According to some; yes. Heaven forbid we field a decent OLine for the first time in YEARS. Let's give Reese another pass, just because. (Not you, just saying in general)
Unfortunately the FO will use this line of excuse making
Not be running routes short of the sticks on 4th down. He's part of the problem but not the entire problem. How Reese didn't hedge his bets by bringing in serviceable back up to flowers in the off season is baffling
But if you're putting tonight on Eli you don't know what you're watching.
McAdoo owns a big part of this - but for the guy who is steadfast in refusing to pay OBJ, the $20M we're dropping on Eli right now is hurting like crazy.
RE: RE: Is he supposed to block and catch the ball?
No - but he's not supposed to hold the ball for 7 seconds and expect protection, or misfire when he has time and open receivers either.
Did you guys watch the same fucking game?
I'm no McAdoo hater, but I wasn't pleased with our playcalling tonight. Of course, that's fairly hard to judge when we can't execute any of it worth shit. Beyond that though, tucking our tails with over a minute left and 3 time outs at the end of the 2nd half? Come on.
Seriously, how so you make any concrete judgements about this guy
Exactly, everyone piling on him, but the talent on this offense is god awful. Reese expecting the OL will be better with a year under their belt was ballsy, but backfired on him.
You can't call a game or do anything when you're OL is that fucking useless.
RE: Seriously, how so you make any concrete judgements about this guy
the offense just looks lost and the head coach is an offensive coach...
soon the defense is going to start saying screw this, jpp makes a great play team has momentum and then int, detroit comes in and scores and thats all she wrote...
the team just doesnt look like they care, team is starijg 0-3 and if you look at the schedule it could be 0-5
You're an absolute clown. We all know you have Coughlins Dick firmly implanted into your mouth, but it's getting ridiculous at this point. The plays were there to be made. They didn't fucking make them. Drops, bad passes, a punt return for a TD, running routes short of the line for a first. Yeah, all on "Ray Handley". You're truly embarrassing yourself in your Coughlin crusade and quite frankly, nobody is in the mood for it so fuck off.
on third and long. They would at least have a chance to convert. They ran well executed screens. Giants seem to run a play where three guys need to miss and it gains 6 yards.
You're an absolute clown. We all know you have Coughlins Dick firmly implanted into your mouth, but it's getting ridiculous at this point. The plays were there to be made. They didn't fucking make them. Drops, bad passes, a punt return for a TD, running routes short of the line for a first. Yeah, all on "Ray Handley". You're truly embarrassing yourself in your Coughlin crusade and quite frankly, nobody is in the mood for it so fuck off.
Last time the Giants went 8 games without scoring 20 points was 1978.
decision-making (going for it on 4th and goal was questionable), use of personnel and insisting on doing the same things over and over with the same results = The definition of McAdoo Madness.
You're an absolute clown. We all know you have Coughlins Dick firmly implanted into your mouth, but it's getting ridiculous at this point. The plays were there to be made. They didn't fucking make them. Drops, bad passes, a punt return for a TD, running routes short of the line for a first. Yeah, all on "Ray Handley". You're truly embarrassing yourself in your Coughlin crusade and quite frankly, nobody is in the mood for it so fuck off.
Didn't TC miss the postseason his last 4 years as a HC?!
RE: You could put Joe Montana behind this line and it would be a mess
You're an absolute clown. We all know you have Coughlins Dick firmly implanted into your mouth, but it's getting ridiculous at this point. The plays were there to be made. They didn't fucking make them. Drops, bad passes, a punt return for a TD, running routes short of the line for a first. Yeah, all on "Ray Handley". You're truly embarrassing yourself in your Coughlin crusade and quite frankly, nobody is in the mood for it so fuck off.
Didn't TC miss the postseason his last 4 years as a HC?!
McAdoo is an offensive coach.
The last time the Giants went 8 games in a row without scoring 20 points was 1978.
nuts? He plants like he's being electrocuted and has no athletic ability at all! Like the classmate who is this huge man and nobody can figure out why he doesn't play ball! He's not getting better, he's GETTING WORSE! This might just be his worst outing yet IMHO!
McAdoo is not the answer. Say what you want about the OL, unless
OBJ is breaking big ones or the opposing defense is in prevent, this offense plain stinks. After 3 years of giving inferior personnel tasks they are incapable of handling, at some point you have to blame the coach for the players' lack of execution too.
I'm no big fan of Reese either. He reaches on too many high picks and misses on them. He's fixated on certain positions to the detriment of other key ones.
Among the big 3, I think Eli should be give the benefit of the doubt. He may be slipping, but he deserves some slack for the past glory he's afforded us.
And the ray handley record in his future. 17 is a season to tank, retire eli, and go into a total rebuild, without jerry,.....he needs to be shown the door.
Were some of the worst coached teams I've seen in my life. So spare me me your Coughlin revisionist bullshit. We all lovecwhat TC did for the Giants, but it's time to let go. For fucks sake.
Oh wait...
According to some; yes. Heaven forbid we field a decent OLine for the first time in YEARS. Let's give Reese another pass, just because. (Not you, just saying in general)
No - but he's not supposed to hold the ball for 7 seconds and expect protection, or misfire when he has time and open receivers either.
Did you guys watch the same fucking game?
Link - ( New Window )
Well, a little.
You know a well coached team when you see it.
Probably because they know they're not going to have a ton of time to throw it with this shit-house OL?
