Hello,
Don’t post here very often but I decided to do a mock tonight on first pick with a trade with the bills and liked how it came out, so I thought I would post here for feedback. Interested to hear thoughts on the mock as a whole or thoughts on feelings about it the picks would be good fits for the Gmen.
Your Picks:
Round 1 Pick 12 (BUF): Edmunds, Tremaine, OLB, Virginia Tech (A)
Round 1 Pick 22 (BUF): McGlinchey, Mike, OT, Notre Dame (A-)
Round 2 Pick 2: Michel, Sony, RB, Georgia (B)
Round 3 Pick 2: Allen, Marcus, FS, Penn State (A-)
Round 4 Pick 2: Toliver II, Kevin, CB, LSU (A+)
Round 5 Pick 2: Norton, Kendrick, DT, Miami (FL) (A+)
Your Future Picks:
2019 Round 1 Pick (BUF)
2019 Round 1 Pick
2020 Round 1 Pick
2 1st rounders in 2018
2 2nd rounders in 2018
2 3rd rounders in 2018
1 1st rounder in 2019
With 8 premium picks in rounds 1-3 this year, they should draft along the lines of 4 OL (2 T, 1 C, 1 G), 2 CB, 1 S, 1 RB).
Obviously you have some thoughts and views as to how the draft will unfold - How would your draft board look on those 8 premium round picks this year? Would be interesting to see how you see it shaking out if they were able to grab those picks this year
Ouch - Sounds like Flowers and Apple. Young players who aren't really developed to be coming out of college
Good try, though.
I don't agree. It is a one year deal.
100% agree with this. I would be so psyched.
Also, ND OT will not be there in the 20s.
This is a good excercise though.
What do we get this year to give up a QB of the future?
Do we end up trading away a bunch of picks in a few years when Webb doesn't work out?
Obviously most of us would favor a shorter trade down like to 3,4,5 or even 6.
Our first 3 rounds could look like this:
RD 1 (#12) R. Smith, LB Georgia
RD 1 (#22) I. Wynn, OT Gergia
RD 2 (#34) I. Oliver, CB Colorado
RD 2 (#53) M. Rankin, OT Miss St.
RD 2 (#56) A. Key, DE LSU
RD 3 (#66) R. Penny, RB SDSU
I am not sure Key is there at #56. If not, I like Lorenzo Carter to pair with Smith. We could also look at Justin Reid, S out of Stanford.
What do you think?
Our first 3 rounds could look like this:
RD 1 (#12) R. Smith, LB Georgia
RD 1 (#22) I. Wynn, OT Gergia
RD 2 (#34) I. Oliver, CB Colorado
RD 2 (#53) M. Rankin, OT Miss St.
RD 2 (#56) A. Key, DE LSU
RD 3 (#66) R. Penny, RB SDSU
I am not sure Key is there at #56. If not, I like Lorenzo Carter to pair with Smith. We could also look at Justin Reid, S out of Stanford.
What do you think?
Old Dirty I would want that as well but keep in mind any good deal has to work for both sides. I don't think Buffalo is going to give up both 1's, both 2's, AND a 1 next year. Drop a 2 and it's realistic, and still a pretty good overpay according to the charts (which it should be), and it's a nice haul for NY. I do like your scenario a lot better. Particularly Wynn at #22, and love Roquan Smith. Couple of notes on the rest...I have a feeling Penny is going to go in the 2nd round. I also think that Arden Key is a guy to avoid. Giants have always been a character first. With a guy like Key...a supremely talented pass rusher but a reputation of being a lazy player, those guys are the ones that bust. He wouldn't be a consideration for me if I was in charge at any pick. I like your other choices. Rankin I believe will be a good pro tackle.