Trade Up Tonight

there a bunch of ongoing threads with this discussion.

Im new to this website, just created an account an hour ago. getting used to it and trying to see where all the threads are. figured it fire something up onto it.

In comment 16485821 DG23. said:

Quote:

Im new to this website, just created an account an hour ago. getting used to it and trying to see where all the threads are. figured it fire something up onto it.

No problem. Welcome. Just saying this is being heavily discussed. If you select "last post" in the menu bar above, you will see the most recent active discussions.

some people here are very sarcastic or crass, dont let it bring you down.

Now test to see if you can figure out the function on how to delete a thread you created.

Penix is better and is a sure thing if Giants want him .

https://ih1.redbubble.net/image.2255947803.7935/bg,f8f8f8-flat,750x,075,f-pad,750x1000,f8f8f8.jpg

Old man yells at cloud? Some can be just like that. Bright side is this site and most of the people are awesome

To answer your question, much depends on the following:

(1) Do the Commanders really take Daniels? Because if they don't, everything changes.

(2) Assuming the Commanders take Daniels, are the reports about Kraft falling love with McCarthy accurate? If so, that changes everything.

(3) There is an asshat report that the Vikings would trade up for Maye, but not McCarthy. Is that accurate? Who the hell knows? But the answer to that question changes everything.

There are scenarios where McCarthy or Maye could even fall to six, but that would be awfully risky for the Giants to wait that out.

In comment 16485866 averagejoe said:

Quote:

Penix is better and is a sure thing if Giants want him .

Penix has many issues. Maye is a 21 year old with a big arm, great size and athleticism.

Is Jones legit or not legit? Be very careful how you answer this.

In comment 16485891 Toth029 said:

Quote:

In comment 16485866 averagejoe said: Quote: Penix is better and is a sure thing if Giants want him . Penix has many issues. Maye is a 21 year old with a big arm, great size and athleticism.

Who has better tape and arm talent ?

for a QB who by consensus is not a big step up from Penix or McCarthy. Whatever they do there is risk. To escape criticism probably safest to trade down and pick one of the 2nd tier QBs and the top player in the draft at almost any position other than QB and WR.

Please stay put at get Odunze.

Maye probably has the biggest upside of ANY QB in this draft, but his floor is the lowest. He is a BIG swing for the Home RUN!

landed Maye at any price. Is he one of the top tier of 3 as he was talked about even a month ago? Has he fallen from tier 1 to tier 2? It’s just not easy to predict which college players will make it in the pros. we know because there are so many misses on first round quarterbacks, despite all the careful scouting and evaluation that happens before a quarterback is taken high..

With the missed pick of Neal in the top 10, throwing away two first round picks on a QB who wasn’t good (enough could easily lead to the end of this GM, and possibly this loyal fan of over 60 years.).

In comment 16485821 DG23. said:

Quote:

Im new to this website, just created an account an hour ago. getting used to it and trying to see where all the threads are. figured it fire something up onto it.

Welcome! Great day to sign up. Despite our profound differences about what the Giants should do, we all love the team.

In comment 16485969 Reese's Pieces said:

Quote:

for a QB who by consensus is not a big step up from Penix or McCarthy. Whatever they do there is risk. To escape criticism probably safest to trade down and pick one of the 2nd tier QBs and the top player in the draft at almost any position other than QB and WR.

Agreed.

I lurked the sight for years, reading all the wonderful banter. Then I was like, Ok I am ready, let join the convo

Then BOOM

Everyone starting yelling at me that I was a Dupe account of some other poster. LOL good times!