You may need more beef against the Cowboys offensive line unless you get to very large distances on 2nd and 3rd down but it seems like for any other team that it would make sense for Collins to move up to linebacker and they insert Adams at strong safety.
I would think we'd probably see JT Thomas alongside Casillas in standard nickel situations. We might see the the personnel you describe but it would be in a creative dime, not a makeshift nickel.
I would think we'd probably see JT Thomas alongside Casillas in standard nickel situations. We might see the the personnel you describe but it would be in a creative dime, not a makeshift nickel.
My guess is this is what would happen. Why have JT Thomas on the roster if he's not here for this role? I'd leave Collins where he is, which is the best safety in the NFL.
A: Good. I mean he moves around like a football player. I talked to him today and I told him that he looks like he is born for the position, but most importantly, he has earned it. First, second and third down, he’s out there. He takes ownership of the defense and I’m excited to watch him play on Sunday.
I'm guessing that in nickel defense it will be Casillas and Goodson, since it seems McAdoo is planning to play BJ all three downs.
He's a line up and go downhill linebacker.
He has value because he can play outside spots, but specifically exposing him to nickel matchups is not the best idea.
Thomas is hard to assess because of the knee, possible rustiness, and a limited body of work overall. FWIW (not much) PFF liked his coverage better than other aspects of his game in 2015.
Collins wouldn't even have occurred to me.
I think it's safe to say that none of the options will be worse than Uani' Unga.
Quote:
But I doubt it. IMO, that just spreads the talent gap over two positions - Collins is almost definitely not as good a LB as he is a SS, so that's a diminished use of his skills, and Adams doesn't really possess the typical SS skill set, so that's a bit of a diminished use as well.
I would think we'd probably see JT Thomas alongside Casillas in standard nickel situations. We might see the the personnel you describe but it would be in a creative dime, not a makeshift nickel.
My guess is this is what would happen. Why have JT Thomas on the roster if he's not here for this role? I'd leave Collins where he is, which is the best safety in the NFL.
Yup. I could see Goodson and Casillas on the field in the nickel sub. And please spare me the gnashing of teeth. Neither are as bad in coverage as some make them out to be.
But I agree with Matt.
Quote:
Q: How has B.J. Goodson looked as an every down linebacker, particularly in coverage?
A: Good. I mean he moves around like a football player. I talked to him today and I told him that he looks like he is born for the position, but most importantly, he has earned it. First, second and third down, he’s out there. He takes ownership of the defense and I’m excited to watch him play on Sunday.
I'm guessing that in nickel defense it will be Casillas and Goodson, since it seems McAdoo is planning to play BJ all three downs.
I don't think he has that much choice without Robinson available. I doubt Robinson will be available by Sunday.
At some point, they have to make a decision on him.
I do expect that we'll see more 3-safety looks from the Giants this season. They seem to have the guys to do it in LC, Adams, Thompson and DRC. I think that the defense, like the offense, is going to look to be be more diverse and give the other side more to think about.
This is an excellent point - hope to see some pressure from him in those situations. I think with our ends Dak's most vulnerability to A-gap blitzes from someone who can get home.
Quote:
so having him on the field gives them more options for bringing the heat.
This is an excellent point - hope to see some pressure from him in those situations. I think with our ends Dak's most vulnerability to A-gap blitzes from someone who can get home.
Except with Martin/Frederick, their OL is least vulnerable to A-gap blitzes. But if Snacks/Bromley/Goodson/etc can push the pocket a little, JPP and Vernon could get home and make Dak very uncomfortable.
Except with Martin/Frederick, their OL is least vulnerable to A-gap blitzes. But if Snacks/Bromley/Goodson/etc can push the pocket a little, JPP and Vernon could get home and make Dak very uncomfortable.
Yes they do - and Zeke has proven to be a very effective blocker. Hoping to see how he handles Goodson because I think BJ can win some there.
I don't think he has that much choice without Robinson available. I doubt Robinson will be available by Sunday.
At some point, they have to make a decision on him.
This is a really good point, and should be kept in mind since they brought in three linebackers for tryouts this week. Maybe Goodson is going to get three downs but they wish they had someone stronger in coverage and are still looking. Spags basically said as much in his presser today when asked about linebacker depth.
A: It’s starting to unfold. As a coach, you always want more depth. You’re always looking for good football players, but we have guys in here that hopefully know what they’re doing and the one challenge in this league with backup guys – talk about depth – is they don’t get a lot of reps now. Should something happen on Sunday, they need to be ready to go.
Think you might be right Carson53.
Adams getting in the game other than on Specials is trouble with a capital T...
Apple.....JPP/Bromley/Harrison\..Wynn.....Jenkins.......DRC
............................Vernon.........
.......Collins.......
...................................Thompson
...................Adams
3 safeties and 3 corners
Quote:
with a way to get Adams in the game. Especially with the way Witten does the Giants.
Adams getting in the game other than on Specials is trouble with a capital T...
Saying it repeatedly doesn't make you correct. Given the way you seem to think everything and everyone related to this team is so mediocre, why not choose one of the other 31 teams? I mean, you're wrong all the time as a Giants fan, why not double down and see if you can be completely wrong about another team too?