*** Official Dave Te Q & A Thread ***

1. Two of "my guys" are Jalen Reeves-Maybin and Deatrich Wise Jr. JRM obviously was hurt for the majority of last year but before that was being discussed as a Day 2 pick. DW Jr. didn't make the jump in his senior year that was expected of him.

But I was just wondering what you think of these two prospects as Day 3 options for the Giants.

2. Of Ramczyk and Bolles, who do you prefer and why?

3. Thoughts on FS Marcus Williams of Utah? And what about Desmond King of Iowa? Could he be a better fit at FS than CB?

a) type at warp speed, or
b) use dictation software, or
c) clone yourself several times over

However you do it, you're amazing. And we on BBI are blessed to have you and Sy scouring the country for us.

Thank you, Happy Easter, and here's hoping you get a breather after the draft.

you told me to remind you about your take on Ereck Flowers next Friday. So, when you get around to it, I'd appreciate your take on his prognosis moving forward..And, do you think Solari can make a difference vis a vis techniques

David Jones, FS, Richmond

Jordan Evans, WLB, Oklahoma

Jeremy Sprinkle, TE, Arkansas

Donnel Pumphrey, RB, SDSU

1 and 2

In comment 13430526 adamg said:

Quote:

David Jones, FS, Richmond Jordan Evans, WLB, Oklahoma Jeremy Sprinkle, TE, Arkansas Donnel Pumphrey, RB, SDSU

My bad, it's much easier to answer an actual question...

How do you project these guys to pan out? I'm particularly interested if David Jones is a guy you like or not and what you think Sprinkle's ceiling is.

Thank you, sir.

1. I would kill to get us an MLB that can be a game-changing 3 down player.
I know you've spoken about your fondness for the two top rated MLB's in this class, Foster from Alabama and Davis from Florida. Are there any other guys you think stand out as potential strong additions at MLB?
Possibly
--Raekwon McMillian from Ohio State
--Anthony Walker Jr from Northwestern.

While Cunningham and Reddick have wider skill sets, do you see either of them ending up as an MLB down the road

2. I saw you mentioned Craig Winston and David Jones as "draft me" guys. As a Richmond grad, what have you seen from the Spiders program that has brought some of their guys into the league (like Kerry Wynn) so ready to compete?

Do you think Njoku is a better value and fit than Lamp and Cunnigham at pick 23? Thank you!

Who in your opinion is a sure fire pick? Disclude OJ Howard from this

I have been a fan of his and like him way better than Cunningham. Davis, to me, just brings that old school LB mentality. He flies around the field. There is also buzz with him similar to what was happening with Beckham late in the process where almost nobody connected the two. Can you elaborate on the negatives with him expecially medicals that we may not be aware of? I know he has had a few different types of injuries but nothing that should be a long term concern. At least that is what the average fan can see. And, where would he rank in terms of the Giants board? I am just using this as an example but if Howard was available I am sure Howard would be above Davis on the Giants board. So, with realistic players that would be available what would it take for him to actually be the pick? Thanks as always.

Some sleeper picks in late rounds

Kareem Are. OG
Tariq Cohen RB
Jeremy Cutrer CB
And my number one sleeper Carroll Phillips. Who should go in 4th

What are your thoughts

Seems to be a chance he is the pick at 23...

What do you see other than arm tackles

...every time I saw this guy play, he looked stiff to me running down the field.

Not robotic-stiff, but just a little tight in his stride and overall movement.

I guess I have two questions;

1) Am I full of it and just seeing things wrong?
2) If he is a little stiff, does it really matter?

Thanks in advance for your thoughts.

What's your feel on Dalvin Cook? Is he going before 20 or could we see him drop to the Giants?

Also, how do the Giants view him? Would he be in play if he drops?

Over the past several years the Giants have struggled with their 3rd round picks. Are they swinging and missing on high upside gambles or are they reaching? Do you have any thoughts on how the Giants can change their luck in round 3?

2011 Jerrel Jernigan
2012 Jayron Hosley
2013 Damontre Moore
2014 James Bromley
2015 Owamagbe Odighizuwa
2016 Darian Thompson

My condolences to you and your family. Your insight in addition to Sy's is invaluable. While I often try to study prospects with an untrained eye it's great to get both your professional opinions to the BBI community. I'm well on my way to Arm Chair GM of the year thanks to both of you.


Any thoughts or scouting done on Raheem Wilson Southeastern Oklahoma? I've loved what I've seen on tape from
Him as a day 3 pick.

