...and I've searched my memory bank for some beauts of his, such as that crazy Minny game at home many years ago with several INTS and at least one pick six.
This is what has me steaming, and it goes way beyond his inability to complete 6-yard passes to his backs.
Eli's energy level is close to zero and his ability to inspire those around him IS zero.
The path to the Super Bowl no longer rests on Eli's shoulders. That's for a new QB and a new team with many new names.
But yet, your take is he doesn’t have the same energy and will to inspire. Would you blame a pilot if he couldn’t land a plane without engines?
No he's not the same guy.
Nope.
Now if we could just the rest of you onboard...
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
Missing three starting OL (of what is a bad OL)
Starting TE can't catch the ball
Yes he made some bad throws, but he was not the primary problem. The team started 5 UDFA's (Darkwa, Jones, Wheeler, Smith, Lewis Jr.) and 2 others who were recent late picks let go by other teams (Halapio, King). If you add in Travis Rudolph thats 8 guys that nobody wanted at the end of '16 who are now the core of our offense. What do you expect?
Twaddle
By that standard there were no offers in the offseason for Brady, so I guess nobody wanted him as well.
Agreed. He's the same guy, he just can't lead by example anymore because his skill isn't the same. He's just not that good anymore, which is very unfortunate, but he's absolutely the same guy.
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
Agree but there's no reason not to start Eli. In fact, you can send the message that this is still Eli's team by allowing him to start and compete until the game clearly can not be won. Besides, do you really want to see Geno in there? Remember, Webb isn't even dressing for games, he was drafted with a huge question mark and a development/project timeline of a few seasons. If Webb has any chance at all to be a starting NFL QB, and that's very much a question, why risk ruining his chance for longterm success with this horrible offensive personnel and scheme? I'm not saying not to dress and play Webb, just saying don't rush him into starting. Let's start by dressing him and giving him a few NFL snaps.
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
Of course Sy makes a good point, but it's also an irrelevant point.
Next year Eli is another year older, another year more cautious and another year looking to get on the ground when things get hot.
Sure a better supporting cast would help Eli. But our QB isn't taking us on any more improbable Super Bowl runs. And now we need to wake up to the fact that Eli is old and not our future answer. That's the point Sy should be making!
Reb8thVA... I hear ya! Been there, done that with a few companies.
crick n NC... I like your brevity, and I think it deserves a like response. I know precisely what I'm seeing. My thread starter says it all.
Did you just start following Eli? When has he ever gotten pissed off? When has he ever been a rah rah guy? So you expect him to change now?
It can be more than one thing. Yes, talent level isn't good. Yes, coaching isn't good. Yes, level of play at QB isn't sufficient. I'm iffy about blaming scheme. The scheme is short completions. There no situation where it is acceptable for an NFL QB to be scattershot and inconsistent inside 10 yards.
Quote:
His supporting cast is terrible, worst in the NFL but he’s leaving points on the field every week. It seems like every game he misses sure tds. So is it him or the scheme or everyone around him? I thinks it’s all of the above. He’s not helping matters let’s leave it at that
It can be more than one thing. Yes, talent level isn't good. Yes, coaching isn't good. Yes, level of play at QB isn't sufficient. I'm iffy about blaming scheme. The scheme is short completions. There no situation where it is acceptable for an NFL QB to be scattershot and inconsistent inside 10 yards.
To be this bad a lot of talent, trust, planning, coaching and effort have to be off.
A few of the above being better could get it back to competetive. But man for man in the equation you can only keep the variables you think are part of a championship future.
And Manning, to me, unless surrounded by a supremely talented group, isn't a championship level QB any longer.
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
Call a fucking game that gives them a fighting chance to win. What do they have to lose that they still insist on this ridiculous offense? They have a legitimate QB who is still the leader of this team, and instead the coach is castrating him and treating like a 3rd rate guy to manage a game. That doesn't even work when you have no running game to speak of. Let him go out and win the fucking game or go down trying.
