for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

NFT: Need Advice: Lake Weed Killers

GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 4:09 pm
Hoping someone from BBI with experience on this can help. I have a lakefront property in NY that is technically a reservoir. They do however allow residents on the lake to use it for recreational purposes as long as no gas motors are used.

My side of the lake is rather shallow and is COVERED in lily pads and all sorts of weeds that drive me crazy and I need them gone (just in front on my backyard at the least). I've been recommended everything from grass karp to chemicals, but have been hesitant to try anything hoping I can waste as little money as possible with the trial and error approach. Also, considering the hazards some of these options come with, I did not want to take my chances knowing very little.

Anyone with experience on this please help!!!! Looking for the most effective way to get rid of these weeds. The lake would be much more enjoyable without the weeds at least just in front of my backyard. Killlakeweeds.com was highly recommended as well.
can you use chemcials if it's a reservoir?  
giants#1 : 4/24/2017 4:11 pm : link
That doesn't seem advisable.

Not sure you can get rid of weeds 'just in front of your yard'. Won't the wind/current just blow the lily pads back in front after you clear them?
RE: can you use chemcials if it's a reservoir?  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 4:26 pm : link
In comment 13440430 giants#1 said:
Quote:
That doesn't seem advisable.

Not sure you can get rid of weeds 'just in front of your yard'. Won't the wind/current just blow the lily pads back in front after you clear them?


That is sort of what I am trying to figure out. Almost positive no water is drawn from it anymore for usage as it did in the past. So in terms of can I- probably not from the town's perspective, but would it hurt anyone- most likely not and obviously I'll make sure of that before I do use chemicals.

Apparently if you do use chemicals, they are effective only where you drop them in the water (such as pellets). So where they fall to the bottom would only effect within a few feet. Lily pads all have roots that connect to the bottom of the lake so probably wouldn't drift.

Also, it is rumored other people have used chemicals in the past on the lake in front of their property, however those are no longer sold.
As a fisherman,  
fivehead : 4/24/2017 4:31 pm : link
I have noticed that lily pads have been disappearing over the years. Tall weed beds have given way to murky, muddy waters. Something is changing the Fingerlakes Region water systems, and not for the better. I hope you reconsider the destruction of the dwindling aquatic plants.
You sound like the typical idiot american  
Taggart : 4/24/2017 4:33 pm : link
Dont like the weeds? Why dont you pay up and buy a house on the deeper side of the lake? Or move to a different lake? No no, you just want to simply use chemicals to kill the weeds in a fuckin reservoir just because you dont like how it looks. Fuckin idiot.
Don't release  
steve in ky : 4/24/2017 4:35 pm : link
any non-native wildlife (grass carp)into the water. That could alter the entire ecosystem, and likley is illegal as well unless done so with cooperation of the states wildlife agency.

Also usually most reservoirs are controlled by some type of agency which govern what is allowed within so many feet of the waters edge. Check with them as far as what is permissible before killing any plant life or introducing any chemicals.

They may even have a web site with that information available to you.

Did you sign any type of agreement that may have listed restriction when you purchased the property?

RE: As a fisherman,  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 4:40 pm : link
In comment 13440460 fivehead said:
Quote:
I have noticed that lily pads have been disappearing over the years. Tall weed beds have given way to murky, muddy waters. Something is changing the Fingerlakes Region water systems, and not for the better. I hope you reconsider the destruction of the dwindling aquatic plants.


Man not in my lake!!! Almost seems to get worse every year. It is nice to have them in some parts of the lake, however they literally take over the water. It's great fishing near and in the beds, but difficult when they get so bulky. If I could just get rid of portion near my property (50ft or so) my dog could swim without taking him out past the pads and I could use my motor from my dock instead of paddling the boat out about a football field long in bulky weeds. A lake down the street from me stocked the water with Karp this past year and all the lily pads are completely gone. Most likely that is the reason you are seeing less now.
RE: You sound like the typical idiot american  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 4:45 pm : link
In comment 13440463 Taggart said:
Quote:
Dont like the weeds? Why dont you pay up and buy a house on the deeper side of the lake? Or move to a different lake? No no, you just want to simply use chemicals to kill the weeds in a fuckin reservoir just because you dont like how it looks. Fuckin idiot.


