so Brady goes all "reduce the suspension completely to clear my name or I'll sue" and then destroys his cell phone?? If this is correct, that was just completely moronic and really makes him look bad.
Listening to everyone try to figure out what he did and whether the suspension matches. This league is first and foremost about the owners and their business interests. So, from the start, this was really about whether the other owners (especially Baltimore who lost a much closer game) wanted and whether they had enough clout and anger to override the relationship between Kraft and Goodell. This decision was about balancing the competing interests. Apparently the other owners won out.
Francesca just mentioned a lot of pressure from the rest of the league.....
the suspension is not for deflating the footballs, it's for obstructing the league's investigation. Brady has no one to blame but himself. Good for the league to not back down under pressure from the Patriots' homers.
that situation is completely irrelevant to Brady and comparisons, which won't end, are not analogous, I don't think anyone is saying what Brady did is worse or as bad even though the suspensions match.
Stick to your values and protect the leagues game integrety.
Will this be legally challenged. Probably. Most likely. Very sad when it does.
Will Brady miss the first 4 games, probably not. He may not even miss a game all year due to anticipated legslation and court interference.
Internal league (and CBA ratified by the players union) accountability and discipline should not be a court action.
The courts have already interferred with NFL trying to police itself and its misbehaving union members / players.
What is truly sad here is the message of acceptable conduct (physical abuse of women, drug violations, gun violence, cheating, lying and coverups) is all lost in the shadows of the point counter point legal actions that become center stage.
I appluad the NFL for trying to do the "right thing" and cringe when the legal system is mal used to deflect the wrong doing of the offending player and his actions to the league and how they are attmepting to hold that same player accountable for those acitons, and attempting to preserve the NFL institution, its code of conduct and the values it exspuses.
How sad that when an organization attempts to hold someone accountable, the person often cries foul and gets sympathy and or relief from that accountability.
an independent arbitrator reduced it to 4. Not sure why this fiction about the NFL going easy on Hardy keeps being brought up. Hardy was suspended by his team last season with league approval.
I don't see how this is any court's business. Doesn't the CBA cover this sort of thing so the league can take care of it internally? Unless the judge is a blatantly biased Pats' fan, the case should be dismissed out of hand.
I don't see how this is any court's business. Doesn't the CBA cover this sort of thing so the league can take care of it internally? Unless the judge is a blatantly biased Pats' fan, the case should be dismissed out of hand.
And the only "victory" the players had was because the state of Minnesota requires drug test results to be given to an employee within 3 days, which the league had not done. Don't see any correlation to the Brady case really.
The nfl and Goodell screwed this up from the very beginning. It will be the nfl with egg on their face when all is said and done. The game officials did not handle the balls properly and they had 2 gauges that gave 2 different readings plus they did not check all of the balls from both teams and I can go on and on with what a joke this whole thing has been.
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
The nfl and Goodell screwed this up from the very beginning. It will be the nfl with egg on their face when all is said and done. The game officials did not handle the balls properly and they had 2 gauges that gave 2 different readings plus they did not check all of the balls from both teams and I can go on and on with what a joke this whole thing has been.
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
That's assuming the Courts don't kick it back citing that it's a league matter..
I was at Gillette Stadium for a concert on Saturday,
and in the course of the evening I fell into a conversation with a security guard. In the course of our conversation I revealed that I was a Giants fan but said I was hoping the suspension would be reduced. The better for the Pats to beat the Cowboys, blah-blah-blah.
Out of the blue, the guy said, "I'm tellinya, Brady didn't know a THING about all that deflating stuff." He was adamant - there was no WAY Brady had anything to do with it. The guys were doing it by themselves, he said.
I bit my tongue, but it's astonishing how Pats fans are in such denial about it.
The nfl and Goodell screwed this up from the very beginning. It will be the nfl with egg on their face when all is said and done. The game officials did not handle the balls properly and they had 2 gauges that gave 2 different readings plus they did not check all of the balls from both teams and I can go on and on with what a joke this whole thing has been.
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
Then why did Brady destroy his phone AFTER the league asked to investigate it? If the league screwed up, he would've been happy to clear his name by providing the phone and answering the league's questions. Instead he tried to cover it up and got burned.
