for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

Tucker and Cosell discuss DE's

Coach Mason : 4/11/2015 1:57 pm
Ross Tucker and Greg Cosell discuss DE's

Another phenomenal job by Mighty Giants over at Big Blue Huddle in transcribing:

This is just exterior rushers, they will do interior defenders next week

Ross started out by suggesting that outside of QB, pass rusher's are perhaps the most important players on the team

Greg thinks it’s a pretty good pass rushing class and that 4 could go in the top 12-15 picks.  He is basing that assessment on just film study, and not off the field issues.  He thinks it’s a particularly good group this year, unlike last year.

Donte Fowler was the guy who the more tape he watched the more he stood out to him.  Thinks he could develop into a Justin Houston type player.  Thinks he could play 3-4 or 4-3.  Thinks he has a lot of explosive traits to work with for a man that size (6’ 2” or 3” 260).  Watching him move at the combine really opened his eyes as well.  After watching 5 or 6 games (the usual number of games he watches on each prospect) the more he liked him.
Ross asked Greg is there a clear number 2 or do they bunch up after that and Greg mentioned Randy Gregory and said he thinks he is a really talented kid.  Greg was really impressed by his flexibility and compared him to Clowney.  He said Clowney is the bigger man but that Gregory was the more flexible athlete.  Went on to say he has really good balance and body control and good movement flexibility (which is needed to rush the QB).   Ross agreed that those “gumby like” players are tough to block and Ross has no idea how some of those guys do it.   Ross then mentioned how people are concerned about Gregory’s weight.   Ross mentioned how he has talked to retired DE Jason Taylor and how Taylor told him he played at between 232 and 245 and often felt his best at 235.    Ross says he sometimes laughs at fan’s concerns about weight as fans don’t know the real weights behind what is listed.  Here was a potential Hall of Fame DE that played his best at 235 pounds (even though he was listed at 250+).  If you got good hands and can lock people out it’s not as much of a concern as people think it should be.  Greg agreed with Ross on this point.

Greg then addressed Shane Ray and Vic Beasley.  Greg described Ray as a Kamikaze player that plays with an unbelievable amount of competitiveness and a bit of nasty.  You can tell watching him that he doesn’t like getting beat and comes back stronger.  Ray is a quick twitch guy with natural explosive traits.   He looked bigger than his listed weight when you watched him on tape.  Greg thinks Ray could line up at DE.  Ray was often moved inside to rush against guards and he killed guards.  Ray has an explosive first step and he uses his hands well and he loves how he plays.  Ross chimed in about some of Ray’s bad numbers at his Pro Day.  Ross said he doesn’t know Ray’s ceiling but that at a minimum he could be a 6 – 9 sack guy and a lot of teams would take that.  Greg added that teams would have to factor in his extreme competitiveness.   Ross agreed and they both talked about Ray having the sort of motor and competitiveness you can’t develop.   Ross said guys don’t develop toughness or competitiveness or a motor, they either have it or they don’t.  Says guys don’t develop a work ethic after they get paid millions of guaranteed dollars.  Greg added that he has talked to many long time scouts who say you can make guys stronger but you can’t make them more athletic.  

Ross then went to Beasley who he has heard mentioned as possibly going to Jacksonville at three.  Greg said with Beasley you are hoping he could become Von Miller.  Greg said he is a quickness, speed, explosion pass rusher. Even though he came in at 245 he is a smaller guy.   His lower body looks like a RB and if you watch him on tape, that’s what he looks like a running back rushing the QB.  He is another guy that can bad the edge that has great hip and body flexibility.  He gets moved sometimes in the run game or if he is stopped on his pass rush. Greg feels he is not as strong as he needs to become but you can make guys stronger but you can’t teach the body flexibility.  With Vic you are dealing with high level flexibility and movement pass rusher.

Ross then tells Greg he heard a negative about Beasley but not Gregory, Fowler or Ray.  Greg countered by saying with Gregory there were too many times where Greg felt he was a beat late off the snap which could negate his speed/quickness advantage.  With Ray he didn’t see negatives on tape but mentioned his testing numbers and his 245 weight and wondered that since he mostly played DE he can do that in the NFL at 245.   Greg then came back to Beasley’s weakness and how he would hold up to the run in the NFL and would be start his career as a situational pass rusher.