McAdoo owns a big part of this - but for the guy who is steadfast in refusing to pay OBJ, the $20M we're dropping on Eli right now is hurting like crazy.
Quote:
.
No - but he's not supposed to hold the ball for 7 seconds and expect protection, or misfire when he has time and open receivers either.
Did you guys watch the same fucking game?
I'm no McAdoo hater, but I wasn't pleased with our playcalling tonight. Of course, that's fairly hard to judge when we can't execute any of it worth shit. Beyond that though, tucking our tails with over a minute left and 3 time outs at the end of the 2nd half? Come on.
He hasn't. The buck stops there. He's the head coach.
Exactly, everyone piling on him, but the talent on this offense is god awful. Reese expecting the OL will be better with a year under their belt was ballsy, but backfired on him.
You can't call a game or do anything when you're OL is that fucking useless.
Yup. Not to mention, short passes that Eli doesn't even hit accurately quite a bit of the time, even with time..
soon the defense is going to start saying screw this, jpp makes a great play team has momentum and then int, detroit comes in and scores and thats all she wrote...
the team just doesnt look like they care, team is starijg 0-3 and if you look at the schedule it could be 0-5
Quote:
The WRs aren't fucking up each and every time and Eli can only throw it where they are/are going to be.
Probably because they know they're not going to have a ton of time to throw it with this shit-house OL?
Two yards or so, in most cases, isn't going to make that much of a difference.
Trust me, I'm not excusing this shit stain of an OL either.
Not if you saw that first half, and really, most of the game.
How bout running off to boos with a smirk on his face after not calling a timeout before the fg. And then giving up on the half with 3 timeouts.
You're an absolute clown. We all know you have Coughlins Dick firmly implanted into your mouth, but it's getting ridiculous at this point. The plays were there to be made. They didn't fucking make them. Drops, bad passes, a punt return for a TD, running routes short of the line for a first. Yeah, all on "Ray Handley". You're truly embarrassing yourself in your Coughlin crusade and quite frankly, nobody is in the mood for it so fuck off.
Quote:
Is a solid way to show you suck at football
Not if you saw that first half, and really, most of the game.
You're definitely a simpleton when it comes to football
Quote:
.
You're an absolute clown. We all know you have Coughlins Dick firmly implanted into your mouth, but it's getting ridiculous at this point. The plays were there to be made. They didn't fucking make them. Drops, bad passes, a punt return for a TD, running routes short of the line for a first. Yeah, all on "Ray Handley". You're truly embarrassing yourself in your Coughlin crusade and quite frankly, nobody is in the mood for it so fuck off.
Last time the Giants went 8 games without scoring 20 points was 1978.
You're right - he's blameless. He did enough to win.
The INT, holding the ball far too damn long - all because of the OL. Or the coach.
Save for a handful of seasons, we've been making these excuses for Eli for a long damn time, even while TC was here.
Quote:
In comment 13604876 crick n NC said:
Quote:
Is a solid way to show you suck at football
Not if you saw that first half, and really, most of the game.
You're definitely a simpleton when it comes to football
Nah. Just don't have Eli's cock in my mouth 24/7.
Eli was, as usual, PART of the problem, not ALL...
but keep apologizing for him..or excuse. ol, Eli, Mac, drops by receivers. st breakdown atwrong time..its broken record. period!
Quote:
.
You're an absolute clown. We all know you have Coughlins Dick firmly implanted into your mouth, but it's getting ridiculous at this point. The plays were there to be made. They didn't fucking make them. Drops, bad passes, a punt return for a TD, running routes short of the line for a first. Yeah, all on "Ray Handley". You're truly embarrassing yourself in your Coughlin crusade and quite frankly, nobody is in the mood for it so fuck off.
Didn't TC miss the postseason his last 4 years as a HC?!
He wasn't shit talking - he was yelling at his own team to pick up the pace.
At this point, paying Eli $20M/yr is a much bigger part of the problem.
I think 62 yards rushing too...
Quote:
Is a solid way to show you suck at football
You're right - he's blameless. He did enough to win.
The INT, holding the ball far too damn long - all because of the OL. Or the coach.
Save for a handful of seasons, we've been making these excuses for Eli for a long damn time, even while TC was here.
Reading comprehension, I didn't say he is blameless, however, how do you expect a qb to perform in this mess?
Quote:
In comment 13604782 Britt in VA said:
Quote:
.
You're an absolute clown. We all know you have Coughlins Dick firmly implanted into your mouth, but it's getting ridiculous at this point. The plays were there to be made. They didn't fucking make them. Drops, bad passes, a punt return for a TD, running routes short of the line for a first. Yeah, all on "Ray Handley". You're truly embarrassing yourself in your Coughlin crusade and quite frankly, nobody is in the mood for it so fuck off.
Didn't TC miss the postseason his last 4 years as a HC?!
McAdoo is an offensive coach.
The last time the Giants went 8 games in a row without scoring 20 points was 1978.
I'm no big fan of Reese either. He reaches on too many high picks and misses on them. He's fixated on certain positions to the detriment of other key ones.
Among the big 3, I think Eli should be give the benefit of the doubt. He may be slipping, but he deserves some slack for the past glory he's afforded us.
Quote:
In comment 13604888 Dave in Hoboken said:
Quote:
In comment 13604876 crick n NC said:
Quote:
Is a solid way to show you suck at football
Not if you saw that first half, and really, most of the game.
You're definitely a simpleton when it comes to football
Nah. Just don't have Eli's cock in my mouth 24/7.
Simpleton