|
|
Quote: |
Hosley is back this year with a new attitude, a new position, new coaches, a new coordinator. And, most importantly, another opportunity. With Prince Amukamara (groin) and Chykie Brown (knee) sidelined by injuries, Hosley is starting opposite Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie and back at an outside corner spot. Most importantly, he has new confidence in himself after being stripped of it last season. |
Jury is still out until we see it when the games count but Spags is giving a lot of the defense more confidence in camp
He's small and not that quick or fast to compensate for lack of size and apparently too fucking stupid to play any kind of zone. This press corner stuff is horseshit. Anyone want to see him press Dez Bryant? Please.
How about we root for players on the team to succeed instead of being negative.
By comparison, Spagnuolo is much more a Cover 2 coach. He was fired by the Saints because he played way too much zone. Looking to this season, when you hear Beason say that Spagnuolo runs a complicated system that banks on making the opposition guess as to who is rushing the passer, what he is talking about are fire-zone blitzes, whereby the slot corner might rush, but a DE falls back into the flat zone. That defense has been copied, laid, replayed and parlayed. Everybody uses versions of it. As with any scheme, the most important determinant of success is the talent involved.
Coughlin said that Spagnuolo interned during a past summer with the great Urban Meyer to gain knowledge defending the read option. spreads and tempo. This is good. This is encouraging. Gruden said that you cannot play 2-deep against the Read because there are too many gaps to cover. So let's see what happens against the Eagles & Redskins. Dallas is different. They run what will be a frightening version of the Coryell Vertical. Spagnuolo's got his work cut out for him in the division.
One fair thing to be said is the defensive talent is better this season than last. The safeties are untested but, really, they could not be any worse than last year. Even when Beason gets hurt, JT Thomas will be an adequate replacement, as he was last season in Jacksonville. There is adequate C+ type depth on the D-Line. That is good, especially against tempo. But asking Spagnuolo to start off against Dallas is almost criminal. The Cowboys have added another great o-lineman in Collins. 6 TDs against in the opener could very easily happen. Should it, hold the fort and wait for things to turn around.
Lastly, the whole Read N React analysis of poor defenses is particularly dense. Poor defensive play lends an appearance of passivity because too many guys are getting their balls handed to them in their individual match-ups. They are slow to react. They commit penalties. That is why they suck. Scheme has its place, no question. But talent rules. There is no such animal as a high-performance, low-talent defense. I don't give a shit what the scheme is and who is coordinating it. Talent rules and lately Dallas has been getting the better players. And if you want to go the "too complicated" route remember this is going to be a very complicated defense in 15. So that shoots that cliche in the ass.
Do not bet against Coughlin. He is in the fourth year of the four-year cycle. They might just pull it off, if the team stays reasonably healthy, with a dynamite offense and an opportunistic defense that achieves despite long bouts of adversity by hanging together and getting to the ball in key intervals.
As always a pleasure to read, great informative post.
The mere fact he is playing/practicing as the No 2 CB and we are not reading article after article of him being awful is a good sign
You are going to need 5-6 CB to play through the year. Having him as a capable player is good for the team
I agree and was going to make a similar comment. Although Hosley's ability to play effectively at the pro level isn't yet established, I think he, and other defensive players (i.e., Moore), are going to benefit greatly from Spags' more aggressive schemes and focus on playing man more than zone.
As always a pleasure to read, great informative post.
No cool nicknames in this edition, but agree, a great read as usual. The getting-to-the ball thing is key, imho.
As always a pleasure to read, great informative post.
Agreed. Great post. Really hope Hosley produces, for him and the team. I think he was stuck in a defense that didn't suit him, and now is in one that better fits his talents.
By comparison, Spagnuolo is much more a Cover 2 coach. He was fired by the Saints because he played way too much zone. Looking to this season, when you hear Beason say that Spagnuolo runs a complicated system that banks on making the opposition guess as to who is rushing the passer, what he is talking about are fire-zone blitzes, whereby the slot corner might rush, but a DE falls back into the flat zone. That defense has been copied, laid, replayed and parlayed. Everybody uses versions of it. As with any scheme, the most important determinant of success is the talent involved.
Coughlin said that Spagnuolo interned during a past summer with the great Urban Meyer to gain knowledge defending the read option. spreads and tempo. This is good. This is encouraging. Gruden said that you cannot play 2-deep against the Read because there are too many gaps to cover. So let's see what happens against the Eagles & Redskins. Dallas is different. They run what will be a frightening version of the Coryell Vertical. Spagnuolo's got his work cut out for him in the division.
