NFT: Favorite Brand of Ice Cream (throw in flavors, too)

1/2 pint: Ben & Jerry's NY Superfudge Chunk

I can't eat just one Klondike classic

Oh for the days of a mello roll or orange/vanilla creamsicle at Jones Beach or Far Rockaway when I was a kid.

In comment 13330607 nygfaninorlando said:

Quote:

Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip. Try it sometime and thank me later.

My roommate in college was from Cincy and wouldn't shut up about Graeter's and skyline chili. He hyped it up to a point where I thought that couldn't meet the expectations. Skyline was woefully dissapointing but Graeters is the best ice cream I've had. Cookies and Cream.

Too bad that it's only in the Midwest.

try Phish Food. I'm pretty indifferent about Ben and Jerrys but Phish Food is the one that you overlook but tastes the best. I get the milkshake version at the kiosk in Penn Station.

Awesome. Also love Cherry Garcia.

Has come in strong and is great. Slow churned flavors are great also. My face's are still fattie gelato whenever i get it fresh.

in Red Hook, NY.

turkey hill chocolate peanut butter Cup. End of story.

Soooo good. Oooouuuuuuu.

I like it more than I like the Yankees--a lot more.

Can't think of the name of it but salted caramel is the one we always get

.

As a basic go to ice cream to keep stocked in the freezer. But then they kept tweaking the formula, presumably to stretch out the product (i.e. Stealth inflation). Its now less creamy, more gummy, and they pump way more air into it such that it really has become inedible in my mind. Assholes ruined a great product.

Got my first paycheck. Brought home a half gallon of Dad's favorite for him. I think it cost $2.25 for that mint chocolate chip. Best ice cream I've ever tasted. To this day.

Carvel and Breyers

heath bar crunch is my all time favorite...but that new Halo top shit is excellent. Classic vanilla bean.

You can find it in the city and tri-state area though. Excellent stuff.

is Breyers Vanilla not mentioned 20 times?

They have a Blueberry Waffle Cone ice cream where the waffle cone is mixed in. Amazing.

Halo farms. Esp the mint chip. Cheap, too

Unless you've tried Ample Hills Creamery out of Brooklyn, the flavor, Salted Crack Caramel. There is nothing that compares.

My favorite was the Mississippi Mud

Ben & Jerry's Cherry Garcia is another favorite

Breyers Vanilla.

Oh and FYI...If you're out east on Long Island, the pistachio cherry at McNulty's in Miller Place is my favorite ice cream of all time.

In comment 13330692 feelflows said:

Quote:

is Breyers Vanilla not mentioned 20 times?

+1

Talenti's Southern Butter Pecan is pretty swell; I do confess to being unable to curb binging on Breyer's Vanilla with the real specks of black vanilla beans

I'm not a huge sweets guy, but I enjoy a good ice cream now and then. What immediately comes to mind -

Stewart's Mint Cookie Crumble
Stewart's Chocolate Peanut Butter
Stewart's Black Raspberry
Kilwin's Salted Caramel

is good, and not nearly as bad for you as I would have expected. Edy's Slow Churned Chocolate Chip Mint is my go-to.

Vanilla for a national brand.

For homemade here in Rockville Center on Long Island is a place called Five Pennies that makes a Banana Pudding ice cream that is the best flavor ever

- Mint Choc Choc Chip (for hand dip)
- Skan-Ellus Raspberry / Vanilla twist (soft serve drive-in in Skaneateles, NY. Can't go to the Finger Lakes without stopping there).

Milk and Cookies

also, my local icre cream parlor - Hillside Farms has the best ice cream and chocolate milk you will ever taste.

perfection

It's not only available in the Midwest.

I get it at Fresh Market, I live in Atlanta.

A friend brought back Peachy Peterno from State College Creamery and it was really good. Only flavor I've had from there but would be willing to try more

Holsten's Cookies and Cream
Hoffman's Coffee Oreo (Jersey Shore)

when I do eat it, usually in the summer at a beach location when we take the kids, my favorite flavor is mocha chip and it comes from an ice cream shop, blindfolded I couldn't tell Ben and Jerry's from store bought brand.

however my wife a couple years ago bought this girl scout cookie thin mint ice cream and it's great.

We only had the thin mint not the other two

love the Mexican vanilla

ITHACA, NY.

Flat out perfection.

and Ben & Jerry's Sweet Cream & Cookies. Thanks, now I'm hungry!

Ooey Gooey Butter Cake

Not mentioned? Cmon.

It's like all cream.

Was shocked, it's awesome.

In comment 13331508 beatrixkiddo said:

Quote:

Not mentioned? Cmon.

Check my post. I represented.

In comment 13330810 dep026 said:

Quote:

also, my local icre cream parlor - Hillside Farms has the best ice cream and chocolate milk you will ever taste.

Yes, Hillside Farms is fantastic. Being that you are from the area, if you ever get down to Nescopek, there was a great place called Cruzer's. I'm not sure if they are still there, but the owners had attended the Penn State classes on ice cream making and made their own small batch varieties. They would only make a half a dozen varieties for each day. The ice cream would be set in stainless steel pans, and when it was gone that was it. A bit more expensive per scoop, but their product was amazing.

The Tonight Dough ... I'm addicted and I don't have a particularly sweet toof at all.

In comment 13330717 barens said:

Quote:

Unless you've tried Ample Hills Creamery out of Brooklyn, the flavor, Salted Crack Caramel. There is nothing that compares.

Ample Hills is outstanding. Quickly became my favorite this past year.

Not retail, but I also love Mystic Drawbridge in Mystic, CT.

chocolate chip cookie dough

Cinnamon Buns.

Not always easy to find but it's fucking good.

Vanilla Swiss Almond.

ben and jerry's - coffee toffee bar crunch
stewart's - stargazer light
friendly's - butter crunch

i'll get coffee, espresso or mocha flavors from any brand to be "safe"

Real natural ingredients and tastes great.

Pistachio