Shocked so many are upset. Big time talent who has potential to be one of the best players in this draft. He was slated to go top 15 so 10th is not some Keanu Neal reach. People are not looking at how bad we need CB and how much this helps us. We now probably have the top 3 CBs in the league!
maybe picked him too high, I don't know for sure. But contrary to popular opinion, the Giants have hit on their last 3 1st round picks, all of whom were considered reaches by some
But I really think the Giants were outmaneuvered and lost out on the two guys they really wanted...Floyd and Conklin. That just shouldn't have happened.
How much are the Giants spending on corners this year?Reese needed to trade up to get the player who would make a difference this year or trade down and build quality thorough the roster. I guess his record with 3rd and 4th round selections is too strong to give them up for a potential all pro player.
just looked at some more highlights, he's very grabby but if you look at it he's grabby at the end of the route he's almost never beaten deep, looks very susceptible to the comeback route.
He's got all the tools but needs a lot of technique work
...and like most of our CBs, I bet he's gone after his rookie contract.
Nay.
I guess this is what happens when you blab to the media that you want Floyd or Conklin... two teams trade up right before you and grab who you want. Freakin' Cedric Jones all over again.
Most of BBI hated Conklin as he would be stuck at RT.
Hated Floyd because he might not be a fit.
And loved Jack who might have a ticking time bomb for a knee.
I don't follow how Apple is a bad pick or how the Giants were out maneuvered. They didn't offer enough to actually trade up or didn't try to trade up? Probably means they didn't value those other guys as much as other teams...
Tunsil is the only reason IMO people should be mad about this pick and everything around him has turned into a train wreck rather quickly.
Yay. He makes enormous sense for the Giants. Gruden had it right about him needing to close his blind spot faster. That's what gets him in trouble. It's analogous to a basketball player working without the ball and getting in the defender's bubble or blind spot. When they get that fixed , he will be their best corner. They can release DRC early.
Makes sense, too, because they are continuing to provide Spagnuolo with the players required for his system. Apple will play a lot of man under coverage. He will be light years better than Wade and the other assholes.
The Buckeyes have been my team since I was 10. One half a century ago. This was an incredible draft class that still has at least 4 future NFL starters yet to be drafted. Maybe 5. And Eli was right up there in the inner circle.
I don't like Reese. But he stayed on his board, didn't panic, and hog himself a helluva football player. My choices at 10 with the Tunail situation would have been Lee or Fuller, but Apple works just fine for me.
I don't watch much college ball so I don't have an opinion about his talents but I like the idea behind they Giants going after a 20 year old highly ranked CB.
and they have a lot of holes. However I also thought great value existed in the next few rounds. IE burns Williams, et al . Bottom line they could have addressed other needs and hit the DB's in the 2nd and 3rd rounds. They will likely still draft another DB as that is how thin this important position is on the giants
I think he has the potential to be thoroughly mediocre.
There are others I'd prefer, yet I felt the same about beckham. It's a crap shoot in a lot of ways and while I have reservations about our front office they have a good record early. I'll be optimistic.
The Giants allowed 4700+ yards passing last year.
They added 2 DL in FA, and a starting CB.
They had Apple as the top DB in the draft....I would have preferred a trade down, but it appears there were no reasonable offers.
LB, another DE, 2nd WR, and OT (Hopefully a trade with SF for Davis!).
While he may not be a finished product, he may have the highest ceiling of any CB in the draft. His 4.4 40 at the combine, followed by the 4.34 he posted on his pro day may make him the fastest CB in the draft.
When the pick of Ramsey was made, the talk was about technique in man coverage, lack of interceptions. Therefore people should give it a rest and embrace the kid as the newest member of our Giants.
Most of BBI hated Conklin as he would be stuck at RT.
Hated Floyd because he might not be a fit.
And loved Jack who might have a ticking time bomb for a knee.
I don't follow how Apple is a bad pick or how the Giants were out maneuvered. They didn't offer enough to actually trade up or didn't try to trade up? Probably means they didn't value those other guys as much as other teams...
Tunsil is the only reason IMO people should be mad about this pick and everything around him has turned into a train wreck rather quickly.
I'd have selected Hargreaves but they needed a 3rd CB and I trust that this guy will be a better player. With the board as it was, if the pick was Hargreaves no one would said squat about that choice.
I'd rather have Tunsil but the Giants were never going to take a guy pictured smoking pot. One of the problems having old greasers as owners.
So, given that reality and getting outFoxed with Floyd, I think Eli is a very good consolation prize. Glad they did not take Hargreaves. Bust written all over him
I'm going yay. If he develops we've got a solid line and cb which makes for a decent d. You need three solid corners to be competitive in this league and he has the speed and height to match up with the top wr's.
