SB never hyped himself or placed his talents on a pedestal as far as I can tell. Confident? of course, all great players are (and not so great players). He goes out and does his job super well by all (most) accounts. He is NOT THE ONE who is hyping himself, it’s the media and fans. He seems to have his head on his shoulders and seems to be extremely focused.
So expectations, etc., for this guy is again, media and fan created. Given he probably has received incredible accolades since pee-wee football, I strongly doubt he’ll give two shitz about what is poured upon him, imo
Saying you refuse to believe is not so much direct as it is being obtuse, but carry on.
Did you even read what I wrote? I said Fitz and James are great prospects and just as good at their positions as SB is at his. I'm not sure why that would fall under obtuse.
Now, I know that doesn't fit the narrative that comes out of Jints Central or the mainstream sports media - sources that you and most buy as the truth - but I think it's very defensible.
Sure, it's the media and the fans....and Dave Gettleman Â
Saying you refuse to believe is not so much direct as it is being obtuse, but carry on.
Did you even read what I wrote? I said Fitz and James are great prospects and just as good at their positions as SB is at his. I'm not sure why that would fall under obtuse.
Now, I know that doesn't fit the narrative that comes out of Jints Central or the mainstream sports media - sources that you and most buy as the truth - but I think it's very defensible.
So let me get this straight. You have been pounding your fist on the table since the draft because you don’t take a RB with the 2nd pick. Because that’s what you’ve been conditioned to believe. Yet, you’re perfectly fine taking a safety at 2, even though almost no one on the planet ranks those guys as better prospects than Barkley? But you randomly say they are, so it must be true or everyone else is just bowing to the media. Got it.
So let me get this straight. You have been pounding your fist on the table since the draft because you don’t take a RB with the 2nd pick. Because that’s what you’ve been conditioned to believe. Yet, you’re perfectly fine taking a safety at 2, even though almost no one on the planet ranks those guys as better prospects than Barkley? But you randomly say they are, so it must be true or everyone else is just bowing to the media. Got it.
Nice try. "Conditioned to believe..." - now that's a good one. By whom?
I never said take a S. I said those players were just as good at their position as SB.
I didn't write anything complicated to give you any indication that that was what I was saying. Pretty simple stuff - subject, verb, direct object.
In other words, you are completely making up your narrative for whatever reason...
RE: RE: He was the best player in the draft, period Â
If you look at it that way, what you're saying is don't draft a guy unless he's can't miss, and there's no such thing as can't miss. We have years of documented proof that "can't miss" drafted players miss all the time. Fans play the hindsight game all the time in the draft, but many players that went high and failed were sold as can't miss at the time.
I’m not saying that at all. I’m saying you take the best player available and you shouldn’t reach for a need.
And I don’t see how SB busts unless he is injured. He’s just that good of a player.
Did you even read what I wrote? I said Fitz and James are great prospects and just as good at their positions as SB is at his. I'm not sure why that would fall under obtuse.
We can find several sources that have Barkley as one of the highest rated RB's EVER. Several saying he's a generational player and likely the best player in the draft.
How exactly would that translate to two guys being just as good at their positions?
By the way, does the incompetent Jints Central even have control over Brandt and the mainstream media?
Really tough to keep positioning Jints central as equal parts clueless and manipulative, but you keep trying.
We can find several sources that have Barkley as one of the highest rated RB's EVER. Several saying he's a generational player and likely the best player in the draft.
How exactly would that translate to two guys being just as good at their positions?
It's just opinion. It's not like I said a P, K, or LS were in Barkley's football class. So I disagree with the conventional wisdom on SB. Great college player, yes, but I think the projections for him are too big - like so many other generational types from the past.
James and Fitzpatrick are outstanding players. I'm not making some wild-ass stretch here. These guys could be instant pro bowl players. But that would require that you watch them play.
Fitzpatrick played all 4 DB positions for Saban and he played monster. There is nothing he can't do as a DB. Saban calls him one of the best defenders he's ever had. Good enough for me from a defensive mastermind who isn't quick to dole out such high praise.