I truly believe if they do him the great favor of trading/cutting him after drafting a QB that he will lead a real team deep into the playoffs.
He wasn’t playing against the 85 Bears , it was the crappy Redskins !
He three were drops ... but there were also several passes my 11 year old can make. He dumps the ball off with the first sign of any pressure!
Stats don’t lie ... his stats were pathetic.
There's one concept in the whole system that's a game changer, the slant to Beckham. And without it, the offense is worthless.
He threw 27 picks. Would be much worse with this group.
Hes gunshy now. The hits add up. Teams look at his 2014 and 15 stats and say, our qb would do that with Beckham, who was historically productive. Thats why Eli's stats looked good.
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
It's not unfair. Several good QBs have played with poor supporting casts due to injury or otherwise. How many have led their team to historically inept offenses two years running?
It's not unfair. What's unfair is blaming every WR he's every played with for being dumb or lazy when Eli throws a pick. What's unfair is blaming the WR/RB for not catching a ball that's consistently thrown high, in the dirt or behind them. What's unfair is blaming the OL when they've given him plenty of protection several times this season and he still can't get it done.
This isn't a second year QB pushing through a soph slump. This is a seasoned vet that's accounts for the biggest cap hit on the team.
The comparisons to Dak Prescott are ludicrous.
Surrounded by crap players but still picking up that game check.
And its funny how often the defenders have to resort to terms like 'clueless', 'no idea', 'morons' etc.........usually the first sign they have no decent argument.
Quote:
that it is grossly unfair to assess Eli under these circumstances. He should get a pass for the balance of this season.
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
It's not unfair. Several good QBs have played with poor supporting casts due to injury or otherwise. How many have led their team to historically inept offenses two years running?
It's not unfair. What's unfair is blaming every WR he's every played with for being dumb or lazy when Eli throws a pick. What's unfair is blaming the WR/RB for not catching a ball that's consistently thrown high, in the dirt or behind them. What's unfair is blaming the OL when they've given him plenty of protection several times this season and he still can't get it done.
This isn't a second year QB pushing through a soph slump. This is a seasoned vet that's accounts for the biggest cap hit on the team.
The comparisons to Dak Prescott are ludicrous.
Couldn't agree with this more. Even when he was good, any pick was always somebody else's fault
Very well played, Sir! This neatly summarizes a Giant predicament!!!
Eli is past his prime and is not leading this team or any future Giants team to the promised land (for a third time). That's not "idiotic." It's the simple truth.
Quote:
that it is grossly unfair to assess Eli under these circumstances. He should get a pass for the balance of this season.
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
He doesn't need rest. He needs a new team. This isn't just about the lack of talent around him. It is also (equally?) terrible coaching. He is one of two real assets on offense, yet we are running a Mickey Mouse offense. What does anyone expect asking him to throw 2 yard pass after 2 yard pass? He puts it in the ribs of his RBs and receivers and they drop it because they are all worried about turning and running. Then he takes 3 steps and has a DL right on him. ETC. Way down on the list, in my opinion, are the 2-3 passes where he put it over his RBs head on a 2 yard pass.
Call a fucking game that gives them a fighting chance to win. What do they have to lose that they still insist on this ridiculous offense? They have a legitimate QB who is still the leader of this team, and instead the coach is castrating him and treating like a 3rd rate guy to manage a game. That doesn't even work when you have no running game to speak of. Let him go out and win the fucking game or go down trying.
I truly believe if they do him the great favor of trading/cutting him after drafting a QB that he will lead a real team deep into the playoffs.
Quote:
that it is grossly unfair to assess Eli under these circumstances. He should get a pass for the balance of this season.
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
It's not unfair. Several good QBs have played with poor supporting casts due to injury or otherwise. How many have led their team to historically inept offenses two years running?
