Jerry has developed a reputation for being strict about not overpaying a player, even with a Giant like Tuck, who had a big role in both Super Bowl seasons.
The times have changed. Jerry has gone from "In Jerry we Trust" to "Jerry's a bust" after recent drafts that have not gone well and the absence of the Giants from the playoffs for four years.
This last season everything turned for Reese. And you can be sure that Jerry more than anyone wants to keep his magic defense together where it might solidify his reputation as an exceptional GM.
His quick and decisive actions in the free agent market, signing three players who wound up on the 1st or 2nd All Pro team.
His vindication for his acquisition of the prior year, DRC, who eliminated any doubts about him with his team-leading six picks, and 21 pass defenses and his excellence as a blitzer. Last years's 2nd round choice, Collins, who looked to some as if he were headed for a short career in the NFL, turned into one of the NFC's top defensive players.
And both of this year's top two draft picks, Eli Apple and Shepard, had successful rookie seasons, both making somebody's all rookie team.
Gil Brandt said of Apple: Some thought the Giants reached for Apple in the draft, but I think he outplayed expectations, posting 51 tackles, a pick and a forced fumble. Apple looks like he'll be a cornerback in the NFL for a long time; he can play inside or outside.
Jerry pulled out the checkbook for the first time last off-season and found that the experience was pretty good.
Use your eyes. The pass rush was weak all season, and the best football the defense played happened after JPP went down.
And he's about to get paid like an indispensable player. Doesn't add up.
The first seven games of the year the DL only produced four sacks. JPP had two and Vernon one. Maybe it was because they had never played together as a unit and two were new to Spags' system.
Come games eight through twelve. the DL had 15 sacks. Vernon had seven, including two in game 12 at the Steelers. The pass rush was not weak during those five games. Use your eyes to look up the stats.
Game twelve against the Steelers was the last for JPP. In games 13 through 17 (including the playoff game), Vernon had one half of a sack.
Should this be surprising? You have two good pass rushing ends and they can only double one, which was usually JPP. If you have only one then they can double him all the time. If your one guy gets hurt then you've got no on the end who can rush the passer. Season over.
Use your eyes. The pass rush was weak all season, and the best football the defense played happened after JPP went down.
And he's about to get paid like an indispensable player. Doesn't add up.
Get off that MD crack. Our sack numbers dropped significantly when he went out across the board. JPP opens up more hurried and sacks for everyone on the line.
2 straight years with the financial well being of his grandkids grandkids on the line and he blew up his hand with fireworks one year and had a so-so year the 2nd year.
Once he gets $$$$$ what do you think is going to happen?
not the player he once was in spite of his great effort to make a comeback. Love his heart, but really 5.5 sacks against Chicago and Cleveland... Let Okara (spelling) get his chance or draft me a DE.
can stay healthy they'll force alot of presure and sacks.But that is one of the question marks to me.the second one is the salary cap,can the giants pay both?
Get off that MD crack. Our sack numbers dropped significantly when he went out across the board. JPP opens up more hurried and sacks for everyone on the line.
Gotta agree. JPP was hitting that Oline hard and added pressure on just about every snap.
Giants just seem to have their number for a player
and wont go past it. I suspect that number for JPP will sway towards the Giants favor considering JPP's injury history, he didn't finish the season, let's remember that.
For that reason, I see him getting tagged becsude he will not like the number.
I'd rather use that money on 2 LBs that would create havoc and actually cover a TE or a RB out of the backfield than someone who gets close but doesn't really cause any damage.
Where are you getting these guys from? FA? No you're not.
You guys act like FA is a trade game. It's anything but.
Sure...i'd trade JPP for two monster 4-3 LBs too. Who the hell wouldn't? But first off, two great LBs will cost twice what JPP would cost and second, those guys aren't sitting in the FA market with arms wide open for NYG hugs and kisses.
Where's this great FA TE everyone keeps talking about? I don't see him.
Keep JPP assuming he takes something close to Vernon for maybe one less year. It's the only move here.
correlation does not imply causation. Are you honestly trying to say that JPP's absence actually HELPED the pass rush?
The entire defense got better and better as the season progressed. JPP's pass rush improved. Vernon's improved. Then JPP goes down, the Giants play spirited in his absence for 3 out of the 5 weeks he missed and now you're parroting a wacky theory that JPP was actually hurting the pass rush here.
The D would have been even better if JPP was in the lineup and lest we forget that the D played like shit in the biggest game of the year.