Ross and Greg talked about how much tape to watch and Greg says his evaluation stops when he sees the same thing from a player over and over again against different types of opponents.  Greg loves to see good players going head to head like Flowers against Gregory where Flowers couldn’t block him.  Ross chimed in how he can’t see Flowers at LT and he is not sure what people that do are seeing.  

They then discussed Bud Dupree who Ross has heard might go in the top 15 picks.  Greg says he sees Dupree a little differently than others.  He doesn’t think Dupree is a natural or pure pass rusher but that he is incredibly athletic.  He compared Dupree to Jamie Collins  Ross goes back that he is a versatile guy that can do it all.   Greg doesn’t rule out that he could become a good pass rusher but he doesn’t think Dupree has the flexibility that marks the great pass rushers and seems to lack the explosiveness of a pass rusher.  Greg says Dupree won’t go in the top 10 or 12 if people see him the way he does.  

Ross then goes on to say that all the guys mentioned so far all seem to be rated as top picks and then there seems to be a drop off before you get to the next edge rusher.  In this group Ross mentions Eli Harold and Owamagbe Odighizuwa.  Ross asked out of the second tier guys if any of them stood out to Greg.  Greg said Owamagbe Odighizuwa is the most fascinating prospect in the draft to him.  He says Owamagbe Odighizuwa isn’t a top 10 -15 guy but that the athleticism is there.  He is not quite Ziggy Ansah but when you watch him you see a really good athlete with explosive movement traits.  He needs a lot of coaching and refinement but his hands were active and they were fast and heavy which is a positive for a defensive lineman.  You saw him flash speed to power transitions against guys who are going to become NFL tackles.   He mentioned how he got under Jake Fisher’s pads and moved him a couple of times.  Greg says he doesn’t know where he will be drafted because it will be based on what you hope he will become but he thought Owamagbe Odighizuwa was the most intriguing prospect of the next group.  

Ross then asked if there were any sleepers.  Greg mentionedHau'oli Kikaha who he thinks is a really natural pass rusher in terms of hand usage, bend and closing to the QB.  He is not a super twitchy athlete you are not going to watch him and go wow like you would a Vic Beasley but he plays with fanatical effort and determination.  He thinks he is ultimately a 3-4 outside LB.
Link to podcast  
Coach Mason : 4/11/2015 2:03 pm : link
http://www.rosstucker.com/wp/podcasts/ross-tucker-football-podcast/
Quite surprised they didn't talk about Preston Smith  
Coach Mason : 4/11/2015 2:06 pm : link
Who might be one of the best traditional 4-3 edge rushers in the draft.
gregory  
Jesse B : 4/11/2015 2:11 pm : link
Anyone watch that gregory video posted here awhile back that showed gregory rushing with a tackle read (looks like delayed reaction because he is taught to mirror the OL first. It's a conservative run responsibility read first) vs when gregory was allowed to rush with a snap count read (go on Snap).

Ray/Beasley did a lot of snap read but when gregory had them he is very explosive off the snap.

Gregory is the best pass rusher in this class but I doubt the giants taken him. Hope he ends op away from the giants
Great  
AcidTest : 4/11/2015 2:28 pm : link
stuff. Thanks.
I wonder how many on BBI will still say none of them can play 43 DE  
Stupendamatic : 4/11/2015 2:53 pm : link
I had listened to the podcast earlier and that is one heck on a transcript.

I love listening to Cosell, and make an effort to listen to any podcast he's featured on. He doesn't care for much other than what's on the tape and I like that.

RE: gregory  
Stupendamatic : 4/11/2015 2:58 pm : link
In comment 12228864 Jesse B said:
Quote:
Anyone watch that gregory video posted here awhile back that showed gregory rushing with a tackle read (looks like delayed reaction because he is taught to mirror the OL first. It's a conservative run responsibility read first) vs when gregory was allowed to rush with a snap count read (go on Snap).