Do you even know who James is? Have you seen him play? If you aren't impressed by his play and measurables than I don't know what to tell you about what a great prospect looks like. He will be a great NFL safety - and instantly. San Diego got the steal of the draft for a position that needed.
RE: Sure, it's the media and the fans....and Dave Gettleman Â
DG made one hyperbolic comment. The media and fans have been incessant. DG’s other comments about SB have all been in response to reporters’ questions..
RE: RE: Sure, it's the media and the fans....and Dave Gettleman Â
DG made one hyperbolic comment. The media and fans have been incessant. DG’s other comments about SB have all been in response to reporters’ questions..
He's made more than one. But this one was outrageous; and frankly it made him look stupid.
I think he's got more pressure than Barkley. Because if Barkley isn't the second coming of Brown/Sanders/Walter/etc this is going to be a helluva albatross to deal with...
If he doesn’t turn into one of the top three greatest running backs of all time? FFS man. This place has lost its damned mind. Again, you’re just looking for reasons to be outraged because you didn’t like the pick.
Top 3 RB in the history of the sport or it’s an epic failure. Jeezus
If he doesn’t turn into one of the top three greatest running backs of all time? FFS man. This place has lost its damned mind. Again, you’re just looking for reasons to be outraged because you didn’t like the pick.
Top 3 RB in the history of the sport or it’s an epic failure. Jeezus
Whatever.
I'm really not outraged. I'm making an argument. You're applying whatever tone of voice you want to hear.
If you can't recognize Gettleman has bet a lot on Barkley you don't know how football works.
He's the 4th highest paid RB in the NFL day one. Sam Darnold for reference is the 28th highest paid QB.
He's the highest selected running back in some time. He's going to a team with an iconic vet QB looking for his last stand.
When Gettleman virtually says he's perfect in his post-draft comments, that's a pretty decent bet.
Read the posts on this and other threads on what fans expect his numbers to be.
Are you addressing me?
Howdy buddy! Nope, just the general "you," which is always dangerous.
My (very small) fear is if Barkley isn't good out of the gate, he's going to get crushed. Crushed in the media, the fans, social media etc.
I like Gettleman, but his post-draft comments felt self-indulgent for my taste. I don't want the kid to be feel like a failure if he doesn't succeed right away. I think the team is as bad as it showed last year and I am not banking on anyone showing much for a while. And I don't want that to mess with Barkley's head.
Why does everyone keep bringing up he’s the 4 th Â
Highest paid rb? When the position basically gets paid peanuts. In the next few years when backs like gurley Elliot and fournette get their new deals the price will skyrocket. The problem will be when Barkley is up for his second contract the market will be set pretty high.
On a side note Brandt had Hernandez as his 15th best player this year. I’m really looking forward to see him play
If you can't recognize Gettleman has bet a lot on Barkley you don't know how football works.
He's the 4th highest paid RB in the NFL day one. Sam Darnold for reference is the 28th highest paid QB.
He's the highest selected running back in some time. He's going to a team with an iconic vet QB looking for his last stand.
When Gettleman virtually says he's perfect in his post-draft comments, that's a pretty decent bet.
Read the posts on this and other threads on what fans expect his numbers to be.
Are you addressing me?
Howdy buddy! Nope, just the general "you," which is always dangerous.
My (very small) fear is if Barkley isn't good out of the gate, he's going to get crushed. Crushed in the media, the fans, social media etc.
I like Gettleman, but his post-draft comments felt self-indulgent for my taste. I don't want the kid to be feel like a failure if he doesn't succeed right away. I think the team is as bad as it showed last year and I am not banking on anyone showing much for a while. And I don't want that to mess with Barkley's head.
