for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

Fielding Punts At/Inside The Ten

CRinCA : 10/16/2016 6:17 pm
I thought one of football's cardinal rules was to stay away from the ball if the ball is punted that deep. Yet Harris fielded them multiple times today.

Is there something I am simply not understanding or is this poor decision-making on Harris' part?

It's not that simple.  
BlackLight : 10/16/2016 6:22 pm : link
If you see the coverage closing in, and the ball lands inside the 10, you have to assume they'll have a great chance to down it near the goal line. Given that, you'd definitely choose to fair catch it at the 7.

Harris's job is to simultaneously judge where the ball will land, and the likelihood that the coverage will get to it before it goes over the goal line.

I thought Harris did a good job of managing  
gidiefor : Mod : 10/16/2016 6:28 pm : link
punts that could have been downed closer to the goal line
RE: It's not that simple.  
rdt288 : 10/16/2016 6:41 pm : link
In comment 13176555 BlackLight said:
Quote:
If you see the coverage closing in, and the ball lands inside the 10, you have to assume they'll have a great chance to down it near the goal line. Given that, you'd definitely choose to fair catch it at the 7.

Harris's job is to simultaneously judge where the ball will land, and the likelihood that the coverage will get to it before it goes over the goal line.


It is that simple. U put your feet on ten yardline and if it goes over your head you deal w result. It was like Ruben randle only worse
To be fair to Harris he had one where there was clear room to run  
bigbluescot : 10/16/2016 6:44 pm : link
in front of him, but a guy missed a block and the gunner caught him by the shoelaces.
RE: It's not that simple.  
Osi Osi Osi OyOyOy : 10/16/2016 6:45 pm : link
In comment 13176555 BlackLight said:
Quote:
If you see the coverage closing in, and the ball lands inside the 10, you have to assume they'll have a great chance to down it near the goal line. Given that, you'd definitely choose to fair catch it at the 7.

Harris's job is to simultaneously judge where the ball will land, and the likelihood that the coverage will get to it before it goes over the goal line.


Agreed, I thought Harris did a good job with this today.

Harris has fumblitis and it's a big problem to have as a returner. But his football IQ and toughness are both positives for our special teams unit.
Doesn't make sense to me either  
oldutican : 10/16/2016 6:53 pm : link
These are the possibilities when you fair catch inside 10:
1. You catch it and get the ball there.
2. You muff it and give up ball inside the 10.
3. The ball bites and it is downed inside the 10, maybe at the goal line.
4. It bounces into end zone for touchback.


RE: RE: It's not that simple.  
BlackLight : 10/16/2016 8:17 pm : link
In comment 13176615 rdt288 said:
Quote:
In comment 13176555 BlackLight said:


Quote:


If you see the coverage closing in, and the ball lands inside the 10, you have to assume they'll have a great chance to down it near the goal line. Given that, you'd definitely choose to fair catch it at the 7.

Harris's job is to simultaneously judge where the ball will land, and the likelihood that the coverage will get to it before it goes over the goal line.




It is that simple. U put your feet on ten yardline and if it goes over your head you deal w result. It was like Ruben randle only worse



Inexperienced returners might be taught to let it go over their heads at the 10. But the fact is, there's a significant difference between starting your drive on your 7, and starting your drive on your 1 or 2. Every QB/HC in the league would take the former over the latter.
Back to the Corner