for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

NFT: NFT Push style mulching lawnmower rec needed

gmangill : 5/3/2015 7:25 am
Fellow BBIers,

I finally took your sound advice and tossed my shitty old Charbroil grill and bought a Weber... Turned out that you all were correct.... Weber is worth the additional coin.

Now I find myself in need of a lawnmower. looking for walk behind not riding (I only have 1/2 acre and I actually enjoy mowing).

Self propelled is nice but not necessary, mulching and bagging a must.

For the last 20+ years I would go to Sears, by a Craftsman for 250-300 bucks, use it for 4-6 years, beat the shit out of it, buy a new one as soon as it dies.... repeat. the problem, with this is that I get good results for the first 2 years or so and then the mower starts to deteriorate and so do my results.

I am willing to spend more (around double give or take) to get a quality machine that gives me great results for a longer amount of time.

what say you BBI??
I have a Snapper  
JCin332 : 5/3/2015 7:38 am : link
it was pricey but works great..
I have it toro  
mattlawson : 5/3/2015 7:46 am : link
With the gator blades from tractor supply Company. If you mulch it it's the best thing for your grass and you don't need to bag it.

The mower is extremely economical- One 5 gallon can of gasoline lasts me A long long time with this mower. It's not the biggest or the most powerful but I've had no problems with it and it works great.
Honda's are the Mercedes of the push mower world  
aimrocky : 5/3/2015 7:55 am : link
Here's the one I got last year. Love it
Link - ( New Window )
toro / honda  
haper : 5/3/2015 9:39 am : link
I've had a toro mulcher self propelled for almost 10 yrs now and its been rock solid with very little maintenance. Its the first one of its type i've owned so I don't have much to compare it to, but I think there are other mowers out there that do a better job of mulching tall grass. The self propel engagement is the entire upper handle, the idea is the more you push it the faster the mower is propelled . . . I was skeptical at first but it works well. My neighbor borrowed it and thought the whole idea was a gimmick, but he ended up loving it.

The same neighbor is a contractor / carpenter; he swears by honda's small engines.
I had a honda  
pjcas18 : 5/3/2015 9:44 am : link
quad cut, it mulched so fine I didn't need to bag - which is actually better for the grass (not bagging as long as it doesn't leave clumps).

I loved the ease of use (started first pull) easy maintenance, and mulching, but it didn't last long. 5 years maybe and the self propulsion wouldn't work, then the blade broke (which isn't uncommon) but the whole assembly broke and couldn't be swapped out.

could have been a freak accident. regardless I'd buy Honda again.
If I were you  
GiantMike92 : 5/3/2015 9:51 am : link
I'd look for a used commercial walk behind, I did this (Scag)about twenty years ago and I've never regretted it. Mine is 36 inches which is all I need for my lot. Ex Mark is also another great choice, don't be put off by the price because it'll be the last mower you ever buy. New they're very expensive but if you can find a decent used one they're great and also cut down on your mow time because of the turning radius. These are the mowers that landscapers use and I was lucky when I got mine because it was homeowner owned.
FYI  
GiantMike92 : 5/3/2015 9:53 am : link
The standard width is 48 inches and they also come 60 inches wide, obviously the wider the cut the quicker your done but usually price goes up with width
hopefully Red Dog sees this  
Moondawg : 5/3/2015 10:18 am : link
he is the guru of such matters on BBI.
I've had a craftsman for about 8 years now  
Jon : 5/3/2015 10:23 am : link
with no issues. I think if you beat the shit out of something for 6 years it's going to quit on you, regardless of make and model. If you're going to spend that much, make sure maintain the engine and keep the blades sharp. Otherwise you're just pissing your money away. Just my $.02.
thanks  
gmangill : 5/3/2015 10:39 am : link
thanks for all the info... Looks like Honda is the way to go.
jon.. agree. if I do spend more and get a better quality mower, maintenance will be key.

Gas  
Jim in Fairfax : 5/3/2015 10:57 am : link
Whatever you buy, how you handle the gas for it will go a long way in determining how long it lasts.

Ethanol in modern gas is a disaster for small engines. It gums up the carberator and fuel system, gradually making it difficult to impossible to start. I recommend the following:

1) Buy new gas for the mower every 4-6 weeks.

2) Use fuel treatment on each new can. I prefer Star-Tron.

3) If your mower has a fuel line cutoff valve, use it after each mowing and let the mower run until the excess gas in the line runs out. This keeps the fuel off the carberator and fuel lines between mowings.

4) Empty and run the gas completely dry of the mower at the end of the season.
Had a Honda mower for 20 years.  
ChathamMark : 5/3/2015 1:14 pm : link
It died, and I bought a Snapper. Piece of crap. Bought another Honda. Love it.
I've had both Toro and Honda walk mowers  
Red Dog : 5/3/2015 1:28 pm : link
as well as a Craftsman POS, used an electric walk behind some, and tried a few others. Also worked in the outdoor power equipment business but not for any mower manufacturer.

My Honda cut better when it actually ran, which wasn't always when I wanted it to run, but overall the Toro was the better product by a wide margin.

My Toro was much more reliable, definitely easier to start, had better controls, nicer height adjusters, was much easier and less expensive to service, allowed service of important areas (rear axle / gear box) that the Honda didn't, required less service overall, didn't cost much more despite having more features including a cast aluminum deck instead of stamped steel, and lasted me longer.

No contest in my book. Toro wins hands down.



Honda. I have a Toro too, that can't compare to  
RDJR : 5/3/2015 2:24 pm : link
the Honda.
I had a bad experience with a Toro too  
pjcas18 : 5/3/2015 2:26 pm : link
It was my first mower and was a house warming gifts from Lowes.

the pull start came right off (which was the final straw). the mechanism to raise and lower the blade was such a hassle and perpetually stuck, and rear wheel self-propulsion was useless on the slightest incline.

I am sure it was a lower end model ($350?) so you get what you pay for, but a similarly priced Honda was much better for me.

RE: If I were you  
KeoweeFan : 5/3/2015 8:11 pm : link
In comment 12268024 GiantMike92 said:
Quote:
I'd look for a used commercial walk behind, I did this (Scag)about twenty years ago and I've never regretted it. Mine is 36 inches which is all I need for my lot. Ex Mark is also another great choice, don't be put off by the price because it'll be the last mower you ever buy. New they're very expensive but if you can find a decent used one they're great and also cut down on your mow time because of the turning radius. These are the mowers that landscapers use and I was lucky when I got mine because it was homeowner owned.

Used commercial equipment is excellent advice. I retired to a rural property on Canadice Lake in NY with 3 acres of lawn (on a steep slope) and a used Scag 61" 0-turn mower to convert another 3 acres of brush into lawn. When I moved to SC I sold it for more than I paid for it.
I know your acreage is not the same but the principle may be.

Back to the Corner