it again.

in one league my team is named Squib's G Men. I had Foles as my starting QB, then went to Tannehill when he went down, with Orton as a backup playing matchups. Just before this week for whatever reason, Eli was available on the wire and I grabbed him and started him. I play in a PPR with a lot of bonus points, so Eli got me 44 (Tannehill got 42). It want the difference in my win, but I am happy to have Eli as my QB in the championship game. Squib's G Men gotta roll with Eli. Havent felt good about him since he took my team to the playoffs in 2011.

was leading by 3 points leading into yesterday. Opponent had Stills, and beat me. Best record (by far), and bumped in first round of playoffs.

Still, I couldn't really sit him on the bench...I had no backup QB. I wish I didn't dump Brady earlier in the year, but I probably would have started Rodgers anyway.