for display only
Big Blue Interactive The Corner Forum  
Back to the Corner

Archived Thread

If you were Eli and you won another Super Bowl...

Eric from BBI : Admin : 5/19/2017 8:32 am
would you retire or keep playing?
Pages: 1 2 | Show All |  Next>>
I'd keep playing  
David B. : 5/19/2017 8:34 am : link
He's still got a few good years left. Play as long as you're still healthy and capable.
RE: I'd keep playing  
andrew_nyg : 5/19/2017 8:35 am : link
In comment 13475945 David B. said:
Quote:
He's still got a few good years left. Play as long as you're still healthy and capable.


agreed
Play  
Joey from GlenCove : 5/19/2017 8:39 am : link
Not sure why you wouldn't finish out the current deal.

Also he doesn't have any nagging injuries as far as we know.
Eli's still going  
Simms11 : 5/19/2017 8:40 am : link
and so why not then come back and try to win another, ala Elway.
If he wins he would only be two off Brady  
bradshaw44 : 5/19/2017 8:43 am : link
And I'm sure he would like to at least try a back to back.
Keep playing  
halfback20 : 5/19/2017 8:45 am : link
...
It depends how he won  
pjcas18 : 5/19/2017 8:47 am : link
if he won like brady just did - then he comes back, if he won like Peyton did the year before - then he retires.
He has to weigh what's important to him  
mavric : 5/19/2017 8:47 am : link
on one side of the scale is potentially a 4th Lombardi. On the other side of the scale is a beautiful wife and three daughters.

Enough money to retire in a life of luxury? check
Three Superbowl rings? check
Shoo-in for HOF? check
Would he want to spend more time with his daughters who getting older and will be involved in school activities? Not sure. Only he can answer that.

So Eli has to ask himself: Is it worth taking the chance of a serious or debilitating injury that could negatively effect the rest of his life for some additional glory? There in lies the million dollar question!
...  
Dodge : 5/19/2017 8:49 am : link
Assuming health and level of play haven't deteriorated, then you play at least one more year with the tools that you supposedly have this year.

If Eli's play is worse that last year then I think you go out with glory. If he bounces back to 2015 levels, keep going.
I'd keep playing  
YAJ2112 : 5/19/2017 8:50 am : link
I don't think the heavy stuff's gonna come down for quite awhile.
If we won another Super Bowl THIS season?  
Beezer : 5/19/2017 8:51 am : link
I'd keep playing, knowing there was a chance for a 4th, IF the core stayed intact.

If we won another Super Bowl after 3 more seasons? Might be a different story, then. Might pull a Strahan.
Archie quit when he no longer had it or could physically  
Big Blue '56 : 5/19/2017 8:52 am : link
perform..Peyton retired ONLY because he could no longer physically do it. Eli will play as long as his body says yes, imo..

It's in their blood. Deeply.
It depends when he wins it.  
Section331 : 5/19/2017 8:53 am : link
This year, I'd definitely keep playing - you have an opportunity to defend your title! In 2 or 3 years? Then I could see him giving serious thought to calling it a day.
If I were Eli, winning or not winning a SB would not alter my plans  
Marty in Albany : 5/19/2017 8:57 am : link
I like to play. I like to compete. I like to win. That is what drives me.

I am not looking for fame. I don't need anyone's approval except my own, and that includes the folks in Canton. I already have as much fame and money as I will ever need. And I have no ambitions towards becoming a TV personality.

I learned from Tiki's example that it is not a good idea to make my retirement plans public. However, when I make a decision, I will probably tell Jerry and Ben about it, unless I am advised by my family and agent that telling them will hurt me financially.

However, there is a significant likelihood, that my retirement will be a lot sooner if my offensive line cannot keep me healthy.
I'd retire  
ThatLimerickGuy : 5/19/2017 8:57 am : link
And open a sports memorabilia store in the Westfield Mall.

I kid I kid...
If I were Eli...  
x meadowlander : 5/19/2017 8:58 am : link
...I would retire TODAY.

Life's too short. What is the difference between all he has accomplished and one more SB Trophy? He's already a Hall of Famer.

The beatings he's taken? Hell, if it were me, I'd have probably quit after 2013. Who the hell would want to open the door to that hell season repeating??

That said, I'm happy he's dippy enough to keep playing.
RE: Archie quit when he no longer had it or could physically  
Ira : 5/19/2017 8:59 am : link
In comment 13475974 Big Blue '56 said:
Quote:
perform..Peyton retired ONLY because he could no longer physically do it. Eli will play as long as his body says yes, imo..

It's in their blood. Deeply.


You're probably right, but the question is - if you were Eli what would you do. If it were me, I'd retire.
RE: RE: Archie quit when he no longer had it or could physically  
Big Blue '56 : 5/19/2017 9:00 am : link
In comment 13475993 Ira said:
Quote:
In comment 13475974 Big Blue '56 said:


Quote:


perform..Peyton retired ONLY because he could no longer physically do it. Eli will play as long as his body says yes, imo..