QB hurries and pressures are wins for the the DL. They are impact plays. And he made them early and often this year. It wasn't just at the midway point when sack number rose. He did it starting week 2 when JPP was the best defender on the field vs Dallas.
Sacks? That makes up about 1-2% of the total plays of a DL. But let's keep talking about it as the only way a DL brings value to his team.
this way we can all dance and sing kumbaya when JPP leads the Giants defense to a super bowl title one of these coming seasons. That's not a shot by the way, just being hopeful. We have all been wrong about personnel decisions here. You just happened to be wrong about Strahan, the greatest NYG player since LT.
I don't even need to look at stats with a guy like JPP
none of should need to look at the stats, or hurries, hits and sack numbers. Just watch the guy play! He wins more often than not. He's always active. He rarely if every gets washed out. His arms are always swinging around and making things tough on the opposing offense. That's enough for me.
I'm saying the defense was able to function at its highest level despite JPP's absence. To me that says something about whether paying him a huge contract is essential to continued defensive success.
I don't know why you bring up Strahan. Weren't you one of the guys that killed me for calling out Shockey? How did that work out? How did Plax work out after I said to trade him in September 2008? How did Lavar Arrington work out when I was the only guy on this board saying he wasn't worth signing? Shit what did JPP do a couple months after I said he might become a problem? He blew half his hand off. Sorry, but that's not my fault.
He's gonna be back, and I'll root for him. I'm on record as saying the money is better spent elsewhere. Specifically, use it to sign Logan Ryan and ensure that we have the top three CB positions locked down with young talent for the next three years. It's a cheaper route that I think yields more benefit, and probably leaves enough money to help the offensive line.
The Patriots offense was able to function just fine, to the tune of 3-1 without Brady. Should we discredit him for that?
Football is a team game. It's not as simple as pointing to one guy for overall success or failure as a team or unit.
Christ, I never said JPP being out was the reason we got better. I said we know that the defense functioned at a high level without him. I think that matters when we talk about whether to pay him a cornerstone contract.
how can anyone in his shoes say that with a straight face? he made 18 ish mil over the last 2 years, just from football. who knows about endorsements, and that doesn't include his rookie contract. Even if he made horrible, horrible investment decisions, what he'll get from even a bad contract will still allow him to feed his family for the rest of his life.
I don't begrudge him making as much as he can. Just knock off with the bullshit.
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
When it matters? Doesn't every snap matter? You mean crunch-time, right? If so you are contradicting yourself because our very own JPP is awesome at making plays 'when they matter'.. and btw saying JJ Watt is overrated and that you've "never" seen him make plays when it matters will only lead me to believe you "never" seen him play because there hasn't been a bigger playmaker on defense since L.T.
What??? Of course there is only so much he can do LOL there is only so much anyone can do but he can be the best player in the NFL at any spot across the D-Line.
That's like saying.. Odell isn't overrated BUT there's just only so much he can do.. He cant pass block or rush the passer.. WTF?! that's so dumb to say.
You don't like Watt's game either? That's harder to understand than your comments on JPP. Watt is an all timer. One of the best ever. It's Reggie White and then Watt. Watt may be even better than White. Who's been better than this guy in the last 20 years?
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
Holy crap! Is this a joke? Either you are talking out of your ass and you've seen maybe 3 snaps or you have no idea what you see.
This is easily one of the most ridiculous things I have seen on bbi.
Of course Terps doesn't love his game. But the more truthful statement from terps should read as " I don't like him"
Watt is a madman on the field. HE's easily the most disruptive DLineman in the NFL. Whether or not he comes back as awesome following the back thing remains to be seen but I wouldn't bet against him.
you'd be better off quitting the Watt debate. You will lose. Watt eats opposing offenses whole. He's not even human if you ask me. How on earth you could question this guy's greatness is nuts. Kwall is right. He's right there with White but White did it for 15 years. Watt has only done it for 4-5, give or take.
If you have gamepass, go watch some Texans games from the last few years. Watt doesn't just stand out he dominates the scene.
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
You can't be serious.
Watt makes plenty of plays and thats when being double teamed on every down
RE: Jerry Reese. The biggest reason that JPP will be resigned.
Jerry has developed a reputation for being strict about not overpaying a player, even with a Giant like Tuck, who had a big role in both Super Bowl seasons.
The times have changed. Jerry has gone from "In Jerry we Trust" to "Jerry's a bust" after recent drafts that have not gone well and the absence of the Giants from the playoffs for four years.
