I do think Jerry's ass needs to hit the bench. He wasn't just bad last night, he was comically bad (and has been all preseason, after doing a bit better last year).
If Jones isn't much better, or is even a bit worse - then what the hell. At least try.
I'm OK with Darkwa too - he's a good runner, a good complement to Perkins and maybe flipping them is just fine.
But Geno Smith is only good as an answer to a Jets trivia question.
We've been asking the question for 3 years, "Is Eli Done?" While he's not done, he's not getting any younger (or better) and the Giants need to get better at QB.
I expect a similar outcome. Maybe they score 10 since it's a home game. Then at 0-2, that week 3 game in Philly, even with Odell, is going to be a shitshow as they try to save the season.
Darkwa playing. He had three carries at 4.7 yds a pop. I know it is a small sample size, but right now I'd take 3.5 yds a pop. The offense needs something consistent, even if it is not spectacular. Darkway in the backfield keeps the D honest.
As for OL changes. Not sure if the Giants have anyone on the shelf that is better.
#2 guy should always be ready. And if Eli continues to get hit like this, he Geno better be ready.
Every time he plays the offense looks good. McAdoo and the other OL seem to have zero respect for him but he's the only guy who actually blocks and his man STAYS blocked. He latches on like a pitbull. That's what we need, I couldn't give a sh#t he's small, he's the only guy who plays with any intensity up front. And we sit him.
He's smart & he plays with intensity. We have no need for that.
heck even radio announcers are calling Eli gomer pyle now
however I think he would be equally as bad in pass pro and that will get Eli killed. Jones might be a better thought, but even he has problems against bigger DTs.
The problem with the Giants offense isn't the quarterback. The problem with the Giants offense is Ben McAdoo. He had the entire off season to assess the strengths and weaknesses of his team AND the Cowboys and the result was last night's game plan. And what was last night's game plan? Play with heavy hands? Protect the Duke? McAdoo has only proven to be a good cheerleader and a guy who can schedule practice. He needs a legit offensive coordinator. It's a crying fucking shame if Eli's last years here are soiled by this inept coaching. Geno Smith? Holly fucking hell!
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
Completely disagree. The QB's take with him are turning out to be very good. Your whole point is based on speculation, yet we now have Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Mahommes, and Webb who have all played well on actual teams. There is no saying next years class will be as good. Webb has looked very good, has all the intangibles, and done everything asked of him. He also had a stellar career at Cal. T
RE: RE: RE: RE: They need to start thinking about QB
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
Completely disagree. The QB's take with him are turning out to be very good. Your whole point is based on speculation, yet we now have Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Mahommes, and Webb who have all played well on actual teams. There is no saying next years class will be as good. Webb has looked very good, has all the intangibles, and done everything asked of him. He also had a stellar career at Cal. T
Played well? You mean preseason? In next year's draft you'll likely have
Darnold
Rosen
Jackson
Allen
Rudolph
Makefield
Browning
Falk
All of whom could end up being better than any of the QBs drafted last year.
Bravo trueblueinpw, succinct criticism and on the money. He just left
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
By no means am I saying history will repeat itself, but in a draft where only 1 QB went in the 1st rd. and only 3 in the first 4 rds., there is a 6th rd. pick that's done pretty damn well. Let's give Webb at least 1 season to show what's he's got.
It amazes me how people still get shocked when Eli has an off game
I can't recall a season where he didn't have at least a few clunkers.
You take away his #1 target. You put him on the road against the best in the division. In his first real game leading an offensive system that has changed dramatically -- in faces and structure -- from last year. Throw in a little pressure. And that's a good recipe for a clunker.
As much as Eli has accomplished, he has never and will never be Aaron Rodgers in the regular season. He is typically inconsistent, often maddening, and once or twice a year -- entirely unbearable to watch.
But when we've had a team that's good enough to make the playoffs (which we do this year), he has always gotten us there. And when we get there, he's been known to throw God-like passes in high-pressure moments.
If we miss the playoffs this year, it's time to think about what's next. But after one clunker from Eli in week one? Get a fucking life if you're talking about Geno fucking Smith.
Eh, God forbit the Giants shit the bed and end up in position to draft
one of the highly rated QBs (something I think just won't happen given the intense competition to suck this year), if they do end up that bad they can easily draft a QB if they think he's got the goods and end up trading Webb for something.