Ray/Beasley did a lot of snap read but when gregory had them he is very explosive off the snap.

Gregory is the best pass rusher in this class but I doubt the giants taken him. Hope he ends op away from the giants


Yes I had seen it. Put the link below. It opened my eyes to something I never considered when watching DEs.


Link - ( New Window )
Jesse , Stupendamatic  
Coach Mason : 4/11/2015 3:07 pm : link
None of these guys seem like the 'perfect' model of what the Giants go for for a pure 4-3 DE.

However as some like myself have stated, Gregory is pretty damn close. Love his length, flexibility and strength. He probably won't be a stud against the run but at 255 he should be adequate especially with his tenacity and sound technique. Play him in the Kiwi role and I think we have a star at 9.
I'm starting to....  
Strip-Sack : 4/11/2015 3:24 pm : link
like Odi more and more...if the hip checks out, I wouldn't hate the pick at 9...would love Gregory but don't think they'll take him if he's there.
RE: Jesse , Stupendamatic  
Stupendamatic : 4/11/2015 3:38 pm : link
In comment 12228931 Coach Mason said:
Quote:
None of these guys seem like the 'perfect' model of what the Giants go for for a pure 4-3 DE.

However as some like myself have stated, Gregory is pretty damn close. Love his length, flexibility and strength. He probably won't be a stud against the run but at 255 he should be adequate especially with his tenacity and sound technique. Play him in the Kiwi role and I think we have a star at 9.


That is true, but many get it in their head that just because a player doesn't literally measure up to our standards, that then he is not capable of playing the position. I understand if someone feels we won't draft a few for these reasons, but to claim like some have that none of these guys can play defensive end at the next level is foolish.

FWIW: Osi didn't fit the perfect model DE neither.

Quote:
4.78 in the 40-yard dash…Bench presses 225 pounds 26 times…550-pound squat…355-pound power clean…33-inch vertical jump…32-inch arm length…10 1/8-inch hands… Right-handed…26/42 Wonderlic score.


Forgot to link the source of the numbers  
Stupendamatic : 4/11/2015 3:40 pm : link
.
Link - ( New Window )
Do You Draft a Guy at 9  
clatterbuck : 4/11/2015 4:16 pm : link
for 6-9 sacks a season? Value doesn't seem to be there.
No offense to anyone here,  
Big Blue '56 : 4/11/2015 4:54 pm : link
But Cosell is first rate and works very hard at reaching his assessment(s), so he's yet another one I take very seriously..

Ray has been talked about on here of course, but not very often to us at 9..Gonna have to do more homework on him but they're just draftnik opinions and you- tube videos, so for with they're worth.........
RE: Do You Draft a Guy at 9  
Toth029 : 4/11/2015 11:32 pm : link
In comment 12229023 clatterbuck said:
Quote:
for 6-9 sacks a season? Value doesn't seem to be there.

At minimum? It's not that bad of a choice, if so. Plus with JPP and Hankins on the line - those opportunities will rise.
Draft Randy Gregory  
nybeast : 4/12/2015 9:05 am : link
He's the best. He will have the most impact of all the DL/OLB prospects, book it. Last year we gave our new offensive coordinator a much needed weapon on offense to replace Nicks. This year why don't we give Spags a weapon on defense to replace Kiwi? Randy Gregory fits. If we can't get Gregory, I like Vic Beasley and Shane Ray. I don't mind Dupree, but I would prefer a trade down to get him.
RE: I wonder how many on BBI will still say none of them can play 43 DE  
Joey in VA : 4/12/2015 11:44 am : link
In comment 12228895 Stupendamatic said:
Quote:
I had listened to the podcast earlier and that is one heck on a transcript.

I love listening to Cosell, and make an effort to listen to any podcast he's featured on. He doesn't care for much other than what's on the tape and I like that.
I don't think any of them are great fits in the 4-3 and especially if JPP stays at RDE, you need a run defending LDE to complement him. If Spags is smart enough, he'll move JPP to LDE, then one of those guys is a decent Osi type fit possibly.

