for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

NFT: Do You Have A Favorite Potato Salad?

gidiefor : Mod : 6/30/2016 11:42 am
and What's your favorite Potato Salad Recipe?

The NYTimes posted their 11 best PS Recipes today


Quote:
Summer picnics just don't feel complete without at least one potato salad on the table. It tastes great warm or cold, and it's packable and portable. Here are some variations beyond the traditional mayo-laden deli sort (which we love, too!), from lemon potato salad with mint (above) to roasted sweet potato salad with black beans and chile dressing.


-more-
11 of Our Best Potato Salads - ( New Window )
warm  
Berrylish : 6/30/2016 11:44 am : link
german potato salad! yum!
RE: warm  
pjcas18 : 6/30/2016 11:49 am : link
In comment 13015489 Berrylish said:
Quote:
german potato salad! yum!


agree, so good, since I hate all the over-mayonnaised based potato salads.
Italian  
Victor in CT : 6/30/2016 11:49 am : link
sliced red bliss with the skin left on, sliced red onion and basil. salt, pepper, olive oil.
mine is the kind  
YAJ2112 : 6/30/2016 11:56 am : link
with just a baked potato and butter, maybe a little salt and pepper.
RE: Italian  
koko2315 : 6/30/2016 12:03 pm : link
In comment 13015497 Victor in CT said:
Quote:
sliced red bliss with the skin left on, sliced red onion and basil. salt, pepper, olive oil.


add in some hard boiled egg and you're in business
Deviled egg potato salad  
Stan in LA : 6/30/2016 12:19 pm : link
I do a Tarragon Potato/Egg/Bacon salad  
montanagiant : 6/30/2016 12:19 pm : link
That gets some rave reviews.
Do 2lbs of potatoes to 8 hardboiled eggs.
Add a pound of Bacon crumbled
1/4 cup tarragon vinegar
1/4 cup balsamic vinegar
2 tbsp dried Tarragon
1 cup Mayo
2 onions
2 celery stalks
1/4 cup chopped italian parsley
1/2 tsp white pepper
1 tbsp dijon mustard

Salt and Pepper to taste
you can also add capers, dill pickles, even Cilantro if you want

I also mash mine up real good  
montanagiant : 6/30/2016 12:20 pm : link
leave it a bit chunky
Big Daddy's Classic  
Bill in UT : 6/30/2016 12:20 pm : link
has been my favorite the last few years. I'll be making some this weekend


Link - ( New Window )
I make make mine with  
Doomster : 6/30/2016 12:36 pm : link
potatoes, mayo, chopped onion, chopped celery, hard boiled eggs, sweet relish, salt and pepper......and I put it together about 2 hours before serving....
YES. The one my Mom makes..  
10to13td : 6/30/2016 12:45 pm : link
Tastes Great....Not Soggy...Potatoes are Firm...Not to Soft or hard.
Grilled russets....  
Ryan : 6/30/2016 12:58 pm : link
...with bacon and grilled spring onions in a white wine vinaigrette that's got some bacon grease substituted for part of the olive oil. Also like baby golds in a lemon juice, dijon and olive oil dressing with dill and capers. Both are mixed warm/hot and served at room temp.

For a creamy version the one I go with is literally the only recipe I've ever pulled from the nauseatingly pretentious playbook of Vag-Ina Garten.
..  
Named Later : 6/30/2016 1:11 pm : link
Must have Bacon, and lots of it. Don't skimp on the pig.

If you're really feeling it, chop up some Prosciutto.