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
Completely disagree. The QB's take with him are turning out to be very good. Your whole point is based on speculation, yet we now have Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Mahommes, and Webb who have all played well on actual teams. There is no saying next years class will be as good. Webb has looked very good, has all the intangibles, and done everything asked of him. He also had a stellar career at Cal. T
Played well? You mean preseason? In next year's draft you'll likely have
Darnold
Rosen
Jackson
Allen
Rudolph
Makefield
Browning
Falk
All of whom could end up being better than any of the QBs drafted last year.
None if them have ever played an NFL game, they haven't even played their senior year. You've use 100% speculation here. Webb is a better prospect then most of them now. You're too busy reading draft articles.
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
Completely disagree. The QB's take with him are turning out to be very good. Your whole point is based on speculation, yet we now have Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Mahommes, and Webb who have all played well on actual teams. There is no saying next years class will be as good. Webb has looked very good, has all the intangibles, and done everything asked of him. He also had a stellar career at Cal. T
Played well? You mean preseason? In next year's draft you'll likely have
Darnold
Rosen
Jackson
Allen
Rudolph
Makefield
Browning
Falk
All of whom could end up being better than any of the QBs drafted last year.
None if them have ever played an NFL game, they haven't even played their senior year. You've use 100% speculation here. Webb is a better prospect then most of them now. You're too busy reading draft articles.
Almost all of them aren't seniors, and Webb has played a regular season game? Having watched most of them, and yes read what the scouting community has said about the group, there's nothing controversial about concluding that they are likely to be superior to this year's rookie crop.
be ready because Eli's not safe behind this OL? Kim's not a shit-stirrer, and there's no chance Geno gives us a better chance than Eli.
Why not? There are certainly circumstances where Geno might be better. Half the QBs in the league are as good or better than Eli right now. 3 points against Dallas should be setting off alarm bells. The Giants offense was atrocious.
It is pretty clear this team is poorly coached on the offensive side of the ball. And it sounds as if McAdoo is not very flexible when it comes to the way he game plans. That's coming from Carl Banks.
who has shown well. IMO he was better than Geno in preseason. The way to build a team is not to cut bait on a top draft pick with potential one year later, simply because he's not the starter. We'd waste another top pick, not to mention making the 3rd pick last year a waste, and then what? That QB shows promise but doesn't start, so we draft another in 2019? You need to give the kids you have, who are showing good things, a chance. Otherwise you will be in constant re-shuffling. In addition I don't think all those QB's are good, the Wyoming guy looked awful for example. What is the hit rate on QB's something like 30% to just stick? We have a guy who has shown promise at the NFL level, albeit in preseason, but preseason experience is certainly preferable to someone 1 game into their senior college season. If Webb didn't look good then I would have a different stance.
It is pretty clear this team is poorly coached on the offensive side of the ball. And it sounds as if McAdoo is not very flexible when it comes to the way he game plans. That's coming from Carl Banks.
Where did Banks say this? During the game, or was it sometime this morning?
I agree with the above posters, our offensive game plans suck
however I think he would be equally as bad in pass pro and that will get Eli killed. Jones might be a better thought, but even he has problems against bigger DTs.
If Fluker is better in the run game, but equally bad at pass pro, then he should be playing. At least we'll get some run blocking out of it. Jerry has always been a terrible run blocker, and now his pass pro is just as bad. Sit his fat ass down.
Kim just said for Geno to be ready, she didn't say play him
a good idea to hire Mike Sullivan to coordinate a west coast offense with a rookie HC... when he completely bombed in Tampa under Schiano and HAS NEVER RUN A WEST COAST OFFENSE...
It's a fn disgrace... and goes against all reason and common sense.
And for the love of god sit Jerry and start Jones.
Last night was unwatchable and the o-line is an embarrassment. I'm not usually a fire Reese or overreaction guy but he is ruining the final third of Eli's career with this dog shit o-line and never addressing it... Preseason the offense looked exactly the same as yesterday... then they bench Jerry and install Jones in the Jets game and 75 yard drive for a TD... The right side of the line is horrific and Jerry is mostly the cause of it and needs to sit... At least Jones' averageness is better than a turnstile. He locks his guy and even though he gets pushed back a little he is smarter and doesn't give up the QB and coach killing plays. Pocket is always collapsing, we need FIGHTERS up front.
a good idea to hire Mike Sullivan to coordinate a west coast offense with a rookie HC... when he completely bombed in Tampa under Schiano and HAS NEVER RUN A WEST COAST OFFENSE...
