Any QB who is drafted at #2 needs to be starting by week 8.
The Giants can not afford to draft a player who will not get on field for at least
1-1/2 -2 years.
NONE of these QB's have that ability.
I think these QBs have the ability o get on the field. However, i don't think these QBs are further along than Davis Webb. people state that we don't know what we have in D Webb because he hasn't played an NFL game. Well, neither have Allen, Darnold, Rosen, Mayfield, etc.
The only evidence is their college tape, combine and face to face meetings. All of which we have seen from Davis Webb. We also have a better perspective of Webb's work ethic over the past twelve months, which seems pretty good. We also have a reference in Eli manning who would certainly be honest about how Webb studies, learns, etc.
For these reasons, IMO, we will not draft a QB, and stick with D Webb as the future behind Eli.
I think these QBs have the ability o get on the field. However, i don't think these QBs are further along than Davis Webb. people state that we don't know what we have in D Webb because he hasn't played an NFL game. Well, neither have Allen, Darnold, Rosen, Mayfield, etc.
The only evidence is their college tape, combine and face to face meetings. All of which we have seen from Davis Webb. We also have a better perspective of Webb's work ethic over the past twelve months, which seems pretty good. We also have a reference in Eli manning who would certainly be honest about how Webb studies, learns, etc.
For these reasons, IMO, we will not draft a QB, and stick with D Webb as the future behind Eli.
hmmm. let's see ... the top 3 qbs in this draft will likely go 1-2-3.. Davis Webb went late in the 3rd round and couldn't sniff practice time on a 3-13 team.. I think we can safely say 3 or 4 of these guys are ahead of Davis Webb until further notice.
We can’t draft a QB at 2 because they won’t play immediately
We can’t draft a RB at 2 because RBs are a dime a dozen
We can’t draft Chubb at 2 because he doesn’t fit the system and isn’t elite at any one thing
We can’t draft Nelson at 2 because you don’t draft guards at 2 and this draft is loaded with interior linemen
So basically, unless the Giants trade down and refuse to pick anyone at 2, they will get killed by the intelligent masses. Lovely.
WHAT?! Trade DOWN?! But don't you realize we will never be drafting this high again? Drafting down is stupid because now you're not going to get a blue chip player!
- also BBI
I kid...Obviously, 'BBI' refers to a lot of different opinions by a lot of different people only united by their rabid fandom of the NY Giants.
I think these QBs have the ability o get on the field. However, i don't think these QBs are further along than Davis Webb. people state that we don't know what we have in D Webb because he hasn't played an NFL game. Well, neither have Allen, Darnold, Rosen, Mayfield, etc.
The only evidence is their college tape, combine and face to face meetings. All of which we have seen from Davis Webb. We also have a better perspective of Webb's work ethic over the past twelve months, which seems pretty good. We also have a reference in Eli manning who would certainly be honest about how Webb studies, learns, etc.
For these reasons, IMO, we will not draft a QB, and stick with D Webb as the future behind Eli.
hmmm. let's see ... the top 3 qbs in this draft will likely go 1-2-3.. Davis Webb went late in the 3rd round and couldn't sniff practice time on a 3-13 team.. I think we can safely say 3 or 4 of these guys are ahead of Davis Webb until further notice.
What are you talking about with "couldn't sniff practice time on a 3 - 13 team? He practiced all last year. All I am saying is that this staff will have a much better idea of DWebs skills compared to the others after next week's camp. It's his showcase.
I think these QBs have the ability o get on the field. However, i don't think these QBs are further along than Davis Webb. people state that we don't know what we have in D Webb because he hasn't played an NFL game. Well, neither have Allen, Darnold, Rosen, Mayfield, etc.
The only evidence is their college tape, combine and face to face meetings. All of which we have seen from Davis Webb. We also have a better perspective of Webb's work ethic over the past twelve months, which seems pretty good. We also have a reference in Eli manning who would certainly be honest about how Webb studies, learns, etc.
For these reasons, IMO, we will not draft a QB, and stick with D Webb as the future behind Eli.
I would love for this to be the case. Webb was very good at recognizing single coverage on the edge and threw a ton of "9's."
While he threw some great balls and ofter threw his WRs open, the spread doesn't give us much of a glimpse into how quickly he can survey/break down what's in front of him and deliver against a defense in the NFL.
Why would you draft a QB at #2 who will not play for 2 years?
The height of stupidity.
Too many holes to fill. BTW the Giants will be drafting in top 1/3 of draft next year.
Stockpile players for 2020 - ??
I'm the L-A-M the A and the R, I'm the man on the mic that they call Lamar! - ( New Window )
none of these qbs can get on the field in a year and a half?
Rosen, Darnold and Mayfield can all start within a year. Allen maybe a year and a half.
I actually laughed out loud.
The only evidence is their college tape, combine and face to face meetings. All of which we have seen from Davis Webb. We also have a better perspective of Webb's work ethic over the past twelve months, which seems pretty good. We also have a reference in Eli manning who would certainly be honest about how Webb studies, learns, etc.