The nfl and Goodell screwed this up from the very beginning. It will be the nfl with egg on their face when all is said and done. The game officials did not handle the balls properly and they had 2 gauges that gave 2 different readings plus they did not check all of the balls from both teams and I can go on and on with what a joke this whole thing has been.
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
Yep, at the end of the day, it all boils down to stupid policy by the NFL. Baseball doesn't allow pitchers to prepare the game balls. The umpires do it.
Would have been a riot to see Gaylord Perry and Rick Honeycutt prep their own though. :-)
The same way Kraft talked about the 'severity' of the team discipline they received being excessive. Then he shut his mouth and took his medicine.
Same goes for Brady. It didn't hurt his camp to blather about suing if his name wasn't cleared. It might have pressured Goodell into a more favorable ruling. The reality is if this drags into the season they lose all control over when Brady could be forced to miss four games.
It's my understanding that
1) Brady will be forced to produce the cell phone, or at least records
2) People will be put under oath, in some form. Including the two equipment guys that were involved. One who ducked into that room for a minute and a half, and the other whom Brady was talking to daily after not having talked to him at all when the story broke back in January. Something tells me both of these guys aren't going to risk perjuring themselves for a part time job with lousy pay.
And those records prove what? Are they NSA transcripts?
about this from a Patriots hater standpoint is the Patriots and their fan base were so sure at a minimum the suspension was going to be reduced, many thought removed altogether.
especially since Robert Kraft wrote an affidavit that "almost had a holy feel to it"
GTFO here with that Patriots ball-washing crap.
Quote:
UPDATE (10:25 p.m. ET): Krafts letter reportedly had its intended effect, as one source told ESPNs Adam Schefter it had almost a holy feel to it.
It's my understanding that
1) Brady will be forced to produce the cell phone, or at least records
2) People will be put under oath, in some form. Including the two equipment guys that were involved. One who ducked into that room for a minute and a half, and the other whom Brady was talking to daily after not having talked to him at all when the story broke back in January. Something tells me both of these guys aren't going to risk perjuring themselves for a part time job with lousy pay.
or they can go all scientology and subpoena all the owners who might have influenced goodell and the people at the nfl offices who were involved in the case from the start.
The courts will kick it back. The lawyers will have a field day with the wells' report alone. I believe there is lots of legal arguments that could be made.
As far as the phone goes. I don't know. We are getting one side of the story so far. I think it will be quite telling if Tom Brady pursues this. I don't trust or believe Goodell by his own track record.
9m9 minutes ago
Gary Myers @garymyersNYDN
Brady destroying cell phone looks really bad. But phone records show that the NFL already had all the texts between Brady and Jasrtemeski.
9m9 minutes ago
Gary Myers @garymyersNYDN
Brady destroying cell phone looks really bad. But phone records show that the NFL already had all the texts between Brady and Jasrtemeski.
With all the advisors Brady can employ, wouldn't he have been told that Texts can be accessed whether you destroy the phone or not? He probably destroyed the phone on his own, imo
If the nfl already had the text messages as Gary myers says, then don't you think that if there was anything damning, it would be in the wells report or in Goodell's statement?
situation could possibly think Brady had no idea or is innocent. It boggles my mind.
My thoughts exactly...as if the NFL went into this thing wanting to suspend their brightest star, c'mon. The NFL certainly has it's issues and the way the PSI measurements are taken is undoubtedly messed up but to suggest the Brady didn't have anything to do with this doesn't pass any sort of smell test whatsoever.
9m9 minutes ago
Gary Myers @garymyersNYDN
Brady destroying cell phone looks really bad. But phone records show that the NFL already had all the texts between Brady and Jasrtemeski.
Do you think it might be possible that Brady has talked about it with other people?
If the nfl already had the text messages as Gary myers says, then don't you think that if there was anything damning, it would be in the wells report or in Goodell's statement?
Seems like the NFL still has some dirt to release if you didn't get the whole Brady destroyed his phone leak today yet.
If the nfl already had the text messages as Gary myers says, then don't you think that if there was anything damning, it would be in the wells report or in Goodell's statement?