Gee thanks bud, glad that's how you feel. Buy another house because of lily pads? Those sound like smart suggestions. It would have been idiotic of me to just go about doing what I felt like without posting and asking what is safe and what is recommended. As I also mentioned in the comments, no water is drawn from the lake for usage of any sort. It is actually called a lake . And for the record I could care less how it looks, more or less so I can actually use the lake more from my backyard.
RE: Don't release  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 4:48 pm : link
In comment 13440468 steve in ky said:
Quote:
any non-native wildlife (grass carp)into the water. That could alter the entire ecosystem, and likley is illegal as well unless done so with cooperation of the states wildlife agency.

Also usually most reservoirs are controlled by some type of agency which govern what is allowed within so many feet of the waters edge. Check with them as far as what is permissible before killing any plant life or introducing any chemicals.

They may even have a web site with that information available to you.

Did you sign any type of agreement that may have listed restriction when you purchased the property?


Thanks for the info. No agreement signed for anything of the sort. I think there may be town ordinances regarding the usage of the lake. And in terms of releasing wildlife, I really did not want to at all knowing how much it could alter the ecosystem.
NO! NO! NO!  
KeoweeFan : 4/24/2017 4:50 pm : link
I have a cottage on Sodus Bay and until recently lived across the road from Canadice Lake (a reservoir along with Hemlock Lake). Note: all lakeside homes were demolished when those lakes became reservoirs.
There is a very restrictive permitting process for chemicals in Lake Ontario and the person performing the application must be licensed.
In the instance of Canadice/Hemlock (or any other reservoir in NYS), NO CHEMICALS are allowed. Not only are gas motors prohibited, but when I lived there, you could not go in the water barefoot!
There are stiff penalties for violations.
Mechanical weed cutters are used by the towns and private owners to keep the vegetation down in lakes that are not reservoirs.
Think DEC, wetlands and...  
MOOPS : 4/24/2017 4:55 pm : link
ginormous fines.
RE: RE: Don't release  
steve in ky : 4/24/2017 4:56 pm : link
In comment 13440484 GuzzaBlue said:
Quote:
In comment 13440468 steve in ky said:


Quote:


any non-native wildlife (grass carp)into the water. That could alter the entire ecosystem, and likley is illegal as well unless done so with cooperation of the states wildlife agency.

Also usually most reservoirs are controlled by some type of agency which govern what is allowed within so many feet of the waters edge. Check with them as far as what is permissible before killing any plant life or introducing any chemicals.

They may even have a web site with that information available to you.

Did you sign any type of agreement that may have listed restriction when you purchased the property?




Thanks for the info. No agreement signed for anything of the sort. I think there may be town ordinances regarding the usage of the lake. And in terms of releasing wildlife, I really did not want to at all knowing how much it could alter the ecosystem.


You need to find out who governs the lake and check with them. Even though homeowners are allowed usage of, usually the individuals don't actually own any of the water or often even so many feet surrounding the waters edge.

Releasing any chemicals could put you at risk for some hefty fines if done so illegally without proper permission. Even beyond local, there could be state or federal regulations that may apply. Do your homework before taking any action.

What lake is it?
There is nothing legal or effective  
Ron Johnson 30 : 4/24/2017 4:58 pm : link
You can do. Lillys are native and will grow back. They were there long before you.
Hey man.. can I come fishing?  
EricJ : 4/24/2017 4:59 pm : link
seriously... i was crushing the bass and pickerel this weekend fishing in between the lillies
RE: NO! NO! NO!  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 5:02 pm : link
In comment 13440486 KeoweeFan said:
Quote:
I have a cottage on Sodus Bay and until recently lived across the road from Canadice Lake (a reservoir along with Hemlock Lake). Note: all lakeside homes were demolished when those lakes became reservoirs.
There is a very restrictive permitting process for chemicals in Lake Ontario and the person performing the application must be licensed.
In the instance of Canadice/Hemlock (or any other reservoir in NYS), NO CHEMICALS are allowed. Not only are gas motors prohibited, but when I lived there, you could not go in the water barefoot!
There are stiff penalties for violations.
Mechanical weed cutters are used by the towns and private owners to keep the vegetation down in lakes that are not reservoirs.


