McCarthy says he's spent most time with NYG

for the first time in a long time I have no idea what the Giants are going to do.

In comment 16483702 mphbullet36 said:

Quote:

for the first time in a long time I have no idea what the Giants are going to do.

Agreed.

I think the odds we select a QB are way higher than a WR.

Which one and at what pick is another question.

About a draft. Ever

In comment 16483702 mphbullet36 said:

Quote:

for the first time in a long time I have no idea what the Giants are going to do.

Sure we do, all of yesterday, and most of this morning, the consensus on BBI seemed to be they were trading up for Drake Maye. Seems like most want it to be official.

I would be shocked

In comment 16483794 George from PA said:

Quote:

I would be shocked

+1

As long as they love him. I just don’t want a QB because we need one. If the experts on the Giants have to have someone I’ll live with the outcome. I just don’t know how you guess at this point. Maybe we should still Andy Reid’s draft board for QBs.

That is highly suspect. Either JMM is not all that, or some teams are trying to hide their enthusiasms. I bet it’s the latter.

That McCarthy has spent more time with NYG than any other team, becasue I doubt it is.

And here is what I keep on thinking in regards to McCarthy.

1. Sy likes him and I appreciate what Sy sees and loved his video he did comparing Maye to McCarthy

2. If McCarthy stayed in school there is a good chance he would be QB1 in next years draft. Punting on QB this year for next years group and not knowing if you will be able to get the best QB, plus having him a year early and even having it be a red shirt season is a way better scenario IMO.

is it better to draft a pretty good QB in the first round or an excellent WR? I am still of the mind that you need to build the OL first, then pick your QB. We have not done that. I worry that Runyan and Eleumenor are just this year's Glowinski and Tyre Phillips. As a result, if we do pick a QB, he better not start this year. Let Lock and/or Jones take the beating. Build the OL before playing the QB.

In comment 16483793 barens said:

Quote:

In comment 16483702 mphbullet36 said: Quote: for the first time in a long time I have no idea what the Giants are going to do. Sure we do, all of yesterday, and most of this morning, the consensus on BBI seemed to be they were trading up for Drake Maye. Seems like most want it to be official.

That might be what the Giants want...but the latest rumors have the Pats staying at #3 and picking Maye...at that point I have no idea what the Giants will do.

the Giants want to draft a QB and they want to draft one early on in the draft.

That's all we know for sure.

On the QB they knew the least about and will most likely have the opportunity to draft at 4, 5 or 6
It’s a crucial decision
More information is better

Means more than the reporters saying they’ve heard the Giants won’t draft McCarthy.

In comment 16483849 Rjanyg said:

Quote:

And here is what I keep on thinking in regards to McCarthy. 1. Sy likes him and I appreciate what Sy sees and loved his video he did comparing Maye to McCarthy 2. If McCarthy stayed in school there is a good chance he would be QB1 in next years draft. Punting on QB this year for next years group and not knowing if you will be able to get the best QB, plus having him a year early and even having it be a red shirt season is a way better scenario IMO.

Yep I agree. I would not be disappointed at all.

.
McCarthy on Eisen - ( New Window )

At how young he looks.
He certainly has a lot of room to mature physically.
I have talked myself into being good with him - but really do not want to give up next years #1.
I will trust Schoen and Daboll to pick the right QB.
I’m hoping they can get their guy without giving up so much

Odd. I have never heard another player giving a clear response to that standard question before.