You would think..So little of this makes sense, including Brady's seemingly silly pride..
But destroying one's cellphone immediately after being requested for an investigation into wrong doing is enough circumstantial evidence to prove obstruction of investigation which is also one of the big reason laid out in his suspension.
How does Brady get around that issue in court if in the CBA is states that NFL players must cooperate with NFL investigations? He is a member of the union isn't he?
There is cooperating with an ongoing investigation and turning over any cell phone information. I am not a lawyer and I am not at all familiar with what is or isn't required of a player under the cba. We will find out soon enough
He isn't going to convince anyone that doesn't live in and around Boston he's innocent. So what's the point. You did it. Own it. Move on with the rest of your HOF career. The whole thing is stupid.
All he had to do at the very beginning was say. Yeah I ask my equipment guys to set the ball pressure at the low end of the accepted spectrum. It's on me. Result???? $50K fine. Case closed.
If the nfl already had the text messages as Gary myers says, then don't you think that if there was anything damning, it would be in the wells report or in Goodell's statement?
You would think..So little of this makes sense, including Brady's seemingly silly pride..
Brady wasn't aware that they had those guy texts at the time his phone was requested. He claim that he didn't have any relationship with those guys as well. That's why they knew he was lying. He claim the reason why he didn't want to show the phone was because of pics of his wife or something like that. They even gave him a chance to privately remove those images and steamy texts. He said no.
The NFL moved first, but, as expected, it looks like theyll have company in going to federal court in the wake of Commissioner Roger Goodells decision to uphold Patriots quarterback Tom Bradys suspension.
Jim Trotter of ESPN reports that Brady has authorized the NFLPA to go to federal court in an attempt to overturn the suspension.
There arent any other details about the filing, including whether or not the union will seek an injunction that would allow Brady to play while the case is being heard. If Brady does get an injunction and ultimately loses the case, he would have to serve the suspension later in the season or even in the playoffs should the Patriots advance that far this season. If he doesnt go for the injunction, hed serve the suspension while trying to recoup the salary hed lose while out for four games.
With the NFL filing in Manhattan, well also be keeping an eye out for where the NFLPA files their action. Minnesota has been the preferred location because Judge David Dotys rulings have been favorable in the past and the NFLs desire to avoid that venue will likely add to the legal proceedings that will unfold in the coming weeks and months.
If Brady does get an injunction and ultimately loses the case, he would have to serve the suspension later in the season or even in the playoffs should the Patriots advance that far this season. If he doesnt go for the injunction, hed serve the suspension while trying to recoup the salary hed lose while out for four games.
No but given the disparity between how much was lost and the fact that environmental conditions for both sets of balls(heh) were identical, it's pretty obvious there was tampering. The balls were tampered with, just accept it already.
There is cooperating with an ongoing investigation and turning over any cell phone information. I am not a lawyer and I am not at all familiar with what is or isn't required of a player under the cba. We will find out soon enough
He did have to turn over his phone they asked to see it. Also, I wouldn't think people confuse what a government agent is allowed to do to you vs what an employer is allowed to do an employee. This could be cleared up by checking whether he signed and agreed to his NFL contract.
Then why did Brady destroy his phone AFTER the league asked to investigate it? If the league screwed up, he would've been happy to clear his name by providing the phone and answering the league's questions. Instead he tried to cover it up and got burned.
The nfl and Goodell screwed this up from the very beginning. It will be the nfl with egg on their face when all is said and done. The game officials did not handle the balls properly and they had 2 gauges that gave 2 different readings plus they did not check all of the balls from both teams and I can go on and on with what a joke this whole thing has been.
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
Let me guess, you believe the patriots guy is called the deflator because he's trying to lose weight.
to play at Dallas, fuck it, already. How about the Giants just take care of business in the division for a change and not have to worry about some other team doing it for them? Just saying, it would be nice to remember how that feels.
and in the course of the evening I fell into a conversation with a security guard. In the course of our conversation I revealed that I was a Giants fan but said I was hoping the suspension would be reduced. The better for the Pats to beat the Cowboys, blah-blah-blah.