Thanks again, and if you ever decide to get back into scouting full time. Please try to make sure it's for Big Blue

In that Eagles fan thread.

With how bad the kicking got for some teams last season (and week 11 league-wide), how high does Zane Gonzalez go? With the number of teams working him out (at least the Giants, Browns, Bengals, Chiefs, and Vikings), someone is going to take a shot.

injury concerns are what are holding him back. How far will he drop? Could he conceivably make it to Round #2 where the Giants pick 55th (doubtful, I know)?

few decades. Any players that you thought were close to sure things that didn't quite pan out in the pros?

I want to ask which player in this draft, do you believe can have an immediate impact for us. Whether you see them as a day 1 starter or even as a ST contributor and in which round would you like us to pick them?

Understand the joy it brings us bbiers reading your analysis it's just incredible. One quick questions

Do you think drafting shaheen round 2 presents a lot more value than drafting Njoku round 1 and maybe targeting a guy like jarrad Davis or Cunningham round 1 if the offensive lineman you like are gone?

what are your thoughts on San Diego State players RB Donnel Pumphrey, OL Nico Siragusa, OL Daniel Brunskill, DE Alex Barrett, LB Calvin Munson and CB Damontae Kazee.

I think Munson would be a late round, UDFA gem.

Dave! Gun to your head - who is the Giants pick at 23? Considering Howard most likely gone.

Do you have notes on last years Giants draft picks you can share?

Also a one off question. With concerns of O.J. Towards tenacity being raised. Do scouts or other player personnel consult current players i.e. Landon Collins on teammates work ethic, practice habits, motivation ect?

Thanks again Dave

into Isaiah Ford. Likes/dislikes about his game, and what round do you see him being picked?

Also, what do you believe the draft strategy should be with this years OT crop? Since it is supposed to be one of the weakest classes in a while. Do you think the top rated OT's are being overrated, or actually belong where they are estimated to go?

Really enjoy your insight. I'm gonna reach here and ask if you know anything about WR Dalton Crossan. He was at our Showcase and showed up, obviously a more likely I drafted guy but curious if you had a chance to review him and your thoughts on his potential with an NFL club? Thanks in advance.
Fox Sports Article - ( New Window )

Not a question on a specific person, but on the NY Giants inability to draft (or develop) an Offensive Lineman in the later rounds. It is amazing how many picks they have used with little to no results to show for it.

If it is a scouting issue, why aren't the scouts replaced ?

Thanks

If Cam Robinson is still available when the Giants are on the clock, do they take him?

Saw you said that the Eagles were the only team with a first round grade still on Cook, do you think that's smoke and mirrors?

If not could you see the Giants making a move up Round 2?

fully appreciated.

Loved that thread brother and really appreciate what you do. When I was a teen and fell in love with scouting, nfldraftscout was my encyclopedia (along with following threads on BBI and watching lots of tape). Glad the site still operates the original platform even though CBS wants to redirect me every time.

Guys I love you mentioned: Samaje Perrine, Curtis Samuel, Dion Dawkins, Haason Reddick... but the gold stars are for Jordan Evans (how he was snubbed a combine invite is beyond me), Brian Allen, Tanoh Kpassagnon and last but certainly not least Grover Stewart (what a prospect).

I'm a bit surprised about Jarrad Davis given the injury history, his motor and leadership combined with on field talent galore makes sense but how can you justify spending a first round pick on a guy with such a history?

A few names I want to throw your way and see what your take on:

Greyson Lambert QB Georgia
Brian Hill RB Wyoming
Michael Clark WR Marshall
Colin Jeter TE LSU
Jerry Ugokwe OT William & Mary
Greg Pyke OG Georgia
Al-Quadin Muhammad DE U Miami
Eli Ankou DT UCLA and/or Rashaad Coward DT Old Dominion
Matt Milano OLB BC
Tanner Vallejo ILB Boise State
Treston DeCoud CB Oregon State
Jadar Johnson SS Clemson
Delano Hill FS Michigan

I've come to like these guys a good bit while doing my routine this time of year. They are primarily day 3 guys so figured it might be a change of pace for the guys here on the board always looking for new names. Thanks again for all you do and I look forward to your involvement in this forums future.

Anakim : 4/16/2017 7:40 pm : link : reply
1. Two of "my guys" are Jalen Reeves-Maybin and Deatrich Wise Jr. JRM obviously was hurt for the majority of last year but before that was being discussed as a Day 2 pick. DW Jr. didn't make the jump in his senior year that was expected of him.

But I was just wondering what you think of these two prospects as Day 3 options for the Giants.