We went into the offseason knowing we had to improve the defense. So far we have taken two huge negatives from last year and on paper turned them into big positives.
The first is the defensive line with snacks and Vernon and hopefully healthy seasons from Hankins and Jpp.
The second is our cornerback depth. Prince barely played last year and that left us incredibly thin. Drc janoris and a nice looking rookie will turn a glaring weakness into not only being adequate but being a strength.
I also think Apple has all the tools to be a great player. Size speed strength and he stayed healthy in college.
I don't think he's a terrible pick. I think he can be a decent player. He is an aggressive tackler who is excellent supporting the run and playing when the play is in front of him. However, I think his technique will get him flagged often in the NFL. Also, I do not like that he gets initially beat at the line and the bottom of routes. He is often playing catch up to receivers, which is probably why he is also grabbing as much as he is. The things he got away with in college won't fly in the NFL.
He is athletic and has the physical tools to be a good player. But, I think there were better players available at #10.
The bottom line, though, is that really for Reese to come out OK Apple has to be great. I don't see that happening. This is a real head scratcher pick for a guy whose job really should have been on the line.
You need at least 3 solid CBs today. Apple has great measurables and is still only 20 years old. SB Nation compares him to Patrick Peterson, saying he's more raw but headed in the same direction Petersen was coming out as a big, physical press/man corner.
So much bitching, but who wouldn't sign up for that right now?
This is a real head scratcher pick for a guy whose job really should have been on the line.
Apple was the "cleanest" prospect. If your job is on the line, don't you think you'd take the guy with the least red flags? If my job was on the line, I would have had second thoughts about taking the guy with the gas mask lol.
Really liked Jackson over either Apple or Hargreaves. Giants could have traded down to back half of 1st for Apple. Guy is all projection since his game doesn't translate cleanly to the NFL but he is young so I'll hold out hope.
The stud tackle that would have kicked Newhouse right to the bench was sitting there for the taking. That's the part that really stings the most.
Gotta really question a guy that keeps something like that on his social media though. Back in college when you know your probably going to go to the draft, you delete that crap.
The stud tackle that would have kicked Newhouse right to the bench was sitting there for the taking. That's the part that really stings the most.
Gotta really question a guy that keeps something like that on his social media though. Back in college when you know your probably going to go to the draft, you delete that crap.
He didn't deny it was him but said the video was years old. He claims that his account was hacked and I think I believe him ...otherwise somebody would have found it aloooong time ago. I still would have taken him. Wherever they ended up ... Flowers at one side and Tunsil at the other? ooofah .... who really gives a shit about pot these days? Who is the target audience for the NFL anyway ...?
I think you are right David , but it didn't help ... and he still got drafted at at 13? I don't know why his draft reminds my of that idiot who had a HOF career for Tampa Bay ... (Warren Sapp), but I wouldn't be surprised if Tunsil's career ended up the same way. Who knows?
Seems like they got a guy they could have gotten from 15 to 20. Might as well have drafted Shaq Lawson, or any of the top WRS, like the one who went to the Redskins and will make them better. I was against Leonard Floyd, but man, I wish he was there and the Giants didn't underwhelming so badly with this fruit.
Unfortunately for us, this is not the year to roll the dice like that. We got better today. That's all I could ask for. Look at our acquisitions. To sum it all up, we have a good trio of corners, the best run stuffer in the league, retained JPP, and hauled in the top pass rusher in FA. I wouldn't discount Landon Collins making a big leap, especially after hearing he's down to 217 and looking to get to 210. That has to help him get lighter on his feet and extend his range. Even without a standout LB, Spags has no excuses for not fielding a much better defense. After letting the dust settle, I love this pick more and more.
I like the pick more because the Dolphins wanted him at 13
DRC replacement down the road. My only question is (and yes I know I wasn't in the "war room") if we had Floyd,Conklin as priorities on our board, why didn't JR trade up instead of watching consecutive teams move ahead of us & take those 2 players? Apple will get better,very young, so now let's see what direction we take with #2 & #3.
The team has a huge hole on the right side of the O-Line, the best OL (and arguably the highest rated player in the draft) is sitting there at 10, and instead the team picks a project CB that they could have traded back and picked up. They fired the wrong guy this off-season.
DRC replacement down the road. My only question is (and yes I know I wasn't in the "war room") if we had Floyd,Conklin as priorities on our board, why didn't JR trade up instead of watching consecutive teams move ahead of us & take those 2 players? Apple will get better,very young, so now let's see what direction we take with #2 & #3.
Reese said he looked into it, and they decided the price was too steep.
