for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

Trade possibility : Giants/Cleveland/Buffalo

jc in c-ville : 4/18/2018 9:35 am
As we know, its anybody's guess what is going on with front offices throughout the league.

However, if the Giants in fact either have 2 or 3 QB's rated about the same( or not interested in a QB at all with the 2nd pick) and Cleveland does as well regarding QB's as that is where they're going:

Buffalo trades up to # 1 giving up the 12, 22,53,96 + 2019 1st and 2020 2nd ( a haul for sure but that what it would take).

Cleveland then sends the 4, 33, & 104 to the Giants for the second pick.

Grab a Chubb or Nelson and use the 104 to move up for a player that drops late into the second round.
...  
est1986 : 4/18/2018 9:41 am : link
Cleveland needs to send more  
Carl in CT : 4/18/2018 9:43 am : link
To the Giants.
So we move down 2 spots for a  
Kevin in Annapolis : 4/18/2018 9:44 am : link
4th?

I don't see it
CLE isn't giving up the #1 pick with everything that goes with it...  
mphbullet36 : 4/18/2018 9:45 am : link
I could see a 3 team swap where

CLE stays at 1
BUF moves up to 2
Giants move back to 4
CLE moves back to 12 (gets extra draft capital from the bills)

Giants get extra draft capital from moving for #2 to $2 (maybe a couple 2nd rounders or a second rounder and a 3rd rounder).

I think that makes sense for all parties. But no way is CLE moving off #1 IMO
I'll throw this one out there  
Big_Blue_in_the_Bronx : 4/18/2018 9:55 am : link
Listed other possible Giant targets at each draft slot if you feel the guy may be selected beforehand or prefer another player:

TRADE DOWN SCENARIO: 3-WAY TRADE WITH BROWNS AND BILLS + 2nd TRADE WITH DENVER

Cleveland goes from 1 to 2 (3000-2600=400 pts owed)
Cleveland goes from 4 to 12 (1800-1200=600 pts owed)
Cleveland total=1000pts owed

NY goes from 2 to 4 (2600-1800=800pts owed)
NY total=800pts owed

So NY goes to 4 and gets 22 (22=780pts pts) and 2019 3rd pick
And Cleveland goes to 2 and 12 and gets 53+ 56+ 65 ( 370+ 340+265 pts=975 pts) and 2019 1st rd pick

As for why this could work (from George in PA):

Strategic Trade Down while still drafting BPA. Yesterday’s 3-team trade rumor has me intrigued because it is win for all 3 teams. Buffalo seems to be willing to trade away the farm to move up for a QB. The Giants seems to be open to a small trade down (not 12) and The Browns 2 biggest needs are QB and LT. They will get the QB with their 1st pick but their 2nd @ 4 is too early for McGlinchey, possibly the best LT in the draft (or Connor Williams/Kolton Miller), so I understand why moving to 12 is not such a bad idea……and getting a ton of extra picks.



GIANTS GIVE PICK #2
GIANTS GET PICKS #4,22 (3rd round 2019)

GIANTS GIVE PICK #4
GIANTS GET PICKS #5,70,113

ROUND 1 Pick 5
Options: LB Tremaine Edmunds, Quentin Nelson, Saquon Barkley , Minkah Fitzpatrick, Bradley Chubb, Baker Mayfield, Josh Allen
Choice: RB Saquon Barkley- QBs go 1-2-3-4 for the first time in draft history. Giants beneficiary of a double trade down and still get top non-QB in entire draft. Home-run threat in 3 phases: run ,pass and special teams. Giants get highest instant impact player in draft to make another run with Eli

ROUND 1 Pick 22
Options: G ISAIAH WYNN, Conor Williams, Jaire Alexander, Courtland Sutton, Leighton Van Der Esch,Rashaan Evans,Harold Landry(16.5 sacks JR year), Isaiah Oliver CB, LT/RT Kolton Miller, James Daniels, Will Hernandez
Choice: OG ISAIAH Wynn- Not quite the pure mauler Willie is but better all around versatility and can play multiple spots on OL at high level

Round 2 pick 2
Options: Will Hernandez OG, James Daniels,Billy Price, Ronnie Harrison, Ronald Jones, Sony Michel, Isaiah Oliver CB, Justin Reid FS
Choice: Isaiah Oliver CB- one of my favorite CBs in this entire draft. Tremendous smarts,coverage ability, and very long arms. NFL Comp: Nnamdi Asomugha with the Raiders.


