for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

NFT: Intermittent Fasting - No Carbs?

giantsfan44ab : 5/14/2018 9:59 am
In years past, I usually have been successful in dropping ~10 pounds when Spring/Summer roll around. This year, i signed up for the NYC bike tour that was last weekend and I thought I would have no trouble getting to the lowest body fat levels in my life. I've been doing hour long cycling sessions or a few hours of pickup basketball 5-6 times a week for the past few months. I lost about 5 pounds quickly, and then sure enough I put it right back and then some. I've been fairly good about not drinking alcohol and cutting out sweets, but clearly somethings not working.

Gonna try intermittent fasting for a bit. Does this alone help without cutting carbs? Been following a lot of Joe rogan nutrition advice lately and so now everytime I eat some type of carb I feel like im ruining any progress. Today is my first day skipping breakfast (not that I usually eat much, just like an egg sandwich). I usually stay within my caloric limits too, I usually don't exceed 2500 calories on top of doing cardio (im about 6'3, 200 pounds on a good day). Wanna get to about 185 without just outright burning off muscle. Planning on resuming weightlifting after a good 3-4 months off to combat this.

Any suggestions on how to approach this diet or if my thinking is wrong? Should I go no carbs or maybe start limiting them (just stick to fruits for carbs)?
Pages: 1 2 <<Prev | Show All |
RE: RE: RE: RE: Appreciate the advice all  
BigBlue4You09 : 5/14/2018 2:26 pm : link
In comment 13963315 DennyInDenville said:
Quote:
In comment 13963209 giantsfan44ab said:


Quote:


In comment 13963202 BigBlue4You09 said:


Quote:


In comment 13963180 giantsfan44ab said:


Quote:


really look forward to this first meal today lol.



What's on the menu?



Have to pickup lunch today so im thinking a salad from Qdoba (no beans of course). Couldn't really prep due to Mothers Day yesterday.


Nah man, beans are the best and healthiest part. Whatever carbs beans have ignore, the fiber over rules it

One rule of thumb for IF or Keto , etc...

If it's a fruit or a vegetable, the carbs and calories don't count . (In moderation of course)


Absolutely DO NOT ignore them, you look at the net amount. And completely false about fruits and vegetables as well
Thanks for the correction  
DennyInDenville : 5/14/2018 2:28 pm : link
My doctor actually gave me that advice , I just wanted to believe it was true
He's a big south beach diet guy too  
DennyInDenville : 5/14/2018 2:31 pm : link
Which is similar to keto and IF a little bit


I've been doing IF for a month now. Lost about 7 pounds , but literally have ate garbage food and haven't done too much to improve my diet yet besides no fast food , less sugars and IF 16/8 7 days a week

I know if I just exercise and cut down the carbs 50% I'll melt off about 20 pounds of fat with ease in 8-10 weeks, just hoping to also gain some lean muscle and not lose my current muscle
Fruit has a lot of sugars  
nygiants16 : 5/14/2018 2:51 pm : link
You never can eat a ton of fruit...

With veggies the rule is if you are still hungry eat a little more veg, but you can never eat as much as you want...

You eat to much of anything and it becomes bad...

Almonds for example are a great healthy snack, but only a handful, usually 20 to 25 is the healthy amount you start eating more and then it becomes bad
RE: Fruit has a lot of sugars  
giantsfan44ab : 5/14/2018 3:06 pm : link
In comment 13963444 nygiants16 said:
Quote:
You never can eat a ton of fruit...

With veggies the rule is if you are still hungry eat a little more veg, but you can never eat as much as you want...

You eat to much of anything and it becomes bad...

Almonds for example are a great healthy snack, but only a handful, usually 20 to 25 is the healthy amount you start eating more and then it becomes bad


I just started using My Fitness Pal again to track this and with low/no carbs im actually struggling to even come close to my goal of 2,600 calories (goal is set to lose 1 pound a week). So to get in the ball park I'd have to increase the amount of snacks like cashews in order to even get close.
RE: RE: Fruit has a lot of sugars  
nygiants16 : 5/14/2018 3:24 pm : link
In comment 13963460 giantsfan44ab said:
Quote:
In comment 13963444 nygiants16 said:


Quote:


You never can eat a ton of fruit...

With veggies the rule is if you are still hungry eat a little more veg, but you can never eat as much as you want...

You eat to much of anything and it becomes bad...

Almonds for example are a great healthy snack, but only a handful, usually 20 to 25 is the healthy amount you start eating more and then it becomes bad



I just started using My Fitness Pal again to track this and with low/no carbs im actually struggling to even come close to my goal of 2,600 calories (goal is set to lose 1 pound a week). So to get in the ball park I'd have to increase the amount of snacks like cashews in order to even get close.


You are under 2600?
Yup  
giantsfan44ab : 5/14/2018 3:29 pm : link
I put in everything I was gonna eat today in already and it’s coming out to 1800. Not including working out. I accounted for a double scoop of protein, an apple before working out, two servings of cashews, yogurt, and my dinner too.
RE: Yup  
nygiants16 : 5/14/2018 3:40 pm : link
In comment 13963481 giantsfan44ab said:
Quote:
I put in everything I was gonna eat today in already and it’s coming out to 1800. Not including working out. I accounted for a double scoop of protein, an apple before working out, two servings of cashews, yogurt, and my dinner too.