It's in their blood. Deeply.



You're probably right, but the question is - if you were Eli what would you do. If it were me, I'd retire.


I would continue
I'd keep playing  
jcn56 : 5/19/2017 9:19 am : link
but then again, I haven't been getting knocked on my ass by linemen for 14 years. Only he knows how he's really feeling.
assuming it was not in spite of his play  
AnnapolisMike : 5/19/2017 9:21 am : link
and it was this year. I would continue.

In all reality....we are going to see the Giants make a couple of runs in the next few years and likely falling short of winning the Super Bowl. Eli does not need to win another Super Bowl to cement his legacy. Just play well over the next few years.
On paper, this is our best team (possibly) since 2008  
SGMen : 5/19/2017 9:27 am : link
I have a good feeling we can make a real SB run this year. If Eli does win a SB this year, there is no doubt in my mind he keeps playing. This team has nothing but upside right now as we seem to have done well in free agency & the draft of late.

If I'm the Giants and Eli this year, you just pray you stay healthy, get healthy (FS D. Thompson, M. Thompson, N. Behre) and develop the youth (esp. Flowers, Hart, Bisnotway, Wheeler, Goodson, Apple, Adams, Okwara, Tomlinson, Engram, etc.). I tend to be an optimist but man oh man, Eli has to be so happy he now has redzone threats with Marshall, Ellison, maybe Adams and Engram. We can't bog down when we get inside the 30 and areas get tight.

Eli just needs to play ball control and keep the chains moving by hitting the open guy quickly. Given all of our talented targets, we should move the ball easily by drawing coverage to the big 3: OBJ, Marshall and I think Engram.
Depends on health  
SFGFNCGiantsFan : 5/19/2017 9:28 am : link
.
RE: Depends on health  
SGMen : 5/19/2017 9:33 am : link
In comment 13476048 SFGFNCGiantsFan said:
Quote:
.
I wholeheartedly agree. We were healthy last year, overall, which is why we got to the playoffs. But think about how BAD our offensive weapons were? We won close games with defense and special teams. We had no #2 WR or #4 even. We sucked blocking everywhere. We turned it over as Eli was forced. It was an offensive nightmare that I don't think anyone predicted. Losing FB W. Johnson hurt more than we know as at least he could have blocked some for the edge and for the run game.

We get out of camp healthy and stay healthy early, winning 3-0 or 4-0, before the inevitable dings hit, we are on our way to the division championship.

Ball control, keep the defense fresh & attacking, strong specials, don't turn it over while allowing our secondary to get turnovers. We have talent everywhere except maybe the OL. We really could use HUGE years from Pugh & Richburg and for Flowers do develop. That would go a long way to a SB run...and great season.
If he won this year  
NNJ Tom : 5/19/2017 9:36 am : link
I would drop the mike. Smell ya later.

1 more win than Big Brother
1st vote Hof
Time to chill

I love Eli, but it wouldn't shock me if he split after another SB win.
If he doesn't get  
section125 : 5/19/2017 9:44 am : link
whacked around during the season and wins the SB, he stays. If he gets beat up weekly and it doesn't look like it will get better, he goes.
Every year that he plays is real $$$,  
NoPeanutz : 5/19/2017 9:45 am : link
which is even more important to his family and welfare than trophies.
If injuries and quality of life aren't a factor, there's no reason not to keep playing.
Keep playing for one more year. Allow team to transition  
Jimmy Googs : 5/19/2017 9:53 am : link
smoothly to future.

Eli's a good egg...
I think  
Dave in PA : 5/19/2017 9:59 am : link
He would keep playing. He's already reached the apex twice and is a NY sports hero so I don't think he's continued to play out of trying to particularly achieve anything, he's playing because this is all he knows in life. Now I would have personally retired by now knowing all the terrible things about CTE. He's got financial security for several generations of Mannings, he's well liked and respected by just about everybody, he's a two time Super Bowl f'n champ that took down the titan of his generation and did so with ice water in his veins and most importantly he's got little kids at home that I'm sure he wants to be an integral part of their lives well past his playing years.
Tiki announced his plan to retire early on. Imagine how much more  
Ivan15 : 5/19/2017 10:01 am : link
Pissed everyone would have been if he announced it after the season.

Tiki's post season press conference: "Oh by the way, after single handedly carrying this team, I'm done."
I'd come back  
bceagle05 : 5/19/2017 10:02 am : link
so that the media is forced to swallow their pride - finally - and kiss my ass as a three-time champ.
AS mentioned,  
Doomster : 5/19/2017 10:11 am : link
it all depends on when he wins it......I mean, if he finally wins his third one at the age of 45, I would seriously consider it....
Win one more and retire - go out on top  
PatersonPlank : 5/19/2017 10:18 am : link
Better chance at the HOF. If he sticks around, then he'll start declining and people will start complaining about his play again.
Retire  
micky : 5/19/2017 10:21 am : link
It'd most likely seal a hof spot and save wear on his life
i'd play until they dragged me off the field  
djm : 5/19/2017 10:51 am : link
or told me I couldn't play anymore. But that's me.