My mothers  
Vin R : 6/30/2016 1:12 pm : link
.
I like many varieties, but German is my favorite  
Greg from LI : 6/30/2016 1:16 pm : link
Simply, easy to make, and delicious.
This one's solid.  
MOOPS : 6/30/2016 1:19 pm : link
.
Link - ( New Window )
5 lbs Idaho Potatoes chopped ,5 minutes in boiling water is the key  
Shadow : 6/30/2016 1:27 pm : link
That way they don't mash. Small cubes. Mustard, Miracle Whip,Salt,Pepper
Garlic powder,Onion powder,4 chopped Boiled Eggs,1 stalk Celery,2 Dill Pickles chopped. Delicious.
I still use the one printed on the Hellman's Mayo label from years ago  
Klaatu : 6/30/2016 1:30 pm : link
Still tasty after all these years.
I agree klatuu  
Mike B from JC : 6/30/2016 1:45 pm : link
The Hellman's recipe is a good one. Sometimes just add a little Dijon mustard to it, gives it a little more flavor.
Potatoes are one of those foods you can do so many different  
Ira : 6/30/2016 1:53 pm : link
things with and get very good results.
Miracle Whip?  
Ten Ton Hammer : 6/30/2016 1:55 pm : link
What planet are you from?
Miracle Whip is one of the most disgusting substances known to man  
Greg from LI : 6/30/2016 1:56 pm : link
.
Wtf..  
Vin R : 6/30/2016 1:59 pm : link
Miracle Whip...
RE: I do a Tarragon Potato/Egg/Bacon salad  
BlueLou : 6/30/2016 2:08 pm : link
In comment 13015579 montanagiant said:
Quote:
That gets some rave reviews.
Do 2lbs of potatoes to 8 hardboiled eggs.
Add a pound of Bacon crumbled
1/4 cup tarragon vinegar
1/4 cup balsamic vinegar
2 tbsp dried Tarragon
1 cup Mayo
2 onions
2 celery stalks
1/4 cup chopped italian parsley
1/2 tsp white pepper
1 tbsp dijon mustard

Salt and Pepper to taste
you can also add capers, dill pickles, even Cilantro if you want


That is damn close to mine that I call "French," potato salad. Difference are, in mine:

1) No bacon (du'oh)
2) White wine or cider vinegar instead of the balsamic and tarragon vinegars
3) Plenty of freshly chopped tarragon.
4) Always use plenty of minced pickles, Cornichons are best but large Kosher Dill's work too. Get the best brand you can...
5) Less mayonnaise but a good bit of best quality aromatic evoo, OR make your own mayo from EVOO (too time consuming for me)
6) Replace half or all the chopped onion with chopped green onions.

Capers optional
Minced marinated sweet red bell peppers optional

But sans the bacon it's the same flavor profile.

Use red or another waxy yellow fleshed potatoes, ones that are less starchy and don't get mealy when boiled and cut up.

Yellow new potatoes are the best. Plenty of fresh ground black or multi-color peppercorns.
My favorite potato salad  
Modus Operandi : 6/30/2016 2:10 pm : link
Is the one on someone else's plate. Blech.
My favorite Tator Salad  
fbdad : 6/30/2016 3:37 pm : link
is Ron White
Mmmm  
B in ALB : 6/30/2016 3:43 pm : link
Drambuie and potato salad.
RE: RE: I do a Tarragon Potato/Egg/Bacon salad  
montanagiant : 6/30/2016 4:00 pm : link
In comment 13015841 BlueLou said:
Quote:
In comment 13015579 montanagiant said:


Quote:


That gets some rave reviews.
Do 2lbs of potatoes to 8 hardboiled eggs.
Add a pound of Bacon crumbled
1/4 cup tarragon vinegar
1/4 cup balsamic vinegar
2 tbsp dried Tarragon
1 cup Mayo
2 onions
2 celery stalks
1/4 cup chopped italian parsley
1/2 tsp white pepper
1 tbsp dijon mustard

Salt and Pepper to taste
you can also add capers, dill pickles, even Cilantro if you want




That is damn close to mine that I call "French," potato salad. Difference are, in mine:

1) No bacon (du'oh)
2) White wine or cider vinegar instead of the balsamic and tarragon vinegars
3) Plenty of freshly chopped tarragon.
4) Always use plenty of minced pickles, Cornichons are best but large Kosher Dill's work too. Get the best brand you can...
5) Less mayonnaise but a good bit of best quality aromatic evoo, OR make your own mayo from EVOO (too time consuming for me)
6) Replace half or all the chopped onion with chopped green onions.