This last season everything turned for Reese. And you can be sure that Jerry more than anyone wants to keep his magic defense together where it might solidify his reputation as an exceptional GM.
His quick and decisive actions in the free agent market, signing three players who wound up on the 1st or 2nd All Pro team.
His vindication for his acquisition of the prior year, DRC, who eliminated any doubts about him with his team-leading six picks, and 21 pass defenses and his excellence as a blitzer. Last years's 2nd round choice, Collins, who looked to some as if he were headed for a short career in the NFL, turned into one of the NFC's top defensive players.
And both of this year's top two draft picks, Eli Apple and Shepard, had successful rookie seasons, both making somebody's all rookie team.
Gil Brandt said of Apple: Some thought the Giants reached for Apple in the draft, but I think he outplayed expectations, posting 51 tackles, a pick and a forced fumble. Apple looks like he'll be a cornerback in the NFL for a long time; he can play inside or outside.
Jerry pulled out the checkbook for the first time last off-season and found that the experience was pretty good.
Jerry pulled out the check book because his own job was on the line..
RE: RE: Jerry Reese. The biggest reason that JPP will be resigned.
Jerry has developed a reputation for being strict about not overpaying a player, even with a Giant like Tuck, who had a big role in both Super Bowl seasons.
The times have changed. Jerry has gone from "In Jerry we Trust" to "Jerry's a bust" after recent drafts that have not gone well and the absence of the Giants from the playoffs for four years.
This last season everything turned for Reese. And you can be sure that Jerry more than anyone wants to keep his magic defense together where it might solidify his reputation as an exceptional GM.
His quick and decisive actions in the free agent market, signing three players who wound up on the 1st or 2nd All Pro team.
His vindication for his acquisition of the prior year, DRC, who eliminated any doubts about him with his team-leading six picks, and 21 pass defenses and his excellence as a blitzer. Last years's 2nd round choice, Collins, who looked to some as if he were headed for a short career in the NFL, turned into one of the NFC's top defensive players.
And both of this year's top two draft picks, Eli Apple and Shepard, had successful rookie seasons, both making somebody's all rookie team.
Gil Brandt said of Apple: Some thought the Giants reached for Apple in the draft, but I think he outplayed expectations, posting 51 tackles, a pick and a forced fumble. Apple looks like he'll be a cornerback in the NFL for a long time; he can play inside or outside.
Jerry pulled out the checkbook for the first time last off-season and found that the experience was pretty good.
Jerry pulled out the check book because his own job was on the line..
No he pulled out the check book because we had the cap space to do it
The best QB, RB, WR, and Defensive Player of the last decade.
Their teams were able to survive without them for extended stretches, you could argue the Lions actually thrived without Megatron. This is a team sport.
Just because this D played great without JPP doesn't mean he wasn't an important cog. Our DL talent level is one of the main reasons we're so good, let's keep it that way.
Because a big part of your case is "the defense was fine without JPP".
Right now, We can just ignore the small sample size to come up with the conclusion
Watt was brought up because he was out this year in Houston In a larger sample size, the Houston defense was not only fine without him they were the best in the league. Does this mean the team is better going forward without Watt? Hell no!
Sane weak argument can be made about Gronk in NE. He missed time they keep winning. Better withoit him next year? No chance.
JPP is one of the best at his position. You don't just lose a guy like that and easily replace him with a rookie or our current backups.
The times have changed. Jerry has gone from "In Jerry we Trust" to "Jerry's a bust" after recent drafts that have not gone well and the absence of the Giants from the playoffs for four years.
This last season everything turned for Reese. And you can be sure that Jerry more than anyone wants to keep his magic defense together where it might solidify his reputation as an exceptional GM.
His quick and decisive actions in the free agent market, signing three players who wound up on the 1st or 2nd All Pro team.
His vindication for his acquisition of the prior year, DRC, who eliminated any doubts about him with his team-leading six picks, and 21 pass defenses and his excellence as a blitzer. Last years's 2nd round choice, Collins, who looked to some as if he were headed for a short career in the NFL, turned into one of the NFC's top defensive players.
And both of this year's top two draft picks, Eli Apple and Shepard, had successful rookie seasons, both making somebody's all rookie team.
Gil Brandt said of Apple: Some thought the Giants reached for Apple in the draft, but I think he outplayed expectations, posting 51 tackles, a pick and a forced fumble. Apple looks like he'll be a cornerback in the NFL for a long time; he can play inside or outside.