It's a fn disgrace... and goes against all reason and common sense.
And for the love of god sit Jerry and start Jones.
Last night was unwatchable and the o-line is an embarrassment. I'm not usually a fire Reese or overreaction guy but he is ruining the final third of Eli's career with this dog shit o-line and never addressing it... Preseason the offense looked exactly the same as yesterday... then they bench Jerry and install Jones in the Jets game and 75 yard drive for a TD... The right side of the line is horrific and Jerry is mostly the cause of it and needs to sit... At least Jones' averageness is better than a turnstile. He locks his guy and even though he gets pushed back a little he is smarter and doesn't give up the QB and coach killing plays. Pocket is always collapsing, we need FIGHTERS up front.
Giving your franchise QB a terrible OLine the last handful of his prime years is/was a pretty shocking decision by Reese. Wonder he feels about that decision today.
Giving your franchise QB a terrible OLine the last handful of his prime years is/was a pretty shocking decision by Reese. Wonder he feels about that decision today.
Reese speaks in a very condescending tone whenever you question the direction or decision making. It is as if the video is not telling the story and they know more than we do. Some secret inside info on some of the players that never materializes on game day.
This morning, Ross Tucker was talking about our OL. He said that he understood it was a poor draft class for OL and that there wasn't a glut of free agents available. However, he said there were a few out there and we did nothing. He could not understand why we thought going into this season with the same group of guys was going to yield different results.
but I wouldn't say he should take over as the starting back. And I hope she means Eli is going to get hurt, so Geno should be ready, because come on. If Eli is going to be replaced by anyone, it should be Davis Webb, who has a future with this team.
And I don't get what Eli is supposed to do. He literally has half the time he would need to get the ball down the field. Dallas was getting pressure rushing 4 and dropping 7, which means that there are fewer places to go with the ball.
The Geno part is only acceptable if the goal is trying to get
Otherwise, I agree with the rest of it. I thought Darkwa should've played more last night and I'm honestly ready to give up on Flowers at LT. I'd switch him and Pugh ASAP. Bobby Hart was even worse than Flowers... I just don't know what the answer for replacing him is unless they moved Flowers to the right side.
To me the offense feels like the D did a few years ago
Always look out of synch and confused, massive communication breakdowns, and just embarrassing. Then we got a talent infusion and a new coach, we need to do the same with the offense. Get Jerry to the bench, get a new OC, change the attitude of the team.
Also if I play another QB its Webb, not Geno. Playing Geno does nothing for us. He is not the future and offers no additional chances to win this year.
Kim clarified that what she meant by the Geno comment
Call me ignorant, but why is 6'2" considered bad? You always hear that leverage is key and OLmen have to get low. It's not like he' 5'9". It seems girth is more important and he has that. Imo his height shouldn't be a factor and maybe even help w leverage.
But just the eye test indicates he's better than Jerry. I don't care how tall he is.
Eli is not playing well and has not for over a year. the idea that it is just going to magically change isn't necessarily true. right now he is a middling QB on a team with a great defense and weapons at the skill positions.
if this continues, I personally would endorse a change - if only to see what else we have and what it might mean for the offense.
is an incredibly damning statement about Eli. Let that one soak in for a second. This is a Giants guy saying basically ht Eli and he crumbles. Holy sh&t!
Every time he plays the offense looks good. McAdoo and the other OL seem to have zero respect for him but he's the only guy who actually blocks and his man STAYS blocked. He latches on like a pitbull. That's what we need, I couldn't give a sh#t he's small, he's the only guy who plays with any intensity up front. And we sit him.
He's smart & he plays with intensity. We have no need for that.
Because Richburg is a #2 pick and did look good his second year. Same reason Flowers plays. He was a top pick.
That's not just the Giants. Fluker started all four years with Chargers because he was a top ten pick or thereabouts. Now that he does not have that going for him, he can't even get on the field on a team with shitty OL.
