Archived Thread
Hundley 5th round pick
Webb 3rd round pick
Hundley given the chance to develop due to an unfortunate injury to Rodgers has performed admirably Kept the Packers playoff chances alive
Webb needs to be given a look in the last three games to see what this kid has There’s no guarantee that any of these QBs coming out are any better than Webb and could absolutely be busts
The Giants are in great position come draft time to trade down and acquire multiple picks to rebuild this team quickly
its a no brainer that webb should start and finish the final 3....
we are being loyal to eli and i get it, but this is a business...i dont buy the he isnt ready bullshit. guys that were drafted after him have seen time
But I’d still give him a look.
Is hundleys second year so he sat for a year plus. Not the best comparison but I would like to see Webb
one is a figment of our imagination.
We never even drafted him...
The Packers are a playoff quality team without their QB.
The Giants offense is garbage at all levels. Not a good space for a rookie who has never played a live snap under center.
oline? After he threw his fist INT you would be calling him a bust.
blows. What is this thread?
Webb needs to be given a look in the last three games to see what this kid has There’s no guarantee that any of these QBs coming out are any better than Webb and could absolutely be busts
Exactly.
And watching the the shitty OL shitty WRs and bad offense will give the next coaching staff info that will be useful? Doubtful.
In comment
13733776 Jon in NYC said:
| blows. What is this thread? |
Correct Jon in NYC. Hundley blows Guess you haven’t watched many Packer games
and took advantage of it, learned more and is doing just fine.
But Webb should sit...
In comment
13733798 Earl the goat said:
In comment 13733776 Jon in NYC said:
Quote:
blows. What is this thread?
Correct Jon in NYC. Hundley blows Guess you haven’t watched many Packer games |
I watch a ton of packer games. Hundley sucks ass.
But I would hate to spend a pick on a marginal improvement and pass on Cub
Chubb or Nelson who would be definitive improvements
In comment
13733843 Mike in NY said:
| Chubb or Nelson who would be definitive improvements |
I agree. And trading down nets is some additional picks and Nelson would probably still be available
Would be child abuse.
Let's see how the draft plays out.
would do nothing with this offense. No one can.
With the personnel on the field for the Jints. However the D really sucks
In comment
13733764 EddieNYG said:
This thread just blows. Guy is on year 3 and only playing because Rodgers was hurt. He isn’t even good either. But whatever, in a few weeks the Webb threads will be over.
today.
Would like to see if you could ignore a Webb thread as well...
I'm all in on that if so.
In comment
13733987 Jimmy Googs said:
today.
Would like to see if you could ignore a Webb thread as well... |
Sawwwy Jimmy
and Hundley was running around under duress all day.
The o-line isnt the difference...
In comment
13733987 Jimmy Googs said:
today.
Would like to see if you could ignore a Webb thread as well... |
Sure it would. Because, Engram, Shepard, and Joe blow are clearly on the same level as Adams, jordy and Cobb
but are we just going to ignore that small little detail and just continue pretending Webb has been in the league the same amount as Hundley?
The thread sucks because it’s comparing draft pick status and nothing else. Great thread.
In comment
13734018 UConn4523 said:
Well, we sure will look forward to that Focker...
is exactly why this thread is pointless. We are comparing a guy who just started getting reps in practice to a year 3 player who’s only playing because of an injury.
The scenarios couldn’t be any different but hey, they were picked in the mid rounds so let’s compare them.
In a real game situation.
Link - (
New Window )
Webb has been with the team for 7 months.He has been throwing a football since he was 5 or 6. Not ready is the real indictment on the coaching staff. he should be ready.Urban Meyer's red shirt freshman QB's are always ready when the get forced into action.
are 2-5 since Rodgers got hurt, beating the Bears and Bucs.
I'm not really sure how that's playing admirably, but there are some weird things that get posted here.
The packers aren't a playoff caliber team without their QB.
One more thing. The good news for GB is hue learned Hundle isnt very good so they can make a plan on finding a replacement.
Packers got a chance to evaluate their backup QB during regular season games. This was extremely valuable for the organization as they were able to determine that Hundley was not the player they thought he was. And now the Packers have more info on the player and can make a plan in the offseason to improve this position.
Unfortunately the Giants didn't take the same opportunity to evaluate Webb.
In summary, the NYG are Fukin Stupid.
In comment
13734613 KWALL2 said:
The packers aren't a playoff caliber team without their QB.
One more thing. The good news for GB is hue learned Hundle isnt very good so they can make a plan on finding a replacement. |
They are when he's healthy. If they had a more talented backup they'd be able to tread water. The Giants cannot even run an offense when everyone's healthy.
They are missing is Rodgers. That's the only injury that impacts that team.
Who else is injured and hurting the team?
With Rodgers they are a SB cor tender.
Without him, they suck.