Out of the blue, the guy said, "I'm tellinya, Brady didn't know a THING about all that deflating stuff." He was adamant - there was no WAY Brady had anything to do with it. The guys were doing it by themselves, he said.
I bit my tongue, but it's astonishing how Pats fans are in such denial about it.
were using under-inflated balls--they were. The discussion is along the lines of whether or not Brady was covering up any knowledge of it, and not cooperating with the investigation. Also, what should the appropriate punishment be.
There is some real disparity of opinions on the punishment. IMO, you could make a good case that some games were won due to the advantages gained from the better grip and if that is agreed upon, 4 game suspension is appropriate.
were using under-inflated balls--they were. The discussion is along the lines of whether or not Brady was covering up any knowledge of it, and not cooperating with the investigation. Also, what should the appropriate punishment be.
There is some real disparity of opinions on the punishment. IMO, you could make a good case that some games were won due to the advantages gained from the better grip and if that is agreed upon, 4 game suspension is appropriate.
Randy I agree, deliberate obstruction of investigation. Lying through his teeth at this point - and you have to wonder why and how we got to this point.
RE: RE: I was at Gillette Stadium for a concert on Saturday,
and in the course of the evening I fell into a conversation with a security guard. In the course of our conversation I revealed that I was a Giants fan but said I was hoping the suspension would be reduced. The better for the Pats to beat the Cowboys, blah-blah-blah.
Out of the blue, the guy said, "I'm tellinya, Brady didn't know a THING about all that deflating stuff." He was adamant - there was no WAY Brady had anything to do with it. The guys were doing it by themselves, he said.
I bit my tongue, but it's astonishing how Pats fans are in such denial about it.
about a month ago - his suspension was being disussed on the "Sports Reporters". To a man - they all said it would be reduced to 2 games and most felt that he shouldn't even have gotten that. Now the FULL 4 games ... That was an expensive cell phone Tom.
the day after the game with the personnel who handled the balls ... a request was made by Wells for the texts ... Brady refused and eventually Brady destroyed his cell phone ...
The bottom line is that if anyone on BBI was being investigated by your employer of behavior that discredited your company - and if you refused to cooperate (or worse, destroyed evidence), you'd be fired so fast it would make your head spin. It's a fucking disgrace that the NFL chose to allow Brady to give them the finger. He should have been fired just like you or me. I don't like people who think they are better than everyone else and that they are above the rules. I like it even less when they're proven right. Fuck him. He's a piece of garbage.
but this is not a criminal or even civil investigation, Brady had no obligation to turn over his personal cell phone.
by not doing it, and even worse by destroying it, he appeared to be uncooperative and suspicious
While an employer cannot force an employee to cooperate with an investigation into the employee - every employer on earth would fire that employee within seconds of his refusal. Employers have the right to fire an employee for no reason at all. They clearly have the right to fire an employee (and do all the time) for the employee's refusal to cooperate with an investigation.
So yes, you as an employee don't have to cooperate with your employer. But if you refuse, you can rest assured you will be shown the door within 30 seconds of your refusal. Absent negotiated contract provisions, due process and equal protection do not apply in private settings involving employer/employee relations and the employment in most circumstances is "at will". It is my understanding that Goodell had every right - and the power - to tell Brady he's done forever in the NFL for his refusal to comply with the request to turn over the many texts he had with the equipment guys. And it is frankly outrageous that the NFL would tolerate being told "fuck off" by Brady. Who the fuck does he think he is?
BUT, it's the rule and whether he broke the rule is open to question..That he failed, by CBA edict, to fully cooperate is punishable and he hot what he deserved..That he believes his shit doesn't smell, that he's above it all, makes me ecstatic that his great HOF career will have a PR blemish as small as that might be..
Was it worth it you moron? A simple, "Ooops, guilty as charged, I'm sorry, it wasn't my intention to circumvent the rule. I didn't think having a more comfortable grip was a big deal..Again, sorry."
"We're only going to score 17 points? Heh, heh, heh, Ok.." Smug bastard
They have his phone records which establish many calls and texts to the equipment guys the day after the game. The league (through Wells) made a formal request to see the texts. Brady told him to fuck off.