Richburg looks to be heading down the Fluker path. I still hold out some hope for Flowers because LT is tough to play and he should really be at RT or G.
is an incredibly damning statement about Eli. Let that one soak in for a second. This is a Giants guy saying basically ht Eli and he crumbles. Holy sh&t!
Carl Banks was a great football player, but he is a mediocre commentator and analyst. I've seen Eli get pounded early and keep coming back. Remember the NFCC game in SF? Did Eli crumble? I didn't think so.
Your QB list for the upcoming draft is a little specious. Mayfield and Jackson are not NFL QBs. They are great college QBs but neither is likely to be a starter in the NFL for different reasons. Browning does not look to have the necessary arm strength or, possibly, the durability to succeed at the next level. Allen, Rosen and Arnold have intriguing potential but none are there yet. Falk is another with ability but lets see how he does this year. Webb deserves a shot to replace Eli when the time comes -- but not now. Eli will come around.
I thought Eli was awful last night (not enough practice in preseason games???). The line wasn't good early, but Eli repeatedly passed up quick passes to open receivers underneath and then by the time he went back to them they were covered. He caused a penalty for ineligible receiver (Richburg) when he had Engram right in front of him wide open (would have been a minimum 6 to 8 yard gain), held the ball looking for who know what downfield, then dumped it to somebody.
Despite 75% completion percentage, he missed a wide open Marshall badly which would have been a 20 yard gain minimum, got picked off on a double covered Lewis, got sacked on 2nd and goal at the 3 instead of throwing it away, threw passes to receivers well short of the 1st down line all night and had happy feet even when the protection was good - which it was for most of the second half. It might be time for Geno.....(blaaaach).
Agree on Darkwa - Perkins is easily brought down and misses holes and looked slow.
Please get John Jerry off the field - this is imperative for Eli's (or Geno's) life.
Never heard CB call out the coaches in all the years he's been on the air. As far as CB is concerned it's always the players fault. This offense sucks because Eli got hit early and then was skittish? M'k.
I thought Eli was awful last night (not enough practice in preseason games???). The line wasn't good early, but Eli repeatedly passed up quick passes to open receivers underneath and then by the time he went back to them they were covered. He caused a penalty for ineligible receiver (Richburg) when he had Engram right in front of him wide open
Nothing wrong with criticizing Eli's play last night, but I'm curious how he is responsible for Richburg's penalty? Unless it was a blown up screen play, Richburg has no business going downfield, regardless of how long Eli hangs on to the ball.
Questioning the toughness of a guy who just became the third QB in HISTORY to start 200 consecutive games? Come on now.
Carl did not say Eli is not tough. He said Eli gets rattled. We all know it is true so lets stop pretending that it does not happen. You can fucking see it! You can see Eli's clock shorten. You can see him stop looking to the 2nd and 3rd options. If you don't see that, then you just don't have "the shine"... LOL
Now, people here can criticize Carl all day long. In the end, I think he knows just a little bit more about this than we do.
Oh and Darkwa should have been getting more PT 2 years ago.
I think Darkwa was hurt 2 years ago. But agree, no question he should get a bigger share of the work now
yup
Darkwa showed he can play in 2014 when he had a nifty run against the Rams that year to score a TD. He also trucked over Greg Hardy in 2015.
Yet, for some reason he was buried behind guys like Rashad Jennings and Andre Williams. Literally every time I've seen him carry the ball, he's been impressive. He is a decisive runner and that isn't something we've had since Ahmad Bradshaw played here.
He's always produced, albeit in small sample sizes. Not sure why he doesn't get more burn. Perkins looked very indecisive yesterday.
As others have pointed out, Banks talks like a typical defensive player - everything's about toughness, quitting, getting rattled, imposing your will - things that are impossible to actually quantify or explain. Go back to 2007 and you'll hear the same shit said about Eli. It's tiresome.
I thought Eli was awful last night (not enough practice in preseason games???). The line wasn't good early, but Eli repeatedly passed up quick passes to open receivers underneath and then by the time he went back to them they were covered. He caused a penalty for ineligible receiver (Richburg) when he had Engram right in front of him wide open
Nothing wrong with criticizing Eli's play last night, but I'm curious how he is responsible for Richburg's penalty? Unless it was a blown up screen play, Richburg has no business going downfield, regardless of how long Eli hangs on to the ball.