Capers optional
Minced marinated sweet red bell peppers optional

But sans the bacon it's the same flavor profile.

Use red or another waxy yellow fleshed potatoes, ones that are less starchy and don't get mealy when boiled and cut up.

Yellow new potatoes are the best. Plenty of fresh ground black or multi-color peppercorns.

Yeah sometimes I replace the Balsamic for the Cider vinegar and do like mixing in Green Onions also. I make a real good Pico that usually the next day I mix in with the potato salad for some kick
Potato salad, like egg salad, can be either very good or....  
Crispino : 6/30/2016 9:52 pm : link
very bad, depending on how it's made. My wife's grandmother made the best I've ever had. Family simple, pretty chunky with a bit of bacon and celery. Don't know the details of the recipe, unfortunately.
RE: Miracle Whip?  
Shadow : 6/30/2016 10:25 pm : link
In comment 13015815 Ten Ton Hammer said:
Quote:
What planet are you from?

Miracle Whip With yellow mustard gives it a nice creamy sauce. Mayo is no creamy enough. Mayo is Whipped Egg yolks and oil. Tangy. Miracle Whip is better
Miracle Whip was invented in 1933 as a sweeter, more flavorful alternative to mayonnaise, but it contains a few extra ingredients that the FDA says aren't supposed to be in mayonnaise, such as sugar, paprika, and garlic powder.
I love Garlic.
RE: RE: RE: I do a Tarragon Potato/Egg/Bacon salad  
BlueLou : 7/1/2016 2:55 am : link
In comment 13016060 montanagiant said:
Quote:
In comment 13015579 montanagiant said :
Quote:

Yeah sometimes I replace the Balsamic for the Cider vinegar and do like mixing in Green Onions also. I make a real good Pico that usually the next day I mix in with the potato salad for some kick


The balsamic was the one thing in your recipe that's never worked out well for me in PS. In fact I used it only once when I discovered I was out of cider vinegar. I didn't like the sweetness it introduced to the PS at all.

The addition of Pico the day after sounds interesting, but mine is spicier than yours to start out because, my best guess would be, I use twice or more as much Dijon to start.

I can't say definitively because of course I don't measure anything, but I would guess 2-3 tblsp of Dijon mustard for a kilo of taters.

A nice variation on that is one tblsp Dijon and 1 tblsp grainy French mustard A La Ancienne.

Mine evolved or developed originally when I was chef at 464 Magnolia, a very trendy and upscale restaurant in Larkspur, Marin County, CA.

For the restaurant once in a while I would want to roll out a "salade compose" special of 3 small salads on one plate that would complement one another. I wouldn't dared have used commercial mayonnaise there so initially I used a home made evoo based mayo and ultimately for visual purposes dropped the mayo altogether and just used evoo and vinegar... also at the resto level only baby red potatoes with the skins left on for visuals. It's a prettier dish when the sauce is transparent.

I was pleased to note you specified flat leaf Italian parsley. Curly leaf parsley isn't the same flavor at all. With enough green stuff and the roasted red pimentos in it, it's really an attractive salad visually. In the restaurant we called it potato salad "Provencal".
Another flattering herbal variation is to use a  
BlueLou : 7/1/2016 3:20 am : link
"fines herbs" blend of fresh parsley, tarragon, chives and chervil. If you can find fresh chervil...

My Moroccan MIL used to regularly make a very simple potato salad of potatoes, hard cooked eggs, mayo, a bare hint of mustard (if at all), fresh dill and diced carrots and baby peas. It was good, but weird to me.