Round 3 pick 2
Options:Lorenzo Carter,Kyle Lauletta, Frank Ragnow ,Josh Sweat, Darius leonard
Choice:LB Lorenzo Carter -toolsy LB with size and speed in the Leonard Floyd mold , edge rushing potential as well

ROUND 3 Pick 5
Options: Quentin Meeks,Shaquem Griffen, Leonard Davis, Kellen Ballage, Rashaad Penny, Kemeko Turay
Choice: EDGE Kemeko Turay- Pass rusher oozing with potential. Blocked 3 kicks and had 7.5 sacks (as a freshman!)


ROUND 3 Pick 6
Options: Kyle Lauletta,Quentin Meeks,Shaquem Griffen, Lorenzo Carter, Shaquem Griffin,Oren Burks, Darius Leonard
Choice: QB Kyle Lauletta- Another coach on the field. Senior Bowl MVP. Outside the 1st round Qbs Giants paid most interest to him. insurance behind Webb once Eli retires with some upside.


2019 3rd rd pick
Cleveland 1st only works if  
George from PA : 4/18/2018 9:55 am : link
it is arranged that Buffalo does not take Cleveland's choice.....as an accommodation to save a little money, justify the 2nd QB vs the 1st (Allen vs Darnold).
I'd take the 12th pick  
ghost718 : 4/18/2018 9:58 am : link
Browns can have the rest of the war chest
Giants would coup  
jc in c-ville : 4/18/2018 9:59 am : link
The 33rd which would equal the first two picks in the second round with their 34th.

The 104 allows them to move up late in the second.

I believe it makes great sense for Giants if in fact they have a group of QB's rated equal or in fact not looking there at all in the first round.

With a deep draft, you are dropping two spots to get who you want anyway and potentially 3 second rounder's ( with the trade up using 104) and two 3rd rounder's.

So, we get a QB/RB/DE/G at 4 and use the next 5 picks on the BPA's as it relates to OL, LB,RB,CB,S.

Works for me and the Giants but of course, Cleveland and Buffalo need to play along.
Buffalo would have to be morons to do this...  
the mike : 4/18/2018 10:06 am : link
You only mortgage two drafts if you are certain you are getting Andrew Luck in return.... Not a thing is certain re Allen or Darnold...

One of Mayfield, Rosen or Jackson will likely still be there at #12 and would always be better value than mortgaging their entire future for a slightly better quarterback then they could have at #12...

RE: Cleveland needs to send more  
Jay in Toronto : 4/18/2018 10:12 am : link
In comment 13918591 Carl in CT said:
Quote:
To the Giants.


Lots of assumptions to make this work, but if we were going to take one of the non-QBS at 2 we essentially have nothing to lose. It would be nice to get more -- but that is just icing on the cake.
RE: Cleveland needs to send more  
old man : 4/18/2018 10:37 am : link
In comment 13918591 Carl in CT said:
Quote:
To the Giants.


Absolutely need more out of that deal, especially if Buffalo needs that move to work. They need to get Browns to give up at least the 53(not great but a great piece in a package to move up ).
So putting aside the compensation for a moment  
Mike from Ohio : 4/18/2018 11:24 am : link
because I still don't see why Cleveland would make this trade, who do the Giants take with #4 and #12?

Assume Buffalo, Cleveland and NYJ all go QB so Darnold, Rosen and Mayfield are off the board. The Giants select from Allen (possibly Rosen) or Barkley, and at 12 get someone like Vea?

On first blush, I don't hate the idea of having the #4 and the #12.
RE: So putting aside the compensation for a moment  
Big_Blue_in_the_Bronx : 4/18/2018 11:36 am : link
In comment 13918771 Mike from Ohio said:
Quote:
because I still don't see why Cleveland would make this trade, who do the Giants take with #4 and #12?

Assume Buffalo, Cleveland and NYJ all go QB so Darnold, Rosen and Mayfield are off the board. The Giants select from Allen (possibly Rosen) or Barkley, and at 12 get someone like Vea?

On first blush, I don't hate the idea of having the #4 and the #12.


Don't think Cleveland would go for that. More realistic would be we get the 22nd. But if we somehow got the 12th...

It'd be McGlinchey, Derwin James, Tremaine Edmunds, Marcus Davenport , Roquan Smith, Jaire Alexander, Harold Landry, Vita Vea. Those would be the guys that I could think of that would provide max value at that spot and have at least a shot of being there.
If Buffalo is offering  
NYG27 : 4/18/2018 11:49 am : link
Quote:
Buffalo trades up to # 1 giving up the 12, 22,53,96 + 2019 1st and 2020 2nd ( a haul for sure but that what it would take).