I mean if you can get through a day with working out and not feel jittery or starving more power to you but I think once you workout you are going to feel weak and tired...

The reason to diet and workout is to feel good and not lose too much muscle while you cut....

That is why I dont like fasting more than 10 days like a cleanse, I feel it gets to a poi t where you are not eating enough and your body adjusts for that...
RE: RE: And as for coffee  
Klaatu : 5/14/2018 3:45 pm : link
In comment 13962887 antdog24 said:
Quote:
In comment 13962876 giantsfan44ab said:


Quote:


I enjoy my cup of coffee with a little cream/sugar in the mornings, does this "kill" the fast?


yes, adds carbs, especially sugar. Gotta go black.


Do you ever go back?
RE: RE: Yup  
giantsfan44ab : 5/14/2018 3:50 pm : link
In comment 13963492 nygiants16 said:
Quote:
In comment 13963481 giantsfan44ab said:


Quote:


I put in everything I was gonna eat today in already and it’s coming out to 1800. Not including working out. I accounted for a double scoop of protein, an apple before working out, two servings of cashews, yogurt, and my dinner too.



I mean if you can get through a day with working out and not feel jittery or starving more power to you but I think once you workout you are going to feel weak and tired...

The reason to diet and workout is to feel good and not lose too much muscle while you cut....

That is why I dont like fasting more than 10 days like a cleanse, I feel it gets to a poi t where you are not eating enough and your body adjusts for that...


This is my worry too. Lots of my protein intake came from carb sources like bread so I have to increase protein in other ways. Breakfast usually was a solid 30g's of protein normally and that's eliminated for the time being while I try IF. Cooking chicken breast is def the way to go to get it though.
To me fasting is great when you need to lose 5 pounds  
nygiants16 : 5/14/2018 3:50 pm : link
Before you go on vacation or you have some stubborn fat and you want to jumpstart your diet again...

It is not something you can sustain for a long period of time because once you eat a carb you blow it out of the water that is not something you can do for the rest of your life
I have never subscribed to these fasting  
chopperhatch : 5/14/2018 4:06 pm : link
Things. Ive never understood it. I went through a period this year where I gained a bunch of weight. The reasoning was total neglect of nutrition. I was also drinking quite a bit and not working out.

But I dont see the need to FAST to get back down. Ive been prepping food for the week, eating the little carbs that I do at the beginning of the day and loading up on protein and veg. Now I am eating 5 times a day (two meals being protein shakes with almond milk and either peanut butter or frozen berries) and I am making them lean. I have a shake as soon as I wake up in the morning to start my metabolism and I am off.

The idea of shedding lbs= health/being in shape is a canard. Do it the hard way: Eat right, eat often, work out hard for and hour or two 3-5 times a week and limit drinking to a day or two. Watch how easy it is to drop 15-20 lbs and then add another 5-10 of muscle in a few months. Its all what you put into it.
RE: I have never subscribed to these fasting  
giantsfan44ab : 5/14/2018 4:43 pm : link
In comment 13963515 chopperhatch said:
Quote:
Things. Ive never understood it. I went through a period this year where I gained a bunch of weight. The reasoning was total neglect of nutrition. I was also drinking quite a bit and not working out.

But I dont see the need to FAST to get back down. Ive been prepping food for the week, eating the little carbs that I do at the beginning of the day and loading up on protein and veg. Now I am eating 5 times a day (two meals being protein shakes with almond milk and either peanut butter or frozen berries) and I am making them lean. I have a shake as soon as I wake up in the morning to start my metabolism and I am off.

The idea of shedding lbs= health/being in shape is a canard. Do it the hard way: Eat right, eat often, work out hard for and hour or two 3-5 times a week and limit drinking to a day or two. Watch how easy it is to drop 15-20 lbs and then add another 5-10 of muscle in a few months. Its all what you put into it.


I don't think I *need* to fast to lose weight. I've just had massive weight fluctuations for better and worse since high school. I entered college at 125 pounds and I was 6'2. Not an inch of fat or muscle on my body. Gained 15 pounds in my first month in college. Starting working out (and eating tons of garbage food) and got to about 180-190. Probably as much fat as muscle. I'd routinely order pies of pizza for myself, delivery cookies, etc. Then I hurt my leg playing basketball, had surgery and couldn't weight lift for a few months. I took up swimming and got down 25 pounds. Since college I've been on and off weightlifting but staying active by biking or playing pickup basketball. I was never overweight but I am seeking consistency. I'll eat at all times of the day, even though I can be good about limiting sweets and booze I end up replacing it by just eating more.