Moroccan tradition dictates making at least half a dozen salads for presentation on the table before your first course, along with dishes of olives of course. Because some or many of the Moroccan salads are spicy hot, a rather bland potato salad is a welcome relief among spicy eggplant, spicy tomatoes, and simple plates of garlic loaded grilled hot peppers.
Miss my MIL's cooking and generosity for our large Shabbat Friday evening dinner gatherings of 20 or more.
RE: RE: Miracle Whip?  
chopperhatch : 7/1/2016 3:31 am : link
In comment 13016577 Shadow said:
Quote:
In comment 13015815 Ten Ton Hammer said:


Quote:


What planet are you from?


Miracle Whip With yellow mustard gives it a nice creamy sauce. Mayo is no creamy enough. Mayo is Whipped Egg yolks and oil. Tangy. Miracle Whip is better
Miracle Whip was invented in 1933 as a sweeter, more flavorful alternative to mayonnaise, but it contains a few extra ingredients that the FDA says aren't supposed to be in mayonnaise, such as sugar, paprika, and garlic powder.
I love Garlic.


I got your back on this. Miracle whip is good also on baloney sangweeches.
I use the brine from a dill pickle  
PEEJ : 7/1/2016 6:58 am : link
jar instead of vinegar for a little extra tang. Red Bliss potatoes hold their shape better than some others and don't disintegrate in the bowl.
RE: I use the brine from a dill pickle  
BlueLou : 7/1/2016 7:09 am : link
In comment 13016834 PEEJ said:
Quote:
jar instead of vinegar for a little extra tang. Red Bliss potatoes hold their shape better than some others and don't disintegrate in the bowl.


I think you mean vinegar from the dill pickle jar not brine. If you examine pickles carefully there are two distinct types, pickles in brine or pickle in vinegar.

Generally speaking, DILL pickles are jarred in vinegar.
RE: RE: RE: RE: I do a Tarragon Potato/Egg/Bacon salad  
montanagiant : 7/1/2016 9:55 am : link
In comment 13016796 BlueLou said:
Quote:
In comment 13016060 montanagiant said:


Quote:


In comment 13015579 montanagiant said :
Quote:

Yeah sometimes I replace the Balsamic for the Cider vinegar and do like mixing in Green Onions also. I make a real good Pico that usually the next day I mix in with the potato salad for some kick



The balsamic was the one thing in your recipe that's never worked out well for me in PS. In fact I used it only once when I discovered I was out of cider vinegar. I didn't like the sweetness it introduced to the PS at all.

The addition of Pico the day after sounds interesting, but mine is spicier than yours to start out because, my best guess would be, I use twice or more as much Dijon to start.

I can't say definitively because of course I don't measure anything, but I would guess 2-3 tblsp of Dijon mustard for a kilo of taters.

A nice variation on that is one tblsp Dijon and 1 tblsp grainy French mustard A La Ancienne.

Mine evolved or developed originally when I was chef at 464 Magnolia, a very trendy and upscale restaurant in Larkspur, Marin County, CA.

For the restaurant once in a while I would want to roll out a "salade compose" special of 3 small salads on one plate that would complement one another. I wouldn't dared have used commercial mayonnaise there so initially I used a home made evoo based mayo and ultimately for visual purposes dropped the mayo altogether and just used evoo and vinegar... also at the resto level only baby red potatoes with the skins left on for visuals. It's a prettier dish when the sauce is transparent.

I was pleased to note you specified flat leaf Italian parsley. Curly leaf parsley isn't the same flavor at all. With enough green stuff and the roasted red pimentos in it, it's really an attractive salad visually. In the restaurant we called it potato salad "Provencal".

How much Pimentos would you add? That sounds like an interesting variation. Have you ever tried the Cilantro in it? I go light on it if I put it in but it adds some nice flavor. That was what led to adding my Pico the next day
My mother's  
Joey in VA : 7/1/2016 12:10 pm : link
By a mile. One thing she makes that I have tasted better anywhere is her potato salad. It's simple but somehow amazing, hard boiled eggs, celery, mayo, paprika, pepper and celery salt and it's my absolute favorite summer bbq side dish.
Back to the Corner