I'd rather get that haul for the Giants 2nd overall pick. Just leave the Browns out of it.

We lose the blue chip this year but are sure to get one next year with Buffalo's 2019 pick possibly being a Top 5 selection.
Make it STOP  
djstat : 4/18/2018 12:27 pm : link
The OP scenario sucks for the Giants.
RE: I'll throw this one out there  
BleedBlue : 4/18/2018 4:12 pm : link
In comment 13918605 Big_Blue_in_the_Bronx said:
Quote:
Listed other possible Giant targets at each draft slot if you feel the guy may be selected beforehand or prefer another player:

TRADE DOWN SCENARIO: 3-WAY TRADE WITH BROWNS AND BILLS + 2nd TRADE WITH DENVER

Cleveland goes from 1 to 2 (3000-2600=400 pts owed)
Cleveland goes from 4 to 12 (1800-1200=600 pts owed)
Cleveland total=1000pts owed

NY goes from 2 to 4 (2600-1800=800pts owed)
NY total=800pts owed

So NY goes to 4 and gets 22 (22=780pts pts) and 2019 3rd pick
And Cleveland goes to 2 and 12 and gets 53+ 56+ 65 ( 370+ 340+265 pts=975 pts) and 2019 1st rd pick

As for why this could work (from George in PA):

Strategic Trade Down while still drafting BPA. Yesterday’s 3-team trade rumor has me intrigued because it is win for all 3 teams. Buffalo seems to be willing to trade away the farm to move up for a QB. The Giants seems to be open to a small trade down (not 12) and The Browns 2 biggest needs are QB and LT. They will get the QB with their 1st pick but their 2nd @ 4 is too early for McGlinchey, possibly the best LT in the draft (or Connor Williams/Kolton Miller), so I understand why moving to 12 is not such a bad idea……and getting a ton of extra picks.



GIANTS GIVE PICK #2
GIANTS GET PICKS #4,22 (3rd round 2019)

GIANTS GIVE PICK #4
GIANTS GET PICKS #5,70,113

ROUND 1 Pick 5
Options: LB Tremaine Edmunds, Quentin Nelson, Saquon Barkley , Minkah Fitzpatrick, Bradley Chubb, Baker Mayfield, Josh Allen
Choice: RB Saquon Barkley- QBs go 1-2-3-4 for the first time in draft history. Giants beneficiary of a double trade down and still get top non-QB in entire draft. Home-run threat in 3 phases: run ,pass and special teams. Giants get highest instant impact player in draft to make another run with Eli

ROUND 1 Pick 22
Options: G ISAIAH WYNN, Conor Williams, Jaire Alexander, Courtland Sutton, Leighton Van Der Esch,Rashaan Evans,Harold Landry(16.5 sacks JR year), Isaiah Oliver CB, LT/RT Kolton Miller, James Daniels, Will Hernandez
Choice: OG ISAIAH Wynn- Not quite the pure mauler Willie is but better all around versatility and can play multiple spots on OL at high level

Round 2 pick 2
Options: Will Hernandez OG, James Daniels,Billy Price, Ronnie Harrison, Ronald Jones, Sony Michel, Isaiah Oliver CB, Justin Reid FS
Choice: Isaiah Oliver CB- one of my favorite CBs in this entire draft. Tremendous smarts,coverage ability, and very long arms. NFL Comp: Nnamdi Asomugha with the Raiders.


Round 3 pick 2
Options:Lorenzo Carter,Kyle Lauletta, Frank Ragnow ,Josh Sweat, Darius leonard
Choice:LB Lorenzo Carter -toolsy LB with size and speed in the Leonard Floyd mold , edge rushing potential as well

ROUND 3 Pick 5
Options: Quentin Meeks,Shaquem Griffen, Leonard Davis, Kellen Ballage, Rashaad Penny, Kemeko Turay
Choice: EDGE Kemeko Turay- Pass rusher oozing with potential. Blocked 3 kicks and had 7.5 sacks (as a freshman!)


ROUND 3 Pick 6
Options: Kyle Lauletta,Quentin Meeks,Shaquem Griffen, Lorenzo Carter, Shaquem Griffin,Oren Burks, Darius Leonard
Choice: QB Kyle Lauletta- Another coach on the field. Senior Bowl MVP. Outside the 1st round Qbs Giants paid most interest to him. insurance behind Webb once Eli retires with some upside.


2019 3rd rd pick


id cream my pants if we got

barkley
wynn
hernandez
carter
turay

yea that 5 right there is AMAZING. lots of moving parts so i doubt it but yea
Back to the Corner