Go on the Record for your preference of Drafted QB

until the red flag health issues. At 2 Darnold. If he is not there then we trade back or go RB

this is based on Eli playing for the next 1 or 2 years

Just a feeling if they go QB it will be him because he seems to be pro ready. Starting to believe Giants may keep Eli and Webb and draft Barkley.

Hands down

And yes at 2.

.

to amass picks and take Jackson.

.

I may change my min before the draft.. but as of now he has had the best career in college football..

For reasons stated by Superspy. But I bet CLE takes him.

I'm very interested in Mayfield, tho I'm sure I'm in a small minority. Don't know if I'd spend #2, but trade down a few spots and get a second second-rounder(?)

Therefore it'll be Rosen.

trade back to #5/6 and get at least 2019 #1, 2018 #2 and #3. Grab Barkley (long shot), Chubb, Fitz, or Nelson, then add RB, OL, LB and a wildcard with the 4 picks in rds 2-3.

Darnold (slow delivery doesn't bother me enough), Rosen (health issues are concerning but I've come around on his personality and his skills are A+), or Mayfield (size not an issue for me, he's a competitor who plays with a chip on his shoulder and runs a highly efficient offense).

Will be downright shocked if they don't go QB with the #2 pick.

Has the feet...fiery( the good and the bad)..and the type arm it seems the possession system / move the chains type QB I think the Giants are looking for. And the Darnold 'it' factor.
Then again...I liked Gary Wood.
Won't happen but he's my pick.

Darnold if he's there.

If he's not, I'm not sure that I wouldn't try to trade back a few spots (stay in top 10) and get Mayfield or Allen. Just scared of Rosen's concussions and shoulder, now.

He seems like a scary sort of all-potential pick, the type of big-arm prototype looking guy that ends up being blake bortles

...

I want regardless of at #2 or elsewhere. He is the Favre of this group.

My second option is Allen and then Darnold. I do not want Rosen at all.

In comment 13796344 cjac said:

Quote:

this is based on Eli playing for the next 1 or 2 years

My vote too.

.

But I could settle on Darnold

He'll be there in the 2nd and him and Webb can feed off each other.

Trade down for OL.

Rd 2. Falk
Rd 3 silvers

..

We are in the beginning of the process ask me after the combine

alternate scenario would be to take Barkley and trade back in for Jackson.

Saquon Barkley, OL and DL the rest of the draft with a sprinkle of FA OL linemen to block for Barkley.

and draft Barkley at #2.

of right now, in this order:

Kurt Benkert - 4th, maybe 3rd round, depending on combine and pro day results.
No QB.
Josh Allen at #2.
Sam Darnold at #2.

And Trade Down again, they must acquire picks in this draft, and they can load up with a #2 pick, I would say that they should try to acquire a QB while trading down, in that scenario I would say Baker Mayfield, I think he could slip into the 8-12 pick, Giants would acquire plenty trading back in that area.

I really don't follow college ball and the draft like I used to.

I feel like they gotta come out of round 1 with a qb. Whether that's Rosen or darnold with the 2, or a trade down for Allen or mayfield. I'd be happy with anything as long as it's a qb

they will not take a QB and load up on OL and find a rB and go with Eli. I do remember our QB/Punter Gary Wood.

.

In comment 13796356 chuckydee9 said:

Quote:

I may change my min before the draft.. but as of now he has had the best career in college football..

which basically means nothing in terms of what it means for the pros. Not saying you can't like Baker, college careers transitioning to the NFL pretty much mean nothing.

You trade down and still get a QB.. but this isn’t a perfect world.

Stay at 2 draft Josh Rosen

of any..it would be Darnold. Rosen if Darnold is gone.

Guy is going to win a lot of games with NFL talent around him.

With Allen a close second and Mayfield a not too distant third.

.

The best combination of accuracy, size and ability to play in a pro-style offense.

trade down to 5 - 9, take Mayfield or trade down further and take Jackson.

...followed by Allen. IMO there is a serious dropoff after these two.

heard a great Asian qb that can fling shit across the yard

but I mayfield is climbing. Think he would be the perfect fit with Shurmur

The Manning, Rivers, Big Ben class having this many question marks?

Im going to go on record and say I want Rosen. The premise is, if Shurmur is the coach, he will be in the perfect situation to succeed without having to start within the first year. I've always felt that he had the most raw talent and the higher ceiling.

Ultimately will be the best pro out of this QB class with the right development, which Shurmur will provide for him.

Allen is the athletic freak who needs more technical work. I feel he'll be the second QB off the board.

I think he is Drew Brees/Russel Wilson. There is no top 20 QB in the NFL that had a college completion percentage under 60%. Accuracy and Efficiency are the most reliable predictors of NFL success.

appears to have all the intangibles, including being a winner.

After we get past the height, "cannon" arm, running ability and other pure athletic traits, I think the truly successful QB's posses an ability to recognize defenses and audible to counter, a keen pocket presence and awareness and "escapability", ability to scan the field for targets (vs. locking in), "enough" arm strength but superior accuracy, the ability to lead and raise the confidence level of those around him, the ability to move the chains in a number of ways. I would like to see a QB who outperformed the talent around him (the Giants will need this) and who was not just the beneficiary of great field position because he played on a team with a great defense. I would think that the evaluation is a multifaceted process, involving football "smarts" in addition to just strength and speed. I believe the Gruden features (QB Camp) prior to the last drafts gave some insight --I recall Dak Prescott doing well when included in the top names that particular year. This is a very tough and involved process and I don't believe any but the truly "connected" have a real insight.