Supposedly he then destroyed his phone. But whether he did or didn't is beside the point. His refusal to cooperate with an investigation that involves the integrity of the game warrants immediate and permanent dismissal in my book.
They have his phone records which establish many calls and texts to the equipment guys the day after the game. The league (through Wells) made a formal request to see the texts. Brady told him to fuck off.
Supposedly he then destroyed his phone. But whether he did or didn't is beside the point. His refusal to cooperate with an investigation that involves the integrity of the game warrants immediate and permanent dismissal in my book.
Not to mention that were he to have been banned or when he retires, their stadium will go back to being half full..
RE: RE: It's obviously damning based on the timing
but this is not a criminal or even civil investigation, Brady had no obligation to turn over his personal cell phone.
by not doing it, and even worse by destroying it, he appeared to be uncooperative and suspicious
While an employer cannot force an employee to cooperate with an investigation into the employee - every employer on earth would fire that employee within seconds of his refusal. Employers have the right to fire an employee for no reason at all. They clearly have the right to fire an employee (and do all the time) for the employee's refusal to cooperate with an investigation.
So yes, you as an employee don't have to cooperate with your employer. But if you refuse, you can rest assured you will be shown the door within 30 seconds of your refusal. Absent negotiated contract provisions, due process and equal protection do not apply in private settings involving employer/employee relations and the employment in most circumstances is "at will". It is my understanding that Goodell had every right - and the power - to tell Brady he's done forever in the NFL for his refusal to comply with the request to turn over the many texts he had with the equipment guys. And it is frankly outrageous that the NFL would tolerate being told "fuck off" by Brady. Who the fuck does he think he is?
he will be punished and should be, but comparing traditional employers to the NFL is a bad comparison.
the NFL can't fire Brady. and they couldn't suspend him for not providing them his cell phone, the NFLPA would have a field day with that. Brady was suspended for violating the integrity of the game, which is nebulous, but it wasn't for not giving the league his personal cell phone which as I said, he has no obligation to do.
The memo mentions destruction of Brady's cell phone "even though he was aware that the investigators had requested access to text messages"
Another one Goodell will lose in court.
Francesca just mentioned a lot of pressure from the rest of the league.....
"Inflated footballs? I've heard everything now."
Keep giggling idiot..............
If that was a ray rice reference, hasn't anyone noticed that Ray Rice hasn't played a minute in the NFL since then?
If that was a ray rice reference, hasn't anyone noticed that Ray Rice hasn't played a minute in the NFL since then?
no. Greg Hardy
that situation is completely irrelevant to Brady and comparisons, which won't end, are not analogous, I don't think anyone is saying what Brady did is worse or as bad even though the suspensions match.
Will this be legally challenged. Probably. Most likely. Very sad when it does.
Will Brady miss the first 4 games, probably not. He may not even miss a game all year due to anticipated legslation and court interference.
Internal league (and CBA ratified by the players union) accountability and discipline should not be a court action.
The courts have already interferred with NFL trying to police itself and its misbehaving union members / players.
What is truly sad here is the message of acceptable conduct (physical abuse of women, drug violations, gun violence, cheating, lying and coverups) is all lost in the shadows of the point counter point legal actions that become center stage.
I appluad the NFL for trying to do the "right thing" and cringe when the legal system is mal used to deflect the wrong doing of the offending player and his actions to the league and how they are attmepting to hold that same player accountable for those acitons, and attempting to preserve the NFL institution, its code of conduct and the values it exspuses.
How sad that when an organization attempts to hold someone accountable, the person often cries foul and gets sympathy and or relief from that accountability.
Right you are.
Watch them go 4-0 without him, then BB tries to cut Brady's salary the next season. :-)
see the starcap case from a few year ago.
Quote:
of losing games at home they're favored to win..I wouldn't count Belichick et al out of this by a long shot..
Right you are.
Watch them go 4-0 without him, then BB tries to cut Brady's salary the next season. :-)
Lol
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
Yes! BB always comes out ahead.
11-5 with Matt Cassel. Flipped him to KC for 2nd rounder, # 34 overall.
