What if - Eli on the Eagles in 2017 ...

.

Big tree.

I mean when journeyman Nick Foles beats Brady, Right ?

Seriously Manny. Who knows. The Eagles Offense was buil around QBs who have a different skill set. Doesn’t mean Eli would not have been as successful but who knows

..with that defense and running game no doubt about it...

Foles is a better qb at this point. Eli throws high slants, lost deep throw ability and cant move a lick. Old

Manny being Manny.

I don't see much difference between what Eli was in 2011 and what he is now, except that he has an O-line that is worse (not that it was "all that" back then, except that he had Bradshaw & Jacobs).

McAdoo (to his credit) improved his footwork and worked to help him increase his percentage by featuring a dink-and-donk offense. The problem - his best receiver targets all went down (as his O-line was still stinking).

So ... you put him behind an O-line like Philly had this year (which he has NEVER had here), I'm positive he would have taken them to the championship game (and very likely beaten Tom again).

In comment 13826035 NYSports1 said:

Quote:

Foles is a better qb at this point. Eli throws high slants, lost deep throw ability and cant move a lick. Old

Ok

had landed in Nazi Germany? What if Spartacus had a Piper Cub? What if Napoleon had a B-52 Bomber?

open titles that seem silly.

However, my curiosity got the better of me time. My mistake.

In comment 13826101 rebel yell said:

Quote:

had landed in Nazi Germany? What if Spartacus had a Piper Cub? What if Napoleon had a B-52 Bomber?

one pair of walkie talkies would have been as game changing for Napoleon as an airplane.

Napoleon - the Baker Mayfield of QBs

In comment 13826108 markky said:

Quote:

In comment 13826101 rebel yell said: Quote: had landed in Nazi Germany? What if Spartacus had a Piper Cub? What if Napoleon had a B-52 Bomber? one pair of walkie talkies would have been as game changing for Napoleon as an airplane. Napoleon - the Baker Mayfield of QBs

Agree. I should have credited those titles to old SNL skits....which they all were I always enjoyed those skits and as a history buff, also found them to be interesting imponderables.

For my previous snide remark. Having a rough morning and you were con isn't target to dis oN

I get your question. I don t think they win with Eli.

Foles played the last two games at a level few quarterbacks play.

that I just don't know.

And Foles never played his playoff run better than Eli did during his playoff runs. Anyone really believe Foles overcomes that 49er defense in the NFCC game? Come on now.

.
Link - ( New Window )

Then Mac would have had to find another player to throw under the bus

In comment 13826371 mrvax said:

Quote:

that I just don't know.

agreed