This article is a few days old, but I gotta imagine the general premise holds.
"The mindset in Foxboro is the package has to be bigger than what San Francisco put together in 2021 to go up from No. 12 to No. 3 in its trade with Miami. In that deal, the 49ers sent No. 12, a 2022 third-rounder and first-round picks in 2022 and 2023 to Miami for the privilege of selecting Trey Lance."
Curran is-from all I've ever gathered-pretty plugged in. He might not be Mike Reiss, in that Mike might as well be a Kraft son, Haha.
Link - (
New Window )
Three firsts is a lot to give up for the third QB taken in the draft.
If that's the price for a QB Joe & Dabs think can be elite for the next decade plus, sign me up without any hesitation.
Link - ( New Window )
Quote:
Like 6th overall, 3rd rd and 1st in 2025 would do it, but who knows.
If that's the price for a QB Joe & Dabs think can be elite for the next decade plus, sign me up without any hesitation.
Yes, the current QB situation sucks but you can’t shop hungry. I’d take the blue chip WR and continue to build out a good roster.
If there is a guy like Pratt, Rattler, or Milton they like later on, by all means do it. But you can’t let one bad mistake turn into multiple bad mistakes.
Quote:
In comment 16467817 Toth029 said:
Quote:
Like 6th overall, 3rd rd and 1st in 2025 would do it, but who knows.
If that's the price for a QB Joe & Dabs think can be elite for the next decade plus, sign me up without any hesitation.
The Giants have a top tier qb, they have way too many holes to fill to even think about a qb!
Is your top tier defined as all the QBs of all 32 teams? :)
Yes, the current QB situation sucks but you can’t shop hungry. I’d take the blue chip WR and continue to build out a good roster.
If there is a guy like Pratt, Rattler, or Milton they like later on, by all means do it. But you can’t let one bad mistake turn into multiple bad mistakes.
Are they not going to be hungry when they shop next year?
Daniel Jones - probably gone
Lock - expiring contract
DeVito - expiring contract
Sure, lets follow some of the advice I am seeing here that we should just draft a WR. Then, nothing but complaints this September about how bad our QB play is and we cannot get the ball to our new WR.
The QB is the most important position on the field.
If we end up with the 10th pick next year, then getting our QB will cost even more.
QBs for sale at Walmart on draft night
Sure, lets follow some of the advice I am seeing here that we should just draft a WR. Then, nothing but complaints this September about how bad our QB play is and we cannot get the ball to our new WR.
The QB is the most important position on the field.
If we end up with the 10th pick next year, then getting our QB will cost even more.
QBs for sale at Walmart on draft night
You can get a QB at 6 without giving anything else away. And In all probability, he’ll be just as good as the one some want to take a mortgage on.
Quote:
I am seeing comments on this thread and others where some here do not want to give up too much to get the QB we want.
Sure, lets follow some of the advice I am seeing here that we should just draft a WR. Then, nothing but complaints this September about how bad our QB play is and we cannot get the ball to our new WR.
The QB is the most important position on the field.
If we end up with the 10th pick next year, then getting our QB will cost even more.
QBs for sale at Walmart on draft night
You can get a QB at 6 without giving anything else away. And In all probability, he’ll be just as good as the one some want to take a mortgage on.
If I was Schoen I would go Maye/JJM at 6 or trade down/WR if they aren't there and hope Penix slid to the end of rd1 for tradeup.
Sure, lets follow some of the advice I am seeing here that we should just draft a WR. Then, nothing but complaints this September about how bad our QB play is and we cannot get the ball to our new WR.
The QB is the most important position on the field.
If we end up with the 10th pick next year, then getting our QB will cost even more.
QBs for sale at Walmart on draft night
And when they suck and BD is fired people will act surprised. They may suck with a new QB too but if there's progress then at least they can sell the arrow pointing up. Jones and a new wr and the arrow stays pointing straight down
You might be right, but that exact sentiment would have been shared by many BBIers if the Giants were rumored to want Josh Allen or Mahomes in their respective drafts. We really don’t know what these guys might become.
Quote:
In comment 16467817 Toth029 said:
Quote:
Like 6th overall, 3rd rd and 1st in 2025 would do it, but who knows.
If that's the price for a QB Joe & Dabs think can be elite for the next decade plus, sign me up without any hesitation.
The Giants have a top tier qb, they have way too many holes to fill to even think about a qb!
Im not sure Lock is top tier, but maybe
If for some reason they don't have that high a value on any of the remaining QBs, then they will be open to trading down and the price (at least for the Giants) will be lower than what SF paid.
(Don't forget SF was trading up from pick 12, not pick 6.)
Quote:
Or I guess the WR and punt on QB. That’s if the price is too high, of course.
Yes, the current QB situation sucks but you can’t shop hungry. I’d take the blue chip WR and continue to build out a good roster.
If there is a guy like Pratt, Rattler, or Milton they like later on, by all means do it. But you can’t let one bad mistake turn into multiple bad mistakes.
Are they not going to be hungry when they shop next year?
Daniel Jones - probably gone
Lock - expiring contract
DeVito - expiring contract
Scary thought: maybe when you consider how poor the 2025 class may be, perhaps Jones/Lock are here through the end of 2025..maybe ‘26 is a good QB class…
Garoppolo was hardly a major screw up.
In 2019, when Niners went 13-3 and to the SB, they were 3rd in the league in net yards per passing attempt.
2020, JG was hurt for majority of season.
2021, Niners went 10-7, JG started 15 of 17 games, and Niners were first in the league in net yards per passing attempt.
2022, Garapollo was 7-3 in 10 starts with 16 TDs and 4 INTs before getting hurt and Purdy taking over.
Aside from Purdy, look at their 2022 draft. It's awful.
Those 3 WRs make all the difference
Quote:
In comment 16467817 Toth029 said:
Quote:
Like 6th overall, 3rd rd and 1st in 2025 would do it, but who knows.
If that's the price for a QB Joe & Dabs think can be elite for the next decade plus, sign me up without any hesitation.
The Giants have a top tier qb, they have way too many holes to fill to even think about a qb!
Your troll act is getting stale. Loser.
The Giants may or may not trade up, but I get the feeling that many members of the media are underestimating the value in high 1st round picks and essentially saying that all 1st round picks are equal. Not the case at all.