Cassel post Pats, in the immortal words of Lt. Frank Drebben, "Nothing to see here!"
it ended up in court after suspensions were handed out.the court found that the nfl broke a lot of rules but the suspensions were upheld.
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
That's assuming the Courts don't kick it back citing that it's a league matter..
Out of the blue, the guy said, "I'm tellinya, Brady didn't know a THING about all that deflating stuff." He was adamant - there was no WAY Brady had anything to do with it. The guys were doing it by themselves, he said.
I bit my tongue, but it's astonishing how Pats fans are in such denial about it.
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
Then why did Brady destroy his phone AFTER the league asked to investigate it? If the league screwed up, he would've been happy to clear his name by providing the phone and answering the league's questions. Instead he tried to cover it up and got burned.
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
Yep, at the end of the day, it all boils down to stupid policy by the NFL. Baseball doesn't allow pitchers to prepare the game balls. The umpires do it.
Would have been a riot to see Gaylord Perry and Rick Honeycutt prep their own though. :-)
Same goes for Brady. It didn't hurt his camp to blather about suing if his name wasn't cleared. It might have pressured Goodell into a more favorable ruling. The reality is if this drags into the season they lose all control over when Brady could be forced to miss four games.
See you in October Tom.
1) Brady will be forced to produce the cell phone, or at least records
2) People will be put under oath, in some form. Including the two equipment guys that were involved. One who ducked into that room for a minute and a half, and the other whom Brady was talking to daily after not having talked to him at all when the story broke back in January. Something tells me both of these guys aren't going to risk perjuring themselves for a part time job with lousy pay.
So yes, it makes it doubly stupid to have destroyed it. The log proves nothing
especially since Robert Kraft wrote an affidavit that "almost had a holy feel to it"
GTFO here with that Patriots ball-washing crap.
1) Brady will be forced to produce the cell phone, or at least records
2) People will be put under oath, in some form. Including the two equipment guys that were involved. One who ducked into that room for a minute and a half, and the other whom Brady was talking to daily after not having talked to him at all when the story broke back in January. Something tells me both of these guys aren't going to risk perjuring themselves for a part time job with lousy pay.
or they can go all scientology and subpoena all the owners who might have influenced goodell and the people at the nfl offices who were involved in the case from the start.
As far as the phone goes. I don't know. We are getting one side of the story so far. I think it will be quite telling if Tom Brady pursues this. I don't trust or believe Goodell by his own track record.
why do you trust goodell?
9m9 minutes ago
Gary Myers @garymyersNYDN
Brady destroying cell phone looks really bad. But phone records show that the NFL already had all the texts between Brady and Jasrtemeski.
9m9 minutes ago
Gary Myers @garymyersNYDN
Brady destroying cell phone looks really bad. But phone records show that the NFL already had all the texts between Brady and Jasrtemeski.
With all the advisors Brady can employ, wouldn't he have been told that Texts can be accessed whether you destroy the phone or not? He probably destroyed the phone on his own, imo
I still think it should have been reduced to 3, with the 3 games being games the other AFC East teams play at NE.
Glad that Mr "We're only going to score 17 points?" is getting suspended though.
My thoughts exactly...as if the NFL went into this thing wanting to suspend their brightest star, c'mon. The NFL certainly has it's issues and the way the PSI measurements are taken is undoubtedly messed up but to suggest the Brady didn't have anything to do with this doesn't pass any sort of smell test whatsoever.
9m9 minutes ago
Gary Myers @garymyersNYDN
Brady destroying cell phone looks really bad. But phone records show that the NFL already had all the texts between Brady and Jasrtemeski.
Do you think it might be possible that Brady has talked about it with other people?
Seems like the NFL still has some dirt to release if you didn't get the whole Brady destroyed his phone leak today yet.
You would think..So little of this makes sense, including Brady's seemingly silly pride..
How does Brady get around that issue in court if in the CBA is states that NFL players must cooperate with NFL investigations? He is a member of the union isn't he?
All he had to do at the very beginning was say. Yeah I ask my equipment guys to set the ball pressure at the low end of the accepted spectrum. It's on me. Result???? $50K fine. Case closed.