In comment 12931219 David in LA said:
[quote] In comment 12931199 TheMick7 said:
Quote:
DRC replacement down the road. My only question is (and yes I know I wasn't in the "war room") if we had Floyd,Conklin as priorities on our board, why didn't JR trade up instead of watching consecutive teams move ahead of us & take those 2 players? Apple will get better,very young, so now let's see what direction we take with #2 & #3.
Reese said he looked into it, and they decided the price was too steep. [/quote
We know the price was a 4th & JR was willing to do that for LC last year so I always find it hard to ever believe anything JR says. I watched him on MSG Network after our pick & he had "the shakes" again as he tried to explain his "take" on why he did what he did, just like he did during TC's "retirement" PC. Let's see what happens today
world class speed -- good height - and fluid movements and hips -- there were numerous issues around the other highly ranked prospects.
I like Hargreaves - but his height and coverage of tall receivers was suspect -- Apple solves that problem
I liked Treadwell but he had flaws too.
No way the Giants were going to pick Tunsil - that was broadcast already -- very telling that Stanley was drafted first and then Tenn moved up to take Conklin after being linked with Tunsil for months
If the Giants had Apple ranked higher than Hargreaves then he was the right pick at 10
He did well against strong competition, and most of the players he was going up against were older. At 20 you have to believe there's a lot more growth in his game ahead
To Yay after reading some interesting pre-draft analyses.
My Nay was also based on the belief that they could have gotten him with a lower pick. But the claims by the Giants that he wouldn't have lasted and no decent trades are offered also affected my switch.
I was initially thinking WTF....but Apple was not a guy I had heard much chatter about. You can't change how the top of the draft panned out with Tunsil and Jack falling out of favor. I will trust the Giants followed their board.
Not talking about the moving down comment but the prospect of moving up if indeed either Floyd or Conklin was their #1 choice. Titans flipped first round picks & gave a 3rd but their 1st was 15th. Bears traded a 4th for the 9th & flipped 1sts
since I didn't follow college football or the draft this year, but whether he is a star like odell or a bust like cedric jones will only be judged in 5 years.
Yea
BBI scouts...bwahahaha
just looked at some more highlights, he's very grabby but if you look at it he's grabby at the end of the route he's almost never beaten deep, looks very susceptible to the comeback route.
He's got all the tools but needs a lot of technique work
I'd be worried if he COULD cook, should be on the practice field instead of in the kitchen!
Nay.
I guess this is what happens when you blab to the media that you want Floyd or Conklin... two teams trade up right before you and grab who you want. Freakin' Cedric Jones all over again.
Hated Floyd because he might not be a fit.
And loved Jack who might have a ticking time bomb for a knee.
I don't follow how Apple is a bad pick or how the Giants were out maneuvered. They didn't offer enough to actually trade up or didn't try to trade up? Probably means they didn't value those other guys as much as other teams...
Tunsil is the only reason IMO people should be mad about this pick and everything around him has turned into a train wreck rather quickly.
Yeah. Absolutely.
Makes sense, too, because they are continuing to provide Spagnuolo with the players required for his system. Apple will play a lot of man under coverage. He will be light years better than Wade and the other assholes.
The Buckeyes have been my team since I was 10. One half a century ago. This was an incredible draft class that still has at least 4 future NFL starters yet to be drafted. Maybe 5. And Eli was right up there in the inner circle.
I don't like Reese. But he stayed on his board, didn't panic, and hog himself a helluva football player. My choices at 10 with the Tunail situation would have been Lee or Fuller, but Apple works just fine for me.
I don't watch much college ball so I don't have an opinion about his talents but I like the idea behind they Giants going after a 20 year old highly ranked CB.
At #10!?!?
I'd sooner Karl Joseph, even at #10.
Well unless you can name them it really doesn't mean too much. There are usually a handful of first round players out of thirty that will shine.
I don't get criticism of players at this point. The Giants thought he was the best DB when they picked.
They added 2 DL in FA, and a starting CB.
They had Apple as the top DB in the draft....I would have preferred a trade down, but it appears there were no reasonable offers.
LB, another DE, 2nd WR, and OT (Hopefully a trade with SF for Davis!).
But if Tunsil becomes the dominant pro tackle he was hyped to be and Eli gets injured because our line blows, well...
When the pick of Ramsey was made, the talk was about technique in man coverage, lack of interceptions. Therefore people should give it a rest and embrace the kid as the newest member of our Giants.
Hated Floyd because he might not be a fit.
And loved Jack who might have a ticking time bomb for a knee.
I don't follow how Apple is a bad pick or how the Giants were out maneuvered. They didn't offer enough to actually trade up or didn't try to trade up? Probably means they didn't value those other guys as much as other teams...