Eli scrambled to the right, maybe Richburg thought he was going to run. Maybe it was a screen(IDK), but if Eli had thrown the ball to Engram when he was open, there would have been no penalty. It was like Eli didn't want to hit what was open and just held the ball.
But you do bring up a good point.
In comment 13594449 Nomad Crow on the Madison said:
Quote:
Your QB list for the upcoming draft is a little specious. Mayfield and Jackson are not NFL QBs. They are great college QBs but neither is likely to be a starter in the NFL for different reasons. Browning does not look to have the necessary arm strength or, possibly, the durability to succeed at the next level. Allen, Rosen and Arnold have intriguing potential but none are there yet. Falk is another with ability but lets see how he does this year. Webb deserves a shot to replace Eli when the time comes -- but not now. Eli will come around.
I agree with you. It's the other poster who doesn't.
RE: heck even radio announcers are calling Eli gomer pyle now
Who gives a rat's ass what they're calling Eli! Hell Lomas Brown and Anderson called him sheli after a bad game, the name stuck, til they were kneeling and blowing him after winning 46!! Let's dump Gomet/Sheli after one bad game where the O-Line play was abysmal! Eli didn't play well, sure he had the vaunted Dallas front 4 in his face in less than 3 seconds last night. We made Dallas' D-Line look. Like the steel Curtain
I suspect the issue with him is a matter of versatility. He runs well between the tackles, but they don't seem to use him for anything else, which suggests to me he has demonstrated the ability or grasp.
Eg, does he struggle with pass pro, can he catch passes out of the backfield and be effective, is there some aspect of his game outside the tackles that stinks, etc.
I suspect the issue with him is a matter of versatility. He runs well between the tackles, but they don't seem to use him for anything else, which suggests to me he has demonstrated the ability or grasp.
Eg, does he struggle with pass pro, can he catch passes out of the backfield and be effective, is there some aspect of his game outside the tackles that stinks, etc.
He also hasn't demonstrated the ability to stay on the field, which has put him in something of a Catch-22: He can't shake the injury-prone tag without a lot of reps, and the staff may be reluctant to give him the reps because he has been injury-prone.
Eventually, Perkins will probably get dinged - or flop in the lead role - at which point Darkwa will get another chance.
He didn't dress on a night when the team only had four healthy WRs. It's hard to see where a slot for a fourth RB will come from, as long as Shane Smith remains part of the running game and multiple ST units.
If Jones isn't much better, or is even a bit worse - then what the hell. At least try.
I'm OK with Darkwa too - he's a good runner, a good complement to Perkins and maybe flipping them is just fine.
But Geno Smith is only good as an answer to a Jets trivia question.
Yea it's probably time
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
John Jerry has been a starter on this team for FOUR years.
MY guess is this is what she meant. If not, just a stupid comment.
As for OL changes. Not sure if the Giants have anyone on the shelf that is better.
#2 guy should always be ready. And if Eli continues to get hit like this, he Geno better be ready.
Quote:
Geno better be ready because this OL might get Eli killed, which is possible.
MY guess is this is what she meant. If not, just a stupid comment.
Kim Jones is not stupid, not a click bait type. She meant, Eli is going to get hurt behind this line.
it's not eli..eli can't move good..basic pocket passer now worse with age..plus being shell-shocked
now I might've went off deep end..but in end it may not sound as crazy lol
He's smart & he plays with intensity. We have no need for that.
Quote:
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
Quote:
Geno better be ready because this OL might get Eli killed, which is possible.
MY guess is this is what she meant. If not, just a stupid comment.
This^
Quote:
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
Yea it's probably time
What about Webb? He's as good as anyone, on the team, and was a 3rd.
Oh and Darkwa should have been getting more PT 2 years ago.