Jerry pulled out the checkbook for the first time last off-season and found that the experience was pretty good.
And he's about to get paid like an indispensable player. Doesn't add up.
The first seven games of the year the DL only produced four sacks. JPP had two and Vernon one. Maybe it was because they had never played together as a unit and two were new to Spags' system.
Come games eight through twelve. the DL had 15 sacks. Vernon had seven, including two in game 12 at the Steelers. The pass rush was not weak during those five games. Use your eyes to look up the stats.
Game twelve against the Steelers was the last for JPP. In games 13 through 17 (including the playoff game), Vernon had one half of a sack.
Should this be surprising? You have two good pass rushing ends and they can only double one, which was usually JPP. If you have only one then they can double him all the time. If your one guy gets hurt then you've got no on the end who can rush the passer. Season over.
And he's about to get paid like an indispensable player. Doesn't add up.
Get off that MD crack. Our sack numbers dropped significantly when he went out across the board. JPP opens up more hurried and sacks for everyone on the line.
Quote:
2 straight years with the financial well being of his grandkids grandkids on the line and he blew up his hand with fireworks one year and had a so-so year the 2nd year.
Once he gets $$$$$ what do you think is going to happen?
You can't win with idiots.
Can't debate with them either.
Brilliant response djm
Get off that MD crack. Our sack numbers dropped significantly when he went out across the board. JPP opens up more hurried and sacks for everyone on the line.
Gotta agree. JPP was hitting that Oline hard and added pressure on just about every snap.
For that reason, I see him getting tagged becsude he will not like the number.
Where are you getting these guys from? FA? No you're not.
You guys act like FA is a trade game. It's anything but.
Sure...i'd trade JPP for two monster 4-3 LBs too. Who the hell wouldn't? But first off, two great LBs will cost twice what JPP would cost and second, those guys aren't sitting in the FA market with arms wide open for NYG hugs and kisses.
Where's this great FA TE everyone keeps talking about? I don't see him.
Keep JPP assuming he takes something close to Vernon for maybe one less year. It's the only move here.
The entire defense got better and better as the season progressed. JPP's pass rush improved. Vernon's improved. Then JPP goes down, the Giants play spirited in his absence for 3 out of the 5 weeks he missed and now you're parroting a wacky theory that JPP was actually hurting the pass rush here.
The D would have been even better if JPP was in the lineup and lest we forget that the D played like shit in the biggest game of the year.
Sacks? That makes up about 1-2% of the total plays of a DL. But let's keep talking about it as the only way a DL brings value to his team.
I don't know why you bring up Strahan. Weren't you one of the guys that killed me for calling out Shockey? How did that work out? How did Plax work out after I said to trade him in September 2008? How did Lavar Arrington work out when I was the only guy on this board saying he wasn't worth signing? Shit what did JPP do a couple months after I said he might become a problem? He blew half his hand off. Sorry, but that's not my fault.
He's gonna be back, and I'll root for him. I'm on record as saying the money is better spent elsewhere. Specifically, use it to sign Logan Ryan and ensure that we have the top three CB positions locked down with young talent for the next three years. It's a cheaper route that I think yields more benefit, and probably leaves enough money to help the offensive line.
Football is a team game. It's not as simple as pointing to one guy for overall success or failure as a team or unit.
Football is a team game. It's not as simple as pointing to one guy for overall success or failure as a team or unit.
Christ, I never said JPP being out was the reason we got better. I said we know that the defense functioned at a high level without him. I think that matters when we talk about whether to pay him a cornerstone contract.
I thought you were but maybe I'm wrong.
I don't begrudge him making as much as he can. Just knock off with the bullshit.
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
Quote:
Houston was #1 in the league without him.
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
You can't be serious.
Quote:
Houston was #1 in the league without him.
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
When it matters? Doesn't every snap matter? You mean crunch-time, right? If so you are contradicting yourself because our very own JPP is awesome at making plays 'when they matter'.. and btw saying JJ Watt is overrated and that you've "never" seen him make plays when it matters will only lead me to believe you "never" seen him play because there hasn't been a bigger playmaker on defense since L.T.
What??? Of course there is only so much he can do LOL there is only so much anyone can do but he can be the best player in the NFL at any spot across the D-Line.
That's like saying.. Odell isn't overrated BUT there's just only so much he can do.. He cant pass block or rush the passer.. WTF?! that's so dumb to say.