2. Of Ramczyk and Bolles, who do you prefer and why?

3. Thoughts on FS Marcus Williams of Utah? And what about Desmond King of Iowa? Could he be a better fit at FS than CB?
1-Reeves-Maybin has been a bit of a disappointment. Earlier in his career, I thought he was going to emerge, showing great downhill ability and recognition skills, but he seems to lack courage vs. the run. Besides, with his bad shoulder, he’s yet to get medical clearance. At slightly over six-feet, I doubt that he fits the Giants scheme, but looks more like camp fodder at the moment.

2-I pretty much rested my case on those two linemen in an earlier post. If I had to be tied down and take one? Bolles, as I am not one that likes linemen with hip problems. To me, a lineman does not need to be fast – just strong and have the ability to slide laterally. Still, I will “keep a light on” for Lamp as a Giant in Round One.

3-I just wrapped up a bunch of days at Utah. I’m a big fan of Asiata and Brian Allen, but on Marcus? Solid performer who should have gone back to school, as he needs to not only bulk up more, but dedicated hours in the film room. He’s a solid playmaker and has has good “prick” in him with those hands, showing the ability to jostle for the ball or knock a receiver off stride with a grab or shove without being caught. Right now, the Value Board places him in round four.

Hey Dave,
Big Blue '56 : 4/16/2017 7:46 pm : link : reply
you told me to remind you about your take on Ereck Flowers next Friday. So, when you get around to it, I'd appreciate your take on his prognosis moving forward..And, do you think Solari can make a difference vis a vis techniques
ANSWER
Might not get to Flowers until next week-heading to Wyoming after Utah State, Southern Utah & BYU visits this week to see my fave QB.
As for Solari, I prefer to withhold judgement. Why? Well, if anyone got excited about Giants OL play last year, it had to be an opposing defender. Second, look at the track marks (brown spots) he had in his undies after two ill-advised years (2006-07) as KC's offensive coordinator

adamg : 4/16/2017 7:52 pm : link : reply
In comment 13430526 adamg said:
Quote:
David Jones, FS, Richmond

Jordan Evans, WLB, Oklahoma

Jeremy Sprinkle, TE, Arkansas

Donnel Pumphrey, RB, SDSU


My bad, it's much easier to answer an actual question...

How do you project these guys to pan out? I'm particularly interested if David Jones is a guy you like or not and what you think Sprinkle's ceiling is.
ANSWER
Jones is one of my sleepers! I’ve been pushing him hard on Foxboro, as he not only can fly to the ball, he has great hands. I’d take him by 5, but most have him at the tailend due to the foot injury he suffered. Evans might not get drafted, but he’s better than any LB on the Giants first unit. Sprinkle never got a warm fuzzy feeling from me, as he’s a going through the motions player. As much as folks like McCaffrey, I’m a Pumphrey guy – reminds me of an old Cardinal, Stump Mitchell and with the success that Woodhead & Sproles have had, I see the same career route for that Aztec.

2 Questions, thanks Dave
SirYesSir : 4/16/2017 7:55 pm : link : reply
1. I would kill to get us an MLB that can be a game-changing 3 down player.
I know you've spoken about your fondness for the two top rated MLB's in this class, Foster from Alabama and Davis from Florida. Are there any other guys you think stand out as potential strong additions at MLB?
Possibly
--Raekwon McMillian from Ohio State
--Anthony Walker Jr from Northwestern.

While Cunningham and Reddick have wider skill sets, do you see either of them ending up as an MLB down the road

2. I saw you mentioned Craig Winston and David Jones as "draft me" guys. As a Richmond grad, what have you seen from the Spiders program that has brought some of their guys into the league (like Kerry Wynn) so ready to compete?
2.
ANSWER
McMillian does some good things on the field, but he does have recognition lapses. When Darron Lee & Perry played on the flank in 2015, that issue was not exposed, but without them, he had a lot of trouble getting off blocks (yeah, he had a decent amount, but a lot were pile jumpers). Folks say Round 2, but I’d keep my card on the table if he came up for me to pick. Reddick is a perfect fit inside in a 3-4 scheme and Pittsburgh would clamor to get him to insert next to Shazier, but I keep hearing the Lions are all over him. Cunningham is too weak to play on my team. Him, Humphrey (Bama), Tabor, Lattimore, all guys that are getting lots of ink, leaving scouts wondering why. Dog me on this, but my top OLBs are in this order; Reddick, Bowser, Watt, McKinley, Ryan Anderson (yes, over Williams), Cunningham. Now, Anderson is the wild card you want to see in a Big Blue uni!