Tunsil is the only reason IMO people should be mad about this pick and everything around him has turned into a train wreck rather quickly.
+++
So, given that reality and getting outFoxed with Floyd, I think Eli is a very good consolation prize. Glad they did not take Hargreaves. Bust written all over him
Hope it works out.
The first is the defensive line with snacks and Vernon and hopefully healthy seasons from Hankins and Jpp.
The second is our cornerback depth. Prince barely played last year and that left us incredibly thin. Drc janoris and a nice looking rookie will turn a glaring weakness into not only being adequate but being a strength.
I also think Apple has all the tools to be a great player. Size speed strength and he stayed healthy in college.
He is athletic and has the physical tools to be a good player. But, I think there were better players available at #10.
The bottom line, though, is that really for Reese to come out OK Apple has to be great. I don't see that happening. This is a real head scratcher pick for a guy whose job really should have been on the line.
yep, its going to be Meh. Another pretty good JAG.
So much bitching, but who wouldn't sign up for that right now?
Apple was the "cleanest" prospect. If your job is on the line, don't you think you'd take the guy with the least red flags? If my job was on the line, I would have had second thoughts about taking the guy with the gas mask lol.
OT Tunsil provided better value at pick 10, but, let's revisit this question 4 years from now.
Go Apple.
Glad Floyd was gone. Wanted Conklin, especially since Jacks might be there in the 2nd.
I think CB was a bigger need than DE, where the team still has depth with Double-O as a rusher and Wynn as a run stopper.
CB locks up another starter.
Gotta really question a guy that keeps something like that on his social media though. Back in college when you know your probably going to go to the draft, you delete that crap.
It's easy to say we should have traded down. But there was no enticing enough left to use as leverage.
As usual we won't really know for three years.
This guy will be a backup corner his whole career.
Quote:
The stud tackle that would have kicked Newhouse right to the bench was sitting there for the taking. That's the part that really stings the most.
Gotta really question a guy that keeps something like that on his social media though. Back in college when you know your probably going to go to the draft, you delete that crap.
He didn't deny it was him but said the video was years old. He claims that his account was hacked and I think I believe him ...otherwise somebody would have found it aloooong time ago. I still would have taken him. Wherever they ended up ... Flowers at one side and Tunsil at the other? ooofah .... who really gives a shit about pot these days? Who is the target audience for the NFL anyway ...?
Dream of what exactly? Having your first round pick suspended or out of the league within 3-4 years?
He's going to probably play [pretty] poorly this season while he develops; people are going to have to be patient, again.
I think you are right David , but it didn't help ... and he still got drafted at at 13? I don't know why his draft reminds my of that idiot who had a HOF career for Tampa Bay ... (Warren Sapp), but I wouldn't be surprised if Tunsil's career ended up the same way. Who knows?
No ... welcome to the 1950's ... STILL!
Seems to have all the tools.
I think Apple will be a solid Will Allen caliber player.
So yay with a little bit of meh.
Reese said he looked into it, and they decided the price was too steep.
[quote] In comment 12931199 TheMick7 said:
Quote:
DRC replacement down the road. My only question is (and yes I know I wasn't in the "war room") if we had Floyd,Conklin as priorities on our board, why didn't JR trade up instead of watching consecutive teams move ahead of us & take those 2 players? Apple will get better,very young, so now let's see what direction we take with #2 & #3.
Reese said he looked into it, and they decided the price was too steep. [/quote
We know the price was a 4th & JR was willing to do that for LC last year so I always find it hard to ever believe anything JR says. I watched him on MSG Network after our pick & he had "the shakes" again as he tried to explain his "take" on why he did what he did, just like he did during TC's "retirement" PC. Let's see what happens today
I like Hargreaves - but his height and coverage of tall receivers was suspect -- Apple solves that problem
I liked Treadwell but he had flaws too.
No way the Giants were going to pick Tunsil - that was broadcast already -- very telling that Stanley was drafted first and then Tenn moved up to take Conklin after being linked with Tunsil for months
If the Giants had Apple ranked higher than Hargreaves then he was the right pick at 10
My Nay was also based on the belief that they could have gotten him with a lower pick. But the claims by the Giants that he wouldn't have lasted and no decent trades are offered also affected my switch.
Not talking about the moving down comment but the prospect of moving up if indeed either Floyd or Conklin was their #1 choice. Titans flipped first round picks & gave a 3rd but their 1st was 15th. Bears traded a 4th for the 9th & flipped 1sts
A very safe vanilla pick that was better suited for the 18th -26th slot in the draft
Very happy with the pick, and feel that fans will warm up to him quickly.