For these reasons, IMO, we will not draft a QB, and stick with D Webb as the future behind Eli.
Hopefully Rosen or Mayfield.
The only evidence is their college tape, combine and face to face meetings. All of which we have seen from Davis Webb. We also have a better perspective of Webb's work ethic over the past twelve months, which seems pretty good. We also have a reference in Eli manning who would certainly be honest about how Webb studies, learns, etc.
For these reasons, IMO, we will not draft a QB, and stick with D Webb as the future behind Eli.
hmmm. let's see ... the top 3 qbs in this draft will likely go 1-2-3.. Davis Webb went late in the 3rd round and couldn't sniff practice time on a 3-13 team.. I think we can safely say 3 or 4 of these guys are ahead of Davis Webb until further notice.
none of these qbs can get on the field in a year and a half?
Rosen, Darnold and Mayfield can all start within a year. Allen maybe a year and a half.
None of these QB's , if drafted by Giants will get on field for at least 1-1/2 - 2 years.
We can’t draft a QB at 2 because they won’t play immediately
We can’t draft a RB at 2 because RBs are a dime a dozen
We can’t draft Chubb at 2 because he doesn’t fit the system and isn’t elite at any one thing
We can’t draft Nelson at 2 because you don’t draft guards at 2 and this draft is loaded with interior linemen
So basically, unless the Giants trade down and refuse to pick anyone at 2, they will get killed by the intelligent masses. Lovely.
We can’t draft a QB at 2 because they won’t play immediately
We can’t draft a RB at 2 because RBs are a dime a dozen
We can’t draft Chubb at 2 because he doesn’t fit the system and isn’t elite at any one thing
We can’t draft Nelson at 2 because you don’t draft guards at 2 and this draft is loaded with interior linemen
So basically, unless the Giants trade down and refuse to pick anyone at 2, they will get killed by the intelligent masses. Lovely.
Yep, I think you've got it.
We can’t draft a QB at 2 because they won’t play immediately
We can’t draft a RB at 2 because RBs are a dime a dozen
We can’t draft Chubb at 2 because he doesn’t fit the system and isn’t elite at any one thing
We can’t draft Nelson at 2 because you don’t draft guards at 2 and this draft is loaded with interior linemen
So basically, unless the Giants trade down and refuse to pick anyone at 2, they will get killed by the intelligent masses. Lovely.
WHAT?! Trade DOWN?! But don't you realize we will never be drafting this high again? Drafting down is stupid because now you're not going to get a blue chip player!
- also BBI
I kid...Obviously, 'BBI' refers to a lot of different opinions by a lot of different people only united by their rabid fandom of the NY Giants.
;)
Don't we already have the saints first pick
Quote:
I think these QBs have the ability o get on the field. However, i don't think these QBs are further along than Davis Webb. people state that we don't know what we have in D Webb because he hasn't played an NFL game. Well, neither have Allen, Darnold, Rosen, Mayfield, etc.
The only evidence is their college tape, combine and face to face meetings. All of which we have seen from Davis Webb. We also have a better perspective of Webb's work ethic over the past twelve months, which seems pretty good. We also have a reference in Eli manning who would certainly be honest about how Webb studies, learns, etc.
For these reasons, IMO, we will not draft a QB, and stick with D Webb as the future behind Eli.
hmmm. let's see ... the top 3 qbs in this draft will likely go 1-2-3.. Davis Webb went late in the 3rd round and couldn't sniff practice time on a 3-13 team.. I think we can safely say 3 or 4 of these guys are ahead of Davis Webb until further notice.
What are you talking about with "couldn't sniff practice time on a 3 - 13 team? He practiced all last year. All I am saying is that this staff will have a much better idea of DWebs skills compared to the others after next week's camp. It's his showcase.
The only evidence is their college tape, combine and face to face meetings. All of which we have seen from Davis Webb. We also have a better perspective of Webb's work ethic over the past twelve months, which seems pretty good. We also have a reference in Eli manning who would certainly be honest about how Webb studies, learns, etc.
For these reasons, IMO, we will not draft a QB, and stick with D Webb as the future behind Eli.
I would love for this to be the case. Webb was very good at recognizing single coverage on the edge and threw a ton of "9's."
While he threw some great balls and ofter threw his WRs open, the spread doesn't give us much of a glimpse into how quickly he can survey/break down what's in front of him and deliver against a defense in the NFL.
Hopefully Rosen or Mayfield.
Why would you draft a QB at #2 who will not play for 2 years?
The height of stupidity.
Too many holes to fill. BTW the Giants will be drafting in top 1/3 of draft next year.
Stockpile players for 2020 - ??
Quote:
Saints trade up to take a QB at #2? What would they have to give up... at least a first next year and a lot more.
Don't we already have the saints first pick
Crap you are right... So like a Saints first rounder every year for life.