It's not unfair. What's unfair is blaming every WR he's every played with for being dumb or lazy when Eli throws a pick. What's unfair is blaming the WR/RB for not catching a ball that's consistently thrown high, in the dirt or behind them. What's unfair is blaming the OL when they've given him plenty of protection several times this season and he still can't get it done.
This isn't a second year QB pushing through a soph slump. This is a seasoned vet that's accounts for the biggest cap hit on the team.
The comparisons to Dak Prescott are ludicrous.
Modus... well played, Sir!
+1
Eli played poorly and has had a number of bad games this year and no, it's not all on the OL and the injuries...Eli has squandered a number of opportunities that you can't hang on anyone else but him.
However to suggest that the problem is Eli's energy level or ability to inspire his teammates is beyond stupid.
Did you compare his blank stares from every other game he's ever played to last night's game and see some subtle difference that the rest of us missed?
Eli has that ball dumped off before some of the WR’s even get a chance to run their pattern.
Eli’s time is over,we all need to move on.
14 seasons, 12 of the 14 without a playoff win. Blow the whole thing up!
Quote:
I think Eli played like crap, but 'inspiration' and 'energy level' are garbage. He's the same guy that led the team to two Super Bowl victories. Maybe not the same player, though.
+1
Eli played poorly and has had a number of bad games this year and no, it's not all on the OL and the injuries...Eli has squandered a number of opportunities that you can't hang on anyone else but him.
However to suggest that the problem is Eli's energy level or ability to inspire his teammates is beyond stupid.
Did you compare his blank stares from every other game he's ever played to last night's game and see some subtle difference that the rest of us missed?
Have you ever played the game?
Lack of confidence that WRs will catch a ball even if you lob it into their hands from a foot away.
And last night was some horrible play calling by Sullivan.
Any order you want(I've got DC-itis at #1.).
Eli is a part of that failure, I personally do not put him near the top of the list of reasons, but he is the QB.
This is now shit on Eli time and he is on a two win squad so it is hard to argue otherwise.
But, to trot out the tired low energy look from the first days or Eli seems wrong. He looked the same last night as he has in the past. He always looks like that. To question his energy and dedication is bush league.
I almost wish they would play Smith or Webb just to see what would happen. I don't think it would be pretty.
Also, I would love to hear how Eli really feels about this season or this coach. He will be a causality of all this too. I would like to know his side.
He and Papa Archie manipulated their way out of San Diego because spoiled Eli needed to be pampered with the better organization. And then he essentially rode 5 weeks in his playoff career to 2 improbable SB wins. On top of that, he's made a boatload of money in arguably the greatest sports market.
Sympathy is the least of my takeaways from last night...
Quote:
In comment 13703800 That’s Gold, Jerry said:
Quote:
that it is grossly unfair to assess Eli under these circumstances. He should get a pass for the balance of this season.
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
He doesn't need rest. He needs a new team. This isn't just about the lack of talent around him. It is also (equally?) terrible coaching. He is one of two real assets on offense, yet we are running a Mickey Mouse offense. What does anyone expect asking him to throw 2 yard pass after 2 yard pass? He puts it in the ribs of his RBs and receivers and they drop it because they are all worried about turning and running. Then he takes 3 steps and has a DL right on him. ETC. Way down on the list, in my opinion, are the 2-3 passes where he put it over his RBs head on a 2 yard pass.
Call a fucking game that gives them a fighting chance to win. What do they have to lose that they still insist on this ridiculous offense? They have a legitimate QB who is still the leader of this team, and instead the coach is castrating him and treating like a 3rd rate guy to manage a game. That doesn't even work when you have no running game to speak of. Let him go out and win the fucking game or go down trying.
I truly believe if they do him the great favor of trading/cutting him after drafting a QB that he will lead a real team deep into the playoffs.
good post. It is a Mickey Mouse offense.
That is an insult to the entire Disney universe to compare his shit show to mickey
Quote:
that it is grossly unfair to assess Eli under these circumstances. He should get a pass for the balance of this season.