Quote:
If the nfl already had the text messages as Gary myers says, then don't you think that if there was anything damning, it would be in the wells report or in Goodell's statement?
You would think..So little of this makes sense, including Brady's seemingly silly pride..
Brady wasn't aware that they had those guy texts at the time his phone was requested. He claim that he didn't have any relationship with those guys as well. That's why they knew he was lying. He claim the reason why he didn't want to show the phone was because of pics of his wife or something like that. They even gave him a chance to privately remove those images and steamy texts. He said no.
The NFL moved first, but, as expected, it looks like theyll have company in going to federal court in the wake of Commissioner Roger Goodells decision to uphold Patriots quarterback Tom Bradys suspension.
Jim Trotter of ESPN reports that Brady has authorized the NFLPA to go to federal court in an attempt to overturn the suspension.
There arent any other details about the filing, including whether or not the union will seek an injunction that would allow Brady to play while the case is being heard. If Brady does get an injunction and ultimately loses the case, he would have to serve the suspension later in the season or even in the playoffs should the Patriots advance that far this season. If he doesnt go for the injunction, hed serve the suspension while trying to recoup the salary hed lose while out for four games.
With the NFL filing in Manhattan, well also be keeping an eye out for where the NFLPA files their action. Minnesota has been the preferred location because Judge David Dotys rulings have been favorable in the past and the NFLs desire to avoid that venue will likely add to the legal proceedings that will unfold in the coming weeks and months.
If Brady does get an injunction and ultimately loses the case, he would have to serve the suspension later in the season or even in the playoffs should the Patriots advance that far this season. If he doesnt go for the injunction, hed serve the suspension while trying to recoup the salary hed lose while out for four games.
If only that were true.
Depending on how soon you get the phone after they were deleted, they theoretically can be reconstructed.
the timing of this is very questionable though.
Colts balls - ( New Window )
Colts balls - ( New Window )
No but given the disparity between how much was lost and the fact that environmental conditions for both sets of balls(heh) were identical, it's pretty obvious there was tampering. The balls were tampered with, just accept it already.
The guy cheated, he got caught, he lied and tried to cover it up. Pay the price and move on.
Goodell looks like an untrained ape in this one.
He did have to turn over his phone they asked to see it. Also, I wouldn't think people confuse what a government agent is allowed to do to you vs what an employer is allowed to do an employee. This could be cleared up by checking whether he signed and agreed to his NFL contract.
Didn't Hernandez do the same thing?
;)
The nfl has lost every time their rulings have been appealed.
See starcaps case, bounty gate (vilma), Adrian peterson, ray rice
Let me guess, you believe the patriots guy is called the deflator because he's trying to lose weight.
Link - ( New Window )
Out of the blue, the guy said, "I'm tellinya, Brady didn't know a THING about all that deflating stuff." He was adamant - there was no WAY Brady had anything to do with it. The guys were doing it by themselves, he said.
I bit my tongue, but it's astonishing how Pats fans are in such denial about it.
wasn't Taylor Swift at Gillette on Saturday?
There is some real disparity of opinions on the punishment. IMO, you could make a good case that some games were won due to the advantages gained from the better grip and if that is agreed upon, 4 game suspension is appropriate.
There is some real disparity of opinions on the punishment. IMO, you could make a good case that some games were won due to the advantages gained from the better grip and if that is agreed upon, 4 game suspension is appropriate.
Randy I agree, deliberate obstruction of investigation. Lying through his teeth at this point - and you have to wonder why and how we got to this point.
Quote:
and in the course of the evening I fell into a conversation with a security guard. In the course of our conversation I revealed that I was a Giants fan but said I was hoping the suspension would be reduced. The better for the Pats to beat the Cowboys, blah-blah-blah.
Out of the blue, the guy said, "I'm tellinya, Brady didn't know a THING about all that deflating stuff." He was adamant - there was no WAY Brady had anything to do with it. The guys were doing it by themselves, he said.
I bit my tongue, but it's astonishing how Pats fans are in such denial about it.
wasn't Taylor Swift at Gillette on Saturday?
I was thinking the same thing...