Quote:
In comment 13593817 jeff57 said:
Quote:
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
Completely disagree. The QB's take with him are turning out to be very good. Your whole point is based on speculation, yet we now have Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Mahommes, and Webb who have all played well on actual teams. There is no saying next years class will be as good. Webb has looked very good, has all the intangibles, and done everything asked of him. He also had a stellar career at Cal. T
Quote:
In comment 13593833 BillT said:
Quote:
In comment 13593817 jeff57 said:
Quote:
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
Completely disagree. The QB's take with him are turning out to be very good. Your whole point is based on speculation, yet we now have Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Mahommes, and Webb who have all played well on actual teams. There is no saying next years class will be as good. Webb has looked very good, has all the intangibles, and done everything asked of him. He also had a stellar career at Cal. T
Played well? You mean preseason? In next year's draft you'll likely have
Darnold
Rosen
Jackson
Allen
Rudolph
Makefield
Browning
Falk
All of whom could end up being better than any of the QBs drafted last year.
Quote:
In comment 13593817 jeff57 said:
Quote:
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
By no means am I saying history will repeat itself, but in a draft where only 1 QB went in the 1st rd. and only 3 in the first 4 rds., there is a 6th rd. pick that's done pretty damn well. Let's give Webb at least 1 season to show what's he's got.
You take away his #1 target. You put him on the road against the best in the division. In his first real game leading an offensive system that has changed dramatically -- in faces and structure -- from last year. Throw in a little pressure. And that's a good recipe for a clunker.
As much as Eli has accomplished, he has never and will never be Aaron Rodgers in the regular season. He is typically inconsistent, often maddening, and once or twice a year -- entirely unbearable to watch.
But when we've had a team that's good enough to make the playoffs (which we do this year), he has always gotten us there. And when we get there, he's been known to throw God-like passes in high-pressure moments.
If we miss the playoffs this year, it's time to think about what's next. But after one clunker from Eli in week one? Get a fucking life if you're talking about Geno fucking Smith.
Quote:
In comment 13593861 jeff57 said:
Quote:
In comment 13593833 BillT said:
Quote:
In comment 13593817 jeff57 said:
Quote:
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
Completely disagree. The QB's take with him are turning out to be very good. Your whole point is based on speculation, yet we now have Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Mahommes, and Webb who have all played well on actual teams. There is no saying next years class will be as good. Webb has looked very good, has all the intangibles, and done everything asked of him. He also had a stellar career at Cal. T
Played well? You mean preseason? In next year's draft you'll likely have
Darnold
Rosen
Jackson
Allen
Rudolph
Makefield
Browning
Falk
All of whom could end up being better than any of the QBs drafted last year.
None if them have ever played an NFL game, they haven't even played their senior year. You've use 100% speculation here. Webb is a better prospect then most of them now. You're too busy reading draft articles.
I really hope people aren't going to remember this thread and drag her for something she very obviously didn't say.
Quote:
In comment 13593875 PatersonPlank said:
Quote:
In comment 13593861 jeff57 said:
Quote:
In comment 13593833 BillT said:
Quote:
In comment 13593817 jeff57 said:
Quote:
Not to make a change now, but in the first round of next year's draft.
And Davis Webb isn't on this team?
Not the answer. He went in the third round of a weak QB class. There are probably at least 10 QBs in next year's draft that are better than him.
Completely disagree. The QB's take with him are turning out to be very good. Your whole point is based on speculation, yet we now have Trubisky, Watson, Kizer, Mahommes, and Webb who have all played well on actual teams. There is no saying next years class will be as good. Webb has looked very good, has all the intangibles, and done everything asked of him. He also had a stellar career at Cal. T
Played well? You mean preseason? In next year's draft you'll likely have
Darnold
Rosen
Jackson
Allen
Rudolph
Makefield
Browning
Falk
All of whom could end up being better than any of the QBs drafted last year.
None if them have ever played an NFL game, they haven't even played their senior year. You've use 100% speculation here. Webb is a better prospect then most of them now. You're too busy reading draft articles.
Almost all of them aren't seniors, and Webb has played a regular season game? Having watched most of them, and yes read what the scouting community has said about the group, there's nothing controversial about concluding that they are likely to be superior to this year's rookie crop.
I really hope people aren't going to remember this thread and drag her for something she very obviously didn't say.
Thanks, Devon. I take my first comment back then.
THIS
Why not? There are certainly circumstances where Geno might be better. Half the QBs in the league are as good or better than Eli right now. 3 points against Dallas should be setting off alarm bells. The Giants offense was atrocious.
Oh and Darkwa should have been getting more PT 2 years ago.