I thin SB is mentally strong and can handle it just fine if he has a slow start. Also I think we are much better than they showed last year before the additions. I think the biggest issue was coaching/leadership. I think the players saw through all the bs and that’s when the trouble began. Where I think we will be in trouble this year is with depth thanks to several years of piss poor drafts
Fitzpatrick played all 4 DB positions for Saban and he played monster. There is nothing he can't do as a DB. Saban calls him one of the best defenders he's ever had. Good enough for me from a defensive mastermind who isn't quick to dole out such high praise.
Do you even know who James is? Have you seen him play? If you aren't impressed by his play and measurables than I don't know what to tell you about what a great prospect looks like. He will be a great NFL safety - and instantly. San Diego got the steal of the draft for a position that needed.
It seems that you are intentionally being obtuse to not see the difference between two very good players and one that MANY people have said is generational and the majority of whom has said was the best player in the draft.
I happen to think Chubb is a great player too. That doesn't mean that somehow devalues Barkley.
But again - the underlying issue is if you don't try to make these preposterous parallels then you can't throw shade on "Jints Central", and that's the bottom line you keep trying to gloss over.
It seems that you are intentionally being obtuse to not see the difference between two very good players and one that MANY people have said is generational and the majority of whom has said was the best player in the draft.
It was a serious question, actually. You are the same guy who thought Mariotta played for U of Hawaii. So I'm not assuming anything.
RE: Why does everyone keep bringing up he’s the 4 th Â
Highest paid rb? When the position basically gets paid peanuts.
That's really more a function of the league moving away from paying runningbacks specifically to drive down salaries. The average runningback gets peanuts. Players like Leveon Bell, Adrian Peterson, and eventually Elliott will easily be 12-14m cap hits.
I still have no idea why we decided to make J. Stewart the fifth-largest salary cap burden in football.
Dave felt the same way Sayres was he guy that came to mind in Barkley Â
The guy that comes to my mind
Dave on the UWS : 5/24/2018 8:12 pm : link : reply
about Barkley's running style is Gail Sayers. Go back and look at old tapes of Sayers, he too wasn't a small guy, but ran like a scat back. SB is potentially one of the best pass receiving backs ever. He's very natural at it and you can bet he will be majorly featured by Shurmur. He an Odell will make each other even more dangerous.
It reminds me of a guy hooked to a joy stick when he gets in the open field he makes subtle moves that you almost don't pick them up and niether do the defenders the next thing you know he is by you ..
Saying you refuse to believe is not so much direct as it is being obtuse, but carry on.
So expectations, etc., for this guy is again, media and fan created. Given he probably has received incredible accolades since pee-wee football, I strongly doubt he’ll give two shitz about what is poured upon him, imo
Saying you refuse to believe is not so much direct as it is being obtuse, but carry on.
Did you even read what I wrote? I said Fitz and James are great prospects and just as good at their positions as SB is at his. I'm not sure why that would fall under obtuse.
Now, I know that doesn't fit the narrative that comes out of Jints Central or the mainstream sports media - sources that you and most buy as the truth - but I think it's very defensible.
Quote:
"too direct"??
Saying you refuse to believe is not so much direct as it is being obtuse, but carry on.
Did you even read what I wrote? I said Fitz and James are great prospects and just as good at their positions as SB is at his. I'm not sure why that would fall under obtuse.
Now, I know that doesn't fit the narrative that comes out of Jints Central or the mainstream sports media - sources that you and most buy as the truth - but I think it's very defensible.
So let me get this straight. You have been pounding your fist on the table since the draft because you don’t take a RB with the 2nd pick. Because that’s what you’ve been conditioned to believe. Yet, you’re perfectly fine taking a safety at 2, even though almost no one on the planet ranks those guys as better prospects than Barkley? But you randomly say they are, so it must be true or everyone else is just bowing to the media. Got it.
So let me get this straight. You have been pounding your fist on the table since the draft because you don’t take a RB with the 2nd pick. Because that’s what you’ve been conditioned to believe. Yet, you’re perfectly fine taking a safety at 2, even though almost no one on the planet ranks those guys as better prospects than Barkley? But you randomly say they are, so it must be true or everyone else is just bowing to the media. Got it.