I wanna try fasting just to limit myself. If I have a self imposed window there's only so much damage I can do. And I wanna try limiting carbs not just for weight but trying to get my body adjusted to getting energy from better sources and have heard good experiences from people able to do so. I have heard even better things from people who have been able to cut out caffeine and meat but of the 3 I think I can take on carbs the easiest.
RE: To me fasting is great when you need to lose 5 pounds  
Giants in 07 : 5/14/2018 4:54 pm : link
In comment 13963502 nygiants16 said:
Quote:
Before you go on vacation or you have some stubborn fat and you want to jumpstart your diet again...

It is not something you can sustain for a long period of time because once you eat a carb you blow it out of the water that is not something you can do for the rest of your life


This has not been my experience

I eat carbs all the time and I've been doing IF for over a year. Like I said, only recently have a cut carbs because I plateaued.

Everybody is different though, obviously. But the general rule of IF is that you do not need to be restrictive in what you eat.
Chopper  
Giants in 07 : 5/14/2018 4:57 pm : link
More recent studies has shown that eating more little meals throughout the day does little to nothing to a person's metabolism. Not saying it won't work for you, but that's widely been debunked in recent years.

You are right everyone is different  
nygiants16 : 5/14/2018 5:06 pm : link
For someone who has tried both I have never felt better eating 5 small meals a day and working out hard as I can...

When I do a fast I feel like ahit and I never feel like I ate enough, just did not feel good on it...

If you plan on working out hard I would not fast
..  
charlito : 5/14/2018 6:38 pm : link
Video about carb cutting
Link - ( New Window )
Casein is a slow digesting protein  
UESBLUE : 5/14/2018 7:08 pm : link
best used as a shake before bed - not for right after a workout (whey). ALso zIg zagging your carbs can be an effective strategy for weight loss, especially when you hit a plateau.
and for carb sources  
UESBLUE : 5/14/2018 7:14 pm : link
avoid fruits, especially tropical fruits. Very high in fructose (sugars). Choose slower digesting carbs like brown rice and sweet potatoes.
RE: Chopper  
chopperhatch : 5/14/2018 8:22 pm : link
In comment 13963550 Giants in 07 said:
Quote:
More recent studies has shown that eating more little meals throughout the day does little to nothing to a person's metabolism. Not saying it won't work for you, but that's widely been debunked in recent years.


No, that's not what I was saying. Eating right when you get out of bed spikes your metabolism...gets it going. Eating smaller, more frequent meals over the course of the day keeps you full and makes you feel more satiated. it also doesn't overload your digestive system and put things to waste.
RE: and for carb sources  
chopperhatch : 5/14/2018 8:24 pm : link
In comment 13963635 UESBLUE said:
Quote:
avoid fruits, especially tropical fruits. Very high in fructose (sugars). Choose slower digesting carbs like brown rice and sweet potatoes.


I eat brown rice and eggs for breakfast before a work out. I eat a half a microwaved sweet potato post work out. Blueberries are fine. Apples are fine. Melon...

Truth is, you really are not maximizing yourworkout if you are ommitting ALL carbs
RE: RE: and for carb sources  
nygiants16 : 5/14/2018 9:00 pm : link
In comment 13963722 chopperhatch said:
Quote:
In comment 13963635 UESBLUE said:


Quote:


avoid fruits, especially tropical fruits. Very high in fructose (sugars). Choose slower digesting carbs like brown rice and sweet potatoes.



I eat brown rice and eggs for breakfast before a work out. I eat a half a microwaved sweet potato post work out. Blueberries are fine. Apples are fine. Melon...

Truth is, you really are not maximizing yourworkout if you are ommitting ALL carbs


Yup, people think you cant eat carbs, not true, you just have to eat the right carbs and in the correct portions...

Example for dinner, I had Turkey burger with a cup of whole wheat pasta and tomatoes and cucumbers
RE: RE: RE: and for carb sources  
chopperhatch : 5/14/2018 9:53 pm : link
In comment 13963751 nygiants16 said:
Quote:
In comment 13963722 chopperhatch said:


Quote:


In comment 13963635 UESBLUE said:


Quote:


avoid fruits, especially tropical fruits. Very high in fructose (sugars). Choose slower digesting carbs like brown rice and sweet potatoes.



I eat brown rice and eggs for breakfast before a work out. I eat a half a microwaved sweet potato post work out. Blueberries are fine. Apples are fine. Melon...

Truth is, you really are not maximizing yourworkout if you are ommitting ALL carbs



Yup, people think you cant eat carbs, not true, you just have to eat the right carbs and in the correct portions...

Example for dinner, I had Turkey burger with a cup of whole wheat pasta and tomatoes and cucumbers


With grilled stuff, I make a quinoa with red peppers (a little jalapeño if you like spicy), corn, cold black beans, cilantro and lime zest. I dress it with just red wine vinegar, evoo and salt and pepper. If you want it a littke heartier, add two crescents of avocado. Its awesome.
For salads I used to hate balsamic  
nygiants16 : 5/14/2018 10:43 pm : link
My wife makes a balsamic and I can drink it...

Half cup extra virgin olive oil, bartoli brand the best..


1/3 cup balsamic...

Half tablespoon of minced garlic

Half tablespoon of dijon
Pages: 1 2 <<Prev | Show All |
Back to the Corner