I think Darkwa was hurt 2 years ago. But agree, no question he should get a bigger share of the work now
Quote:
big into the sky is falling but she is right.
Oh and Darkwa should have been getting more PT 2 years ago.
I think Darkwa was hurt 2 years ago. But agree, no question he should get a bigger share of the work now
yup
Where did Banks say this? During the game, or was it sometime this morning?
If Fluker is better in the run game, but equally bad at pass pro, then he should be playing. At least we'll get some run blocking out of it. Jerry has always been a terrible run blocker, and now his pass pro is just as bad. Sit his fat ass down.
It's a fn disgrace... and goes against all reason and common sense.
And for the love of god sit Jerry and start Jones.
Last night was unwatchable and the o-line is an embarrassment. I'm not usually a fire Reese or overreaction guy but he is ruining the final third of Eli's career with this dog shit o-line and never addressing it... Preseason the offense looked exactly the same as yesterday... then they bench Jerry and install Jones in the Jets game and 75 yard drive for a TD... The right side of the line is horrific and Jerry is mostly the cause of it and needs to sit... At least Jones' averageness is better than a turnstile. He locks his guy and even though he gets pushed back a little he is smarter and doesn't give up the QB and coach killing plays. Pocket is always collapsing, we need FIGHTERS up front.
It's a fn disgrace... and goes against all reason and common sense.
And for the love of god sit Jerry and start Jones.
Last night was unwatchable and the o-line is an embarrassment. I'm not usually a fire Reese or overreaction guy but he is ruining the final third of Eli's career with this dog shit o-line and never addressing it... Preseason the offense looked exactly the same as yesterday... then they bench Jerry and install Jones in the Jets game and 75 yard drive for a TD... The right side of the line is horrific and Jerry is mostly the cause of it and needs to sit... At least Jones' averageness is better than a turnstile. He locks his guy and even though he gets pushed back a little he is smarter and doesn't give up the QB and coach killing plays. Pocket is always collapsing, we need FIGHTERS up front.
Giving your franchise QB a terrible OLine the last handful of his prime years is/was a pretty shocking decision by Reese. Wonder he feels about that decision today.
One game people. One.
Giving your franchise QB a terrible OLine the last handful of his prime years is/was a pretty shocking decision by Reese. Wonder he feels about that decision today.
Reese speaks in a very condescending tone whenever you question the direction or decision making. It is as if the video is not telling the story and they know more than we do. Some secret inside info on some of the players that never materializes on game day.
This morning, Ross Tucker was talking about our OL. He said that he understood it was a poor draft class for OL and that there wasn't a glut of free agents available. However, he said there were a few out there and we did nothing. He could not understand why we thought going into this season with the same group of guys was going to yield different results.
You can't argue with that
And I don't get what Eli is supposed to do. He literally has half the time he would need to get the ball down the field. Dallas was getting pressure rushing 4 and dropping 7, which means that there are fewer places to go with the ball.
Otherwise, I agree with the rest of it. I thought Darkwa should've played more last night and I'm honestly ready to give up on Flowers at LT. I'd switch him and Pugh ASAP. Bobby Hart was even worse than Flowers... I just don't know what the answer for replacing him is unless they moved Flowers to the right side.
Also if I play another QB its Webb, not Geno. Playing Geno does nothing for us. He is not the future and offers no additional chances to win this year.
But just the eye test indicates he's better than Jerry. I don't care how tall he is.
Quote:
In comment 13593831 SFGFNCGiantsFan said:
Quote:
Geno better be ready because this OL might get Eli killed, which is possible.
MY guess is this is what she meant. If not, just a stupid comment.
Kim Jones is not stupid, not a click bait type. She meant, Eli is going to get hurt behind this line.
He definitely could. There's a lot of top end pass rushers on the schedule who have the ability to abuse this OL.
It exactly a trait that would suggest a quarterback change is beyond consideration
if this continues, I personally would endorse a change - if only to see what else we have and what it might mean for the offense.
He's smart & he plays with intensity. We have no need for that.
Because Richburg is a #2 pick and did look good his second year. Same reason Flowers plays. He was a top pick.
That's not just the Giants. Fluker started all four years with Chargers because he was a top ten pick or thereabouts. Now that he does not have that going for him, he can't even get on the field on a team with shitty OL.
