Was arguing this the other day with a friend of mine.
I say for sure. There aren't any 2 time SB winning coaches not in the hall of fame. Also factor in he took Jax as an expansion team to the AFC Championship.
have lacked consistency, sure they won some big games but throughout Coughlin's tenure here we fans never knew what team would show up on sunday and thats what will keep him out of the HOF...
If the Giants were any better they'd be by far the 2nd best team in the NFL over the last 10 years. As is they are the 3rd best next to Pitt and the Pats. IF you're gonna put some other team ahead of NYG over the last 10 it's not gonna be based on super wins or appearances. How can we put any team not named Pitt or NE over NYG? WHo is that team? Ravens? Only one title. Niners? No titles. Colts? One title. Saints...ditto. Packers come close...but just one.
So you're saying the Giants haven't been consistent enough. They are already the 3rd most successful franchise since 05! Even with the last 2 years of shit...they are still 3rd when you add up the regular season and postseason wins.
Compare the Giants to every other NFL team not named Pitt or the Pats. Then talk to me about consistency.
have lacked consistency, sure they won some big games but throughout Coughlin's tenure here we fans never knew what team would show up on sunday and thats what will keep him out of the HOF...
If the Giants were any better they'd be by far the 2nd best team in the NFL over the last 10 years. As is they are the 3rd best next to Pitt and the Pats. IF you're gonna put some other team ahead of NYG over the last 10 it's not gonna be based on super wins or appearances. How can we put any team not named Pitt or NE over NYG? WHo is that team? Ravens? Only one title. Niners? No titles. Colts? One title. Saints...ditto. Packers come close...but just one.
So you're saying the Giants haven't been consistent enough. They are already the 3rd most successful franchise since 05! Even with the last 2 years of shit...they are still 3rd when you add up the regular season and postseason wins.
Compare the Giants to every other NFL team not named Pitt or the Pats. Then talk to me about consistency.
Sometimes people make it seem as though they'd prefer to have the 'consistency' of the packers/saints/colts/etc... over the 'inconsistency' of TC teams despite us having more titles during that time.
Don't know finishing out with losing records and missing playoffs would put a little damper on it. Also, consistency taken into account, which he hasn't been so.
TC's career as Giants head coach seem to be in the eyes of the beholder
and Giant fans either love him or not so much, I think he's a good coach but not more than that as for those SB wins, we were damned lucky in both of them
If the Giants were any better they'd be by far the 2nd best team in the NFL over the last 10 years. As is they are the 3rd best next to Pitt and the Pats. IF you're gonna put some other team ahead of NYG over the last 10 it's not gonna be based on super wins or appearances. How can we put any team not named Pitt or NE over NYG? WHo is that team? Ravens? Only one title. Niners? No titles. Colts? One title. Saints...ditto. Packers come close...but just one.
So you're saying the Giants haven't been consistent enough. They are already the 3rd most successful franchise since 05! Even with the last 2 years of shit...they are still 3rd when you add up the regular season and postseason wins.
Compare the Giants to every other NFL team not named Pitt or the Pats. Then talk to me about consistency.
Quote:
have lacked consistency, sure they won some big games but throughout Coughlin's tenure here we fans never knew what team would show up on sunday and thats what will keep him out of the HOF...
If the Giants were any better they'd be by far the 2nd best team in the NFL over the last 10 years. As is they are the 3rd best next to Pitt and the Pats. IF you're gonna put some other team ahead of NYG over the last 10 it's not gonna be based on super wins or appearances. How can we put any team not named Pitt or NE over NYG? WHo is that team? Ravens? Only one title. Niners? No titles. Colts? One title. Saints...ditto. Packers come close...but just one.
So you're saying the Giants haven't been consistent enough. They are already the 3rd most successful franchise since 05! Even with the last 2 years of shit...they are still 3rd when you add up the regular season and postseason wins.
Compare the Giants to every other NFL team not named Pitt or the Pats. Then talk to me about consistency.
Sometimes people make it seem as though they'd prefer to have the 'consistency' of the packers/saints/colts/etc... over the 'inconsistency' of TC teams despite us having more titles during that time.