One fair thing to be said is the defensive talent is better this season than last. The safeties are untested but, really, they could not be any worse than last year. Even when Beason gets hurt, JT Thomas will be an adequate replacement, as he was last season in Jacksonville. There is adequate C+ type depth on the D-Line. That is good, especially against tempo. But asking Spagnuolo to start off against Dallas is almost criminal. The Cowboys have added another great o-lineman in Collins. 6 TDs against in the opener could very easily happen. Should it, hold the fort and wait for things to turn around.
Lastly, the whole Read N React analysis of poor defenses is particularly dense. Poor defensive play lends an appearance of passivity because too many guys are getting their balls handed to them in their individual match-ups. They are slow to react. They commit penalties. That is why they suck. Scheme has its place, no question. But talent rules. There is no such animal as a high-performance, low-talent defense. I don't give a shit what the scheme is and who is coordinating it. Talent rules and lately Dallas has been getting the better players. And if you want to go the "too complicated" route remember this is going to be a very complicated defense in 15. So that shoots that cliche in the ass.
Do not bet against Coughlin. He is in the fourth year of the four-year cycle. They might just pull it off, if the team stays reasonably healthy, with a dynamite offense and an opportunistic defense that achieves despite long bouts of adversity by hanging together and getting to the ball in key intervals.
Excellent post, RJ.
Wish more people on this board understood these things but all that seems to compute around here is "aggressive defense"
Or is he wearing lifts now?
<sigh>
Can't anybody see through this stuff? I hope he has "turned the corner" but I highly doubt it.
Agree
I know, I know, Sinorice Moss, there are always the failures, but my point still stands..
Yeah, he's talking about himself. There's one non committal quote from TC in the article, that's it.
Why? BBI does it with almost everyone else from OTAs and minicamp on, why not now?
The Giants really need Hosley to not be a wasted pick.
Far too often it's the BBI way.
And this surprises you how? :)
djm, perhaps you need a BBI break if posts are that frustrating for you. We all need an occasional break.
I actually thought of that as well. Let's see though, how it unfolds, but I wouldn't be surprised if Spags brought out the best in yet another CB.
I thought he was a steal and have been greatly disappointed in what I thought would have been a starter by last season.
Hoping the article is true. For this team to succeed, we're going to need 3 or 4 'surprise' players. Webster, Boss, Cruz style surprises.
It all comes down to health, really. Too thin in too many areas to get away with many major injuries. That includes corner, big-time.
I'm all for credit where credit is due, but how is he "showing growth." By saying a lot of the right things? It's not as if last year he said "I'm gonna give it about 80% this year." Of course he's saying all this.
Is it encouraging that Coughlin says he came to camp in great shape? Absolutely. But I don't feel any different about Hosley today than I did yesterday. We haven't even played 1 preseason game yet. He's a talented kid, but he was a 3rd round pick with 1st or 2nd round talent for a reason. So far he's been exactly what we drafted.
we always had talent. frustrated talent
Oy vey...
A) My comments were not directed to your post specifically but to the many posts on the subject. Those with brains like JonC retorted with intelligence in the spirit of the conversation.
Secondly) Since you chose to insult me personally, GFY.
Cut Hosley a little slack. See if he can become a useful player. Root for him to succeed. We need better players on defense right now. Each guy must step up his game to win in 2015. The Cowboys had a weak D on paper last year but they came together and played rather well.
Spags' Giants can do it too.
It's so strange, like the Hokie bird must have inappropriately touched him as a young child. The blind hate is concerning.
Other than his taste (or lack there of) of collegiate programs, I for the most part agree w/ Greg on various topics. Oh and go Hokies! Go Giants.
Quote:
who roots against Giants from Virginia Tech. This has to be the sickest puppy on this board. The guy can't make a living but he is here all day letting you know how he feels about everything
It's so strange, like the Hokie bird must have inappropriately touched him as a young child. The blind hate is concerning.
Other than his taste (or lack there of) of collegiate programs, I for the most part agree w/ Greg on various topics. Oh and go Hokies! Go Giants.
Despite what he'd say when you asked him directly, he was clearly rooting against Wilson having success, too. Really, really weird.