Poll: Who is your favorite QB in the 2018 draft?

-

...

2) Mayfield
3) Darnold

.

.

I wouldn’t entertain idea of a deal back until I was sure he was not going to be there. Rosen will be very good too.

Darnold 3
Rosen 2
Mayfield 1

Going to be a premier QB.

Rosen

but prefer Barkley or a trade down

The consensus best. It's hard to tell how the others' skills will develop. Will the others reach Rosen's level?

Darnold
Mayfield

It's tied at 4 for Darnold and Rosen

.

4 for Darnold
1 Allen
1 Mayfield

6 for Rosen
5 for Darnold
1 Allen
1 Mayfield

He's going to be great!

..

By far.

7 for Rosen
5 for Darnold
2 Allen
1 Mayfield

Mayfield is getting no love.

This is the second BBI poll of this sort. You do realize there are people who don't want any of these? A meaningful poll would be who do you want, also include trade down. But no, continue the idiotic circle jerk of how to most effectively destroy the Giants

7 for Rosen
5 for Darnold
2 Allen
2 Mayfield

and has always been the prize of the 2018 draft.

The exercise in knocking him down has been a lot of smoke from teams in the 2-5 range, including the Giants.

Rosen......not durable enough
Allen......not accurate enough
Mayfield...not big enough

In comment 13871337 Tim in VA said:

Quote:

This is the second BBI poll of this sort. You do realize there are people who don't want any of these? A meaningful poll would be who do you want, also include trade down. But no, continue the idiotic circle jerk of how to most effectively destroy the Giants

It's not like I'm constraining you from saying what you feel. I'm just curious which QB in particular is the favorite among BBI. I'll add you to a NOTA vote.

7 for Rosen
7 for Darnold
2 Allen
2 Mayfield
1 Trade down/none

would be my choice.

Mayfield #2

9 for Rosen
7 for Darnold
2 Allen
2 Mayfield
1 Trade down/none

say Mayfield. He has the drive and will to win. I love his intangibles.

I thought that Darnold would be #1 here by a mile.

Don't want ANYTHING to do with Rosen or Jackson. Meh on Allen.

Really don't want a QB for the GIANTS this year. Let the Bills trade for the #2 slot and get their guy while the G-men get much needed extra picks.

In comment 13871337 Tim in VA said:

Quote:

This is the second BBI poll of this sort. You do realize there are people who don't want any of these? A meaningful poll would be who do you want, also include trade down. But no, continue the idiotic circle jerk of how to most effectively destroy the Giants

Shut up.

Lauletta??

In comment 13871380 OBJRoyal said:

Quote:

Lauletta??

I'm not limiting the choices. Is that one for Lauletta?

9 for Rosen
7.5 for Darnold
2 Allen
3.5 Mayfield
1 Lauletta
1 Trade down/none

Injury history overblown.

Safest QB in the draft. Worst case Keenum, best case Brees.

10 for Rosen
7.5 for Darnold
4.5 Mayfield
2 Allen
1 Lauletta
1 Trade down/none

In comment 13871381 adamg said:

Quote:

In comment 13871380 OBJRoyal said: Quote: I'm Lauletta?? I'm not limiting the choices. Is that one for Lauletta?

Yes, but not at 2. Maybe 34

In comment 13871404 OBJRoyal said:

Quote:

In comment 13871381 adamg said: Quote: In comment 13871380 OBJRoyal said: Quote: I'm Lauletta?? I'm not limiting the choices. Is that one for Lauletta? Yes, but not at 2. Maybe 34

Probably even in the third. I think based on the vote it's clear that that's not a presumed first round selection.

with anew cast. and see what Webb has to offer.

10 for Rosen
7.5 for Darnold
4.5 Mayfield
2 Allen
2 Trade down/none
1 Lauletta

Darnold = too many turnovers
Like Lauretta second.

that should be Lauletta.

trade down/none for me.

11 for Rosen
7.5 for Darnold
4.5 Mayfield
2 Allen
3 Trade down/none
1 Lauletta

Easily.

No to DollHands Darnold.

12 for Rosen
8.5 for Darnold
4.5 Mayfield
3 Trade down/none
2 Allen
1 Lauletta

.

Super accurate and can make extend plays if the oline breaks down

.

Best pure passer, most pro ready.

1.Mayfield
2. Darnold
3. Allen
4. Jackson

14 for Rosen
9.5 for Darnold
6.5 Mayfield
3 Trade down/none
2 Allen
1 Lauletta

Rosen Mafield Darnold Allen

#1

16 for Rosen
9.5 for Darnold
6.5 Mayfield
3 Trade down/none
2 Allen
1 Lauletta

In comment 13871410 adamg said:

Quote:

In comment 13871404 OBJRoyal said: Quote: In comment 13871381 adamg said: Quote: In comment 13871380 OBJRoyal said: Quote: I'm Lauletta?? I'm not limiting the choices. Is that one for Lauletta? Yes, but not at 2. Maybe 34 Probably even in the third. I think based on the vote it's clear that that's not a presumed first round selection.

