Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner
 

Archived Thread

Just for discussion

rich in DC : 4/21/2018 2:35 pm
No inside info here, just asking what if.

Earlier in the week, there were wild rumors of a 3-way deal involving the Browns, Bills and Giants. Now, we have other insider rumors indicating that the Browns and Giants have at least talked about moving the #2 pick for the #4 plus other picks.

Suppose the 3-way rumors were not really of a 3-way deal, but a 2-step trade by the Giants. Step one is to deal #2 for #4 and other picks. What is step 2 is to deal the #4 pick to the Bills for #12, #22, and other picks?

What would the reaction be if after all was said and done, the Giants ended up with 2 1st rounders, somewhere between 4-5 second rounders, around 3-4 3rd rounders and other picks?

Again, no insider information- just asking for reaction.
Happy With This But  
Samiam : 4/21/2018 2:50 pm : link
What insider rumors are you talked about except somebody creating them here or other team boards or media creations?
It  
thomasa510 : 4/21/2018 2:51 pm : link
For this to be true, Gettleman would have tomorrow be impressed by the quarterbacks, have the browns be infatuated with Barkley, and have the bills desperate for a qb.

If the giants trade down twice in round one there would be such a ridiculous number of elite picks to build your team with.

I would focus on a two year rebuild and try to conver some of the later picks in return to 1st year picks in next years draft.
Can't pass up a 3-way  
Jimmy Googs : 4/21/2018 2:58 pm : link
ever...
Interesting quote by Gettleman  
sharpshooter66 : 4/21/2018 3:04 pm : link
"Sometimes you have to look at it this way and I'm not saying this is the way I always look at it, but sometimes you have to look at it this way," Gettleman said. "We're all in school, do I want to get an A and four C's or do we want an A-minuses, a couple of B-plusses, and a couple of B's? Winning requires depth. If you don't have depth - I've seen teams that had great defenses that folded in the fourth quarter because they had no depth, and now you've got guys on the field for 95-98 percent playing time. You can't win that way, guys wear down. So there is obviously different ways of looking at it depending upon what the A looks like. But if you get a chance to accumulate quality, you put yourself in a position to potentially accumulate picks, and have a lot of very solid players. There is nothing wrong with that."

I wouldnt write off anything, but wouldnt expect a move until the Giants are on the clock
It goes without saying, everyone loves the extra premium picks  
George from PA : 4/21/2018 3:07 pm : link
But I sense, most here wants at least one blue chipper.

So if we do end up trading down once, twice, hell three times........a trade back up ( with some of the extra picks) to get a Nelson.....would be general consensus.

I suspect, the QB is must crowd, would want some ammo next year to use for the all elusive future franchise be QB.

If he comes away with an A and 4 Cs hes failed  
Rudy5757 : 4/21/2018 5:43 pm : link
whether he trades or not he should get at least an A and a B in rounds 1 and 2 at the very least. He should get an A and an A- staying put. I doubt they trade down to 12. The premium picks seem to be around 7-8 and if you factor in 2 or 3 QBs I think you will be left out at 12. If they trade to 4 they are staying put.

Factor in that DG has never traded down in the 1st round, he is not going to do it twice.
Trading down only makes sense..  
Sean : 4/21/2018 6:01 pm : link
IF the Browns draft Darnold & NYG has a close enough grade with Chubb/Nelson in comparison to Barkley. Im assuming theyd draft Darnold if available. And all this assumes there is another willing party (CLE/DEN) which I doubt.
Back to the Corner