Should we trade OBJ for a high draft pick?

ly.

Does it pass the sniff test?

Here we go again

Let's trade him for the best pot smoker from a major school.

See what I did there? Huh?

For the Browns' #1 and #4. Who says no?!!!??!!

seems to be trickling down.

no.

If the market dries up, it's still probably worth it to get a 4th or even a 5th for him.

Heck no

.

I'm just glad you started this thread.

No one has brought this idea up yet, so it's good to have it come to the forefront here!

Are you high?

We will start with the Cons:

He's a distraction
He tried to pee on the field
Everyone hates him
He's constantly tweeting and IG'ing
He drops too many passes
He's not a big time player(see the only game he's ever played in that matters)
He's married to an object
He's overrated


Pros:

I can't think of any



Conclusion: Addition by subtraction, just get rid of him.

that they still owe us for Shockey.

In comment 13860116 Keith said:

Quote:

We will start with the Cons: He's a distraction He tried to pee on the field Everyone hates him He's constantly tweeting and IG'ing He drops too many passes He's not a big time player(see the only game he's ever played in that matters) He's married to an object He's overrated Pros: I can't think of any Conclusion: Addition by subtraction, just get rid of him.

Here's a con that's a pro. Without a threat at WR, Eli and the Giants will end up in the top 5 of the 2019 NFL draft.

.

Maybe the 1st and 4th might get it done.

In comment 13860116 Keith said:

Quote:

We will start with the Cons: He's a distraction He tried to pee on the field Everyone hates him He's constantly tweeting and IG'ing He drops too many passes He's not a big time player(see the only game he's ever played in that matters) He's married to an object He's overrated Pros: I can't think of any Conclusion: Addition by subtraction, just get rid of him.

Gotta add major coke problem to the cons list.

then you have to go out and find a #1 receiver.

In comment 13860116 Keith said:

Quote:

We will start with the Cons: He's a distraction He tried to pee on the field Everyone hates him He's constantly tweeting and IG'ing He drops too many passes He's not a big time player(see the only game he's ever played in that matters) He's married to an object He's overrated Pros: I can't think of any Conclusion: Addition by subtraction, just get rid of him.

The hot take could fry many eggs!

In comment 13860116 Keith said:

Quote:

We will start with the Cons: He's a distraction He tried to pee on the field Everyone hates him He's constantly tweeting and IG'ing He drops too many passes He's not a big time player(see the only game he's ever played in that matters) He's married to an object He's overrated Pros: I can't think of any Conclusion: Addition by subtraction, just get rid of him.

I must have missed the part where every hates him.

when he isn't the field...

In comment 13860116 Keith said:

Quote:

We will start with the Cons: He's a distraction He tried to pee on the field Everyone hates him He's constantly tweeting and IG'ing He drops too many passes He's not a big time player(see the only game he's ever played in that matters) He's married to an object He's overrated Pros: I can't think of any Conclusion: Addition by subtraction, just get rid of him.

why does the dog piss celebration annoy you?

In comment 13860130 arcarsenal said:

Quote:

In comment 13860116 Keith said: Quote: We will start with the Cons: He's a distraction He tried to pee on the field Everyone hates him He's constantly tweeting and IG'ing He drops too many passes He's not a big time player(see the only game he's ever played in that matters) He's married to an object He's overrated Pros: I can't think of any Conclusion: Addition by subtraction, just get rid of him. Gotta add major coke problem to the cons list.

when was the last stretch of games Eli Manning looked like an even remotely good QB without Odell Beckham as his top target... 2012? The day they get rid of Odell, they might as well send Eli packing too.

for someone who in all statistical likelihood will never be close to OBJ as a player.

sense to fill one hole and have an even larger hole open.

But hey, Keith says so!

If they can get a 1st rounder for him in this draft, I'd say go for it. That would necessitate replacing the top receiving threat. However, I think this could all be part of a good rebuild for the Giants. Let's not forget, good free agent wide receives are available nearly every off season. And, it's hard to remember the last time a team won a championship with a receiver like Odell. It's much the same argument as not needing a top rb- it helps to have one but you need not have the best in the game to win.

I'll admit I was disgusted when the latest video surfaced, mostly because he is being a poor role model for kids, and the thought of trading him briefly crossed my mind along with anger at him being so stupid. He has to have lost a lot of endorsements with his behavior and damage to his image.