Thanks. Yea I could definitely see to that. However, this is sort of a tricky label to this piece of water. It definitely was a reservoir at some point feeding into a small portion of the town's waterline. They then changed the name "reservoir" to "lake" after they stopped using the water. Still no gas allowed, but can be used to swim for the residents. Neighbors along the lake used something for their property at some point, but said it's no longer sold (seems sketchy, probably very illegal). Hoping I could get pointers as to what is effective and legal. The weed cutting machine works for about a week or so and they grow right back.
RE: You sound like the typical idiot american  
Bockman : 4/24/2017 5:04 pm : link
In comment 13440463 Taggart said:
Quote:
Dont like the weeds? Why dont you pay up and buy a house on the deeper side of the lake? Or move to a different lake? No no, you just want to simply use chemicals to kill the weeds in a fuckin reservoir just because you dont like how it looks. Fuckin idiot.


Holy fuck dude, slow your roll. U mad bro?
RE: RE: RE: Don't release  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 5:05 pm : link
In comment 13440496 steve in ky said:
Quote:
In comment 13440484 GuzzaBlue said:


Quote:


In comment 13440468 steve in ky said:


Quote:


any non-native wildlife (grass carp)into the water. That could alter the entire ecosystem, and likley is illegal as well unless done so with cooperation of the states wildlife agency.

Also usually most reservoirs are controlled by some type of agency which govern what is allowed within so many feet of the waters edge. Check with them as far as what is permissible before killing any plant life or introducing any chemicals.

They may even have a web site with that information available to you.

Did you sign any type of agreement that may have listed restriction when you purchased the property?




Thanks for the info. No agreement signed for anything of the sort. I think there may be town ordinances regarding the usage of the lake. And in terms of releasing wildlife, I really did not want to at all knowing how much it could alter the ecosystem.



You need to find out who governs the lake and check with them. Even though homeowners are allowed usage of, usually the individuals don't actually own any of the water or often even so many feet surrounding the waters edge.

Releasing any chemicals could put you at risk for some hefty fines if done so illegally without proper permission. Even beyond local, there could be state or federal regulations that may apply. Do your homework before taking any action.

What lake is it?


Steve - appreciate the advice and my mission is to do this in the safest way possible knowing I won't get thrown in jail for some serious environmental law. Problem is, people on the lake seem to get rid of them, but are shady about it. So I am hesitant to bring attention my way to the town about it in case they notice and start questioning me.

Lake Mombasha in Monroe, NY.
RE: There is nothing legal or effective  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 5:08 pm : link
In comment 13440499 Ron Johnson 30 said:
Quote:
You can do. Lillys are native and will grow back. They were there long before you.


For all the research I've done, this is where I keep ending up. There literally is nothing you can do outside of having the governor of the water do something or going the illegal route which I have no intention of doing.
I place a tarp over area I wanted cleared  
George from PA : 4/24/2017 5:09 pm : link
Remove access to sun.....Will move plant life
RE: Hey man.. can I come fishing?  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 5:10 pm : link
In comment 13440502 EricJ said:
Quote:
seriously... i was crushing the bass and pickerel this weekend fishing in between the lillies


Eric your welcome anytime! Lots of pickerel and bass for sure. Great fishing lake and swimming as well.
George  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 5:11 pm : link
Great idea. I might have to give this a try.
RE: There is nothing legal or effective  
GuzzaBlue : 4/24/2017 5:44 pm : link
In comment 13440499 Ron Johnson 30 said:
Quote:
You can do. Lillys are native and will grow back. They were there long before you.