Again, anyone who believes this is remotely Eli's fault is simply not dealing with reality.
Now that he has broken Peyton's record and we know he will never catch Favre, time to let Eli sit and rest. I never, ever thought I would say that.
He doesn't need rest. He needs a new team. This isn't just about the lack of talent around him. It is also (equally?) terrible coaching. He is one of two real assets on offense, yet we are running a Mickey Mouse offense. What does anyone expect asking him to throw 2 yard pass after 2 yard pass? He puts it in the ribs of his RBs and receivers and they drop it because they are all worried about turning and running. Then he takes 3 steps and has a DL right on him. ETC. Way down on the list, in my opinion, are the 2-3 passes where he put it over his RBs head on a 2 yard pass.
Call a fucking game that gives them a fighting chance to win. What do they have to lose that they still insist on this ridiculous offense? They have a legitimate QB who is still the leader of this team, and instead the coach is castrating him and treating like a 3rd rate guy to manage a game. That doesn't even work when you have no running game to speak of. Let him go out and win the fucking game or go down trying.
I truly believe if they do him the great favor of trading/cutting him after drafting a QB that he will lead a real team deep into the playoffs.
Very good post Matt. Maybe he does need a mental break because i5 can really wear on you having to constantly pretend everything is normal.
Quote:
In comment 13703786 BrettNYG10 said:
Quote:
I think Eli played like crap, but 'inspiration' and 'energy level' are garbage. He's the same guy that led the team to two Super Bowl victories. Maybe not the same player, though.
+1
Eli played poorly and has had a number of bad games this year and no, it's not all on the OL and the injuries...Eli has squandered a number of opportunities that you can't hang on anyone else but him.
However to suggest that the problem is Eli's energy level or ability to inspire his teammates is beyond stupid.
Did you compare his blank stares from every other game he's ever played to last night's game and see some subtle difference that the rest of us missed?
Have you ever played the game?
I played in HS. What does that have to do with anything?
Is that the extent of your ability to handle anyone who disagrees with one of your incredibly bad takes (and there have been many of the years) to infer that the only reason they're disagreeing with you is because they haven't "played the game" and you have?
If you've played football at a major college level or in the NFL I'd be absolutely shocked, because you've never demonstrated a knowledge of the game above BBI average. So I have no idea what you're going for with that comment.
In any event, Eli has looked the same game after game year after year, whether he's winning or losing. If you think it's something else then it has more to do with what you're feeling than what your years of "game playing" experience has taught you.
Yeah but if you do that, will you do it with energy and a will to inspire?
I dunno, maybe I'm imagining it.
Quote:
In comment 13703988 Jim in Tampa said:
Quote:
In comment 13703786 BrettNYG10 said:
Quote:
I think Eli played like crap, but 'inspiration' and 'energy level' are garbage. He's the same guy that led the team to two Super Bowl victories. Maybe not the same player, though.
+1
Eli played poorly and has had a number of bad games this year and no, it's not all on the OL and the injuries...Eli has squandered a number of opportunities that you can't hang on anyone else but him.
However to suggest that the problem is Eli's energy level or ability to inspire his teammates is beyond stupid.
Did you compare his blank stares from every other game he's ever played to last night's game and see some subtle difference that the rest of us missed?
Have you ever played the game?
I played in HS. What does that have to do with anything?
Is that the extent of your ability to handle anyone who disagrees with one of your incredibly bad takes (and there have been many of the years) to infer that the only reason they're disagreeing with you is because they haven't "played the game" and you have?
If you've played football at a major college level or in the NFL I'd be absolutely shocked, because you've never demonstrated a knowledge of the game above BBI average. So I have no idea what you're going for with that comment.
In any event, Eli has looked the same game after game year after year, whether he's winning or losing. If you think it's something else then it has more to do with what you're feeling than what your years of "game playing" experience has taught you.
I asked if you played because you dismissed the idea of energy and inspiration.
to Mickey, Donald, Pluto and the rest of the crew