Love when people get on athletes for hanging on too long. FU. Go quit your job while you still need money and want to work and then tell me an athlete held on too long. I don't blame these guys for playing until the drop or even longer. It's what they do. Most of them love the game.
RE: Win one more and retire - go out on top  
djm : 5/19/2017 10:53 am : link
In comment 13476142 PatersonPlank said:
Quote:
Better chance at the HOF. If he sticks around, then he'll start declining and people will start complaining about his play again.


Eli is a near lock now. If he wins another title and then proceeds to throw 500 INTs and 0 Tds while shitting all over every NFL field he'd still be a first ballot lock. 2 rings is great. 3 rings is legendary.
RE: Archie quit when he no longer had it or could physically  
Elisthebest : 5/19/2017 10:55 am : link
In comment 13475974 Big Blue '56 said:
Quote:
perform..Peyton retired ONLY because he could no longer physically do it. Eli will play as long as his body says yes, imo..

It's in their blood. Deeply.

Don't know who said it but it was something to the effect of : Fast forward 25 years and Peyton's grinding at perfecting the latest innovation and Eli is sitting on the floor playing with his grandkids. Gotta love them both.
more than likely  
djm : 5/19/2017 10:55 am : link
if Eli won another one, he'd stay and try and win yet another one after that.

Winning is never enough for anyone that competes. You just want more. It's rare to see an athlete retire right after winning a title. Elway is the exception. He was 38 and running on fumes at that point.
retire....  
GMAN4LIFE : 5/19/2017 10:57 am : link
.
I think it is always special to go out on a win ...  
Beer Man : 5/19/2017 11:23 am : link
But if the game was still in my blood, and I still had my health and what it takes to win, then I would play on.
Keep Playing  
armstead98 : 5/19/2017 11:26 am : link
Eli has some stats that are good but with a few more years he would be in truly legendary territory.

Touchdowns

1. Peyton: 539
2. Favre: 508
3. Brees: 465
4. Brady: 456
5. Marino: 420
6. Tarkenton: 342
7. Eli: 320
8. Rivers: 314
9. Big Ben: 301
10. Elway: 301

With a few more years he moves into top 5, passing Marino and puts some room between him and Big Ben, arguably is biggest competition for the HOF.

Total Wins:

1. Brady: 208
2. Peyton: 200
3. Favre: 199
4. Elway: 162
5. Marino: 155
6. Big Ben: 136
7. Brees: 135
8. Montana: 133
9. Tarkenton: 130
10. Unitas: 124
11. Bradshaw: 121
12. Eli 116

Eli probably moves into the top 10 after this year. If he plays 3 more years and averages 10 wins per year (counting playoffs) he could move up to 5 or 6, depending on Brees and Big Ben. I think Big Ben retires after this year.

Those two jumps in stats would not only get him into the HOF but get him up into some rarefied air.

It depends on the will and the body  
JonC : 5/19/2017 11:27 am : link
If he can do it physically and the fire still burns, play until it burns out. When the fire is gone, it's time to retire.
ok.  
vanclelone : 5/19/2017 11:30 am : link
so, that battle would be legendary!
the question is  
giantfan2000 : 5/19/2017 11:46 am : link
if Giants won Super Bowl Eli gets another year
but what happens after that next year?
hmmm..  
annexOPR : 5/19/2017 11:52 am : link
I'd retire a multi millionaire with 3 SB rings and beloved by fans of 1 of the most storied franchises in sports history - with the ability to walk/remember things.



If he wins another one  
Carl in CT : 5/19/2017 11:58 am : link
He is gone!
If I'm getting the shit kicked out of me on the way to doing it  
widmerseyebrow : 5/19/2017 12:07 pm : link
Then yes.
Walk away...  
trueblueinpw : 5/19/2017 12:20 pm : link
No doubt about it. Three Supes and I'd be done.
my rationale:  
annexOPR : 5/19/2017 12:21 pm : link
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PrIah78tKI4

[I will never forget this game. 1 of my all time favorite games. exhausting to even watch on tv]
I would have to ask Abby.  
Big Blue Blogger : 5/19/2017 12:31 pm : link
She would probbaly have a big say in that decision. Heck, Ava is already six - pretty soon, she'll have a vote.

Eli would probably want to keep playing.
win and retire  
Paulie Walnuts : 5/19/2017 12:31 pm : link
you would have bragging rights over Peyton forever
Pages: 1 2 | Show All |  Next>>
Back to the Corner