In all of the drama of the past couple of years, I feel Snacks Harrison's story has been lost a bit. In my opinion, I don't think I've witnessed a Giants' defensive tackle as dominant as him. He has 162 tackles in two years... and these are not of the downfield variety. I would argue he was the best player on the team in 2017 and certainly was in the conversation in 2016 (with Odell and Landon).
Keith Hamilton is the only one I can think of who comes close. He was a mean enforcer who could rush the passer, but I see Harrison as an All-Pro type lineman.
It's really remarkable story. The guy wasn't drafted and the Jets let him go in free agency.
Generally understood as the Super Bowl era
Personally I agree that he is the best NYG DT of the modern era.
Linval was the worst, but also:
Hankins ( we'll see)
Barry coffield
Cornelius griffin.
Cofield wouldn't fit that description. He played three more years after walking from the giants.
9 sacks, 52 tackles in 51 Redskins game. Nothing to write home about. Griffin was legit. Linval went to Minnesota and became a far better player than he ever was here.
Harrison
Hamilton
Howard
Mendenhall was also a standout on some awful teams. Troy Archer was very good as well, talented.
I'd mention Jim Burt in this conversation. Not better than Snacks. But tough as hell.
I'd mention Jim Burt in this conversation. Not better than Snacks. But tough as hell.
Based on Madden mentions alone, Burt should be in HOF.
Quote:
he eats offensive lineman -- there's two or more on him on every play, and he still manages to shack them and chase after the QB
I don't get why he's not thought of as a pass rusher -- because he rushes and pressures the passer often
The real shame is that our d-ends have really not taken maximum advantage of him
I remember a play or two where Snacks engaged a double and knocked an OL to the ground with one arm.
I really want to know why we had such a hard time getting a rush from outside with this guy and Tomlinson in the middle.
Because JPP sucks and Vernon is overrated and overpaid.
Troy Archer is a "what might have been". Mendenhall great but more of a speed guy.
The Giants haven't had another as good as him - Hamilton, Mendenhall, Howard, etc - all great players, but Harrison is HOF, IMO.
Linval Joseph is very good, but Snacks is very much better.
yep. Alan Page played at 225 later in his career
I'd mention Jim Burt in this conversation. Not better than Snacks. But tough as hell.
Was a big fan Burt when he was with the Giants but he dropped several notches after his hit on Hostetler in the 1990 NFCC game.
What an upgrade too over Kuhn.
Quote:
In comment 13783793 gidiefor said:
Quote:
he eats offensive lineman -- there's two or more on him on every play, and he still manages to shack them and chase after the QB
I don't get why he's not thought of as a pass rusher -- because he rushes and pressures the passer often
The real shame is that our d-ends have really not taken maximum advantage of him
I remember a play or two where Snacks engaged a double and knocked an OL to the ground with one arm.
I really want to know why we had such a hard time getting a rush from outside with this guy and Tomlinson in the middle.
Because JPP sucks and Vernon is overrated and overpaid.
Kind of funny that the GM who signed DH (brilliant) also signed JPP and Vernon (dumb from the looks of things so far).
Quote:
In comment 13783810 Snacks said:
Quote:
In comment 13783793 gidiefor said:
Quote:
he eats offensive lineman -- there's two or more on him on every play, and he still manages to shack them and chase after the QB
I don't get why he's not thought of as a pass rusher -- because he rushes and pressures the passer often
The real shame is that our d-ends have really not taken maximum advantage of him
I remember a play or two where Snacks engaged a double and knocked an OL to the ground with one arm.
I really want to know why we had such a hard time getting a rush from outside with this guy and Tomlinson in the middle.
Because JPP sucks and Vernon is overrated and overpaid.
Kind of funny that the GM who signed DH (brilliant) also signed JPP and Vernon (dumb from the looks of things so far).
It's what happens when you're forced to go FA out of desperation. You pay All-Pro $$ to good but not great players.
Quote:
In comment 13784284 Victor in CT said:
Quote:
In comment 13783810 Snacks said:
Quote:
In comment 13783793 gidiefor said:
Quote:
he eats offensive lineman -- there's two or more on him on every play, and he still manages to shack them and chase after the QB
I don't get why he's not thought of as a pass rusher -- because he rushes and pressures the passer often
The real shame is that our d-ends have really not taken maximum advantage of him
I remember a play or two where Snacks engaged a double and knocked an OL to the ground with one arm.
I really want to know why we had such a hard time getting a rush from outside with this guy and Tomlinson in the middle.
Because JPP sucks and Vernon is overrated and overpaid.
Kind of funny that the GM who signed DH (brilliant) also signed JPP and Vernon (dumb from the looks of things so far).
It's what happens when you're forced to go FA out of desperation. You pay All-Pro $$ to good but not great players.
And why was there desperation? Because of his poor drafts. (Injuries didn't help)
Quote:
In comment 13784493 Snacks said:
Quote:
In comment 13784284 Victor in CT said:
Quote:
In comment 13783810 Snacks said:
Quote:
In comment 13783793 gidiefor said:
Quote:
he eats offensive lineman -- there's two or more on him on every play, and he still manages to shack them and chase after the QB
I don't get why he's not thought of as a pass rusher -- because he rushes and pressures the passer often
The real shame is that our d-ends have really not taken maximum advantage of him
I remember a play or two where Snacks engaged a double and knocked an OL to the ground with one arm.
I really want to know why we had such a hard time getting a rush from outside with this guy and Tomlinson in the middle.
Because JPP sucks and Vernon is overrated and overpaid.
Kind of funny that the GM who signed DH (brilliant) also signed JPP and Vernon (dumb from the looks of things so far).
It's what happens when you're forced to go FA out of desperation. You pay All-Pro $$ to good but not great players.
And why was there desperation? Because of his poor drafts. (Injuries didn't help)
Yes. Poor drafts are the cause.
Mendenhall was smaller, quicker and a better pass rusher. Nowhere near the run stuffer Snacks is. Come to think of it, they would have been perfect compliments to each other as a starting DT combo.