for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

NFT: NFT - student loan interest - variable or fixed?

gmangill : 5/30/2015 6:24 am
Looking for advice on student loan interest rates... My eldest will be attending Suffolk University as a freshman this fall. I am just now applying for the first of many private student loans (we didn't qualify for much FAFSA / Stafford).

Here is my question... Variable or fixed interest? 15yr term, interest only while in school. fixed is 7% (wow! that's high),variable is 3.18% (quite a difference).

2015/2016 loan amount will be somewhat shy of 25k

the dilemma is obvious... Satisfy my conservative side and lock in now knowing that rates have no place to go but up? or... roll the dice and save quite a bit of $$$ if the rates stay flat?

appreciate any input.. I will also be talking to the CFO at my company and my financial guy prior to signing any loan doc.

as always BBI... appreciate any help! Gman
Dont know the answer  
spike : 5/30/2015 6:56 am : link
But you should go through this discussion with your child.
Its a major life lesson, getting a loan. Well, money management isnot something taught in school
I'd  
Metnut : 5/30/2015 9:58 am : link
think long and hard about taking private student loans for undergrad unless it's an ivy league school or an equivalent. These loans aren't subject to income-based repayment options and can ruin credit for both student and co-signor for life. I'd recommend taking a look at state schools because I wouldn't suspect the job opportunities would be that different and having less debt will make a big difference.

I'll echo the earlier comments  
Jim in Fairfax : 5/30/2015 10:05 am : link
As to your question, it's impossible to give advice from the information given. All the particulars of how/when/why/how much the variable rate adjusts have to be considered.
Might be too late, but I'd consider having him  
eclipz928 : 5/30/2015 10:26 am : link
start at a community college first to save a little money, and make sure that he definitely has the mindset to making it through to complete his degree.

Private loans are very tricky, and will be expensive no matter what option you decide on. With most financial institutions the safe play is usually to go with the fixed rate. If you have a variable rate, there is no question that it will go up every year.

Before you make a decision, you should read the small print of the loan details. Find out under the variable rate plan what is the maximum that the rate can increase each year, and do a little math to figure out what would be the maximum interest your son might be paying on the loan after about 10 years. It's possible the variable rate plan might be better.
Suffolk University  
chuckydee9 : 5/30/2015 1:05 pm : link
has an acceptance of 82%.... any private school that has such a high acceptance is not worth the money... Someone was smart enough to tell me to go to Public school over a better private college... The difference of 100K+ in price is not worth it.. I'd tell my kid to look into a state college even if its not highly ranked..
SUNYs are underrated and provide good value  
spike : 5/30/2015 1:07 pm : link
Stony Brook, Binghamton, etc are top notch public schools.
at this point, I'm not sure if college is really worth it  
SHO'NUFF : 5/30/2015 5:49 pm : link
being buried in school loan debt... i like the community college/technical school option first, which are expensive as well, but not quite as expensive as a 4-year.
My guess is rate rise over that 15 yr period  
steve in ky : 5/30/2015 5:59 pm : link
If it were me I would lock them in while they are basically historically low.
I didn't see where it was 7% fixed  
steve in ky : 5/30/2015 6:00 pm : link
Wow that is high. I don't think I would lock that in.

If able I would take a home equity loan instead of this.
appreciate the feedback all  
gmangill : 5/31/2015 4:58 am : link
My wife and I are both products of state schools and have done fairly well... I tried my best to "persuade" her to go in that direction..

That being said, we have some math to do to make the best choices going forward.

She did get a decent scholarship from the school 15,500/yr which helps. Me and the Misses are chipping in 40k+ (we cant commit to much more that this because her sister is only 2 years behind so whatever we commit to one we have to have for the other).

I do have plenty of equity in the house and can "loan her" her portion from there but I want her to have skin in the game with her name on the loans. I think it will have a positive effect.

as far as the "worth" of going to college.... this is something I have been wrestling with for some time. I have always been a believer in education but the prices have really skyrocketed with no relief in site. A state school in Ma is almost 20k a year (all included)... 80 - 90k is a lot for a state school in my opinion.

thanks again all.... heading out now to do a little SCUBA diving for lobsters! go Giants!
All due respect...  
trueblueinpw : 5/31/2015 2:03 pm : link
I think you're making a mistake borrowing money for that caliber of undergraduate degree. Debt for a top notch school is a debatable burden for an undergraduate. But for anything below the top 20 or so colleges, especially in this day and age, debt is almost certainly an unforgiving mistake.

Two years of community college and then transferring into your home state public university for BA/BS is where the smart money is going. Take on debt for a graduate degree, and even that should be on your kids shoulders.

Remember too, you're daughter may want to go to graduate school. And you and your wife will want to retire. That won't be a viable option if your saddled with tens of thousands of dollars paying off a relatively low value undergraduate degree.

Again, all due respect, I get the kids want to go to a particular school. But, its a serious decision that needs to made based on financial reality and long term planning.
I agree with the fact that..  
EricJ : 5/31/2015 2:27 pm : link
it is a lot of money for that school. In the end, a degree is a degree. Your grades do not even matter. What matters most to employers is whether you can do the job and if you have related job experience in that field.

Would recommend any kid to go to a less expensive school that can afford you the time to work part time with companies in the field of choice. That way, the kid graduates with a full resume and immediately is more marketable than all of the other graduates even from more prestigious schools.

Now, about the financing which is really what you wanted to hear about. Suggest looking into a home equity line of credit which is much less expensive and the interest may be tax deductible. Your kid can make the payments. Would be cheaper.
Back to the Corner