Dr James Andrews: Myles Jack Does Not Need Microfracture

Weren't those two guys important key contributors to 3 Super Bowl wins for the Giants?


In comment 12933774 Giants2012 said:

Quote:

Mark Bavaro Kenny Phillips We've seen the result. Kinda tough to take a risk. Smith makes more sense.

In comment 12933762 732NYG said:

Quote:

That's not really the issue they are speaking about. What the issue deals with is Jack's articular, or hyaline, cartilage. There is a layer of smooth cartilage that lines articular surfaces, and Jack has a defect with the blood supply to that area. It's not that it is coming detached, but it can degenerate or even die. It will also heal at a decreased rate.

Jack tore his lateral meniscus in a particular (and unusual) way. The anterior horn of the lateral meniscus attaches to the tibia. He tore the attachment off the tibia and it had to be sewn back on. Not surprising that the injury caused a defect to the articular cartilage lining the tibial plateau.

But, with that granted as the context, the prognosis is all in the details, the medical records and the professional competency of the prognosticator.

In comment 12933798 Randy in CT said:

Quote:

In comment 12933774 Giants2012 said: Quote: Mark Bavaro Kenny Phillips We've seen the result. Kinda tough to take a risk. Smith makes more sense. Because the drop foot isn't a big deal?

We don't know that he still has the drop foot. Is he still wearing an AFO?

In comment 12933415 ryanmkeane said:

Quote:

...

I call so much bs. Myles Jack and his agent lied so he could fall.

Remember TOP 10 Pick LaEl Collins?

Nobody questioned that situation and it is sad because the Leauge made that up so Dallas could get him. So you have him "Supposedly" being involved in a Crime......

Then Collins who Had a tattoo of the Cowboys on his arm said " If I'm not drafted before the Fourth Round I WILL NOT SIGN with any team"

Then what do you know Dallas picks up a Top 10 Pick after going into the NFC championship.

What happens after? The Talk about the Crime VANISHED and he Plays the Following season.

NFL Has never mentioned this "Incident" ever again.


If I'm correct that was last year? Well isn't it Ironic how it sets them up Perfectly Now that they Drafted Elliot?

Does anyone think the Giants Trade up?

...yet.

The concern is if and when he will need it.

Please PASS!!!!!!! We don't need the headache. I'm sick and tire of seeing our defensive players in street clothes.

In comment 12933881 HeavyLevy said:

Quote:

Does anyone think the Giants Trade up?

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

In comment 12933499 Eric from BBI said:

Quote:

did marvelous work with Bob Griffin too (sarcasm off)

He brought a Benny Hill element to that circus.

In comment 12933858 HeavyLevy said:

Quote:

In comment 12933415 ryanmkeane said: Quote: ... I call so much bs. Myles Jack and his agent lied so he could fall. Remember TOP 10 Pick LaEl Collins? Nobody questioned that situation and it is sad because the Leauge made that up so Dallas could get him. So you have him "Supposedly" being involved in a Crime...... Then Collins who Had a tattoo of the Cowboys on his arm said " If I'm not drafted before the Fourth Round I WILL NOT SIGN with any team" Then what do you know Dallas picks up a Top 10 Pick after going into the NFC championship. What happens after? The Talk about the Crime VANISHED and he Plays the Following season. NFL Has never mentioned this "Incident" ever again. If I'm correct that was last year? Well isn't it Ironic how it sets them up Perfectly Now that they Drafted Elliot?

So let me get this straight. You're saying that Myles Jack - widely considered a top 5 prospect - colludes with his agent to falsify a knee injury, thereby losing millions of dollars in the process.

You seriously believe this?

.