The problem with a guy like Ray is that we've been shredded on the ground and a 6-3 245 DE won't help that. If you want to use him a joker role that's fine, move him around and create mismatches but we already have a player like that in Moore.
The question surrounding ray to the Giants are legit  
raever : 4/12/2015 11:50 am : link
As an organization we would have to embrace flexibility in our fronts to maximize his impact or it doesn't make sense to commit such a vital pick on him imo. Spags has the experience with the ravens to make it work.
re: Cosell  
Joey in VA : 4/12/2015 11:56 am : link
Just because he does it, doesn't make him perfect at it. Ray is NOT a 4-3 DE, no way no how. I usually like Cosell but once in a while he whiffs badly and I think the analysis of Ray is a whiff similar to what he said about RGIII v Luck

1. Indianapolis: My highest rated quarterback is Robert Griffin III. My conclusion: Griffin is a superior arm talent and better natural passer than Luck.
RE: Draft Randy Gregory  
dguy901 : 4/12/2015 12:48 pm : link
In comment 12229614 nybeast said:
Quote:
He's the best. He will have the most impact of all the DL/OLB prospects, book it. Last year we gave our new offensive coordinator a much needed weapon on offense to replace Nicks. This year why don't we give Spags a weapon on defense to replace Kiwi? Randy Gregory fits. If we can't get Gregory, I like Vic Beasley and Shane Ray. I don't mind Dupree, but I would prefer a trade down to get him.

Gregory doesn't fit the every down DE requirements which categorically pushes him out of contention for the Giants at #9! Fowler is definitely #1, Beasley and Ray don't warrant a #9 for the Giants with there needs, I view the (3) (Gregory, Beasley and Gregory) as luxury picks. Fowler will definitely be gone by the time we pick, The only DE I feel is worthy of our 9th pick is Dupree. Although he only had 7 sacks, he was a stand-up DE in college and wasn't rushing the QB as much as the others listed in the article. He is also extremely quick and fast enough to drop into coverage easily. That is the ideal DE in my mind. JMHO.
raever and Joey on target  
JonC : 4/12/2015 3:41 pm : link
.
Gregory  
Joey in VA : 4/12/2015 10:06 pm : link
Is Simeon Rice minus 20 lbs plus a drug habit. Pass
Not sold on Ray for this system  
Coach Mason : 4/13/2015 10:32 am : link
Shane Ray, DE, 6-3, 245, 4.54, Jr., Missouri: Ray was unable to match the phenomenal combine workouts from Beasley and Gregory at his March 19 pro day and has slipped down my board as a result. It is important to remember his tape. This is the reigning SEC Defensive Player of the Year -- he led the power conference with 14½ sacks and 21½ tackles for loss in his first season as a starter. However, the extra 15 pounds Ray put on for his workout robbed him of some of his speed and explosiveness (33-inch vertical) and scouts on hand questioned his weight distribution, noting his thin legs and narrow hips that might limit the weight Ray can gain and force him to play linebacker in the NFL.
He lacks child-bearing hips...  
Dunedin81 : 4/13/2015 10:35 am : link
clearly not Giant material.
I don't care what position Ray is  
djm : 4/13/2015 11:57 am : link
i'd take him here in a heartbeat. That dude is gonna rack up a lot of big plays in the NFL. Giants need big plays on defense. If the Giants like him they need to draft him and adjust this defense to his strengths.
RE: He lacks child-bearing hips...  
Semipro Lineman : 4/13/2015 1:46 pm : link
In comment 12230653 Dunedin81 said:
Quote:
clearly not Giant material.


Well done, sir. Well done!
The scheme equation will have to change  
Coach Mason : 4/13/2015 3:06 pm : link
to consider most of these guys. Gregory IMO will require the smallest adjustment as he could play the Kiwi role (DE/LB) better than Kiwi did.

Giants are very big fans of size/length in their pass-rushers and Gregory fits the model awfully well (except for the weight which he can add anyways).

Is there still too much projection or character flags to mitigate his potential as one of the top pass rushers in this draft?

That's the key question here IMO.
Back to the Corner