The bottom line is that if anyone on BBI was being investigated by your employer of behavior that discredited your company - and if you refused to cooperate (or worse, destroyed evidence), you'd be fired so fast it would make your head spin. It's a fucking disgrace that the NFL chose to allow Brady to give them the finger. He should have been fired just like you or me. I don't like people who think they are better than everyone else and that they are above the rules. I like it even less when they're proven right. Fuck him. He's a piece of garbage.
by not doing it, and even worse by destroying it, he appeared to be uncooperative and suspicious
by not doing it, and even worse by destroying it, he appeared to be uncooperative and suspicious
While an employer cannot force an employee to cooperate with an investigation into the employee - every employer on earth would fire that employee within seconds of his refusal. Employers have the right to fire an employee for no reason at all. They clearly have the right to fire an employee (and do all the time) for the employee's refusal to cooperate with an investigation.
So yes, you as an employee don't have to cooperate with your employer. But if you refuse, you can rest assured you will be shown the door within 30 seconds of your refusal. Absent negotiated contract provisions, due process and equal protection do not apply in private settings involving employer/employee relations and the employment in most circumstances is "at will". It is my understanding that Goodell had every right - and the power - to tell Brady he's done forever in the NFL for his refusal to comply with the request to turn over the many texts he had with the equipment guys. And it is frankly outrageous that the NFL would tolerate being told "fuck off" by Brady. Who the fuck does he think he is?
BUT, it's the rule and whether he broke the rule is open to question..That he failed, by CBA edict, to fully cooperate is punishable and he hot what he deserved..That he believes his shit doesn't smell, that he's above it all, makes me ecstatic that his great HOF career will have a PR blemish as small as that might be..
Was it worth it you moron? A simple, "Ooops, guilty as charged, I'm sorry, it wasn't my intention to circumvent the rule. I didn't think having a more comfortable grip was a big deal..Again, sorry."
"We're only going to score 17 points? Heh, heh, heh, Ok.." Smug bastard
They have his phone records which establish many calls and texts to the equipment guys the day after the game. The league (through Wells) made a formal request to see the texts. Brady told him to fuck off.
Supposedly he then destroyed his phone. But whether he did or didn't is beside the point. His refusal to cooperate with an investigation that involves the integrity of the game warrants immediate and permanent dismissal in my book.
Quote:
Kraft seems to debunk that in his statement?
They have his phone records which establish many calls and texts to the equipment guys the day after the game. The league (through Wells) made a formal request to see the texts. Brady told him to fuck off.
Supposedly he then destroyed his phone. But whether he did or didn't is beside the point. His refusal to cooperate with an investigation that involves the integrity of the game warrants immediate and permanent dismissal in my book.
Not to mention that were he to have been banned or when he retires, their stadium will go back to being half full..
Quote:
but this is not a criminal or even civil investigation, Brady had no obligation to turn over his personal cell phone.
by not doing it, and even worse by destroying it, he appeared to be uncooperative and suspicious
While an employer cannot force an employee to cooperate with an investigation into the employee - every employer on earth would fire that employee within seconds of his refusal. Employers have the right to fire an employee for no reason at all. They clearly have the right to fire an employee (and do all the time) for the employee's refusal to cooperate with an investigation.
So yes, you as an employee don't have to cooperate with your employer. But if you refuse, you can rest assured you will be shown the door within 30 seconds of your refusal. Absent negotiated contract provisions, due process and equal protection do not apply in private settings involving employer/employee relations and the employment in most circumstances is "at will". It is my understanding that Goodell had every right - and the power - to tell Brady he's done forever in the NFL for his refusal to comply with the request to turn over the many texts he had with the equipment guys. And it is frankly outrageous that the NFL would tolerate being told "fuck off" by Brady. Who the fuck does he think he is?
he will be punished and should be, but comparing traditional employers to the NFL is a bad comparison.
the NFL can't fire Brady. and they couldn't suspend him for not providing them his cell phone, the NFLPA would have a field day with that. Brady was suspended for violating the integrity of the game, which is nebulous, but it wasn't for not giving the league his personal cell phone which as I said, he has no obligation to do.