If you can add Barkley/Nelson + Lauletta, could be good value. Sleeper QB

...

Trust the professionals.

Fun year though!

The Giants pick

16 for Rosen
10.5 for Darnold
6.5 Mayfield
3 Trade down/none
2 Allen
1 Lauletta

Not even close

Best combination of being the 'cleanest' of the QB prospects by far and the high ceiling he possesses.

17 for Rosen
11.5 for Darnold
6.5 Mayfield
3 Trade down/none
2 Allen
1 Lauletta

...

Done deal. That's all

then Mayfield

L.Jackson.

.

18 Rosen
11.5 Darnold
6.5 Mayfield
3 Trade down/none
3 Allen
2 Jackson
1 Lauletta

18 Rosen
12.5 Darnold
6.5 Mayfield
3 Trade down/none
3 Allen
2 Jackson
1 Lauletta

and Giants go Darnold?

In comment 13871373 capegman said:

Quote:

say Mayfield. He has the drive and will to win. I love his intangibles.

+1.
Been saying it for a while.
Will, drive, proven winner.
How much they devaluate the B12 is important.
I think he fits an aggressive O like Shurmur/Shula would scheme; if Clev,NYJ,Denver,Miami don't seem to covet him, and neither does Buffalo, there's the opportunity for a QB @12, OL/CB/DE @22,then the 34 and Buffalo's 2 seconds. IK its diminishing probability to fall that way but if Kiper-McShay-Mayock can usually hit it 1 day, 1hour, 1 minute before the pick.......

Mayfield a very close second, like them almost equally but slightly prefer Rosen because of size.

19 Rosen
12.5 Darnold
7.5 Mayfield
3 Trade down/none
3 Allen
2 Jackson
1 Lauletta

Mayfield is 2 years older than Rosen; 2 1/2 years older than Darnold. The difference between 21 and 23 at the QB position is considerable.

Drafting the short guy who is already at his ceiling is a bad bet. The combine showed that Mayfield is nowhere close to Russell Wilson athletically. There is only one Drew Brees and betting that Mayfield will be another is doubling down on the bad bet.

That would be my choice

In comment 13871711 shyster said:

Quote:

Mayfield is 2 years older than Rosen; 2 1/2 years older than Darnold. The difference between 21 and 23 at the QB position is considerable. Drafting the short guy who is already at his ceiling is a bad bet. The combine showed that Mayfield is nowhere close to Russell Wilson athletically. There is only one Drew Brees and betting that Mayfield will be another is doubling down on the bad bet.

Correction: just say Mayfield is about two years older than both. I was thinking of the Eli comparison.

Get RB/OL in next two rounds.

Rosen. Love him and think he’s going to be a star.

.

.

23 Rosen
12.5 Darnold
8.5 Mayfield
4 Allen
3 Trade down/none
2 Jackson
1 Lauletta

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RUI2Lv_Glc

In comment 13871754 Jimmy Googs said:

Quote:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RUI2Lv_Glc

Why would post that video dude. Ugh. What a buzz kill.

24 Rosen
12.5 Darnold
8.5 Mayfield
4 Allen
3 Trade down/none
2 Jackson
1 Lauletta

In comment 13871758 adamg said:

Quote:

In comment 13871754 Jimmy Googs said: Quote: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RUI2Lv_Glc Why would post that video dude. Ugh. What a buzz kill.

Because that play earned us this #2 pick and what is should be used for...

In comment 13871767 Jimmy Googs said:

Quote:

In comment 13871758 adamg said: Quote: In comment 13871754 Jimmy Googs said: Quote: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1RUI2Lv_Glc Why would post that video dude. Ugh. What a buzz kill. Because that play earned us this #2 pick and what is should be used for...

You're a sick man

1 Darnold
2 Allen
3 Rosen
4 Mayfield

Darnold 2nd choice

.

25 Rosen
14.5 Darnold
8.5 Mayfield
4 Allen
3 Trade down/none
2 Jackson
1 Lauletta

In comment 13871430 BlueinRoch said:

Quote:

trade down/none for me.

Lamar Jackson

I feel this is a trap draft for qb talent. Like the Trent dilfer, Heath shuler year.

I wanted a qb bad but starting to realize these guys may not be amazing at such a high spot.

.

They are average at best. Not worth the second pick.

Kurt Benkert

He could be great with some real coaching.