So, I re-watched this last night (my first full re-watch since 2012), and really took my time analyzing the game. The Pats were lucky to even get a sniff at possibly winning that game. There was so much holding and several no-call PI's. I didn't remember being so pissed watching it live back then, but they were pretty blatant and obvious.
They say the two Giants SB wins against the Pats were "flukes" or "lucky". The first one, yeah, I can see it. The second one, no freaking way.
The Pats were up with a minute left to play on a 3rd and 5 in the Giants territory. They were mauling Eli in the 4th and looked to maul him on the play where he connected with Tyree. Some call that a fluky play. I don't, but I can see it. Take away that play and the Pats win, despite us beating them up and down the field or no.
Quote:
Just how was it lucky? There was nothing lucky about it. We beat the up and down the field. Unless you count the greatest play in SB history as lucky. And to do that you'd have to not understand the word luck because luck played no part in that play. The truth is "Norwood Wide Right" is closer to luck but you don't hear it called that because even it really wasn't luck either.
The Pats were up with a minute left to play on a 3rd and 5 in the Giants territory. They were mauling Eli in the 4th and looked to maul him on the play where he connected with Tyree. Some call that a fluky play. I don't, but I can see it. Take away that play and the Pats win, despite us beating them up and down the field or no.
But we got that play done and it wasn't luck or a fluke. It was the simply greatest play in SB history and the Giants were the ones that made it happen. That's a win and a deserved one.
They were the better team on those fields both games.
They were the better team on those fields both games.
they were close games, but this statement is right on the money...
They were the better team on those fields both games.
You mean after beating the #1 and #2 seeds in the NFC to get there both years. Yeah, they deserved to be there as much as any other team deserved to be there
Quote:
either Super Bowl.
They were the better team on those fields both games.
You mean after beating the #1 and #2 seeds in the NFC to get there both years. Yeah, they deserved to be there as much as any other team deserved to be there
Sorry, ignore this. Misread the original post!!
I agree, I was more nervous for 46. I think for 42 most of us considered the season a success already even if they lost the SB. For me, everything after beating Dallas was just icing on the cake. I think with 46 the fans expectations were higher. Also I think we all knew that if the Pats beat us in 46, it would take some of the luster off of 42 (being the only team to beat Brady/Belicheck in the SB).
The only lucky aspect to that play was the Ref doing the right thing and not whistling the play dead before Eli escaped
The second one...I wasn't so sure. But when Eli hit Manningham. It was over.