That also applies to dandelions and millions of people including yourself possibly use chemicals to get rid of them simply for viewing pleasure.
I dont care if its a  
Taggart : 4/24/2017 6:10 pm : link
Reservior, a lake, a pond or the ocean. What kind of a selfish asshole even thinks of dumping chemicals into a body of water to kill some unsightly weeds? Just because he "thinks" its a reservoir that isnt used anymore and of course has a crystal ball that tells him nobody will ever want to use it again. Like its his fuckin water. In a couple years this asshole will be here asking for advice on how to sue some govt agency Because there is not enough fish in his weed free lake.
Give the folks  
sometimeswrite : 4/24/2017 7:54 pm : link
at Cornell Unv a call, been too many years since I've worked with them on this issue and hence anyone of the people I knew are probably long gone. They have a great deal of expertise on this, I know they'll be glad to help.
I'd reiterate,  
RAIN : 4/24/2017 7:55 pm : link
that chemicals aren't good for the water, for people swimming, or for the fish in the lake. I'd look at alternative methods. I wouldn't use chemicals at all, especially if kids are in or around the water.


you checked this out? - ( New Window )
Also,  
sometimeswrite : 4/24/2017 8:05 pm : link
if you can find a number for Prof Gary Miller , probably retired and definitely not at Cornell he's expert in this field.
RE: I dont care if its a  
LS : 4/24/2017 8:45 pm : link
In comment 13440574 Taggart said:
Quote:
Reservior, a lake, a pond or the ocean. What kind of a selfish asshole even thinks of dumping chemicals into a body of water to kill some unsightly weeds? Just because he "thinks" its a reservoir that isnt used anymore and of course has a crystal ball that tells him nobody will ever want to use it again. Like its his fuckin water. In a couple years this asshole will be here asking for advice on how to sue some govt agency Because there is not enough fish in his weed free lake.


You're a fucking jackass aren't you buddy.
Cut them off and  
LS : 4/24/2017 8:49 pm : link
take them out.
lily pad removal - ( New Window )
what steve in ky, keowee and Mook said  
ColHowPepper : 4/24/2017 9:57 pm : link
There is certain to be a wetlands commission that regulates not only the use, planting, dredging type and other activities permitted in and around the lake to a distance of xxx feet from the shore. You get on the wrong side of the regulations that are meant to preserve the lake and its recreational, aesthetic, and health issues and park or lake users and the public won't be so kindly disposed.

You say "other" lake shore owners are "shady" about what they've done; maybe if all of the lake shore residents become shady, you'll all have a dead body of water that begins to stink. Call the Wetlands Commission or whatever the relevant body is in Monroe Township and inform yourself. Cornell Ag Extension is a good idea too.
Most herbicides say right on the bottle  
buford : 4/25/2017 7:05 am : link
not to use near water, so those are out. You might be able to remove them physically, but if that is the natural state of the water, then you are kind of stuck. Was it like this when you bought the property?
Taggart  
GuzzaBlue : 4/25/2017 10:57 am : link
You are one strange cat aren't you. Sounds like you are talking to yourself and writing the comment as you go.
RE: Most herbicides say right on the bottle  
GuzzaBlue : 4/25/2017 10:59 am : link
In comment 13440866 buford said:
Quote:
not to use near water, so those are out. You might be able to remove them physically, but if that is the natural state of the water, then you are kind of stuck. Was it like this when you bought the property?


Yes it's always been like this. Gets worse each year (thicker and spreads). Only on one side there are weeds. The other 60% or so is clear water.
This is all great advice!  
GuzzaBlue : 4/25/2017 11:08 am : link
Thank you to everyone, including my bud Taggart. This idea was really brought about because my pup loves (loves is an understatement) swimming, but he is getting older and its difficult for him to jump in and out of the boat. I was hoping to clear some space near my backyard for him to swim as well as make it easier to get out to clear water from my dock.

No matter the circumstances I do not feel comfortable using chemicals and rather use a machine or pull them out by hand. But again thanks for all your help and if you are ever in the Monroe NY area shoot me a BBI shoutout and we'll do some fishing and talk some GMEN football.
Back to the Corner