Hi Dave
Rjanyg : 4/16/2017 8:00 pm : link : reply
Do you think Njoku is a better value and fit than Lamp and Cunnigham at pick 23? Thank you!
ANSWER
Lamp over anyone expected to fall to the bottom third of Round One, hands down.
Would only consider Cunningham on late Day 2 action – not my type of backer.
No, they need to get Lamp & if not, a linebacker in the Jarrad Davis, Tyson Bowser mold. There are enough tight ends to pick from in Day three that offer very good value (Hodges in 4, Saubert & Roberts 6/7, Hollister 7)

Of the guys that have been "linked to us"
superspynyg : 4/16/2017 8:06 pm : link : reply
Who in your opinion is a sure fire pick? Disclude OJ Howard from this
Confusing question? Do you mean pick one guy only in this draft, regardless of position or team? If so, obviously my choice is LSU’s Jamal Adams.

SEE DAVIS REPORT ON POST ON BOARD

Dave-Te, a question about David Njoku...
M.S. : 4/16/2017 9:40 pm : link : reply

...every time I saw this guy play, he looked stiff to me running down the field.

Not robotic-stiff, but just a little tight in his stride and overall movement.

I guess I have two questions;

1) Am I full of it and just seeing things wrong?
2) If he is a little stiff, does it really matter?

Thanks in advance for your thoughts.
ANSWER
Yes, he looks like Tank McNamara, but those are pretty narrow legs on him. Besides, he’s dropped over 11% of his passes & go look at the Pitt game last year. Elijah Price made him his girlfriend. I still reiterate – coaches need to park their butts in stadiums on Saturdays rather than wait for Indy, where they fall in love with a guy in DVDs. Here’s the thing – he’s as raw as Bucky Hodges & has the same agility skills. Yet, boards have the Hurricane in 1 & the Tech kid in 4 – go figure.

Dave, really appreciate the reports
aimrocky : 4/16/2017 9:49 pm : link : reply
What's your feel on Dalvin Cook? Is he going before 20 or could we see him drop to the Giants?

Also, how do the Giants view him? Would he be in play if he drops?
ANSWER
All indicated are the Eagles want Cook at 14 - good riddance. Actually, the Giants are looking more at big backs, early day three guys. If Cook drops to the Giants, he will continue to fall, but again, I don't see him getting past #14.
Prediction-Fournette to Jacksonville
McCaffrey in a trade, with either Cincy or Carolina moving up (with Jets)

Dave
FOXLIN : 4/16/2017 10:07 pm : link : reply
My condolences to you and your family. Your insight in addition to Sy's is invaluable. While I often try to study prospects with an untrained eye it's great to get both your professional opinions to the BBI community. I'm well on my way to Arm Chair GM of the year thanks to both of you.


Any thoughts or scouting done on Raheem Wilson Southeastern Oklahoma? I've loved what I've seen on tape from
Him as a day 3 pick.

Thanks again, and if you ever decide to get back into scouting full time. Please try to make sure it's for Big Blue
ANSWER
Sorry brutha, 4.65 at 179 pounds is not going to cut it for this kid. Wilson’s Pro Day #s:
Dates: 03/10/17 and 03/08/17
Hand: 09 3/4
Arm: 29 7/8
Wingspan: 72 7/8
Height: 5100
Weight: 179
40 Yard Dash (HH): 4.65
20 Yard (HH): 2.69
10 Yard (HH): 1.57
225 Lb. Bench Reps: 11
Vertical Jump: 34 1/2
Broad Jump: 10'06"
20 Yrd Shuttle: 4.12
3-Cone Drill: 6.95
40 Time Range: 4.60-4.70/Bests

Zane Gonzalez
Typecast : 4/16/2017 11:02 pm : link : reply
With how bad the kicking got for some teams last season (and week 11 league-wide), how high does Zane Gonzalez go? With the number of teams working him out (at least the Giants, Browns, Bengals, Chiefs, and Vikings), someone is going to take a shot.
ANSWER
Actually, I spent a lot of time with this kid as he trained at Toby Wright’s (ex Rams safety) where I now live in Arizona. Yes, he’s going to fly off the board by Round 5 and boy can he connect from anywhere (NCAA record 115 field goals). He won’t be the only kicker taken, as Jake Elliott is a sixth round guy out of Memphis & Giants have been in on Stanford’s Conrad Ukropina.