Nice try. "Conditioned to believe..." - now that's a good one. By whom?
I never said take a S. I said those players were just as good at their position as SB.
I didn't write anything complicated to give you any indication that that was what I was saying. Pretty simple stuff - subject, verb, direct object.
In other words, you are completely making up your narrative for whatever reason...
Quote:
And the second best player was probably Chubb.
Taking a ‘good’ QB at #2 can put you in QB hell.
If you look at it that way, what you're saying is don't draft a guy unless he's can't miss, and there's no such thing as can't miss. We have years of documented proof that "can't miss" drafted players miss all the time. Fans play the hindsight game all the time in the draft, but many players that went high and failed were sold as can't miss at the time.
I’m not saying that at all. I’m saying you take the best player available and you shouldn’t reach for a need.
And I don’t see how SB busts unless he is injured. He’s just that good of a player.
We can find several sources that have Barkley as one of the highest rated RB's EVER. Several saying he's a generational player and likely the best player in the draft.
How exactly would that translate to two guys being just as good at their positions?
By the way, does the incompetent Jints Central even have control over Brandt and the mainstream media?
Really tough to keep positioning Jints central as equal parts clueless and manipulative, but you keep trying.
We can find several sources that have Barkley as one of the highest rated RB's EVER. Several saying he's a generational player and likely the best player in the draft.
How exactly would that translate to two guys being just as good at their positions?
It's just opinion. It's not like I said a P, K, or LS were in Barkley's football class. So I disagree with the conventional wisdom on SB. Great college player, yes, but I think the projections for him are too big - like so many other generational types from the past.
James and Fitzpatrick are outstanding players. I'm not making some wild-ass stretch here. These guys could be instant pro bowl players. But that would require that you watch them play.
Fitzpatrick played all 4 DB positions for Saban and he played monster. There is nothing he can't do as a DB. Saban calls him one of the best defenders he's ever had. Good enough for me from a defensive mastermind who isn't quick to dole out such high praise.
Do you even know who James is? Have you seen him play? If you aren't impressed by his play and measurables than I don't know what to tell you about what a great prospect looks like. He will be a great NFL safety - and instantly. San Diego got the steal of the draft for a position that needed.
DG made one hyperbolic comment. The media and fans have been incessant. DG’s other comments about SB have all been in response to reporters’ questions..
Quote:
.
DG made one hyperbolic comment. The media and fans have been incessant. DG’s other comments about SB have all been in response to reporters’ questions..
He's made more than one. But this one was outrageous; and frankly it made him look stupid.
I think he's got more pressure than Barkley. Because if Barkley isn't the second coming of Brown/Sanders/Walter/etc this is going to be a helluva albatross to deal with...
Top 3 RB in the history of the sport or it’s an epic failure. Jeezus
Top 3 RB in the history of the sport or it’s an epic failure. Jeezus
Whatever.
I'm really not outraged. I'm making an argument. You're applying whatever tone of voice you want to hear.
He's the 4th highest paid RB in the NFL day one. Sam Darnold for reference is the 28th highest paid QB.
He's the highest selected running back in some time. He's going to a team with an iconic vet QB looking for his last stand.
When Gettleman virtually says he's perfect in his post-draft comments, that's a pretty decent bet.
Read the posts on this and other threads on what fans expect his numbers to be.
He's the 4th highest paid RB in the NFL day one. Sam Darnold for reference is the 28th highest paid QB.
He's the highest selected running back in some time. He's going to a team with an iconic vet QB looking for his last stand.
When Gettleman virtually says he's perfect in his post-draft comments, that's a pretty decent bet.
Read the posts on this and other threads on what fans expect his numbers to be.
Are you addressing me?
Quote:
If you can't recognize Gettleman has bet a lot on Barkley you don't know how football works.
He's the 4th highest paid RB in the NFL day one. Sam Darnold for reference is the 28th highest paid QB.