Can you list a few defenders you do like?
Quote:
Houston was #1 in the league without him.
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
Holy crap! Is this a joke? Either you are talking out of your ass and you've seen maybe 3 snaps or you have no idea what you see.
This is easily one of the most ridiculous things I have seen on bbi.
Of course Terps doesn't love his game. But the more truthful statement from terps should read as " I don't like him"
Watt is a madman on the field. HE's easily the most disruptive DLineman in the NFL. Whether or not he comes back as awesome following the back thing remains to be seen but I wouldn't bet against him.
If you have gamepass, go watch some Texans games from the last few years. Watt doesn't just stand out he dominates the scene.
Quote:
In comment 13368388 KWALL2 said:
Quote:
Houston was #1 in the league without him.
I think he's overrated, and have said so here in the past. To be fair I haven't watched a huge number of Texans games, but in those I have I've never seen him make a play when it matters.
You can't be serious.
Watt makes plenty of plays and thats when being double teamed on every down
The times have changed. Jerry has gone from "In Jerry we Trust" to "Jerry's a bust" after recent drafts that have not gone well and the absence of the Giants from the playoffs for four years.
This last season everything turned for Reese. And you can be sure that Jerry more than anyone wants to keep his magic defense together where it might solidify his reputation as an exceptional GM.
His quick and decisive actions in the free agent market, signing three players who wound up on the 1st or 2nd All Pro team.
His vindication for his acquisition of the prior year, DRC, who eliminated any doubts about him with his team-leading six picks, and 21 pass defenses and his excellence as a blitzer. Last years's 2nd round choice, Collins, who looked to some as if he were headed for a short career in the NFL, turned into one of the NFC's top defensive players.
And both of this year's top two draft picks, Eli Apple and Shepard, had successful rookie seasons, both making somebody's all rookie team.
Gil Brandt said of Apple: Some thought the Giants reached for Apple in the draft, but I think he outplayed expectations, posting 51 tackles, a pick and a forced fumble. Apple looks like he'll be a cornerback in the NFL for a long time; he can play inside or outside.
Jerry pulled out the checkbook for the first time last off-season and found that the experience was pretty good.
Jerry pulled out the check book because his own job was on the line..
Quote:
Jerry has developed a reputation for being strict about not overpaying a player, even with a Giant like Tuck, who had a big role in both Super Bowl seasons.
The times have changed. Jerry has gone from "In Jerry we Trust" to "Jerry's a bust" after recent drafts that have not gone well and the absence of the Giants from the playoffs for four years.
This last season everything turned for Reese. And you can be sure that Jerry more than anyone wants to keep his magic defense together where it might solidify his reputation as an exceptional GM.
His quick and decisive actions in the free agent market, signing three players who wound up on the 1st or 2nd All Pro team.
His vindication for his acquisition of the prior year, DRC, who eliminated any doubts about him with his team-leading six picks, and 21 pass defenses and his excellence as a blitzer. Last years's 2nd round choice, Collins, who looked to some as if he were headed for a short career in the NFL, turned into one of the NFC's top defensive players.
And both of this year's top two draft picks, Eli Apple and Shepard, had successful rookie seasons, both making somebody's all rookie team.
Gil Brandt said of Apple: Some thought the Giants reached for Apple in the draft, but I think he outplayed expectations, posting 51 tackles, a pick and a forced fumble. Apple looks like he'll be a cornerback in the NFL for a long time; he can play inside or outside.
Jerry pulled out the checkbook for the first time last off-season and found that the experience was pretty good.
Jerry pulled out the check book because his own job was on the line..
No he pulled out the check book because we had the cap space to do it
Peterson
Calvin
Watt
The best QB, RB, WR, and Defensive Player of the last decade.
Their teams were able to survive without them for extended stretches, you could argue the Lions actually thrived without Megatron. This is a team sport.
Just because this D played great without JPP doesn't mean he wasn't an important cog. Our DL talent level is one of the main reasons we're so good, let's keep it that way.
Right now, We can just ignore the small sample size to come up with the conclusion
Watt was brought up because he was out this year in Houston In a larger sample size, the Houston defense was not only fine without him they were the best in the league. Does this mean the team is better going forward without Watt? Hell no!
Sane weak argument can be made about Gronk in NE. He missed time they keep winning. Better withoit him next year? No chance.
JPP is one of the best at his position. You don't just lose a guy like that and easily replace him with a rookie or our current backups.