I love Jarrad Davis. I think he's the best MLB in this draft, but the
Optimus-NY : 4/16/2017 11:08 pm : link : reply
injury concerns are what are holding him back. How far will he drop? Could he conceivably make it to Round #2 where the Giants pick 55th (doubtful, I know)?
ANSWER
I love Davis too, but you may want to check out that MLB out of Bama before you hail Davis as king. He’s big on the Steelers charts & I don’t think he makes it to Round 2 – I just posted his scouting report excerpt on the main board

Thanks for all the info that you're been giving us.
3r76jp : 4/16/2017 11:45 pm : link : reply
I want to ask which player in this draft, do you believe can have an immediate impact for us. Whether you see them as a day 1 starter or even as a ST contributor and in which round would you like us to pick them?
ANSWER
I usually go by the three-year plan Year One-Get your feet wet; Year Two-Apply what you learned/learn from your mistakes; Year Three-Produce or the draft is where they find a replacement.
I’m a big Forrest Lamp fan, think Bucky Hodges would be a steal/mismatch for CBS/hedging that if Brandon Marshall melts down, Hodges steps in. I think Jarrad Davis is an excellent MLB, but later in the draft – three steals – OLB/DE Ryan Anderson-Bama, CB/FS Brian Allen-Utah & WR Kenny Golladay-NIU. Whoever gets these guys, gets great value.

Dave, thanks so much for doing this you don't even
Tuckrule : 4:48 am : link : reply
Understand the joy it brings us bbiers reading your analysis it's just incredible. One quick questions

Do you think drafting shaheen round 2 presents a lot more value than drafting Njoku round 1 and maybe targeting a guy like jarrad Davis or Cunningham round 1 if the offensive lineman you like are gone?
ANSWER
Oh God yes, Shaheen was a guy I turned lots of scouts on last year while out there last spring. Honestly, he could be a baby Gronk & certain fan favorite. As for Davis, yes, I’d take him, but I really like Jordan Willis (if still there) for rush end & no, I would not draft Cunningham Day One 9or two-not my kind of player).

Good stuff
ryanmkeane : 8:44 am : link : reply
Dave! Gun to your head - who is the Giants pick at 23? Considering Howard most likely gone.
ANSWER
Depends on who is there. If I had to give you my “circle of five” in order. I say Reddick, Lamp, Willis, Jarrad Davis, Bowser

Last years draft
FOXLIN : 9:05 am : link : reply
Do you have notes on last years Giants draft picks you can share?
ANSWER
No, on the road & all previous files are archived-check with moderator if he still has them but all posted with the FA guys back then

Also a one off question. With concerns of O.J. Towards tenacity being raised. Do scouts or other player personnel consult current players i.e. Landon Collins on teammates work ethic, practice habits, motivation ect?
We check EVERYTHING. Me, I go way deep into family & talk to everyone on campus. I need everything but what hand they wipe their butt with before done. My full reports are a minimum of 100 pages on a guy.

Hey Dave
kelsto811 : 10:31 am : link : reply
Really enjoy your insight. I'm gonna reach here and ask if you know anything about WR Dalton Crossan. He was at our Showcase and showed up, obviously a more likely I drafted guy but curious if you had a chance to review him and your thoughts on his potential with an NFL club? Thanks in advance.
Fox Sports Article - ( New Window )
ANSWER
That freaking RKO reporter stole my line! I told scouts while I was there that this kid is the purr-fect Patriot, like Edelman & Hogan, White & the rest of those motley crew of versatile guys. I was actually there to get a look on the safety, Casey DeAndrade, but Crosson blew me away. He tore Lehigh up for three scores & 184 yards on 24 runs, but boy, that TD catch inside the 10 was sweet! I stood around for the Maine game & he reals off a 35-yard TD scamper that saw him break five tackles. You know Bill – if not drafted, nothing good gets past him out of New England. UNH has not had a talent like him in years. Shame the conference only thought he was worth second team honors.

Dave
Bob in Vt : 11:39 am : link : reply
Not a question on a specific person, but on the NY Giants inability to draft (or develop) an Offensive Lineman in the later rounds. It is amazing how many picks they have used with little to no results to show for it. If it is a scouting issue, why aren't the scouts replaced ?
ANSWER
I gotta site the 5th ammendment. I work with them, who they hire is their choice. Do I agree with their choices? The reason I've been doing this since 1968 for the league is simple. I am Dr. Watson - I do all the research, leave no stone unturned, make a suggestion & take a back seat.
The GM plays Sherlock Holmes - makes the decision, gets the glory or the rotten tomatoes tossed at him. Unless a scout makes a total ass of himself on campus, it's the team's Human Resources department that has to deal with them