He's the highest selected running back in some time. He's going to a team with an iconic vet QB looking for his last stand.
When Gettleman virtually says he's perfect in his post-draft comments, that's a pretty decent bet.
Read the posts on this and other threads on what fans expect his numbers to be.
Are you addressing me?
Howdy buddy! Nope, just the general "you," which is always dangerous.
My (very small) fear is if Barkley isn't good out of the gate, he's going to get crushed. Crushed in the media, the fans, social media etc.
I like Gettleman, but his post-draft comments felt self-indulgent for my taste. I don't want the kid to be feel like a failure if he doesn't succeed right away. I think the team is as bad as it showed last year and I am not banking on anyone showing much for a while. And I don't want that to mess with Barkley's head.
On a side note Brandt had Hernandez as his 15th best player this year. I’m really looking forward to see him play
Quote:
In comment 13975445 christian said:
Quote:
If you can't recognize Gettleman has bet a lot on Barkley you don't know how football works.
He's the 4th highest paid RB in the NFL day one. Sam Darnold for reference is the 28th highest paid QB.
He's the highest selected running back in some time. He's going to a team with an iconic vet QB looking for his last stand.
When Gettleman virtually says he's perfect in his post-draft comments, that's a pretty decent bet.
Read the posts on this and other threads on what fans expect his numbers to be.
Are you addressing me?
Howdy buddy! Nope, just the general "you," which is always dangerous.
My (very small) fear is if Barkley isn't good out of the gate, he's going to get crushed. Crushed in the media, the fans, social media etc.
I like Gettleman, but his post-draft comments felt self-indulgent for my taste. I don't want the kid to be feel like a failure if he doesn't succeed right away. I think the team is as bad as it showed last year and I am not banking on anyone showing much for a while. And I don't want that to mess with Barkley's head.
I thin SB is mentally strong and can handle it just fine if he has a slow start. Also I think we are much better than they showed last year before the additions. I think the biggest issue was coaching/leadership. I think the players saw through all the bs and that’s when the trouble began. Where I think we will be in trouble this year is with depth thanks to several years of piss poor drafts
The ones throwing a tantrum because we didn’t go qb
Playing the old, "have you seen him play card"?
Do you even know who James is? Have you seen him play? If you aren't impressed by his play and measurables than I don't know what to tell you about what a great prospect looks like. He will be a great NFL safety - and instantly. San Diego got the steal of the draft for a position that needed.
It seems that you are intentionally being obtuse to not see the difference between two very good players and one that MANY people have said is generational and the majority of whom has said was the best player in the draft.
I happen to think Chubb is a great player too. That doesn't mean that somehow devalues Barkley.
But again - the underlying issue is if you don't try to make these preposterous parallels then you can't throw shade on "Jints Central", and that's the bottom line you keep trying to gloss over.
Playing the old, "have you seen him play card"?
It seems that you are intentionally being obtuse to not see the difference between two very good players and one that MANY people have said is generational and the majority of whom has said was the best player in the draft.
It was a serious question, actually. You are the same guy who thought Mariotta played for U of Hawaii. So I'm not assuming anything.
That's really more a function of the league moving away from paying runningbacks specifically to drive down salaries. The average runningback gets peanuts. Players like Leveon Bell, Adrian Peterson, and eventually Elliott will easily be 12-14m cap hits.
I still have no idea why we decided to make J. Stewart the fifth-largest salary cap burden in football.
Dave on the UWS : 5/24/2018 8:12 pm : link : reply
about Barkley's running style is Gail Sayers. Go back and look at old tapes of Sayers, he too wasn't a small guy, but ran like a scat back. SB is potentially one of the best pass receiving backs ever. He's very natural at it and you can bet he will be majorly featured by Shurmur. He an Odell will make each other even more dangerous.
It reminds me of a guy hooked to a joy stick when he gets in the open field he makes subtle moves that you almost don't pick them up and niether do the defenders the next thing you know he is by you ..