Why is it that this guy will get a pass but when it comes down to it he's not that good anymore i don't see the media saying that the Saints need to move on from Brees. The thing that makes it worse is that he has a better O line then the shit sack Eli has but i'm sure even many on here will protect and make excuses for this overrated stat padder.
That happened a bit last year too. Don't let his inflated stats fool you.
Why does he get a pass when an inferior player might not get the same pass? That's really your question.
He's better than Eli and has been for a decade. Maybe that's why he gets a pass.
Not questioning he has been a great QB. But folks blaming last nights game and several last year including games at home with the playoffs on the line, he was flat out not good, yet no one looks at that.
Why does he get a pass when an inferior player might not get the same pass? That's really your question.
He's better than Eli and has been for a decade. Maybe that's why he gets a pass.
No he's not but thanks for playing..
Your right Eli is better....smh
Did the game take a turn for the worst for him that I missed?
Rank Player Rate Years Tm
1 Bart Starr+ 104.8 1956-1971 gnb
2 Kurt Warner+ 102.8 1998-2009 2TM
3 Matt Ryan 102.4 2008-2017 atl
4 Drew Brees 100.7 2001-2017 2TM
5 Aaron Rodgers 99.4 2005-2017 gnb
6 Joe Montana+ 95.6 1979-1994 2TM
13 Tom Brady 89.0 2000-2017 nwe
16 Eli Manning 87.4 2004-2017 nyg
............................................................
Ok and in 2014 and 2015 Eli went for 65 Td's and 8,846 but he had a losing record and that's all people cared about but Mr. Brees can put losing season year after after and people will still cream themselves over the guy.
Quote:
the past 2 years. You can say he's a compiler if you want but thats a shit ton of compiling. The guy moonwalks into the HOF on the first ballot...
............................................................
Ok and in 2014 and 2015 Eli went for 65 Td's and 8,846 but he had a losing record and that's all people cared about but Mr. Brees can put losing season year after after and people will still cream themselves over the guy.
To truly be a good QB you have to look at both total numbers and Efficiency... Most of Eli's career he wasn't efficient because of Gilbride's offensive game plan.. Fine high risk high reward offense got us 2 SB.. but once BM came over Eli has been in an offensive game plan that no longer excuses inefficiency.. Brees is putting up those number (BTW 1,400+ yards is a huge difference) at a much more efficient rate.. when you put both together you can see that Brees was pretty freaking awesome and the losing had to do with Historically bad defense.. His passer rating hasn't been below 97 and usually is at 101-104 range since 2012..
Quote:
on the road has he won? can't remember any...
Your right Eli is better....smh
Not saying Eli is better, I'm saying what do you want stats or someone who gets the job done at crunch time! Brees has had plenty of opportunities in the playoffs and not got it done whereas Eli would have at least one more win last year if the rest of his offense showed up. I'll take that anytime.
Quote:
the past 2 years. You can say he's a compiler if you want but thats a shit ton of compiling. The guy moonwalks into the HOF on the first ballot...
............................................................
Ok and in 2014 and 2015 Eli went for 65 Td's and 8,846 but he had a losing record and that's all people cared about but Mr. Brees can put losing season year after after and people will still cream themselves over the guy.
Eli was definitely underrated in 2014 and 2015.. actually most of his career he has been underrated.. but Brees is no slouch.. there isn't a QB who means more to his team than Brees over the past 10+ years.. Even brady's team went 3-0 without him.. It wasn't until they were playing their thrid QB who had a broken hand had to start before Pats lost last year..
Quote:
In comment 13595245 gmenatlarge said:
Quote:
on the road has he won? can't remember any...
Your right Eli is better....smh
Not saying Eli is better, I'm saying what do you want stats or someone who gets the job done at crunch time! Brees has had plenty of opportunities in the playoffs and not got it done whereas Eli would have at least one more win last year if the rest of his offense showed up. I'll take that anytime.
Again look at the table above and try telling me Brees hasn't done enough.. he has a higher passer rating in the playoffs than brady, Peyton, Montana and Rodgers and Eli.. he can't help it if his defense can't tackle Beast mode with 14 guys or SF scored 36 points with Alex smith..
+
In the dome, Eli's numbers aren't much better than his average.
We went down this road a couple of months ago.
Brees Vs Eli - ( New Window )
Quote:
In comment 13595349 Tuckrule said:
Quote:
In comment 13595245 gmenatlarge said:
Quote:
on the road has he won? can't remember any...
Your right Eli is better....smh
Not saying Eli is better, I'm saying what do you want stats or someone who gets the job done at crunch time! Brees has had plenty of opportunities in the playoffs and not got it done whereas Eli would have at least one more win last year if the rest of his offense showed up. I'll take that anytime.
Again look at the table above and try telling me Brees hasn't done enough.. he has a higher passer rating in the playoffs than brady, Peyton, Montana and Rodgers and Eli.. he can't help it if his defense can't tackle Beast mode with 14 guys or SF scored 36 points with Alex smith..
Again with the stats, win the fucking game, he has had the ball in his hands with a chance to win and not got it done. I'm not arguing who's better, it's who would you rather have...I'll take the wins!