Tuck/Boothe

he is like another coach on that team. Great presence for the young players.

On one leg he would've been better than what we had last two years at guard

In comment 12109489 mattlawson said:

Quote:

On one leg he would've been better than what we had last two years at guard

Boothe's work deteriorated his last year here..Would have loved the Boothe of 2011..For that matter, Nicks, JPP and even Cruz as well..

Tuck will eventually come home and retire a Giant. That would be enough for me

You can't retool by picking up 30-somethings. I hope Tuck returns to the Giants - but only to sign a 1-day contract.

.

because of what was playing to the left and right of him....they paid this guy vet min, and then they give 2.5M to Walton who wasn't as good as him?

Boothe was screwed monetarily while he was here....he would have been a good backup for this line......we had injured OLmen, go out there week after week because the backups sitting on their arses sucked.....Boothe would have done the job.....

You don't bring back these players now, you move on.....Tuck will never be the Tuck he once was....Boothe is on the wrong side of 30.....time to start signing players who can play and stay on the field.....

played 16 snaps for the Raiders this year. Was he injured?

In comment 12109591 pjcas18 said:

Quote:

played 16 snaps for the Raiders this year. Was he injured?

Sorry, 19 and they all came week 13.

bringing back ex Giants? Boothe was terrible during his final season here. Did you watch any Raiders games last season? Did you even see how Boothe did? He didn't even start for them he was a backup and barely played.

Nope. They both left for more money than NYG valued them at, turn the page.

But at 32 it's time to move on. He was declining in 2013.

In comment 12109634 Jay on the Island said:

Quote:

bringing back ex Giants?

Familiarity makes for simple solutions.

Let it gooooo

Turn away and slam the door.

had a time machine back to 2011.

letting him go was another NYG Front Office mistake.

But bringing him back probably isn't going to work. The relationship was damaged, and he's not the player he was a few years ago either.

Pass.

Ditto Tuck.

Boothe would be better then Brewer. Tuck would provide part time pass rushing badly needed. That's all I'm considering here.