BUT...Lets not get crazy and trade the best player on our team... You give him a very long leash. Let's see if Shurmur/Gettleman have an impact on him this year. Or he could just get healthy, play at a high level, and I don't care what he does on social media.

In comment 13860116 Keith said:

Quote:

We will start with the Cons: He's a distraction He tried to pee on the field Everyone hates him He's constantly tweeting and IG'ing He drops too many passes He's not a big time player(see the only game he's ever played in that matters) He's married to an object He's overrated Pros: I can't think of any Conclusion: Addition by subtraction, just get rid of him.

Agreed this guy is going to blow up, it's so apparent he's got problems.

Definitely must go

Probably not the only player in the league who smokes pot and sleeps with beautiful women.

Without question the best receiver in my lifetime which stretches back to the Kyle Rote and Del Shofner era.

Real issue is contract demands.If he will not sign a reasonable contract I would try to trade him or do what the Dolphins did with Landry- let him play out his contract and then tag him and trade him.

When does it get to the point where "Enough is Enough" as Donna Summer and Barbra Streisand once sang? When should the Giants make a move and trade him?

forgot the biggest con of all.

Shitty taste in pizza.

Ship his ass out tomorrow for a deep dish from Chicago....

you can't think of any pros for Beckham? Like maybe before the injury he was on pace to be one of the best WRs to ever play football? That might be a pro.

for Cleveland's 1 and 4.

It really is a stupid question because it cannot be answered without identifying what we would get. THAT is the only determining factor... the ONLY one.

Even those who think the idea of trading him is stupid would agree to make the trade if the browns offered both #1 picks this year plus their first pick in the next two drafts.

So, there IS a price at some point for everyone.

I was hoping somebody would finally post one. Thanks Frankie!

Personally, "enough is enough" came for me when I saw that he may be gay.

I find that to be appalling and a major distraction for an NFL team.

Since he raised the topic on the FA thread and then took the feedback literally:

Quote:

RE: OBJ Ten Ton Hammer : 2:27 pm : link : reply In comment 13860076 Frankie in Flushing said: Quote: I know it hasn't been talked about, but after this last video, anyone think we should trade OBJ? This should be it's own thread.

Link - ( New Window )

in a heartbeat....going into his 5th yr. this guy will never grow up...will just keep being the headlines for all the wrong reasons....how can u invest in a time bomb like this?.....ibeen a giant fan since 1957..never anything like this except shockey......and they finally dumped him...

may be gay?? The resident insider has all but said he's gay!

Quote:

. arcarsenal : 3:04 pm : link : reply Personally, "enough is enough" came for me when I saw that he may be gay.

Looking at things through the lens of information is a powerful drug. More powerful than Coke!!

How high of pick are you talking about? How high will OBJ be at the time of the trade? Are there any horse socks? You've left out a lot of key considerations.

In comment 13860199 FatMan in Charlotte said:

Quote:

may be gay?? The resident insider has all but said he's gay! Quote: . arcarsenal : 3:04 pm : link : reply Personally, "enough is enough" came for me when I saw that he may be gay. Looking at things through the lens of information is a powerful drug. More powerful than Coke!!

It's very frustrating to be the only one here who understands how the NFL works in a sea of peasants!!!

In comment 13860175 Frankie in Flushing said:

Quote:

When does it get to the point where "Enough is Enough" as Donna Summer and Barbra Streisand once sang? When should the Giants make a move and trade him?

He would have to be completely unreasonable in contract negotiations for a year or more, a complete cancer to the locker room, poor play, serious injury, commit a violent felony, he has a long way to go in my opinion.

So far I've seen his antics more as poor judgement and a public relations mess, then signs of a serious problem, the dude is emotional, competitive, and wants to win. You don't draft talent like him very often.

so we aren't getting punked by this Frankie in Flushing?? He's being serious.

I really can't tell and the last post about Donna Summer and Babs is just confounding me to no end.

do we need another reason. Clearly that guy is clued in to the goings on in the NFL, specifically the night clublife if you know what i mean.

Quote:

Bucky Brooks @BuckyBrooks 46 minutes ago Based on recent developments, would it make sense for the @jaguars to offer up a 1st and 3rd to the @giants for @OBJ_3 ?

Link - ( New Window )

In comment 13860175 Frankie in Flushing said:

Quote:

When does it get to the point where "Enough is Enough" as Donna Summer and Barbra Streisand once sang? When should the Giants make a move and trade him?

If we start spotting Brad Wing in the luxury box wearing his jersey.

.