Richburg looks to be heading down the Fluker path. I still hold out some hope for Flowers because LT is tough to play and he should really be at RT or G.
Carl Banks was a great football player, but he is a mediocre commentator and analyst. I've seen Eli get pounded early and keep coming back. Remember the NFCC game in SF? Did Eli crumble? I didn't think so.
He doesn't like to point the finger at coaches or injuries because that seems like excuse-making to someone with his mentality.
Basically his comments are those of a smash-mouth player, not an analyst.
Despite 75% completion percentage, he missed a wide open Marshall badly which would have been a 20 yard gain minimum, got picked off on a double covered Lewis, got sacked on 2nd and goal at the 3 instead of throwing it away, threw passes to receivers well short of the 1st down line all night and had happy feet even when the protection was good - which it was for most of the second half. It might be time for Geno.....(blaaaach).
Agree on Darkwa - Perkins is easily brought down and misses holes and looked slow.
Please get John Jerry off the field - this is imperative for Eli's (or Geno's) life.
Nothing wrong with criticizing Eli's play last night, but I'm curious how he is responsible for Richburg's penalty? Unless it was a blown up screen play, Richburg has no business going downfield, regardless of how long Eli hangs on to the ball.
Carl did not say Eli is not tough. He said Eli gets rattled. We all know it is true so lets stop pretending that it does not happen. You can fucking see it! You can see Eli's clock shorten. You can see him stop looking to the 2nd and 3rd options. If you don't see that, then you just don't have "the shine"... LOL
Now, people here can criticize Carl all day long. In the end, I think he knows just a little bit more about this than we do.
Quote:
In comment 13593867 McNally's_Nuts said:
Quote:
big into the sky is falling but she is right.
Oh and Darkwa should have been getting more PT 2 years ago.
I think Darkwa was hurt 2 years ago. But agree, no question he should get a bigger share of the work now
yup
Darkwa showed he can play in 2014 when he had a nifty run against the Rams that year to score a TD. He also trucked over Greg Hardy in 2015.
Yet, for some reason he was buried behind guys like Rashad Jennings and Andre Williams. Literally every time I've seen him carry the ball, he's been impressive. He is a decisive runner and that isn't something we've had since Ahmad Bradshaw played here.
He's always produced, albeit in small sample sizes. Not sure why he doesn't get more burn. Perkins looked very indecisive yesterday.
One game people. One.
really? guess you don't see the issue..but it's ok..
Quote:
I thought Eli was awful last night (not enough practice in preseason games???). The line wasn't good early, but Eli repeatedly passed up quick passes to open receivers underneath and then by the time he went back to them they were covered. He caused a penalty for ineligible receiver (Richburg) when he had Engram right in front of him wide open
Nothing wrong with criticizing Eli's play last night, but I'm curious how he is responsible for Richburg's penalty? Unless it was a blown up screen play, Richburg has no business going downfield, regardless of how long Eli hangs on to the ball.
Eli scrambled to the right, maybe Richburg thought he was going to run. Maybe it was a screen(IDK), but if Eli had thrown the ball to Engram when he was open, there would have been no penalty. It was like Eli didn't want to hit what was open and just held the ball.
But you do bring up a good point.
That's the way I read it.
I agree with you. It's the other poster who doesn't.
Who gives a rat's ass what they're calling Eli! Hell Lomas Brown and Anderson called him sheli after a bad game, the name stuck, til they were kneeling and blowing him after winning 46!! Let's dump Gomet/Sheli after one bad game where the O-Line play was abysmal! Eli didn't play well, sure he had the vaunted Dallas front 4 in his face in less than 3 seconds last night. We made Dallas' D-Line look. Like the steel Curtain
Eg, does he struggle with pass pro, can he catch passes out of the backfield and be effective, is there some aspect of his game outside the tackles that stinks, etc.
Eg, does he struggle with pass pro, can he catch passes out of the backfield and be effective, is there some aspect of his game outside the tackles that stinks, etc.
Eventually, Perkins will probably get dinged - or flop in the lead role - at which point Darkwa will get another chance.
^^^ This -- he really wasn't hitting at all too --
compare to Zeke -- he was running into defenders (including Snacks) and knocking them backwards