Giants Mount Rushmore

.

then pick 'em.

Whitlock DT, Whitlock FB, Whitlock ST, and that bum Eli.

for sure.
I then say Roosevelt Brown, Frank Gifford.

close call: Strahan, Mel Hein, Steve Owen.

.

And Butch Woolfolk

..

In comment 12452616 Davisian said:

Quote:

And Butch Woolfolk

Ridiculous. McConkey should be nowhere near that group of scrubs. Shame on you. 2 minutes in the box.

Thomas Randolph
Pete Monty
Jeremy Lincoln

.

We'd need the whole Rocky Mountain chain!

Those Black Hills are too small for all of the Giants' Greats.

Thomas Lewis & TIm Carter

In comment 12452569 David B. said:

Quote:

then pick 'em.

+1

LT, Carson,Bavaro,Gifford

Frank Gifford
Emlen Tunnell
Lawrence Taylor
Michael Strahan

Gifford
Eli
Strahan
LT

Jonas Seawright
Jonas Seawright
Jonas Seawright
Jonas Seawright

the JPP of tight ends?

I say you put Wellington Mara on there, The man who started it all!!!

Mara
LT
Tarkenton
Gifford

As LT! Don't even embarrass him or yourself for suggesting.

Pete Athas, Ottis Anderson, Billy Ard, Will Allen

Rosey Brown, Em Tunnel, Gifford, LT, Y.A., Rote, Huff, Eli, Hein, Bavaro, Simms...

LT
Sam Huff
Gifford
Eli

One from each

Hein
Gifford
Taylor
Eli

I think you have to go with Super Bowls. LT, Parcells, TC and Eli.

LT
Strahan
Harry Carson
Hein or Rosie Brown

Rushmore.


Then more seriously, LT, Gifford, Strahan, Eli.

that think Wellington Mara "started it all"? His father started it. His brother ran it when the Giants were great in mid 50's and early 60's. When his brother Jack died way too young in 1965 Wellington ran it into the ground until his nephew Tim, Jack's son, and 50% owner mutinied in 1979 until Pete Rozelle stepped in and found them George Young. I never met Wellington Mara. His reputation as great family man and gentlemen is most likely true. As a football person not so much. Wellington's son Chris is the Giants football person now and has been since 2011. Seems to going well so far......

.

Really though, you only have a couple spots to play with because we know Eli and LT are both on it..

Maybe Parcells? Simms? I'm sure some of the older guys probably can stake more of a claim, but being born in '89, I never got to see them play so it's tough for me to even know who would be deserving. Gifford? Tarkenton? Tarkenton was more a Viking, right?

I think you can definitely give Strahan a spot also, now that I think about it further..

in my lifetime for sure. #4 could be a lot of people Conerly, Rosie, Tunnel, Simms, Strahan. For me I'll put Parcells on as #4.

Rocky Bernard
Stoney Woodson
Gordon Gravelle